Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[csarmi]

Oh yeah you're the new Ithi.

 

I'm sorry Rags. Ithi played so well. Must suck to be undermined by your dump spouting your team.

 

Gonna weep for you, promise.

[csarmi]

*symp

[csarmi]

If it's any consolation... Once I replaced into a game where the symp outed the whole team night one, got vigged, then Mafia was lynched every day... And I replaced in as Mafia recruit n5.

[Turin Turambar]

@Turin - read the timing of the claim too.

Who's claim? 

[Tsukibana]

 Not sure why you're making such a fuss.

 

No fuss. Clarification.

[csarmi]

 

 

Game probably solved.

 

Need a good analyst to check if that fits.

 

Turin: #Ithi may fit the bill?

Ithi(now Rags) was and is town. Do you think that the inspector is a safe claim?

 

Chae is the one claimed JOAT. And she took a shot without owning it at a town player. Me thinks you might be having the wool pulled over your eyes. But more likely is that you are mafia together.

Yea why not.

 

Forget about the claim and read day one carefully especially when we switched to Mynd from Thane. Who didn't get dirty moving their vote?

 

I urge you to reread with the symp flip and check what fits.

 

As for Chae... Still 95% on her. Close to 100% with my reread till page 15 and Thane's talk.

[csarmi]

 

 

@Turin - read the timing of the claim too.

Who's claim?

Mine. Basically I woke up. Read my role pm. And claimed in half an hour. That with the morning routine.

[TheRagnarok]

Oh yeah you're the new Ithi.

 

I'm sorry Rags. Ithi played so well. Must suck to be undermined by your dump spouting your team.

 

Gonna weep for you, promise.

This is really funny. 

 

Do you actually expect anyone to believe the desperate failings of scum when they're caught?

[csarmi]

Umm yea?

 

Rags you're conceding scum there ty. What a fail reaction.

 

 

I'm town. They might listen to me now... Or when I flip. I'm happy either way.

[Turin Turambar]

I don't see what the timing has to do with anything. 

 

I also don't see what the symp flip has to do with anything irt Ithi/Rags. What you saying that Thane gave a signal that the mafia picked up on? Not buying it. But w/e. You doing a good job spinning things for your team. 

 

Why do you think Thane would self hammer as mafia symp? that doesn't make much sense to me. I am having a wonder about that.

[Pralaya]

 

Oh yeah you're the new Ithi.

 

I'm sorry Rags. Ithi played so well. Must suck to be undermined by your dump spouting your team.

 

Gonna weep for you, promise.

This is really funny. 

 

Do you actually expect anyone to believe the desperate failings of scum when they're caught?

 

 

Caught? Where did Csarmi get "caught"? Also, why does this seem like trying to dismiss and reduce the importance of his analysis. 

[csarmi]

Who knows they may just read the thread.

[Pralaya]

 

Why do you think Thane would self hammer as mafia symp? that doesn't make much sense to me. I am having a wonder about that.

 

He probably expected Hallia to nullify his lynch?

[csarmi]

I don't see what the timing has to do with anything.

 

I also don't see what the symp flip has to do with anything irt Ithi/Rags. What you saying that Thane gave a signal that the mafia picked up on? Not buying it. But w/e. You doing a good job spinning things for your team.

 

Why do you think Thane would self hammer as mafia symp? that doesn't make much sense to me. I am having a wonder about that.

The timing means I wouldn't have been able to discuss with team.or check anything.

 

Anyway.

 

The symp flip means that Thane likely knew the Mafia team... And my take is that yes he would have been stupid enough to signal them that way.

 

See what I quoted. Or rather, start reading from page one.

[csarmi]

My guess is Thane wanted out by now. And limiting discussion time actually helps his team right.

 

I don't think he understands how crucial role he got.

[TheRagnarok]

Umm yea?

 

Rags you're conceding scum there ty. What a fail reaction.

 

 

I'm town. They might listen to me now... Or when I flip. I'm happy either way.

Hahahahaha.  You are too funny.  If that's what you got from my comment then all I can do is laugh.  Flail more.

 

 

 

Oh yeah you're the new Ithi.

 

I'm sorry Rags. Ithi played so well. Must suck to be undermined by your dump spouting your team.

 

Gonna weep for you, promise.

This is really funny. 

 

Do you actually expect anyone to believe the desperate failings of scum when they're caught?

 

 

Caught? Where did Csarmi get "caught"? Also, why does this seem like trying to dismiss and reduce the importance of his analysis. 

