Clash of Divinity - Advanced Mafia - Day 7 - Reckoning

[Tommyrod]

Turin recruited Chaelca N1

Dice recruited Rags N1

Get @ me

Maybe it actually was Chael

[Tommyrod]

Dap tell me what you're bringing to the table

 

I still think you're a god candidate

[Darthe]

@Tom, who are the other two if you had to guess?

@EVERYONE, town/scum list.  Don't include yourself like a weirdo, it looks scummy even though it logically isn't.

 

 

Dice

Tommy

GF
Golden

Dap

Hally

Ley

Chaelca

Rag

 

Include those areas that you had an issue with.  I, for instance, realized when making this list that between golden dap and hally I had no real clue about any of them.  They aren't just my null section, they've really not been relevant and so most of my reads on them are Meta.  Golden is just not as active as usual when scum and Dap is less... involved than I would expect of him but he doesn't feel right so he ended up lower.  Likewise, the disparity between Ley and Chael is something I struggled with.  Not wholely certain why.  

[Tommyrod]

Darthe can you tell me with confidence that Dice's play D1 was his town self, and can you maybe show me some examples of him doing that in other games?

 

I'm reluctant to say that he's for sure a town cop instead of a god who somehow interacted with Turin last night.

[Tommyrod]

I would probably swap Dap and Ley on your list. I get why you have Rags on the bottom but keep in mind I don't know if your results are real or not.

[Tommyrod]

I said Dice/Dap/Turin gods when I first scanned the game.

 

I'd hope I'm right about at least 2 of them, so Dap would be my next guess.

[Tommyrod]

I have no idea what Hallia thinks she is doing in this game since she claimed she has no night ability.

[Tommyrod]

I wonder if the recruits have abilities.

[GoldeneyesND]

Dice- confirmed himself with Turin

Tommy

Dap

GF

Ley 

Hally

Chaelca

Rag/Darthe- One is town one is scum. Whomever is not scum is at the top of this list ^.

 

Darthe- At one point in time here I was in 5 games and in feuds with Csarmi, Mish and Tommy in three separate games. It almost made me want to stop playing altogether. I'm a little burnt out, but yeah I understand what you mean. Also, starting to find that trolling and being super aggressive means I have less fun in games overall.

[Tommyrod]

Hey Golden what gives you a town lean on Dap?

 

He just seems so damn scummy to me in D1

[Hallia]

I think I'm playing a game! ^_^

[Tommyrod]

I think I'm playing a game! ^_^

Lol

 

Hallia post your list please

 

Just like Darthe and Golden did

[Hallia]

Meeeee

Dice

GF

Darthe

Tommy

Goldy

Ley

Dap

Rags/Chael

[GoldeneyesND]

Hey Golden what gives you a town lean on Dap?

 

He just seems so damn scummy to me in D1

 

Dap wasn't really a case of pushing him up the list. I just kept pushing others further down and he wound up where he wound up. I don't find him particularly townie though. Below you, dice and whomever is not lying between Darthe/Rags I find everyone to be muddled shades of scummy.

[Hallia]

And if ya don't like me not having an ability take it up with the mod who gave me vanilla!

[Tommyrod]

And if ya don't like me not having an ability take it up with the mod who gave me vanilla! [/quote

 

Why am I lower than GF?

Meeeee

Dice

GF

Darthe

Tommy

Goldy

Ley

Dap

Rags/Chael

 

Why am I scummier than GF?

 

What did Chael do to get lowest on your list?

[Hallia]

You claims might as well be on the same line.  

 

So right below you is where the water gets murky

 

Were those two not recruited?

[Hayl3y]

Also, i want to have ur ideas about what happens to minions after a god/their god would die. So it would be easier to judge the size of the opposing party.

 

then my list (most suspicious up)

 

Rag - was my last vote

Dap/Darthe - one must be town though

Hally/Ley/Golden - They didn't post enough for me to judge yet

Tommy/GF/Dice - regarding to the claims i don't want to sacrifice resources

 

seeing it's late i'll try to give more material tomorrow but so you have my list

[Tommyrod]

You claims might as well be on the same line.  

 

So right below you is where the water gets murky

 

Were those two not recruited?

I don't know if they were recruited.

 

I forgot GF claimed before I asked you that question.

 

Things are getting confusing!

 

Who would you kill tonight if you could?

[Hallia]

 

Turin recruited Chaelca N1

Dice recruited Rags N1

Get @ me

Maybe it actually was Chael

 

 

 

^ That's why, I thought you were stating fact.

 

 

Probably Rags.

