[Advanced] French Revolution Mafia - Day 3

[John E. Kelley]

I'm still feeling best about an Ishy lynch. I get that he's not feeling the pressure, fine, that's Ishy. But he could still give some explanation as to some of the things people have questioned him over, like being so certain about Mish, for one.

This was already asked and answered, long ago.

[dapianoplay3r]

If you have 0 bread today, you will die tomorrow morning

[Krakalakachkn]

 

If I live long enough, I'll try to put together a real case on Ishy after my appointments today.

Any excuse you can find to check me out eh?

 

 

Who are you thinking today?

[John E. Kelley]

 

 

If I live long enough, I'll try to put together a real case on Ishy after my appointments today.

Any excuse you can find to check me out eh?

Who are you thinking today?

I don't even know who's still alive.

[nervositee]

I'm actually leaning more and more towards an Ishy-lynch too. I get his coy answers and all that, but his complete lack of contribution to the town-team makes him look iffy.

 

Do we have a doc thats alive by the way, that wants to come forth? One confirmed townie would be nice, and make it easier to read alot of the previous game. I realize some scum might take advantage of the fact that we got three dead without a report and take a opportunistic gamble on a fake-claim, so everything with a grain of salt. But still, worth throwing out there I guess. This is do or die, LYLO, and unless the baker has been very good at sniffing out who to give bread to, some of us are starting to get pretty hungry here at the barricades   

[John E. Kelley]

What I do know though, is that it's pretty scummy to start throwing votes around this quickly at LYLO. Know who does that?

 

Scum.

[LilyElizabeth]

 

If I live long enough, I'll try to put together a real case on Ishy after my appointments today.

Any excuse you can find to check me out eh?

 

 

You know it, sexy one!

[nervositee]

Heh, first of all, that is your reply to that you have been completely absent from playing on towns side this game? A quick shot at the player who pointed it out?

 

However, I'll give you the first sentence right. Its überscummy, not to mention incredibly stupid to cast a vote RIGHT at the start of day 1, I'm not gonna bother saying otherwise.

 

The vote on Lily, on my behalf—and probably from Krak judging by his comment on her in his read—was pure frustration. That town is in big trouble, we lynched a VT, there are so many players not contributing, and I'm sure there is a party in the Mafia-QT. My one certain scum-read turned out to be wrong. For a while I was very ready to just have everyone hammer Lily, if we're right - great, if we are wrong, then we lose, and eff' it all. 

 

But eyh, lets all chip in here.

 

Unvote

[LilyElizabeth]

You're right, Ishy. That was a bad move. I'll Unvote until after I case you. We can't afford to make a mistake right now. 

[John E. Kelley]

Watch 'em scramble.

 

Vos and Lily, Krak. There's two.

[Krakalakachkn]

That was seriously like, textbook.

 

 

Nice play Ishy.

[LilyElizabeth]

This is what I get for agreeing with you.

[LilyElizabeth]

I'm not going to have time today to do a whole reread, but I'll do what I can. 

[LilyElizabeth]

A couple of those weird "I'm sure they're town" posts. 

 

 

 

Stop being dense. Des was Town, he copy-pasted his role pm. Debating his alignment is ridiculous.

 
Did he? Are you positive of that? I am not.

Yes, he did. He was vanilla town.

 

 

 

 

I'm gonna say it, I agree with Mish on the AJ - Hallia thing, I read it as AJ was scum rather than anything on Hallia. I won't belabor it because AJ isn't here, but I think anyone voting Mish for that reason is wrong.

Mish is definitely Town. Anyone voting for her at this point is pushing an agenda.

 

 

 

Okay, I was wrong. Thanks for your breakdown Lils, it made everything clear.

Vote GF.

 

Still don't get how I made things clear for him. Another weird post. 

 

Vote Turin.

For tunneling.

 

Votes Turin on a weak reason

 

There's your mistake big guy. I simply don't care about any heat on me. Never did.

As for my flip flop on Lily? She's hot. Sue me. Haven't spent a second thinking about it.

Carry on.

 

Admits he doesn't care about the heat. 

 

All game (until the last little bit) Ishy has been apathetic about whether he lives or dies. I think that's because he's scum for the (what is it?) 10th time in a row. Now that he sees the win in sight, he suddenly cares. My vote will go back on Ishy. 

[LilyElizabeth]

Know what else I learned? This game is pitifully short on content. I read all the way from the reset. Didn't take long at all. 

[nervositee]

That was seriously like, textbook.

 

 

Nice play Ishy.

 

 

Yes Ishy, we scrambled because we realized that it was a bloody stupid move to start throwing out votes at Lylo. 

 

Krak has been one of the best scum-hunters in this game. If you walk into his easy trap for me who is a relatively new player, and Lily, who I'm thinking right now is laughing her ass off with Ishy in the QT, I might throw my last bread at you, sorry. 

 

I'm 99% sure at least one of them is scum. I'm not certain enough who to say for sure yet though. I like the two posts above from her, even though it can be you two distancing like crazy to make sure one of you is lynched and the other is home free together with one inactive player.  

[Hallia]

I'm with you on this Nervie.  It seems less like scum scrambling, moreso townies making a pro-town move.  We have pleennnty of time.

[John E. Kelley]

So you're saying with a straight face that you think Lily's Town Hobbit?

