[Basic] Die Hard for Mafia Game Thread

[csarmi]

Gonna read up when I get home.

[dicetosser1]

what dice has to say is that lens self vote came across to me like he was intentionally breaking the rules but just for fun. Not bobs stance on self voting is fine if not taken to extremes. I think someone else has the same attitude to it,  might be nolder. I dont like it much during games either  but D1 first post? that i can live with. 

 

I have read the last couple of pages but honestly dont have a great grip on this game atm due to my migraine. Hopefully it will be totally gone by tonight and i can reread. I need to to really need to cause im not seeing what ppl are talking about re praya atm.

 

for now i will just give an intention to vote notbob. 

[_CLOUD]

 

 

 

You really are always trying to lead town in every game that you play in, and for some reason it always results in pressuring me Why don't you do something useful instead and vote for Pral? The dude is obviously scum.

 

"Obviously" is such a loaded word on Day 1. Trying to deflect attention, eh?

 

 

You mean like you are doing right now? I have stated my intention to vote for you since page 4.

 

 

Yeah, you can find me suspicious, you can vote me, you can state your intentions but "obviously"? That is an intentional diversion move.

 

 

Or I'm, you know, thinking that you are scum at this point? You are using a diversion move yourself by voting for me, and your only reasoning seems to be that I'm driving the town which isn't true at all. Both Dap and Darthe are leading the town way more than I am and they have been cheerleading for your lynch, so why aren't you voting for them instead? You have to have a better reason if you want to make a serious vote against someone.

 

Anyway, you are at L-1 so you should claim.

[csarmi]

I believe that someone should unvote and let Pralaya claim at L-2.

[Luciena]

So Csarmi is trying his best to play it safe. Interesting.

I am so not sure about you, but you bug me.

 

 

Vote Lenlo

 

 Verry Intrresting...

 

Can't argue with this logic.

 

Vote Lenlo

 

 

Not Bob not so sure about you. You seem to pick on people very randomly, it might be the self voting but it could also have been a mafia move? You know, go for the safe one as Len has already voted for himself?

 

Quibby is town

Salami is town

 

Notbob

Quibbsy might be town, however he bites, so wouldn't be so sure on that. I haven't seen enough of Quibbsy to form an opinion.

 

Everyone but Pral has checked in.

 

VOTE LENLO

 

I was given some pre-game information. 

We have established that this was just a piss take.

 

Checking in

 

Self-voting ! Trying to do something new or a subtle way of distancing himself?

 

vote Lenlo

Same move as NotBob. Mafia much?

 

 

Checking in

 

Self-voting ! Trying to do something new or a subtle way of distancing himself?

 

vote Lenlo

This is an odd vote considering Peaces "reveal"

 

 

 

 

 

Kaylee, I don't believe Darthe has people written off.

Never said he did. I was just saying that sometimes you feel very sure of someone, not typically this early, and so you dismiss them as town. I was putting it out there that sometimes these feelings are wrong and that's good to keep in mind to find scum. (Ex. If felt Tress was on her town meta I might not watch her as closely.) I have since learned just because someone gives a town vibe doesn't mean they shouldn't still be looked at, just not first. I had completely written someone off as town and not a possibility until it was too late, thus losing the game. I was simply sharing this information is all. (Mostly because I was upset with myself for being fooled and mislead).

 

 

I agree with this and I also think that dismissing someone as town can be more damaging than being convinced that someone is mafia. 

 

Seeing as the game had just started, the excuse that you "forgot" to read them is very weak in my opinion.

So are you going to vote for him or not?

 

 

This is my first game. I am trying to make up my mind. 

 

 

It means that I feel like you're pointing the finger at others to take attention away from yourself.

I think that's more of what Csarmi has been doing than Darthe tbh

 

Might have been mistaken. We are mistakes we make humans. 

 

 

It means that I feel like you're pointing the finger at others to take attention away from yourself.

I'm trying to understand... the logic... going through your head... something must be failing you.

 

What does my non-game-related question to Lenlo have to do with myself past the fact that I asked it? And if it was game related how would it be drawing attention from myself? And what does thay have to do with crying wolf? And if you can anseer all of thay then how is that a scummy thing to do?

