[Advanced] Settlers of Catan Mafia - Game Over

[BFG]

 

 

 

If I die, Verbal did it.

 

If Darthe dies, Leelou did it.

 

If Despo dies, Nolder did it.

 

If Verbal dies, Ishy did it.

 

If Leelou dies, Despo did it.

 

If Ishy dies, whoever let him sleep on his back did it.

 

 

:feels left out:

 

 

I'm just kidding that's not Ishy's real role and he's not modkilled I'm just really bored and Monday can't come soon enough. /trollmod

 

It's Monday here :off to work sadface:

 

 

Sorry, I haven't played with you so I can't predict who would kill you.  I might be able to tell a few days in though.

 

 

(feels better)

 

Not sure I can keep up with the witty banter.

[hazelkrs1]

Brain is scrambled right now, will have to give my thoughts later tonight.

[_CLOUD]

I don't really see the case on Leelou tbh. I didn't read her actions as serious as Wombat has been presenting them in his case on her.

 

 

I could go for Blackhoof. He checks in to the game and votes me because he doesn't get a good feeling from me. Leelou has already remarked that it sounds like a weak excuse for blatant bandwagoning.

 

 

 

She's been fake scumhunting.

 

fake scumhunting?

 

to be fair, that is what we are all doing....

 

 

The interesting bit here is that he immediately starts defending Leelou after Wombat mentioned that she has been fake scumhunting. I also don't get Blackhoof's comment on fake scumhunting, but that isn't really important. The important thing here is that he feels the need to start defending someone right out of the gate, and it gives me the feeling that he knows that Leelou is town.

 

 

unvote

vote Leelou

 

 

why vote me for such a transparently obvious fake-buddy? if I was a mafia legitimately trying to buddy I would deserve being lynched for that "attempt" hahaha

 

In his next post he votes for Leelou while he had just been defending her, and talks about how he was obviously fake-buddying in his previous post, and that if he was mafia he would deserve being lynched for that sorry attempt. He is acknowledging Leelou's comment about him buddying to her, and is trying to downplay it instead of dismissing the idea and state that it wasn't his intention to come across that way and maybe even call her out on misinterpretation, which is something I could see a townie doing.

 

 

 

And he starts with the "why me" posts. 

 

not at all. I was merely musing that it is suspicious that you would OMGUS me for "buddying" when it was clearly not a serious attempt to do so. 

are you trying to deflect from Cloud, perhaps? protect your scum buddy that you perhaps arranged this whole banter with?

 

hmmmmm.... perhaps

 

 

Oh, and I'd classify your vote as an OMGUS vote. 

 

not really.... more a "hmmm don't like this guy" random Day 1 vote. It isn't like I quoted one little thing and based my entire reason for voting from that... like you did 

 

 

 

And he starts with the "why me" posts. 

 

Nice try, but that isn't a classical example of a whymefryme as it acknowledges the reason you voted him.  It is WIFOM though.

 

Never heard this particular Mafia jargon before. Out of curiosity, may I ask you to elaborate?

 

 

Here he seems overly sure about believing that I'm scum and calls my interaction with Leelou staged, while just before he was voting for me because of a gut feeling. He then ends with a nonchalant "perhaps", which is making it seem like he isn't really sure about his reads, but this is in contrast to his previous comments about my allignment. It gives him a nice excuse if he wants to wiggle away from his current reads on a later date. I think Blackhoof also doesn't really know what an OMGUS is, because he calls Leelou out for it.

 

Darthe is also starting to seriously ping because it looks like he was actually being serious about thinking that I'm scum with AJ.

 

 

Unvote, Vote Blackhoof

[Darthe]

Blackhoof is town.

 

Cloud/Leelou/AJ legitomately contains at least 1 scum.

[John E. Kelley]

Vote Leroy.

 

Competing trains and whatnot.

[Verbal32]

We need a deadline.

[_CLOUD]

We need a deadline.