[dapianoplay3r]

Dap tell me what you're bringing to the table

I still think you're a god candidate

do you mean my role claim?

Also I'm not here right now cos I work weekend nights

Today though I've got to drive down (2hourz) to my sisters engagement party

I'll be on my phone briefly

[dapianoplay3r]

As for my list

 

Hally is being scummy as all hell.

Rags I think is scummy but I distrust Darthe more

Darthes claim is odd from the begining. From the moment he claimed I've explained why it seems off.

Chael is nowhere in particular for me, but she is an easy recruit.

Ley, nothing really ATM

Tom, think the claim is BS but playing a good game in the town direction

Dice, cop claim, somewhat verified. Best town going into tonight

Me town

Gf, claimed useful, play not really

Golden, pretty solid going into the night

 

Golden, dice, Darthe, tom

Likeliest recruits tonight

(Mwtly due to roles possessed )

[Darthe]

Darthe can you tell me with confidence that Dice's play D1 was his town self, and can you maybe show me some examples of him doing that in other games?

 

I'm reluctant to say that he's for sure a town cop instead of a god who somehow interacted with Turin last night.

 

Sounds like a lot of work while I am modding but yes =p  Gimme a day or so.

[Leyrann]

Reads:

 

Turin - A bit spamhappy with memes at the start, but I suppose I can't blame him for that, with that glorious thread we have here. Going too hard on the setup talk in my opinion, considering nothing else was going on. It may also be worth noting that two of the three people Turin has called out for setup talking have already flipped town. I'm not sure if we can really make anything from that though. What I don't like is that he is attacking people on "voting lurking GF when GF lurked with an important role recently". That should be out of the question for this game. It's not the fault of the voter if an important town role gets lynched due to inactiveness or lurking. And then "Golden, if you want to talk setup by all means go ahead. " That sounds a lot different from before to me. It's still day 1, but at once talking about setup isn't a mafia read anymore, but just something Turin doesn't agree with. A few posts later: "AJ you did say that I was saying everything you do is a mafia tell. To me that is kind of the definition of tunnelling.". Well, the only one who you've called out for actions has been, at this point, AJ, and one time him together with others. "I would think you would vote for in game reasons over mets reasons." I'd say the same holds true when defending someone... I suppose that all is outdated now.

 

Chae - Not sure. I don't know how much I should exactly expect from a new player. I suppose that is because I simply haven't played enough the recent months and therefore can't remember a lot of new players...

 

Darthe - Stepped up his play a lot D2. D1 he seemed troll(ish) to me, but I liked his D2. And it simply makes sense that we get a mafia or I don't know what kind of anti-town from lynching Rags, as it would indeed be Darthe if it isn't Rags.

 

Rags - I don't really know. He doesn't look particulary townie or scummy to me, but has been arguing a lot against Darthe about what I believe is very simple - Lynch the one that is claimed to have given an untrustworthy result, if it is false, lynch the one that made the claim.

 

GF -  Saying "Literally was last mafia 2 years ago," is enough to make you raise 3 spots on my mafia list. Just saying. Also for someone who's been playing for at least two years you seem to know pretty little about how a cult/recruiting game works... On top of that you're contributing next to 0 to the scumhunt. Conclusion: I don't like you. At all. After the Darthe/Rags wifom has been handled?

 

Hallia - This can indeed be true, but is not in your case.

 

Dap - I feel like he is stretching a bit sometimes in going against Darthe when he attacks Rags. Mostly the Darthe making up and Rags not claiming a role that would explain Darthe's result (ever seen anyone claim mirror? Neither did I, and I don't expect to ever see it either. And now don't fake claim it to prove me wrong). Slight scum read. Not high priority though, considering I am far from sure about it.

 

Chuckles/Tom - Whoa that's a lot of activity. I don't believe that Vig claim, but it sure was a good way to get the game rolling hard. Leaning town, but I can see your play for a mafia trying to hide behind a lot of offense too. So, leaning town, but not ruling out the possiblity you're scum. I trust you, for now (though I suppose that holds true anyways in a recruit game).

 

Golden - Not super active, but playing well when posting. Leaning town.

 

Dice - Either town and cop or a god who in some way found out Turin was a god (which I don't expect). And as he said, he indeed implied it a bit earlier already.

[Tommyrod]

 

Dap tell me what you're bringing to the table

I still think you're a god candidate

do you mean my role claim?

Also I'm not here right now cos I work weekend nights

Today though I've got to drive down (2hourz) to my sisters engagement party

I'll be on my phone briefly

I was talking more about thread play than role claiming. Despite how it may look I'm not a big fan of role claims.

 

I am a fan of bluffs though :P