Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[Pralaya]

 

Screw it, I'm going YOLO

 

[v]Turin[/v]

 

 

[Turin Turambar]

Mafia team is Csarmi, Hallia and Despo. BOOK IT...

 

Yesterday Despo was certain Csarmi flips mafia. He gets saved by the person he now suspects is a mafia governor and he is voting

 

 

 

...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

wait for it

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

...

 

 

 

 

 

 

Turin.

 

the person that has been thinking they were both mafia since D1 when they both claimed and tried to say that their claims made them auto confirmed town. Because I am supposedly trying to set him up. I feel that I clearly stated that only a Csarmi mafia flip really points to you being mafia with him due to your actions which you just reinforced with your vote as well as his stance changing from how YOU were assuredly mafia to now putting both Len and Tina ahead of you in the desire to lynch order. It is classic mafia play. FoS hard but when it comes down to time to vote, choose someone else. You are doing it again with Hallia now that you have your vote on me and are going to reread. You shoot Hallia a FoS so that you can say you were suspicious of her all along but you will come back with a silly MQ thng about how I am the mafia here. 

 

You are nearly as obvious as Csarmi with his "one of Ithi or Turin must be mafia" drivel. He has flip flopped back and forth with whoever he thought had the best chance of actually getting lynched. He claimed that he thought Ithi's claim was fake. I don't think there is a post that says that. Surely he would have stated for the record that he doubted her claim somewhere in his 300+ posts in the game. Transparency of thought process and all that, right? not so much I guess.  

 

Come @ me all you like.  

[csarmi]

So you sure Despo is Mafia?

[Pralaya]

Anyway,, looking at the flips

 

Inspector Lestrade - Cop

Sherlock Holmes - Detective

Irene Adler - Symp

Wiggins - Gladiator

Dog - Oracle

 

The role more or less matches the character. 

 

That means, Krak -> Mycroft kind of makes sense. And King of Bohemia -> Governor too. 

Thaddeus Sholto also is interesting, because he is the character who is arrested wrongly in Sign of Four.

 

So, I do believe Hallia, Krak and Csarmi are all town here.

 

That leaves Turin, Des, Dice, Tsuki, Len, BFG and Tina

 

Turin - has been active and is making good reads. Town.

BFG - I believe her VT claim especially when countering Thane. Town.

 

I believe the scum to be in Des, Tina, Dice, Tsuki and Len.

 

Tina, I have always had a big scumread on her since Day 1.

Des - he also had a lot of scummy posts which I pointed out D1 and D2. His vote on Turin today is downright bad.

Dice - Turin makes a good point of NotBob's read of Dice., It was abrupt, early and definitely looked like NotBob knew something. Also, Dice's vote on Tsuki D2 as a counter to Thane looked like him trying to push a countertrain

 

Which makes me believe Tsuki is town.

 

Len, I am not sure of. I would put him in the to-be-watched list.

[Pralaya]

[v]Des[/v]

[csarmi]

Turin be serious. I made it very clear that I thought Ithi/Rags was scum.

 

You know that I knew her claim.

 

Lestrade can't be scum.

 

---

 

What does that tell you?

[csarmi]

@Pral I do agree that Hally and Krak are town and I'm town too. But how do you get there from character matching role?

[Lenlo]

Turin be serious. I made it very clear that I thought Ithi/Rags was scum.

 

You know that I knew her claim.

 

Lestrade can't be scum.

 

---

 

What does that tell you?

What does this even say? You thought Ithi/Rags was scum. But you say you knew her claim. And then you say that Lestrade cant be scum. Which is it?

[Tsukibana]

 

Turin - has been active and is making good reads. Town.

 

 

Not too sure how you can say that, and yet contradict 2/3 of those reads, but OK.

 

Interesting, about the roles and such... but wasn't the King of Bohemia a generally bad person?

[csarmi]

I believed Rags were scum. Thus I didn't believe his char claim.

[csarmi]

 

 

 

Turin - has been active and is making good reads. Town.

 

Not too sure how you can say that, and yet contradict 2/3 of those reads, but OK.

