[BASIC] Physics Mafia: GAME OVER, Town and Lenlo wins!

[dawnflower8]

I fused Nolder hasn't said much since day break. I was wrong. He built a case on Lenlo. Who's the we? When did I say anything about his role? That's very odd thing for you to say.

 

Chae

Vos

You after that potential slip

Lenlo

 

Lily

 

Dap

Nolder

Ice

Wolverine

Me

 

Top my best suspect pool for scum

 

Middle = neutral

 

Bottom my best reads for town

When I said "we," I was referring to myself and the majority of other players. Very few people (if anyone) seems to think you are scum.

[Tyler Glembo]

Vote Count

 

Dawn (2): Nolder, Chae

Chae (1): Jack_D

Nolder (1): Amega

Amega (1): Vos

 

Not Voting (6): Lily, Krak, IceKnight, Len, Dap, Dawn

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

Also, as you now know, Krak is replacing theWolverine.

[Sedai]

unvote and vote dawn

 

That seemed like a slip. Willing to follow this line of suspicions

[Krakalakachkn]

What's my connection with Amega? I don't think I have ever specifically talked to him, and I also don't even think I have mentioned him.

 

Other players linking you two, mainly Dap from what I've read.

[nervositee]

unvote and vote dawn

 

That seemed like a slip. Willing to follow this line of suspicions

 

Just to be clear, the slip you're refering to, is it "although we do think he's town"?

[Sedai]

 

 

unvote and vote dawn

 

That seemed like a slip. Willing to follow this line of suspicions

Just to be clear, the slip you're refering to, is it "although we do think he's town"?

No. It's referring to Nolder's role. Which no one ever mentioned

[Sedai]

 

 

1. It's an educated guess based off the number of players who started this game. And the apparent lack of a SK (serial killer)

 

2. Soft claim is when you hint at a role and don't actually claim it

 

3. It's his inactivity

 

4. Because I've been suspicious of her since day one and her couple of recent posts have been glorified fluff

 

5. Yeah they could. But this is a basic game so set ups are pretty standard. If someone claimed doc and was lying there would be a counterclaim and we'd have at least one gauranteed mafia

 

6. I never said I didn't think lily was scum. Said I have a neutral vibe there. Chae I think is scum based on over all play. I was wrong Nolder. He built a card on Lenlo and I've liked his gameplay. It's been very clean.

 

7. Agreed

 

8. You hadn't really done anything of note. Good observation though.

If someone soft claimed a role, it most likely means they are not a regular townsperson. Either they actually are the cop or scum trying to convince you they are not scum. What were you "wrong" about with Nolder? His role is not confirmed, although we do think he's town, he still could be scum. (I highly doubt it, though)

 

Besides Chae, who do you think seems the most scummy?

This pairs with earlier statements leads me to believe Dawn is mafia, mafia team shot Nolder. Nolder was protected. Mafia is unsure if Nolder is doc or doc got lucky.

 

Couple that with the rapid improvement in play. Makes me believe dawn is scum.

[LilyElizabeth]

Nice catch, Jack. 

 

Vote Dawn

[Lenlo]

Very nice. Anything to say about this Dawn?

[dapianoplay3r]

I've missed the last few lynches cos they have happened about an hour before I wake each day.

 

I will hold off my vote until dawn replies, avoiding ninja hammers and all that jazz

[Krakalakachkn]

Nice catch, Jack. 

 

Vote Dawn

 

Anything to add?

[LilyElizabeth]

Nope. I didn't see her as mafia, but that slip is hard to miss.

[Nolder]

I wasn't casing Lenlo because I think he's scum btw.

Just want to clear that up. As you can see my vote is elsewhere.

 

I was just doing it to do it.

No one plays a perfect game and it's important to keep in mind who has done what.

[Sedai]

I wasn't casing Lenlo because I think he's scum btw.

Just want to clear that up. As you can see my vote is elsewhere.

 

I was just doing it to do it.

No one plays a perfect game and it's important to keep in mind who has done what.

I know. I just saw the case and rectified my post about you where I said you hadn't said much.

[dawnflower8]

Very nice. Anything to say about this Dawn?

Ehh, I honestly don't care whether you vote me off or not. 

 

 

 

unvote and vote dawn

 

That seemed like a slip. Willing to follow this line of suspicions

Just to be clear, the slip you're refering to, is it "although we do think he's town"?

No. It's referring to Nolder's role. Which no one ever mentioned

 

I think multiple other players have said that they think Nolder is town, with the exception of Amega. 

[dapianoplay3r]

Apathy is never a good look dawn

Would you like to try again?

[iceknight27377]

unvote wolverine. vote nolder. i have accused him before, and accusing him i am again. (Mainly cuz everything he says is talking everyone + he gives really long posts which makes him suspicious) 

[dawnflower8]

unvote wolverine. vote nolder. i have accused him before, and accusing him i am again. (Mainly cuz everything he says is talking everyone + he gives really long posts which makes him suspicious) 

How does long posts = suspicious? Please explain your reasoning for this. All you do is give random accusations that make no sense. This is really the first reason that you've ever gave for why you think someone is a mafia, and it's not a very good reason. And what does "everything he says is talking everyone" supposed to mean? I honestly didn't think you were scum at first, but now I'm starting to think otherwise because of this dumb reasoning. 

[Nolder]

He might mean talking down.

I do do that sometime although it's rarely intentional.

Just kind of happens when I'm in "lecture" mode you know?

[iceknight27377]

Ok, didn't all of you kinda expect that i would vote nolder? 

 

 

unvote wolverine. vote nolder. i have accused him before, and accusing him i am again. (Mainly cuz everything he says is talking everyone + he gives really long posts which makes him suspicious) 

How does long posts = suspicious? Please explain your reasoning for this. All you do is give random accusations that make no sense. This is really the first reason that you've ever gave for why you think someone is a mafia, and it's not a very good reason. And what does "everything he says is talking everyone" supposed to mean? I honestly didn't think you were scum at first, but now I'm starting to think otherwise because of this dumb reasoning. 

 

GOOD POINT!

[iceknight27377]

Dawn, you think i am the mafia?

[dawnflower8]

Dawn, you think i am the mafia?

Maybe. 

 

He might mean talking down.

I do do that sometime although it's rarely intentional.

Just kind of happens when I'm in "lecture" mode you know?

Is that considered a scummy thing to do, though?

[iceknight27377]

no. not really. unvote nolder

[iceknight27377]

Eb would be a good mafia

[iceknight27377]

i know shes not playing, but she would be