 

Like I said might have jumped to a conclusion.

 

 

Kk gonna go ahead and state intentions to vote plralaya or cloud atm.

You vote Len, I vote pray and we get competing trains going?

To vica Versa (I know it's not cloud but we can do that tomorrow)

 

 

This makes it look like you're in this together and know something the rest of us don't. It rings alarm bells.

 

Or we both vote cloud actually and get a three way started

 

Sandwiches???? Things just got Interesting!

 

 

Or we both vote cloud actually and get a three way started

 

I don't wanna vote Len but I do want to see a response from Pral and Cloud before making the next step.

 

Like I said above this looks very suspicious in my opinion. You two look like you are working together.

 

Now bear in mind that this is my first official game. So might make mistakes in the future. 

 

Csarmi no idea what to say about him, he looks genuine but not so sure. He confuses me.

 

Unvote 

[Darthe]

Working with you a little bit, people who think one another are town or that they have mutual goals will work tigether. Its good that you are suspicious and careful, its great that you are making note of these interactions and I encourage that. However you won't beable and make early casework off of it. Reason being is that if mafia openly worked to gether ton such a regular basis it would give them away.

[Darthe]

Salami is confusing you because he plays without direction.. don't worry about it, he is town this game. When he gets a bit more involved he will shape up for claritys sake, like someone learning chess that is actually tougher before they get their strategies dkwn pat.

[_CLOUD]

@Luci: I know that this is your first game and my earlier comment towards you was only meant as a little pressure. I have a town read on you so far.

 

 

I think I have only played one game with Csarmi before where he was mafia (Kronos' AC game) and even there I thought that he was town... I'm not familiar with his scum meta at all.

[csarmi]

I think I have only played one game with Csarmi before where he was mafia (Kronos' AC game) and even there I thought that he was town... I'm not familiar with his scum meta at all.

Maybe cause I was vanilla town in the Kronos AC game. :)

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

what dice has to say is that lens self vote came across to me like he was intentionally breaking the rules but just for fun. Not bobs stance on self voting is fine if not taken to extremes. I think someone else has the same attitude to it,  might be nolder. I dont like it much during games either  but D1 first post? that i can live with. 

 

I have read the last couple of pages but honestly dont have a great grip on this game atm due to my migraine. Hopefully it will be totally gone by tonight and i can reread. I need to to really need to cause im not seeing what ppl are talking about re praya atm.

 

for now i will just give an intention to vote notbob. 

 

Wow!

 

This post is gross on so many levels.

[_CLOUD]

 

I think I have only played one game with Csarmi before where he was mafia (Kronos' AC game) and even there I thought that he was town... I'm not familiar with his scum meta at all.

Maybe cause I was vanilla town in the Kronos AC game. :)

 

 

Really? Lol. I really thought that you were mafia in that game... I must have mixed up games where we played in together.

 

I just remembered that it was Peace's Poker game! Yes, you were mafia in that game and I'm sure that I had a town read on you. You just make too much sense in mafia :P

[csarmi]

what dice has to say is that lens self vote came across to me like he was intentionally breaking the rules but just for fun. Not bobs stance on self voting is fine if not taken to extremes. I think someone else has the same attitude to it,  might be nolder. I dont like it much during games either  but D1 first post? that i can live with. 

 

I have read the last couple of pages but honestly dont have a great grip on this game atm due to my migraine. Hopefully it will be totally gone by tonight and i can reread. I need to to really need to cause im not seeing what ppl are talking about re praya atm.

 

for now i will just give an intention to vote notbob.

Intentions schmintentions. Game's been going for 4 days and eleven pages and you post an intention to vote someone? Can we expect you to vote by what, D3?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Lenlo(2): NotBob, Pral

Pralaya(3): Lenlo, Cloud, Kaylee

Csarmi(1): Darthe

Kaylee(1): Csarmi

Darthe(1): Luci

NotBob(1): Peace

 

Not Voting: Quibby, Dice, Dap

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.  A deadline has been set for Friday, Sept. 20th at 7pm PST.

