[Basic] The Walking Dead Mafia - Game Over. Theo Wins!

[dapianoplay3r]

Or is rick a bad human?

[GoldeneyesND]

T-Dog died saving Carol's life. He was a hero

[BFG]

When I say controversial I only mean that they're listed by the wiki as being dead, I don't watch the series, so don't know anything about the characters themselves.

 

• the wiki has a list of names of 'walkers' could be as straight forward as the mafia have one of those, or 'walker 1, 2, 3, etc' but then either have 'safe' fake claims or came up with them themselves.  People that have died in the series may be possibles for the mafia (if they had to come up with their own fake claims) as they may be less likely to be chosen by AJ for Town roles.
• Someone or other has stated that there are humans who work against Rick - the Governor being one (Des gave a list earlier) so the mafia could be those.  Dora has said that she has one of those roles and also said that she's Town. 

If Golden is right about how he died then that does sound like a more Townie character, but until I get more information I'm taking claims with a grain of salt.

 

[peacesells]

Seriously? You guys don't watch the Walking dead?  Wow.

[Andrej]

The hammer has been dropped.

 

Final Count 1

Peace (3) - Nolder, Despo, Theodora
Despo (1) - Lenlo

BFG (1) - Pral

Goldeneyes (1) - Err

Lenlo (7) - Ishy, Mish, BFG, Leelou, Peace, Goldeneyes, Dap

 

Not Voting:

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

 

Lenlo - Maggie Green: Town Lover has been lynched.

 

 

Pralaya - Glenn Rhee: Town Lover is dead.

 

 

It is now Night 1. I'll write up the scene in the morning. You have 24 hours to get your Night Actions in.

[Lenlo]

I literally got back 5 min ago. Damn people.

 

Look at that face. My daddie aint gonna be happy bout dis.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Also Err, please explain that cryptic comment about you and Mish

i was just coming to a conclusion based on the vote counts for me and mish.... i dont know the game history of mish.. so i thought she was intentionally trying to avoid getting into conflicts because till that point there had been no accusations or votes

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Err too. 

i have taken a stance... i still really believe GoldenEyes is a scum

[Babar Hasan Khan]

 

First of all, I'm POSITIVE Perrin here is being coached. I haven't seen anyone else use the word "flail" yet in the game before him, and besides the fact that I don't think I was flailing at all, how would Perrin learn to use such a concept so quickly without ever being told about it? Unless of course, he WAS told, on his team's QT.

 

There's also a scumslip in the first part, where he says I name 1/3 of the town in my reads. Even if this wasn't a true slip, but that he meant to say game instead of town, why try and fos me for having 4 reads as scum? I obviously didn't think each one of my reads was concrete, so why not include other people I've had bad feelings about, instead of just naming a couple of people I was already focusing on?

 

He also admits outright to sheeping... then tries to pass off sheeping as a protown move, that it somehow gets info. Sheeping is actually a way of PREVENTING town from getting info, not getting more. When you sheep, you bandwagon without giving solid reasoning that you can be held accountable for later. Furthermore, you give scum the opportunity to sheep as well without risking much, since there are already sheep on the train. There's no way you can convince me sheeping is a good move, and trying to take credit for the flurry of activity afterwards is also a newb scum move.

 

He also says that he doesn't see how jumping from one train to the next accomplishes anything- and remember, scum are always more likely to park their vote somewhere instead of move it. Town can only go by their reads, so as their reads change, their vote can as well. Instead, Goldeneyes has kept his sheep vote parked on Dap for a while now, and tries to link anyone he can to Dap as well (first me, then Nol, and saw him do it to someone else too).

 

Unvote, Vote Goldeneyes

 

 

Peace I don't know if you're working or sleeping or what but I wasn't messing around I want more than a summary of what has occurred from you.

Deadline is tomorrow and I'm not letting you slip by without taking any kind of a stand on something.

 

Unvote

Vote Peace

 

I find it interesting that Nolder has now taken votes off of the two people most under scrutiny. If it turns out that Dap, Des and Nolder are all mafia at the end of this, I'll be impressed at the little game of musical chairs you just played. Not saying you're scum. I just find the move interesting.

 

 

Here's where he links me, Dap, and Nol. Completely missing the fact that all of that depends on Dap being mafia in the first place (personally I have a town read on him now due to the bandwagon votes on him yesterday as well as his catchup wot, he tends to overexplain a bit during his wot's as scum).

