Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[Tsukibana]

The only thing is, I would say that those who had Thane as TOWN (CS, Hallia, Chae - Looking at you folks) are the ones who need the re-read. I KNEW he was scum, but thought (and still think) Hallia is worse, and wanted to get her to burn her Pardon on her self. If she is, we can't afford to leave a two-day scum around. (as in, would take two-days to get rid of her)

[Hallia]

Or you can look for people who are actually scum and stop tunneling? 

[csarmi]

But I'm meh on it...

 

For now I'll go with the lazy pile.

[csarmi]

Umm Tsuki where did I have Thane as town?

 

I suggest you read in context not by people BTW.

[Tsukibana]

Or you can look for people who are actually scum and stop tunneling? 

 

You just keep falling over yourself to OMGUS me, don't you?

[Hallia]

Work with me then.  besides me, who else bears looking at in a reread, and I give you my solemn vow to really really look at them tonight.

[TheRagnarok]

The only thing is, I would say that those who had Thane as TOWN (CS, Hallia, Chae - Looking at you folks) are the ones who need the re-read. I KNEW he was scum, but thought (and still think) Hallia is worse, and wanted to get her to burn her Pardon on her self. If she is, we can't afford to leave a two-day scum around. (as in, would take two-days to get rid of her)

I already made that point to Csarmi which he chose to ignore.  My initial efforts to read individuals in the thread were made with the assumption that Thane was scum.

 

But hey, just let him keep calling me scum for no reason past Thane mentioning Ithi as scum sometimes and town others just like he did with a lot of people.

[Tsukibana]

Does it matter if I say who they are? They are the one's who had Thane as a Town read - and YES, I am aware that turin is in this category.

[csarmi]

@Hally: read the first day and give your general impressions.

[Basel Gill]

Holmes and Watson examined the body left by the latest lynching from the citizens of London. The corpse was lying facedown, and seemed to be female. "Watson looked closer, and asked, "Is it Moriarty?"
 
"Of course not, Watson. Moriarty is no more a woman than you are."* Holmes rolled the body over, gently so as not to disturb the scene. "And Moriarty certainly isn't this woman.* Irene Adler has beaten me once in the past, but this time, she was unable to get away. She can't help the opposition any longer."
 
Thane, Irene Adler, Mafia Symp, has been lynched.

DL for night actions is Tues. Jun. 24th at 9 PM EST.

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140624T21&p0=422

 

*Why yes, that was a dig at Elementary.

[csarmi]

@Rags:

 

1) Thane spew

2) Turin/Ithi

3) the Mynd switch

...

4) your total reaction fail in the last hours

 

I have been pretty sure one of Ithi/Turin was sc NY D1... Banked on Turin but with the new info it's you

. Pretty sure too.

 

Keep trying to spin tho.

 

You know me being town will eventually work my way ... Or people may read you know.

 

One or the other.

[csarmi]

* was scum by the end of d1

[Turin Turambar]

The only thing is, I would say that those who had Thane as TOWN (CS, Hallia, Chae - Looking at you folks) are the ones who need the re-read. I KNEW he was scum, but thought (and still think) Hallia is worse, and wanted to get her to burn her Pardon on her self. If she is, we can't afford to leave a two-day scum around. (as in, would take two-days to get rid of her)

I'm starting to think that she never was a governor. That is why she claimed it on D1 during the town/town 1v1 but then decided to not save the person she sided with with her vote(although her posts were seeming to see Ithi as more town. *Words not matching actions*). It gives a viable reason for the Twilight period. I am starting to think that her real role was as the symp recruiter. Maybe 1 or 2 shots to guess who the symp was. But there was too much heat on to pick Thane or maybe she didn't really believe he was the symp. I dunno.   

[csarmi]

Hally, can you pardon your own lynch?

[Hallia]

I sure can

[TheRagnarok]

@Rags:

 

1) Thane spew

2) Turin/Ithi

3) the Mynd switch

...

4) your total reaction fail in the last hours

 

I have been pretty sure one of Ithi/Turin was sc NY D1... Banked on Turin but with the new info it's you

. Pretty sure too.

 

Keep trying to spin tho.

 

You know me being town will eventually work my way ... Or people may read you know.

 

One or the other.

1.  He spewed a ton of people

2.  Your assumption which is amusing.

3.  Elaborate this one again for my amusement.

4.  Just cause you keep repeating something you've made up doesn't mean it will suddenly become true.

 

But feel free to keep it up.  It's worth a good laugh at the least.

[csarmi]

3) Leading the lynch off Thane onto Mynd.

4) Its on the thread you know.

[csarmi]

Krak you gonna weigh in?

[csarmi]

Okay night folks. Unlikely to be around much on the next couple of days. But my availability and my mood is very swingy.

[TheRagnarok]

3) Leading the lynch off Thane onto Mynd.

4) Its on the thread you know.

3.  So Ithi and Mynd getting into an argument over a character and Mynd making an emotional, less-than-intelligent decision to lock in the two of them is proof in your mind of Ithi being scum.  Especially being as Ithi had literally no way of knowing that Mynd had that ability?

4.  No, the only thing in the thread is you trying to make up a narrative.  I'll say it again, repeating something that is not true over and over does not make it true.

[Turin Turambar]

the "one of them is scum" gameplan is mafia 101. If you manage to get Rags lynched then you come back and say "Oh I guess it was Turin after all" 

 

You defended Thane quite a bit Csarmi. I don't know if you officially listed him as town however. Which actually is worse to me.

[csarmi]

You do realize I'm in that "one of them" pool right?

 

Are you suggesting that the Thane lynch wasn't being derailed there?

 

[And no its not Mynds action that started it]

[csarmi]

I hold everything I said about Thane, Turin.

[csarmi]

Turin if you're town (and I'm betting you are now) then you need to get your head out of your butt.

 

Every single one of your assumptions start with Csarmi (or insert scum read) being Mafia and go from there.

 

Which fails at me being town (all but confirmed).

 

Again, fit reads to facts, not facts to reads.

 

And stop the wild theories.

[Turin Turambar]

First off there is NO WAY you are all but confirmed. I don't know how you come off thinking that. 

 

Why are the theories wild? just because you don't agree with them. Just say you disagree and move on with your thought process.