[Basic] Die Hard for Mafia Game Thread

[Luciena]

Or he's town and was just messing around. Why would a townie need to gather sympathy? I'm genuinely curious. 

I wasn't accusing him of garnering sympathy, it's just one of the two viable reasons for a self vote.

[Luciena]

 

 Drunk Mafia!!! :)

Ishy?  Also sounds fun! I'll start drinking in about an hour though, need to eat something first.

 

Lol yeah!

[csarmi]

I'm gonna be voting Luci tomorrow. That hammer stinks.

 

Also, I disagreed about the Dap lynch then and I disagree about it now. Since when is it a good idea to lynch a town view when we have 7 town / 1 scum left most likely?

 

Bad play.

[Kaylee]

Self vote, seems like he hasn't learned his lesson. Either trying to gather sympathy or just scummy 

Luci I was referring to this post of yours.

[csarmi]

Also I don't have time for this game now. Apparently. Too man ythings going on and I'm addign nothing.

 

So I'll just protect Peace. Maybe he gets a scum view or smth.

Come and get me.

[csarmi]

/csarmiout

 

Have a nice game!

[Kaylee]

I didn't say you were accusing him of it. I just want to know what reason he would have to gain sympathy as a townie because the other option you gave puts him as scummy. I read that as saying scummy as in scum. 

[dapianoplay3r]

Told you

town can be self sacrificing too

 

blah

[Luciena]

 

Self vote, seems like he hasn't learned his lesson. Either trying to gather sympathy or just scummy 

Luci I was referring to this post of yours.

 

Yes I called attention to it as he looks like he won't stop self votes. Bad idea in every game not just this one

[Kaylee]

Told you

town can be self sacrificing too

 

blah

Yes, and the last game I saw you do it you were scum. (With Cindy I believe)

[dapianoplay3r]

Blah cont.

Not sure what game you mean but we can discuss it post game

 

Blah

[peacesells]

first time players don't get to policy vote.

[Hallia]

REMEMBER: Dead is dead. 1 bah post.  >=(

[Hallia]

Another night passed in the ever increasingly tense building.  The atmosphere was nearly unbearable...and made worse by the loss of a good cop.

 

Peace - Sgt. Al Powell - Town Cop has been killed!

 

 

It is now Day 4.  With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch.  You have until 11pm PST on Monday, Sept. 30th to reach a lynch.

[csarmi]

I self-protected

[csarmi]

There was no point in protecting Peace when we are lynching his town reads. Was hoping that scum would understand that too. Apparently, they suck. Oh well.

[Lenlo]

 

 

 

 

I am not sure what to make of this. I didn't like Len from the beginning since he self voted but not sure what to think now. However, since Dap suggested the trains...

 

 

 

 

Vote Dap 

Are we bringing up the joke vote bull crap again? Seriously?

Atleast you've learnt your lesson lol

 

Oh no im definitely doing it again. So much fun at the beginning of the game. Ill just make sure its allowed in the rules next time. :P

 

Self voters will be lynched on principle. I suggest Len gets run up tomorrow

 

Self voters who joke about it on D1. Your making this way to serious.

 

Self vote, seems like he hasn't learned his lesson. Either trying to gather sympathy or just scummy 

Learned my lesson? What? Im sorry ive been playing this for quite a while. I know how self voting looks and all of the reasons people could see behind it. Hell ive used many of them to my own gain in different games. This is why I made it a joke vote in the very beginning of a basic game.

 

 

Or he's town and was just messing around. Why would a townie need to gather sympathy? I'm genuinely curious. 

I wasn't accusing him of garnering sympathy, it's just one of the two viable reasons for a self vote.

 

Garnering sympathy. Yes. Definitely a viable strategy if it wasnt for the fact that the vote happened on D1.

 

 

 

Self vote, seems like he hasn't learned his lesson. Either trying to gather sympathy or just scummy 

Luci I was referring to this post of yours.

