[Advanced] Blackhoof's Cthulhu Mythos Mafia Game- Day 1

[RandA lThor]

Well... Mynd get over here and confirm that you got a nightmare, and that the mod directly said that either me/Dap, Despo, or Womby (? or someone else who died don't remember) is antitown.  Cuz when you do, its you v me.

 

And also, if Mynd got a positive ability when he said the name 3 times, why aren't we also doing that?  Are you guys just too scared to be silenced or get something bad?  Cuz if you are, and if you guys are set on lynching me, I could try my hand at it.  Worst that could happen is I die, and then you lynch Mynd regardless right?

 

And assuming that Mynd is saying that he got it from the mod, then [vote]Mynd[/vote]

[RandA lThor]

Rand may be too clueless to be scum.

 

thanks?

[RandA lThor]

[vote] Mynd [/vote]

[Nynaeve]

Rand may be too clueless to be scum.

lmfao omg xD

[RandA lThor]

[v] Despo [/v]

 

Stop making fun of me

[Clovdyx]

[v] Despo [/v]

 

Stop making fun of me

 

He's dead.

[Hallia]

o.o Why'd you go back to voting him when he's dead?

[Nynaeve]

im laughing at dawn, not you xD

[RandA lThor]

OHH MY GOD!!

 

[v]Mynd[/v]  I am so sleepy...

 

 

 

[v] Despo [/v]

 

Stop making fun of me

 

He's dead.

 

 

o.o Why'd you go back to voting him when he's dead?

Got confused with my voting thing.

 

 

im laughing at dawn, not you xD

lol ik its fine i was just joking.

[RandA lThor]

join my bw! Mynd is a LLL who lies and should be thrown into jail.  And executed.  Beard first.  That scummy scummy beard.

[Clovdyx]

Rand, do you think Des was a vig kill, chosen mafia kill, or insane mafia kill?  Doesn't really matter if the vig intended to shoot Despot or somebody else.  I just want to hear your take on it.

[Nynaeve]

lol

[RandA lThor]

Rand, do you think Des was a vig kill, chosen mafia kill, or insane mafia kill?  Doesn't really matter if the vig intended to shoot Despot or somebody else.  I just want to hear your take on it.

It'd be interesting if it was an insane mafia kill.  I think I already asked how that would work, since all the mafia collectively kill someone, but I don't think Hoof has responded.  He might not want to, idk.  I don't think he was a chosen mafia kill at all.  If Mynd is mafia, which FMPOV he almost completely is, then he wouldn't kill one of the people on his list.  He would use that as a list for town to lynch off of.  A vig kill seems much more likely because a vig would like to go down the list to raise his chance of hitting a mafia.  So in order of likelihood, vig kill >>> insane mafia kill >>>>>> chosen mafia kill

[dawnflower8]

Ok, I'm pretty sure Rand is third party now, because if Mynd is telling the truth, than he's not town. He also didn't realise Despo is dead. A third party player wouldn't need to know who is dead, because they wouldn't care, so long as it wasn't them.

[Red2111]

yeah but any vig worth their grit wouldn't have killed Despo or Pral.

 

 

we all thought Pral claimed cop and Pral was vetting Despo.  hell i even moved my damn vote off of him because of it.

[Red2111]

*looks at Dawns posts*

 

 

soooooooooo

 

 

Rand today and Dawn tomorrow yes?

[Clovdyx]

 

Rand, do you think Des was a vig kill, chosen mafia kill, or insane mafia kill?  Doesn't really matter if the vig intended to shoot Despot or somebody else.  I just want to hear your take on it.

It'd be interesting if it was an insane mafia kill.  I think I already asked how that would work, since all the mafia collectively kill someone, but I don't think Hoof has responded.  He might not want to, idk.  I don't think he was a chosen mafia kill at all.  If Mynd is mafia, which FMPOV he almost completely is, then he wouldn't kill one of the people on his list.  He would use that as a list for town to lynch off of.  A vig kill seems much more likely because a vig would like to go down the list to raise his chance of hitting a mafia.  So in order of likelihood, vig kill >>> insane mafia kill >>>>>> chosen mafia kill

 

 

Bold is precisely why I asked.  I was going to correct Red's first post where she said it should be obvious why you were the lynch, as she was discounting the possibility Mynd was lying, but then thought better of it - what are the odds that Mynd would have Des set up for a mislynch only to kill him?

 

That would leave a vig kill, but...

 

yeah but any vig worth their grit wouldn't have killed Despo or Pral.