 

Scum number three. Number four want to make it as obvious as your teammates did?

[nervositee]

By the way, Ishy. 15 people from start = probably 4 scum. We're 8 left at LYLO which means there is 5 town and 3 scum.

 

Which means at least one, maybe two are flying completely under the radar. Lily has a point with the pityful amount of usable content from the reset, and a lot of people have been posting very little. I'll post up my thoughts in a sec. 

[Hallia]

I didn't say that, lemme post this reread info.

 

 

And I really mean that: if the famine wasn't mentioned in your pm, and you're a townie: come out and say so.  It would make the basel-case kinda moot.

 

 

Peace

 

For keeping on pushing about this non-issue, hoping for a reveal. Which would ONLY be advantageous for mafia.

 

^ This is the only thing that really stood out pre-gameblowout.  Thorum calling out peace for 'hoping for a reveal' right after asking people to reveal.

 

 

After all that's gone on, I've forgotten what I thought about any of you before. I was focused on the Yates/Des/AJ stuff, I'm sure. I also feel that Mish's lynch will give us the best info. 

 

Vote Mish

 

 

 

I'm going to have to make time to go back and look. I already said I don't remember much of what went on before the craziness started. I do remember that Mish had quite a few votes on her, which is why I thought she'd give us information. I agree that my lynch would do the same. If y'all think that's the way to go, I don't really have any problem with it. 

 

Mish, I'll try to find time today to answer your question. 

 

Lily went from saying that Mish would still be the best info lynch to not remembering what info she could provide.

[Hallia]

So I find Thorum a great candidate, but I'd like to hear what Turin has to say now that he's in slot.

[nervositee]

04. Ishy - Done nothing for town all game, being coy and cheeky but nothing more. Then throws out an easy leg to trip me and/or Lily to either manage to push a lynch on me so mafia wins, done and done - or lynch Lily, which either also ends the game or give him some real town-cred for finding the first mafia, both saving him and probably placing him where he can dictating the next lynch. If we are 5/3 now, and find mafia, then a night kill, we're 4/2, and if Ishy manages to put himself at the steering wheel by bussing Lily, a town-lynch 3/2 and a nightkill 2/2 and boom, mafia wins. On the other hand, there is a possibility he is just playing the most lazy game ever, saw what he thought might be a scum-slip and just decided that whatever, lets just pursue that and make me look active. But then again, if he is playing the most lazy town-game ever, does get lynched and make town lose, then so be it. 

05. Lily - Using self-meta-defence for the whole of D1, claiming she never "digs her teeth in" before d2. Votes Mish without quite remembering why, but thinks it'll be a nice info-lynch. Gives analyzing it a shot, but comes out quite empty-handed. Looks to Turin but immediately clears him off when she remembered he jumped off it at last second, then claimed that it didn't clear him, then jumps back on him. Seems like her opinions are a bit all over the place and she's working hard on following the line of thought that'll make her look most like town, which of course makes her look more scum.
06. Thorum Turin - Awkward self-contradiction on the reveal-thing. Other than that not that much to go on. Hopefully Turin can chip in again. And of course I'm hesitant to go running "Turins back, lets kill Turin one more time and see if it works now". 
07. Nerv
08. Hally - Strange buddying with Lily early-game, but anything on her is grasping at straws. Also some typical self-meta defence. However, my gut says if she was scum she would have "tried harder", but just a gut-feel. Null-leaning-town. 
09. Krak - Played a good game and actively scumhunting. Seems like a suprisingly easy pushover to Ishy's cocky "look here, I got your answer". But I'm leaning town, even my threat of bread-throwing still stands.  
14. Alanna - Strong advocate for the Mish-info-lynch, even though it gave us no info whatsoever. Defending Lily, although delivering a solid ISO for doing so. Still alot of silly self-meta-defending though, both of herself and Lily. Always being very clear that she would "be okay with a Lily lynch, but I want to lynch Mish". Could be soft distancing? Then goes after Ishy, which is fine. She does so while the Turin-train (heh) is rolling, and ends up voting for Turin, so again, might be a distancing-move, but that is a farther stretch. But I do like her posts and cases, it seems like she is actively trying to catch scum. So null-with-town-lean-ish. 
15. Graendals Fav - 28 posts over 41 pages, most of which has no real content at all, except for delivering the hammers. Might be trying to lay low while still "participating". Could be lazyness or busyness. Offered no clear opinions on anyone. Came with some cryptic comments about a role after the last lynch, but still not sure what to make of that

 

-

 

Some thoughts at least. I'm leaning on Ishy for todays lynch actually, but I'd rather be as certain as I can (now that we decided hammering Lily in the first hour of lylo-day wasn't the best option ;)). Anyone else have any thoughts on who mafia #2 and #3 is?

[LilyElizabeth]

I'm going to come clean before this gets out of hand. I'm not vt. I'm a 3rd party survivor. Lynch me and I obviously lose, but so will you. I've been scumhunting all game, and I'm still doing so. I don't like Ishy's push to lynch me at all. It reeks of scum trying to win the game quickly. 

[LilyElizabeth]

Or another way of putting it, he's seeing my lynch slip out of his hands along with the quick victory and he's scrambling. 

[Turin Turambar]

So you're saying with a straight face that you think Lily's Town Hobbit?

 

Scum number three. Number four want to make it as obvious as your teammates did?

Ironic post is ironic