 

Scum Verbal asking for an early deadline is scum. You did the same thing in Darthe's METAL game 

[Leelou]

We need a deadline.

 

Day 1 just started yesterday. 

[WWWwombat]

 

And he starts with the "why me" posts.

 

not at all. I was merely musing that it is suspicious that you would OMGUS me for "buddying" when it was clearly not a serious attempt to do so. 

are you trying to deflect from Cloud, perhaps? protect your scum buddy that you perhaps arranged this whole banter with?

 

hmmmmm.... perhaps

 

 

Oh, and I'd classify your vote as an OMGUS vote.

 

not really.... more a "hmmm don't like this guy" random Day 1 vote. It isn't like I quoted one little thing and based my entire reason for voting from that... like you did 

 

 

 

 

And he starts with the "why me" posts.

 

Nice try, but that isn't a classical example of a whymefryme as it acknowledges the reason you voted him.  It is WIFOM though.

 

 

Never heard this particular Mafia jargon before. Out of curiosity, may I ask you to elaborate?

 

 

First of all, how is Leelou voting you for buddying her OMGUS?  That's almost the exact opposite of OMGUS.  Secondly, whymefryme is a general scumtell where someone's immediate reaction on being voted is to ask why he or she is supsicious rather than to scumhunt.

 

 

 

We need a deadline.

 

Scum Verbal asking for an early deadline is scum. You did the same thing in Darthe's METAL game 

 

Meh.  More of a tooltell than a scumtell imo.

[WWWwombat]

And Leelou, if you're always so jokey on D1, then why did you interpret Cloud's joke seriously and accuse him of hypocrisy?

[WWWwombat]

Blackhoof is town.

 

Cloud/Leelou/AJ legitomately contains at least 1 scum.

 

Your D1 reads have a P-value of 0.8

 

 

Vote Leroy.

 

Competing trains and whatnot.

 

Why not Cloud or Hoof?

[Leelou]

And Leelou, if you're always so jokey on D1, then why did you interpret Cloud's joke seriously and accuse him of hypocrisy?

 

So you don't misrepresent me: 

 

OMGUS! 

 

 

God, I hate it when people try to use that as a valid accusation, but you have to admit that your post is pretty bad Darthe. I mean you don't even explain your vote. What's up with that?

 

So you are allowed to have secret reasons, but Darthe needs to post a reason why he's voting you? Hypocrite much? 

 

 

Has nothing to do with me being jokey, I called out something I saw. It had to do with the fact that he said Darthe needs an explanation but he can just vote with no reason, especially after he said it wasn't a joke.

[_CLOUD]

^ My comment towards Darthe's vote on me was just a joke btw. I never said that it was meant to be taken seriously.

[WWWwombat]

 

And Leelou, if you're always so jokey on D1, then why did you interpret Cloud's joke seriously and accuse him of hypocrisy?

 

So you don't misrepresent me: 

 

OMGUS! 

 

 

God, I hate it when people try to use that as a valid accusation, but you have to admit that your post is pretty bad Darthe. I mean you don't even explain your vote. What's up with that?

 

So you are allowed to have secret reasons, but Darthe needs to post a reason why he's voting you? Hypocrite much? 

 

 

Has nothing to do with me being jokey, I called out something I saw. It had to do with the fact that he said Darthe needs an explanation but he can just vote with no reason, especially after he said it wasn't a joke.

 

 

He was quite obviously being facetious/jokey.  Yet you, in your jokey mood, decided to take it seriously?

[Leelou]

 

 

And Leelou, if you're always so jokey on D1, then why did you interpret Cloud's joke seriously and accuse him of hypocrisy?

 

So you don't misrepresent me: 

 

OMGUS! 

 

 

God, I hate it when people try to use that as a valid accusation, but you have to admit that your post is pretty bad Darthe. I mean you don't even explain your vote. What's up with that?

 

So you are allowed to have secret reasons, but Darthe needs to post a reason why he's voting you? Hypocrite much? 

