[Advanced] Star Wars Thrawn Mafia, Heir To The Empire, Town and 3rd party win

[Niniel]

I can rarely read Des (or anyone else) the first days. A made up case is still a made up case. 

[Darthe]

Pretty much, he always looks scummy.  The best way to pick him out is to frustrate him over time (also how to get him killed when you're mafia) or to overwhelm him early on so that he makes mistakes.

[Cory Caboose]

vote Nolder

 

Ty!!!

 

Tommy I have salami, despot, puppets & darthe looking town. Someone made an OP I liked as well - tell me who for bonus mindmeld points

 

Who have you played with here before?

Hey modders I'm totes on Nolder

 

No accidental hammer plz

[peacesells]

Why does people say that Des looks town? He is just making up reasons for voting Csarmi, who is obviously town. 

 

Vote Des

 

 

Didn´t like TGs fence sitting post. 

 

 

He makes up cases every game.  He's null so far in my eyes.

[Cory Caboose]

Des is no chimneysweep but I've seen Salami as Maf for 2 day ones and both he was far more conservative

 

My meta read and tone read of playing with Salami is obv superior to Des lifetime of Salami play

[Tommyrod]

I can rarely read Des (or anyone else) the first days. A made up case is still a made up case.

 

Is that scummy though?

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

 

vote Nolder

Ty!!!

Tommy I have salami, despot, puppets & darthe looking town. Someone made an OP I liked as well - tell me who for bonus mindmeld points

Who have you played with here before?

Hey modders I'm totes on Nolder

No accidental hammer plz

please review the voting rules

[WolfbrotherKronos]

Why does people say that Des looks town? He is just making up reasons for voting Csarmi, who is obviously town. 

 

Vote Des

 

 

Didn´t like TGs fence sitting post. 

 

 

How is Csarmi obviously town - you can't be sure of anyone's alignment.

 

This one doesn't sit well with me.

 

vote tina

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Vote count:

 

Des (2) Cory, Tina

Csarmi (3) Des, GE, Nolder

Nolder (4) Tommy, darthe, peace, Turin

TG (1) csarmi

Tina (1) Kronos

 

Not voting (5): everyone else

 

No DL yet.

 

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

[Niniel]

 

I can rarely read Des (or anyone else) the first days. A made up case is still a made up case.

Is that scummy though?

 

 

I would say yes. In fact - I´ll say yes. Do you think it´s something townies should do? Do you think it proves Des to be town?

[Niniel]

 

Why does people say that Des looks town? He is just making up reasons for voting Csarmi, who is obviously town. 

 

Vote Des

 

 

Didn´t like TGs fence sitting post. 

 

 

How is Csarmi obviously town - you can't be sure of anyone's alignment.

 

This one doesn't sit well with me.

 

vote tina

 

 

Ehm... show me any game here at DM where scum has started with a claim (lie detector proof) on day 1. And as other have pointed out, Csarmi usually plays more focused when he is scum. 

[WolfbrotherKronos]

 

 

Why does people say that Des looks town? He is just making up reasons for voting Csarmi, who is obviously town. 

 

Vote Des

 

 

Didn´t like TGs fence sitting post. 

 

 

How is Csarmi obviously town - you can't be sure of anyone's alignment.

 

This one doesn't sit well with me.

 

vote tina

 

 

Ehm... show me any game here at DM where scum has started with a claim (lie detector proof) on day 1. And as other have pointed out, Csarmi usually plays more focused when he is scum. 

 

 

Doesn't change the fact that the only people who know who is town is the mafia - obviously town =/= I think is town.

[Tommyrod]

vote Nolder

Ty!!!

Tommy I have salami, despot, puppets & darthe looking town. Someone made an OP I liked as well - tell me who for bonus mindmeld points

Who have you played with here before?

I would guess it's Prae

 

Cory your town list looks good so far

 

I can comment on people I know when I'm home in three hours or thereabouts

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

 

I can rarely read Des (or anyone else) the first days. A made up case is still a made up case.

 

Is that scummy though?

 

I would say yes. In fact - I´ll say yes. Do you think it´s something townies should do? Do you think it proves Des to be town?

I've played with Des five or ten times now, I think

 

He does the over-reaching as either alignment

 

But he seems to not be at all restrained about it here so I'm leaning town

 

I find your stance surprising since you should have even more experience with Des than I do

 

He's hard to read but I didn't expect you to get @ him and not talk about Nolder at all

 

What do you make of the case for Nolder?