 

What analysis?  He is in desperation mode and is trying to reach for anything at this moment.  The only possible town thing he has going for him is his 'claim' which means nothing. 

 

If you do find his analysis important, then tell me what actual aspects you find worth paying attention to.

[csarmi]

I'm saying he didn't pick put Tina randomly from the lurkers and the three he named there are no coincidence either.

 

I may be wrong. Go ahead and analyze.

 

But make sure to read that crucial day one. If you can. Best if you do it yourself.

[Lenlo]

 

Len says he is pretty sure. He then gives exactly three scum reads. I would have expected to get 4 mafia spots or for him to say not sure on the fourth. food for thought I guess,

 

Len, how sure are you that they're both town? Because I can derail the thunder dome.

Im pretty sure. I dont think Ithi or Mynd are scum, I still think those spots belong to Chae, Thane and X.

 

Just saw this bit. Is there something wrong with "exactly" 3 scum reads on D1? Is there a way for them to be "approximate"? Id say thats a pretty good number for that early in the game. Also why were you expecting 4?

 

Pral please explain how thats important btw please.

[Pralaya]

What analysis?  He is in desperation mode and is trying to reach for anything at this moment.  The only possible town thing he has going for him is his 'claim' which means nothing. 

 

If you do find his analysis important, then tell me what actual aspects you find worth paying attention to.

 

 

Why do you think he is flailing?

 

He is on the right track trying to look at the symp link and where he was trying to signal. What is it that you don't agree with (other than the fact that he names you scum)?

[Pralaya]

Just saw this bit. Is there something wrong with "exactly" 3 scum reads on D1? Is there a way for them to be "approximate"? Id say thats a pretty good number for that early in the game. Also why were you expecting 4?

 

Pral please explain how thats important btw please.

 

 

With 16 members, the standard is 25%, which is 4 scum. Why would you think it is otherwise? Especially on D1?

A symp present changes things and it explains why you would make a slip that there are 3 scum. 

[Tsukibana]

Loving the sudden surge in activity.

 

@ Pral - your thought has merit, in my book.

 

@ CS - I still say we drop Chak, regardless of your read. "To close to this case" is what you would be told, were you a cop.

[Lenlo]

25% is a standard? Huh.

[TheRagnarok]

 

What analysis?  He is in desperation mode and is trying to reach for anything at this moment.  The only possible town thing he has going for him is his 'claim' which means nothing. 

 

If you do find his analysis important, then tell me what actual aspects you find worth paying attention to.

 

 

Why do you think he is flailing?

 

He is on the right track trying to look at the symp link and where he was trying to signal. What is it that you don't agree with (other than the fact that he names you scum)?

 

First of all, he is one of the people I named as scum along with Thane and Chae when I first joined the game and started reading.  So he is attacking his attacker.

 

Secondly, with the connections between himself, Thane and Chae...he knows that they are in a tight spot.

 

Third, his thread play has been hilariously scummy with his only perceived townie point being his claim which could be(and I think is) utter bull.

 

Fourth, a number of people have already connected the dots between those 3 and he knows it. 

 

Fifth, he is insinuating that Thane named all of his scummates as town in a single post. 

[csarmi]

quick post of thoughts, in general and from memory:

 

1. Thrax: townlean for the moment. solid, well thought of, explanatory posting.

2. Len: no idea... chae's gut feeling is usually right, but i haven't seen anything of him recently to believe he might be scum.

3. Mynd: yeah, still keeping my vote there. Call it bussing, i think there's a scummer right there.

4. Dawn: null, not in the game

5. Tina: started to get more active, which is good.

6. Turin: from what i saw, got a townfeel for him.

7. Despo: mixed feeling about that one. Could be scum, could be town... certainly wants me gone..

8. Hally: not much to go after... would've expected more by now (and not only sheeping on the obv target)

9. Chae: are gut feelings enough for a lynch? i dunno, i doubt it. But gut feelings can be right. Town for you for the moment.

10. Ithi: strongest townread in here.

11. Thane: is even town, yup (even if he has a really odd way to show it)

12. Tsuki: townread for now.

13. Dice: LD impression in this game, though didn't like the interaction with BFG.

14. Charis/BFG: Comes in with a focus on the obvious target, being me. Get the feeling she's going for an easy lynch with me. Scummy tingle.

15. Pral:made a few posts, soft claimed town PR, then vanished. Doubt it has to do with DM weekend

16. Salami: claimed miller fast: Follows Chae without further investigation.... have some problems buying his story

"Read list"

[csarmi]

No I'm saying that he called all his teammates as scum in one post.