 

 

Has nothing to do with me being jokey, I called out something I saw. It had to do with the fact that he said Darthe needs an explanation but he can just vote with no reason, especially after he said it wasn't a joke.

 

 

He was quite obviously being facetious/jokey.  Yet you, in your jokey mood, decided to take it seriously?

 

 

People are more likely to slip when being jokey. I called it out. Simple as that. 

[John E. Kelley]

 

Vote Leroy.

Competing trains and whatnot.

 

 

Why not Cloud or Hoof?

I'm playing "Follow the Marsupial."

[WWWwombat]

 

 

 

And Leelou, if you're always so jokey on D1, then why did you interpret Cloud's joke seriously and accuse him of hypocrisy?

 

So you don't misrepresent me: 

 

OMGUS! 

 

 

God, I hate it when people try to use that as a valid accusation, but you have to admit that your post is pretty bad Darthe. I mean you don't even explain your vote. What's up with that?

 

So you are allowed to have secret reasons, but Darthe needs to post a reason why he's voting you? Hypocrite much? 

 

 

Has nothing to do with me being jokey, I called out something I saw. It had to do with the fact that he said Darthe needs an explanation but he can just vote with no reason, especially after he said it wasn't a joke.

 

 

He was quite obviously being facetious/jokey.  Yet you, in your jokey mood, decided to take it seriously?

 

 

People are more likely to slip when being jokey. I called it out. Simple as that. 

 

 

That makes no sense.  If you got the joke, you'd know it was an attempt at self-deprecation and not a slip.

 

 

 

 

Vote Leroy.

Competing trains and whatnot.

 

Why not Cloud or Hoof?

I'm playing "Follow the Marsupial."

 

 

Good man.

[Verbal32]

 

We need a deadline.

 

Scum Verbal asking for an early deadline is scum. You did the same thing in Darthe's METAL game 

 

 

Eventually you'll learn that people can break & manipulate meta.  That's why you shouldn't scumhunt with it.  Better come correct, or not at all.

[Verbal32]

 

Blackhoof is town.

 

Cloud/Leelou/AJ legitomately contains at least 1 scum.

 

Your D1 reads have a P-value of 0.8

 

 

Vote Leroy.

 

Competing trains and whatnot.

 

Why not Cloud or Hoof?

 

 

Doofus, if you really knew what a P-value was, you'd know that 0.8 is actually good and well above what would otherwise cause a rejection.

 

Protip: we know you're smart....but you're not alone, punchy.  See my above advice to CloudyMcClouderson.

[Verbal32]

If anybody needs me, I'll be <over there> saving the world, one DM mafia game at a time.

 

 

I'll take a Jack & Coke when you have a minute.

[Darthe]

Hey Verb, .8 means that Womby thinks I am pretty accurate.

 

Am I being buddied?  Flattery is a weakness and I need the help of a champion.

 

 

 

 

Also, watching Cloud try to step away from his own statements should be its own game.

[Pralaya]

Oh yeah. Aggressive Day 1 Leelou is usually a scum Leelou

 

vote Leelou

[Pralaya]

 

Doofus, if you really knew what a P-value was, you'd know that 0.8 is actually good and well above what would otherwise cause a rejection.

 

Protip: we know you're smart....but you're not alone, punchy.  See my above advice to CloudyMcClouderson.

 

 

First, you need to ask if it is a one-tailed or a two-tailed test.

 

A p-value of 0.8 for a two-tailed is meh ;)

[_CLOUD]

Also, watching Cloud try to step away from his own statements should be its own game.

 

?

 

I don't think that I have been doing that in this game.

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

 

 

We need a deadline.

Scum Verbal asking for an early deadline is scum. You did the same thing in Darthe's METAL game

Eventually you'll learn that people can break & manipulate meta. That's why you shouldn't scumhunt with it. Better come correct, or not at all.

Uh... If youre saying youre abusing your meta, then how is Cloud not coming "correct"? You didn't correct him about your meta, you accepted the meta read as spot on but dismissed it.

 

Vote Verbal