[Cory Caboose]

I'M ON A COMPUTER NOW!!!!

[Cory Caboose]

 

vote Nolder

Ty!!!

Tommy I have salami, despot, puppets & darthe looking town. Someone made an OP I liked as well - tell me who for bonus mindmeld points

Who have you played with here before?

I would guess it's Prae

 

Cory your town list looks good so far

 

I can comment on people I know when I'm home in three hours or thereabouts

 

IT WAS PRAE!

 

Cause DGAF, yaknow. His second post was good too, if he posted some more he could be LOCK CLEAR.

 

I don't think Nolder would think the way he thinks if he were town

[Tommyrod]

Agreed

 

At this point I think Nolder is outed and I'm observing how people respond to that

 

Tina ignoring it is #notagoodlook

[Cory Caboose]

Nolder, GE, TG & Tina

 

ez life

[Cory Caboose]

Tom's town

 

mindmeld 4eva & eva

[Niniel]

 

 

 

I can rarely read Des (or anyone else) the first days. A made up case is still a made up case.

Is that scummy though?

 

I would say yes. In fact - I´ll say yes. Do you think it´s something townies should do? Do you think it proves Des to be town?

I've played with Des five or ten times now, I think

 

He does the over-reaching as either alignment

 

But he seems to not be at all restrained about it here so I'm leaning town

 

I find your stance surprising since you should have even more experience with Des than I do

 

He's hard to read but I didn't expect you to get @ him and not talk about Nolder at all

 

What do you make of the case for Nolder?

 

 

People put Des on their town lists. I have not seen anything that convinces me that he is town. I believe Csarmi to be town and I think Des made a crappy case on him. 

 

Not sure about Nolder. The "vote inactives" is his thing. 

[Cory Caboose]

Yeah but Des had dat town!passion, you know? It wasn't mechanical. Scum v Town is always logical & mechanical, at least from experience it usually is pretty heavy and Despot is a strong player but it's very hard to fake that effectively.

 

So Tina you are NULL on Nolder?

[Niniel]

 

 

 

Why does people say that Des looks town? He is just making up reasons for voting Csarmi, who is obviously town. 

 

Vote Des

 

 

Didn´t like TGs fence sitting post. 

 

 

How is Csarmi obviously town - you can't be sure of anyone's alignment.

 

This one doesn't sit well with me.

 

vote tina

 

 

Ehm... show me any game here at DM where scum has started with a claim (lie detector proof) on day 1. And as other have pointed out, Csarmi usually plays more focused when he is scum. 

 

 

Doesn't change the fact that the only people who know who is town is the mafia - obviously town =/= I think is town.

 

 

You don´t believe that Csarmi is town? To me it´s obvious that he is town. 

[Niniel]

Yeah but Des had dat town!passion, you know? It wasn't mechanical. Scum v Town is always logical & mechanical, at least from experience it usually is pretty heavy and Despot is a strong player but it's very hard to fake that effectively.

 

So Tina you are NULL on Nolder?

 

Yeh. 

[WolfbrotherKronos]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Why does people say that Des looks town? He is just making up reasons for voting Csarmi, who is obviously town.

 

Vote Des

 

 

Didn´t like TGs fence sitting post.

 

How is Csarmi obviously town - you can't be sure of anyone's alignment.

 

This one doesn't sit well with me.

 

vote tina

Ehm... show me any game here at DM where scum has started with a claim (lie detector proof) on day 1. And as other have pointed out, Csarmi usually plays more focused when he is scum.

Doesn't change the fact that the only people who know who is town is the mafia - obviously town =/= I think is town.

You don´t believe that Csarmi is town? To me it´s obvious that he is town.

I do believe he is town...the difference between my statement and yours is that I can't be sure if he's town. You're saying you know he is.

[Darthe]

 

Why does people say that Des looks town? He is just making up reasons for voting Csarmi, who is obviously town. 

 

Vote Des

 

 

Didn´t like TGs fence sitting post. 

 

 

How is Csarmi obviously town - you can't be sure of anyone's alignment.

 

This one doesn't sit well with me.

 

vote tina

 

 

This post doesn't sit well with me.  Semantic tells are shown to not work.  You aren't picking at her game or thoughts, you're picking at her phrasing.  unvote vote WBK

 

Tom's town

 

mindmeld 4eva & eva

 

Already know