[Standard] - Hitchhiker's Game to the Galaxy - Game Over

[Cory Caboose]

... Why would Des out himself to save Dice? Especially considering if Dice was lying about being the watcher he'd immediately be outed if anyone else targeted him. And I don't think Dice was being lynched today anyway, scummy threadplay or not.

[Cory Caboose]

It makes sense to me if Des was tracker and really weirded out Dice targeted himself. Why the fudge would a watcher target himself? Looks more like Des was trying to catch Dice in a lie

[Niniel]

But why did he insist on Dice claiming even though he asked Des if he really wanted his result?

[Cory Caboose]

 

It's your role, so as always you can choose what info you'd like to share or omit. But since you WERE one of the "persons of interest" this game, it would def behoove you to be upfront about who your target was at least.

 

 

I think Des was looking more for Dice's target, not Dice's result.

[Lazy]

I think i will nickname this moment as the double d.

[Cory Caboose]

there's inherent lulz already in the idea that the watcher saw the tracker track the watcher to the watcher

[Pralaya]

Yeah, I agree with Cory. Des wanted Dice to reply "I watched myself" and not who visited him. So that he can test him if he was really a watcher. 

[Niniel]

As if anyone would have believed that. No one think it´s strange that Dice and Des tries to clear each other? 

 

Who are your characters?

[Lazy]

Dice said he is slartibarfast already. Dont remember des claiming

[Cory Caboose]

As if anyone would have believed that. No one think it´s strange that Dice and Des tries to clear each other? 

 

Who are your characters?

 

Think about it like this:

 

If you were Des, and the tracker, and you targeted the claimed watcher and got a result back that says "Dice targeted himself"

 

What would you say in the thread?

[Lazy]

Who watches the watchmen.

[csarmi]

The mods watch over you all.

[Niniel]

 

As if anyone would have believed that. No one think it´s strange that Dice and Des tries to clear each other? 

 

Who are your characters?

 

Think about it like this:

 

If you were Des, and the tracker, and you targeted the claimed watcher and got a result back that says "Dice targeted himself"

 

What would you say in the thread?

 

 

Probably nothing. What scum role visits only himself? There might be some but I can´t remember any right now.

 

At least I would have stopped when Dice asked if he really wanted to know. 

 

Even though Dice had only said that he visited himself people would guess that Des was tracker if he accepted Dice answer. 

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

It's your role, so as always you can choose what info you'd like to share or omit. But since you WERE one of the "persons of interest" this game, it would def behoove you to be upfront about who your target was at least.

 

 

I think Des was looking more for Dice's target, not Dice's result.

 

 

This.

 

Dice, I've mulled it over and decided you're derptown instead of a scum Watcher.

 

First of all, self-targeting last night prob wasn't the best decision. Scum would have known that the sole PR claim would likely get protected, so wouldn't kill, and even if they had a BD'er to make sure you died, you wouldn't have lived to share your results anyways. Watching yourself was MUCH more likely to catch town PR's than potential scum (Doc protecting a potential PR, or Cop or some other investigative role making sure you weren't lying). If that was the plan, to figure out who else was town, then meh I wouldn't agree with it but w/e. But then OUTING said potential town PR like that? Le sigh.

 

After all, you knew you weren't blocked, so you knew I wasn't a RB'er or a killing role. Revealing that I targeted you was extremely antitown.

 

Ftr, I just wanted you to name your target to see if you would lie. Ideally, it would have been nice for you to tip me off that you saw me visit you without tipping off the rest of the thread, but I would have hoped you would go for something more subtle than "Are you SURE you want me to reveal that Des? winkwinknudgenudge".

[hazelkrs1]

And Tina, waaaay too early for tinfoiling. Just stahp.

[hazelkrs1]

Watching Nyn last night would have been grand, since I pointed out earlier she was a consensus villager read for pretty much everyone not named AJ. I even said she would prob be NK'ed last night- and I bet after seeing me say that scum prob killed her to try and frame me

[BFG]

 

i watched myself

 

Des came and visited me

 

Why the freak did you watch yourself???

 

Cat's outta the bag. Was hoping if Dice was town he wouldn't derp and out me like a tard.

 

I'm the Tracker. Dice DID visit himself last night. Thanks for outing me btw Dice.

 

 

This!

 

 

 

And can I check that I have this the right way round?

 

Tracker finds out where someone goes and a Watcher finds out who visits somebody?