 

 

we all thought Pral claimed cop and Pral was vetting Despo.  hell i even moved my damn vote off of him because of it.

 

100% agree with Red on the bold. 

[dawnflower8]

*looks at Dawns posts*

 

 

soooooooooo

 

 

Rand today and Dawn tomorrow yes?

If Rand ends up being third party, will you still try to lynch me?

[RandA lThor]

Ok, I'm pretty sure Rand is third party now, because if Mynd is telling the truth, than he's not town. He also didn't realise Despo is dead. A third party player wouldn't need to know who is dead, because they wouldn't care, so long as it wasn't them.

 

No i realized despo was dead, which I pointed out right after the mod posted it.  I didn't connect it to the realization of Mynd's vision though, because my first reaction was that I knew it wasn't me, and womby was dead, so I voted for despo.  I remembered he was dead though, and started typing the unvote before anyone commented.

 

 

yeah but any vig worth their grit wouldn't have killed Despo or Pral.

 

 

we all thought Pral claimed cop and Pral was vetting Despo.  hell i even moved my damn vote off of him because of it.

true I forgot about Pral's soft that you talked about before.  That lowers the probability of a vig, so maybe insane mafia kill, or insane vig kill?  Actually I'd lean towards insane vig kill, since I don't know how insane mafia kill works.

 

Honestly guys though... I'm town.  I even pinky promise.

[dawnflower8]

If Rand is town, than Mynd is scum (because why would a townie make up a fake dream?) And I'm pretty sure Mynd is town. I still think Red should be lynched today.

[Clovdyx]

If Rand is town, than Mynd is scum (because why would a townie make up a fake dream?) And I'm pretty sure Mynd is town. I still think Red should be lynched today.

 

Unless somebody comes in with something concrete, I don't see an argument for anybody that's NOT Rand or Mynd.  There's an argument to be made against each.  You're absolutely right in that a townie wouldn't make up a fake dream, resulting in two or three mislynches, so there almost HAS to be one (and potentially two...) scum between Mynd/Rand. 

 

By all means, build a case on whoever you want, but if you're town you pretty much HAVE to vote for Rand or Mynd at this point.

[RandA lThor]

 

If Rand is town, than Mynd is scum (because why would a townie make up a fake dream?) And I'm pretty sure Mynd is town. I still think Red should be lynched today.

 

Unless somebody comes in with something concrete, I don't see an argument for anybody that's NOT Rand or Mynd.  There's an argument to be made against each.  You're absolutely right in that a townie wouldn't make up a fake dream, resulting in two or three mislynches, so there almost HAS to be one (and potentially two...) scum between Mynd/Rand. 

 

By all means, build a case on whoever you want, but if you're town you pretty much HAVE to vote for Rand or Mynd at this point.

 

 

just saying, I see these kinds of posts more from mafia.  Supporting obvious facts like its between me and Mynd, admonishing someone who, imo, is town for something they probably won't do.  Saying that you have to do something if you're town implying that they are town and the person they criticized is probably not.  Now of course, clov is going to say that he wasn't implying that, but the point of that sentence is to suggest it subtly to other people without implying or advocating for it yourself.

 

FoS on Clov

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Clovdyx]

 

 

If Rand is town, than Mynd is scum (because why would a townie make up a fake dream?) And I'm pretty sure Mynd is town. I still think Red should be lynched today.

 

Unless somebody comes in with something concrete, I don't see an argument for anybody that's NOT Rand or Mynd.  There's an argument to be made against each.  You're absolutely right in that a townie wouldn't make up a fake dream, resulting in two or three mislynches, so there almost HAS to be one (and potentially two...) scum between Mynd/Rand. 

 

By all means, build a case on whoever you want, but if you're town you pretty much HAVE to vote for Rand or Mynd at this point.

 

 

just saying, I see these kinds of posts more from mafia.  Supporting obvious facts like its between me and Mynd, admonishing someone who, imo, is town for something they probably won't do.  Saying that you have to do something if you're town implying that they are town and the person they criticized is probably not.  Now of course, clov is going to say that he wasn't implying that, but the point of that sentence is to suggest it subtly to other people without implying or advocating for it yourself.

 

FoS on Clov

 

 

Actually, I'll gladly admit to that.  The more she pushes votes away from you and/or Mynd, the more I'm going to assume she's trying to keep heat off of whichever one of you isn't town.

[Myndrunner]

I have no words. 

 

[v] Rand [/v]

 

Thanks for playing!