[Advanced] Red Wedding Mafia - Post Game, MakersMark

[Yates]

 

 

okay Yates. and without quotes or anything, just notes.

Great.

 

So your top 3 scum in order are?

 

And your top 3 Town in order are?

 

 

I like this question on the surface, but if Red flips town, how much will you actually trust her reads?  You and Tommy have been blasting her play every chance you get.

 

I guess it depends on how much I agree or disagree with what she has to say about each person. If she makes a coherent and logical arguments based on actual game content? More than I can imagine I would be otherwise. I'm kind of lazy at heart. I'm not going to go chasing cases or links until it makes sense to do it. If she flips Town? I'll look at her top reads [at least] and compare them to how her wagon formed and consolidate that with whatever new information we have at the time.

 

The point of this exercise, though, is to have her state for the record what her strongest reads are given that she claims she doesn't want to "vote hop" or be "bullied" into voting for a stronger read. This is really a continuation of that discussion.

[WWWwombat]

I like your style.

 

##unvote; vote Mynd

 

ALL ABOARD!

 

##unvote

##Vote Mynd

[Yates]

Wait. Doesn't your read on Mynd require a scum flip from Red?

[Andrej]

Not in the least.

[WWWwombat]

Nope.  He's hedging/nudging.  Which is scummy regardless of Red's alignment.  Could be a scummate trying to distance without looking like bussing or a lone scum trying to get her lynched while on the opposite train.

[Cory Caboose]

CorryCurn is too busy at work to contribute but fully endorses Mynd CFD

[Andrej]

CorryCurn is too busy at work to contribute but fully endorses Mynd CFD

 

[Andrej]

Official Bloody Vote Count:

 

 

Verbalina (2/10): Len, Jack
Crayjay (1/10): Dice
Yates (1/10): Krak
Mistress (4/10): Mynd, NyanCat, Red, X
Red (7/10): Dawn, Nol, Tommy, Yates, Halleeloujah, MegaLoud, Verbalina
Cloud (1/10): Mistress

Mynd (2/10): Crayjay, Desbat

Not Voting (1/19):
Zen

20 Hours Remain

[hazelkrs1]

Alright, here to wreck this thread's face

 

[hazelkrs1]

Nope.  He's hedging/nudging.  Which is scummy regardless of Red's alignment.  Could be a scummate trying to distance without looking like bussing or a lone scum trying to get her lynched while on the opposite train.

 

Hey there other head. Fill me in while I continue reading up?

[Sedai]

 

Misused memes *shudder*

 

 

Much easier to look over 12 pages of jokes right before bedtime, than serious game.

 

Seriously though....why did you have to explain your apparent "joke post"? It has been my experience that mafia tend to OVER-explain things, including why they are posting some random picture that kinda-sorta has to do with the Red Wedding. Its like you are ready to jump on a bandwagon but there are no bandwagons to jump on yet.

 

Misheru = Scum

Agreed

 

 

On page 16.

 

AJ makes a long winded post agreeing and liking the votes and pressure on Mish. Dislikes red casting suspicion on Mish but not voting. Case of pot kettle.

 

3 scum down.

 

Page 19

 

I discovered Lenlo was LOCKCLEAR

 

Also don't have my usual strong townie vibe on womby, which is odd. Possibly due to hydra. Des seems town.

 

Nyn bread crumbs a defense for Dawn asking how many games has she been in.

 

Cloud is being thoughtful. That's a good sign.

 

Tess doesn't seem to be getting into the game

 

On to page 20.

 

Zanube posts for the second time. No actual game play.

 

Enter the Yates. Perpetuation spam and moving away from the actual playing of the game.

 

Red reaction fishing. In her meta. Null . Her posts have me feeling townie. However the interplay with AJ from earlier in the game is still not sitting well with me.

 

No read on tommy as of yet.

 

Page 21

 

Hallia's second post? Feel she's scum. Lets do some more reading.

 

Page 22

 

Hallia picks up on a Dawn post which actually seemed like a townie kind of post cause I think scum would be a little more hands on with her. It's Wifom regardless but I'm getting townie vibes from the dawn direction. Ergo Hallia seems to be more scummy for jumping at low hanging fruit.

 

Commenting on one half of a hydra. I feel obligated to talk about the other side. Leelou your playing a solid game.

 

Page 23

 

##unvote and vote mishtress

 

She basically said. Um tress is sharing this hydra and she's played great so we can't be scum. That's begging for a vote.

 

Page 24

 

AJ comes back with his whole gross Mish/red love triangle thing

 

X makes a long post. We have same read of Mish's post. Yet no vote. Hmmm

 

Townie vibe from Womby defending Dawn. I'll move you to a townie pile and work with you and des for now.

 

 

Page 25

 

Tommy keeps bringing up the goat thing. It's weird and raising flags.

 

Corey seems typical Corey from what I've saw up to this point. The whole "she's just young. Young people can't hide their alignment" that was bad and reaching.

 

I'm done with my reread for now.

[Sedai]

And just incase darthe didn't see it

 

 

 

##unvote ##vote mishtress

[Tommyrod]

That might be one of the scummier catchup posts I've seen lately.

[Yates]

That might be one of the scummier catchup posts I've seen lately.

Words from my mouth...

[Cory Caboose]

Normally I'd thunder Jack here for that alone

 

I still want to

 

Trying to be a better person

[Cory Caboose]

Jack - do you disagree that younger players typically have trouble tone-wise?

[Tommyrod]

I think you should do it. It's really bad. Plus, I wanna laugh.

[Verbal32]

 

 

 

I don't really have a huge issue with hydras in general.

I just think it's really stupid for a GOT/Red Wedding theme.

I'm all about theme and hydras just don't fit.

Captain america! HYDRA!

 

Beat me to it. I like Avengers better, though. More characters. Plus - I have a bromance with Coulson.

 

http://www.myndjack.com/forums/index.php?topic=7415.0

 

 

Loved that game.

[Verbal32]

That was the most painful catchup I've ever had to do.

[Verbal32]

Red, I love you.  Really.  But for the love of spiderman, no more colors within quotes!  It makes my brain melt, and I need to conserve what little is left of it.

[Sedai]

Jack - do you disagree that younger players typically have trouble tone-wise?

Younger with experience? No. They all usually sound scummy unless being coached until they can find their rhythm.

Younger in age? Never really saw a correlation. But also never really tried to look for it in that direction.

 

If you want to thunderdome you can. I don't mind. Haven't finished catching up past page 25. But that's what I'm thinking honestly.

 

Sorry if I wasn't drooling over you tommy and protesting how awesome and town you are. Cause the former I don't know you well enough. The later has you null to scum for me.

 

Other then you saying it's bad. Can you say why? And what reasons you have for it?

[Cory Caboose]

Tom I've jumped @ Jack's throat in nearly the exact same situation twice so far at DM and both time he's been town

 

He's Gary.

[Tommyrod]

I don't even know what he's saying. I read his last post ten times and can't wrap my head around what he's trying to say to us.

[Cory Caboose]

I'll go through some stuff when I get home from work

[Darthe]

I think I have enough info to break this game wide open.