[hazelkrs1]

Srsly tho, in search of more commentary on my Thane case. He is das scum.

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

i watched myself

 

Des came and visited me

 

Why the freak did you watch yourself???

 

Cat's outta the bag. Was hoping if Dice was town he wouldn't derp and out me like a tard.

 

I'm the Tracker. Dice DID visit himself last night. Thanks for outing me btw Dice.

 

 

This!

 

 

 

And can I check that I have this the right way round?

 

Tracker finds out where someone goes and a Watcher finds out who visits somebody?

 

 

 

 

 

Btw BFG, you're still on my scum list and you been sniping at me all game. Hows your read on me look now?

[BFG]

But why did he insist on Dice claiming even though he asked Des if he really wanted his result?

Once Dice asked Des if he REALLY wanted that result there wasn't really anywhere else for Des to go. By asking there was the chance Dice would just reveal his target.

[Leelou]

A scum watcher would watch themselves for that very reason, Des. To find town PRs.

[BFG]

 

 

 

i watched myself

 

Des came and visited me

 

Why the freak did you watch yourself???

 

Cat's outta the bag. Was hoping if Dice was town he wouldn't derp and out me like a tard.

 

I'm the Tracker. Dice DID visit himself last night. Thanks for outing me btw Dice.

 

 

This!

 

 

 

And can I check that I have this the right way round?

 

Tracker finds out where someone goes and a Watcher finds out who visits somebody?

 

 

 

 

 

Btw BFG, you're still on my scum list and you been sniping at me all game. Hows your read on me look now?

 

 

 

Thanks

 

 

 

My read on you now is that you're probably town. Tracking Dice makes sense from a town POV, not so sure I can understand a Watchers reasoning for watching themselves, but will wait for Dice to actually give it.

 

I kind of figured that I was still on your list, since you just said it and all

 

In what way have I been sniping?

[hazelkrs1]

 

But why did he insist on Dice claiming even though he asked Des if he really wanted his result?

Once Dice asked Des if he REALLY wanted that result there wasn't really anywhere else for Des to go. By asking there was the chance Dice would just reveal his target.

 

 

I could have backed off when Dice asked me if I really wanted him to reveal his target, which would have been incredibly stupid. Would have made me look ridiculously sketchy, and I would prob have been forced to claim anyways, and scum wouldve figured out that I targeted him.

 

I really thought my hints were subtle enough for scum but obvious enough for Dice to know I just wanted his target.

 

Anyways BFG, wanna answer my question?

 

A scum watcher would watch themselves for that very reason, Des. To find town PRs.

 

Obviously I know a scum Watcher might watch themselves - the question was obviously under the guise that he would present himself as town. Think of it like "Why would you, as town, watch yourself?"

 

Incidentally, what do you think bout all this Leelou? Think Dice is a scum Watcher? Think Tina is onto something, that me and Dice cleared each other cause we wanted to be the most obvious scumbuddies ever? What do you think about my Thane case?

[BFG]

 

 

But why did he insist on Dice claiming even though he asked Des if he really wanted his result?

Once Dice asked Des if he REALLY wanted that result there wasn't really anywhere else for Des to go. By asking there was the chance Dice would just reveal his target.

 

 

I could have backed off when Dice asked me if I really wanted him to reveal his target, which would have been incredibly stupid. Would have made me look ridiculously sketchy, and I would prob have been forced to claim anyways, and scum wouldve figured out that I targeted him.

 

I really thought my hints were subtle enough for scum but obvious enough for Dice to know I just wanted his target.

 

Anyways BFG, wanna answer my question?

 

A scum watcher would watch themselves for that very reason, Des. To find town PRs.

 

Obviously I know a scum Watcher might watch themselves - the question was obviously under the guise that he would present himself as town. Think of it like "Why would you, as town, watch yourself?"

 

Incidentally, what do you think bout all this Leelou? Think Dice is a scum Watcher? Think Tina is onto something, that me and Dice cleared each other cause we wanted to be the most obvious scumbuddies ever? What do you think about my Thane case?

 

Already did. And I guess whether or not you could have stopped is a matter of opinion.

 

Edit *could/should

[hazelkrs1]

@BFG: You're constantly bringing up little small things against me, contradictions you think you've found or something, without ever really coming @ me. It's more overt than Hallia's sniping, but still sniping nonetheless imo