 

Interesting, about the roles and such... but wasn't the King of Bohemia a generally bad person?

Well was Irene Adler a bad person?

 

I don't think we should judge the claim on gaming the mod.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

 

Vote count:

 

Csarmi (3): Len, Turin, Tsuki

pray (1): csarmi

Tsuki (1): Hally

Turin (1): des

Des (1): pray

 

Not voting (4):Tina, Krak, Dice, BFG

 

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

 

DL is Wed. Jul. 2nd at 9 PM EST.

 

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140702T21&p0=422

[Lenlo]

I believed Rags were scum. Thus I didn't believe his char claim.

Alright thanks for the explanation, because it wasnt very clear in that post.

[Tsukibana]

 

 

 

Turin - has been active and is making good reads. Town.

Not too sure how you can say that, and yet contradict 2/3 of those reads, but OK.

 

Interesting, about the roles and such... but wasn't the King of Bohemia a generally bad person?

Well was Irene Adler a bad person?

 

I don't think we should judge the claim on gaming the mod.

 

 

Quiet, you. I was talking to someone else :P

Go talk about how much everyone is soo blind for thinking you, hallia, and Chak are scum.

[csarmi]

I lowered my susp on Despo and now he isn't voting me.

 

Too bad I'm torn on Turin.

[Lenlo]

 

 

 

Turin - has been active and is making good reads. Town.

Not too sure how you can say that, and yet contradict 2/3 of those reads, but OK.

 

Interesting, about the roles and such... but wasn't the King of Bohemia a generally bad person?

Well was Irene Adler a bad person?

 

I don't think we should judge the claim on gaming the mod.

 

She wasnt exactly a good person I can tell you that much.

[Tsukibana]

I lowered my susp on Despo and now he isn't voting me.

 

Too bad I'm torn on Turin.

 

So why don't YOU list your scum reads, plain as day.

[Tsukibana]

No fence sitting.

[csarmi]

 

 

 

 

 

Turin - has been active and is making good reads. Town.

Not too sure how you can say that, and yet contradict 2/3 of those reads, but OK.

 

Interesting, about the roles and such... but wasn't the King of Bohemia a generally bad person?

Well was Irene Adler a bad person?

 

I don't think we should judge the claim on gaming the mod.

Quiet, you. I was talking to someone else :P

Go talk about how much everyone is soo blind for thinking you, hallia, and Chak are scum.

This sort of behaviour is nor justified no matter what your alignment and/or reads are.

 

You're being rude.

[Tsukibana]

I was joking, or did you miss the :P ? 

[Lenlo]

It was a joke CS. As advertised by the  face of joyous mocking/playing.

[Pralaya]

@Pral I do agree that Hally and Krak are town and I'm town too. But how do you get there from character matching role?

 

Your character matches with a miller. So, I believe you are town.

Hally's character matches with Givernor. She wouldn't have saved you if she was scum and you were town. So, i believe she is town.

Krak's character matches with JOAT. Don't think Mycroft would be scum.

 

Agreed it is associative read but thats the same reada that I have onserved in general throughout the game too.

[csarmi]

 

 

I lowered my susp on Despo and now he isn't voting me.

 

Too bad I'm torn on Turin.

So why don't YOU list your scum reads, plain as day.

Pure scum read on:

Tina.

Lenlo.

 

Torn on Despo now. Gun to my head scum.

I keep second guessing myself on Turin. Gun to my head he's town.

I'd think Pral to be town if not for Rags signal.

 

Sure town:

 

Hally, Chak, BFG

[csarmi]

I'm trying to decide if Tsuki is derptown. Leaning that way.

[Pralaya]

 

 

Turin - has been active and is making good reads. Town.

 

 

Not too sure how you can say that, and yet contradict 2/3 of those reads, but OK.

 

Interesting, about the roles and such... but wasn't the King of Bohemia a generally bad person?

 

 

You can go and read his posts. Although I don't agree with his reads, he is making good points. As an example, even today, he was looking back at NotBob's posts trying to see what he could have said. 

 

And, no, don;t think the King was a villain. He just hired Holmes for a case.