 

 

 

UNVOTE VOTE PRAL

 

 

 

UNVOTE VOTE PRAL

 

I can follow this logic.

 

Unvote

 

Vote Pral

 

 

 

No difference.

 

Kill them both?

 

Vote Rorsh

 

L-1!

 

L-1!

 

L-1!

 

Is Rorsh Pral?

 

Unvote

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

By my count Pralaya was at L-2.

 

Unless Darthe has a pet name for her.

[_CLOUD]

Rorschach is Pralaya's nickname.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Rorschach is Pralaya's nickname.

 

How?

 

By whom?

 

What fer?

[_CLOUD]

Well, Pralaya was just too difficult to spell so we had to give him a nickname and then Darthe came up with Rorschach because that's just soo much easier.

[dapianoplay3r]

Cloud

This game I've been leading the town far far less than usual. I'd even go as far as to say I haven't been leading the town. Yet you are determined to make people think I am

 

So far you present that one instance with Darthe. It was just me and Darthe, no one else involved. Yet you say town. So you either are referring to Darthe as town, and therefore are mafia. Or you are just trying to curry favour in some weird way. It doesn't sit right

 

 

I won't be joining Rory's train at this point. I'd like to hear more from him first

After that I will probably switch and hammer if his response is lacking. However till then ill try even out the trains a bit, get some more pressure in the mix

 

unvote vote len

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Well, Pralaya was just too difficult to spell so we had to give him a nickname and then Darthe came up with Rorschach because that's just soo much easier.

 

Of course.

[csarmi]

@Dap - what do you think about Dice's play?

[Lenlo]

Cloud

This game I've been leading the town far far less than usual. I'd even go as far as to say I haven't been leading the town. Yet you are determined to make people think I am

 

So far you present that one instance with Darthe. It was just me and Darthe, no one else involved. Yet you say town. So you either are referring to Darthe as town, and therefore are mafia. Or you are just trying to curry favour in some weird way. It doesn't sit right

 

 

I won't be joining Rory's train at this point. I'd like to hear more from him first

After that I will probably switch and hammer if his response is lacking. However till then ill try even out the trains a bit, get some more pressure in the mix

 

unvote vote len

So your evening out the trains by voting me, when you have absolutely no idea what the case on me is ((If there even is one.))? So your evening the trains between a townie and someone who looks really really scummy.

 

FOS on you.

[_CLOUD]

Cloud

This game I've been leading the town far far less than usual. I'd even go as far as to say I haven't been leading the town. Yet you are determined to make people think I am

 

So far you present that one instance with Darthe. It was just me and Darthe, no one else involved. Yet you say town. So you either are referring to Darthe as town, and therefore are mafia. Or you are just trying to curry favour in some weird way. It doesn't sit right

 

 

I won't be joining Rory's train at this point. I'd like to hear more from him first

After that I will probably switch and hammer if his response is lacking. However till then ill try even out the trains a bit, get some more pressure in the mix

 

unvote vote len

 

I know that you haven't been leading the town as much as you usually do, but you and Darthe still have been leading more than I have because I haven't been doing it at all. That was the point of mentioning you two. I also haven't been referring to Darthe as town at all.

[dapianoplay3r]

Don't be silly Len

I never said I didn't find you scummy

Plus even if I think you are more likely town, evening a train on you has its uses. By doing so you can watch and gauge where people will vote. If pray flips mafia it will be especially telling to see who comes in now to vote you instead of him. Its the whole reasons competing trains are great

 

Now stop whining about it

[dapianoplay3r]

You say I'm leaning town. All I've done is tell lead Darthe (and it was more of an offer than a lead)

Ergo Darthe=town in your head if I'm leading pretty much only him and I'm leading town.

[_CLOUD]

You say I'm leaning town. All I've done is tell lead Darthe (and it was more of an offer than a lead)

Ergo Darthe=town in your head if I'm leading pretty much only him and I'm leading town.

 

I know that you were referring to Darthe when you made that offer, but I had the feeling that you were planning to convince everyone of your plan. You mentioned competing trains, and you can't get trains started with only two players.