 

And yet, Goldeneyes also didn't seem to care much about Dap's more recent posts, which imo have looked very townie. He wants to stick to his read, perhaps was coached not to backtrack away from it too quickly, and focuses more on linking others to Dap instead of making any actual arguments for WHY he thinks Dap is scum. Seriously, look through his posts. He's never really stated WHY he voted Dap, just that he had a scum read on him.

 

That is correct. As I already explained, I didn't have a particularly scum read on Dap before viting for him. My vote for Nolder didn't particularly give me any information, so I switched to see if voting for Dap would do anything. Yes, it's my first game. No, I'm not being coached as evidenced by what I assume is an incorrect use of the term sheeping. I googled the term and got a definition that states sheeping is the act of following a crowd without a particular reason for doing so. Your post indicates admitting to that is somehow a bad thing, which frankly I don't get.

 

Flailing is a word in the English language. I use it on a daily basis. I haven't changed my vote off of Dap solely because Despo so clearly wanted votes to come off. So, in summary, not coached, first game. If flail is a genuine scum term, I'm unaware. I went to read the list of terms on the madiascum website and it was way too long to memorize before I playd this game. But you're correct, I do have a sheep vote parked on Dap. As he only has 3 votes at present it seems as good a place to park as any. But since there is a deadline looming I'll go ahead and put my vote on the person I absolutely have a scum read on.

 

unvote, vote Des

 

 

It's also fairly easy to count which vote I was, it involves going back a couple pages and seeing when my vote changed from Nolder to Dap. Since I did that in response to Err and you're going on a "feeling", I'd suggest you follow Boston's lead and go with "more than a feeling."

 

 

thank you for making my point more clear... u jumped again 4th vote this time

[Babar Hasan Khan]

 

 

i agree... and if Goldeneyes is a walker then theodora and BFG are most likely his (infected) accomplices 

 

 

 

Did you not read what I said about the walkers? I highly doubt they're the scum team. Thread says to fear the living, I know I have a named character so it seems silly to have Walker #X named scum.

 

Plus, you really think the Governor or Merle would be town? Or Caesar or Shane, for that matter?

 

the only way i can make sense of having governor as a non walker in the game is that there might be 2 mafia teams.... one walkers and one governors team..... 2 scums each

[Babar Hasan Khan]

 

 

Is there a way to search this thread and isolate posts by author?

 

Yes, it's explained in the new player tips thread..2nd or 3rd post.

 

 

Thanks, I figured it out.

 

UNVOTE

VOTE LENLO

 

He hasn't given a straight answer all game and brushes aside any requests for clarification. Since he wouldn't give his reads at L-4, maybe he will deign to do so at L-1

 

and there we go again... u can rationalize being L1... but thats what it is L1....... was i wrong when i said u are jumping on trains to get lynch as soon as possible??????

[Babar Hasan Khan]

hey are we allowed to comment after the day is over???

[Andrej]

Lol sure man.

 

Rant on.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

The hammer has been dropped.

 

Final Count 1

Peace (3) - Nolder, Despo, Theodora

Despo (1) - Lenlo

BFG (1) - Pral

Goldeneyes (1) - Err

Lenlo (7) - Ishy, Mish, BFG, Leelou, Peace, Goldeneyes, Dap

 

Not Voting:

 

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

 

Lenlo - Maggie Green: Town Lover has been lynched.

 

 

Pralaya - Glenn Rhee: Town Lover is dead.

 

 

It is now Night 1. I'll write up the scene in the morning. You have 24 hours to get your Night Actions in.

two people dead?? hmm.... Generals team making a day time kill????    2 mafia teams?? kill the dead, fear the living?

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Lol sure man.

 

Rant on.

k good to know :) thanks

[Babar Hasan Khan]

i think no one is awake in this time zone to read the results of day 1

[John E. Kelley]

I'm wide awake, comment/ask away.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

how do we have 2 kills/lynchs?

[Andrej]

where are you from Err?

[Babar Hasan Khan]

m in uae

[Theodora]

Morning everyone. This is horrible - why two people indeed?

[John E. Kelley]

Lovers are a Town role that when one is killed, the other dies as well.

[BFG]

Can also be Town-Mafia pairing, being a lover doesn't necessarily confirm someone as Town.

[BFG]

^obviously not in this case, just in general

[John E. Kelley]

And Len was asked to claim. He refused. This lynch is entirely on him, he had multiple hours to make a case.