 

Yes I called attention to it as he looks like he won't stop self votes. Bad idea in every game not just this one

 

1) Not always a bad idea. Speaking from experience here. Many times it can help for different reasons based on your alignment.

2) How do you know I wont stop it? Maybe ill completely forget about the joke after this game?

3)Your pushing this bullcrap over and over and over and over again is just ludicrous and distracting for the rest of town from the real issues at hand of finding scum.

[Kaylee]

1. Peace - Town

2. Luci (Being mentored by Ishy) Possible Scum.

4. Darthe - Town Vig

5. Kaylee - Town

6. Pralaya - Town

7. Mish - Town

10. Csarmi -Town

11. Lenlo - Possible scum.

12. Dap - Vanilla Town

These are my reads so far.

 

CSARMI. I AM THE COP. DO WHATEVER YOU THINK BEST.

I viewed Kaylee night 1. I actually thought she was scum initially and gave town reads on her day 1 to try and throw off the scum team. She came back town. I do not think she is a godfather. I have very strong town reads on her now.

I'll be viewing one of my 3 scum reads tonight. Luci, Lenlo or Dap. It will be random.org'ed.

 

Now before you all waaa waaa about me revealing early, I think it was getting pretty obvious that I would be a good Night Kill target. At least now there will be some wifom on the NA.

[Kaylee]

That leaves Pral, Mish, Luci and Leno. From that pool I'll Vote Luci

[csarmi]

vote Lenlo

[michellem]

I feel Lenlo more than Luci. I dunno, I might just be naivé, but I think if she was mafia (this is of course if her team hasn't bailed), she would have asked them questions instead; and if soeone pointed out in thread that she asked suprisingly few questions to be a newbie, she could blame the fact that she has a mentor to ask. But I know how busy Ishy has been this last week, he's usually home from work midnight my time, no problem for me because I have a messed up sleeping routine; but if you have a more normal one on about the same time zone, I guess they always miss each other.

 

Vote Lenlo

[Kaylee]

Last day phase you thought the mafia was between Dap, Leno and Pral...

 

I could lynch Kaylee as well.  She should have been the target last night.  Scum could easily of painted Darthe as an SK and not vig. 

 

No but then killing him the same night after Kaylee started to lay the hints kinda blows that theory.

 

I can agree to both a Dap and a Len lynch; I still think the final mafia is between those two and Pral, and we do have the numbers to survive a mislynch or two.

 

unvote vote Dap

 

That's L1 I believe

 

I bolded it to show your wording.

 

 

I feel Lenlo more than Luci. I dunno, I might just be naivé, but I think if she was mafia (this is of course if her team hasn't bailed), she would have asked them questions instead; and if soeone pointed out in thread that she asked suprisingly few questions to be a newbie, she could blame the fact that she has a mentor to ask. But I know how busy Ishy has been this last week, he's usually home from work midnight my time, no problem for me because I have a messed up sleeping routine; but if you have a more normal one on about the same time zone, I guess they always miss each other.

 

Vote Lenlo

This day phase you say you still feel Leno, more than Luci, but make no mention of Pral. Just curious, does this mean you're no longer suspicious of him or you just wanted to go between the two people that were being voted for?

 

I ask because up till this point you seem to have been bent on Pral being scum, now there's no mention. I understand about what you're saying about Luci, and you may be right, but to suddenly not mention the one that has been at the top of your list to this point is odd.

[Kaylee]

I know you're unCC'd Doc but I wanted to point some things out...

 

I'm gonna be voting Luci tomorrow. That hammer stinks.

Also, I disagreed about the Dap lynch then and I disagree about it now. Since when is it a good idea to lynch a town view when we have 7 town / 1 scum left most likely?

Bad play.

Bold: you state your intentions to vote Luci next day phase...

Blue: This is interesting as you seemed so sure that I was the GF a few pages back. (I pulled that posts too).

 

 

Feel like sharing your innocent view?

Agreed on people relying on the cop too much.

This post just seems odd. You ask for the view, which I understand, and yet also state that people rely too much on the cop? Huh? 

 

 

 

Pray that seems counter intuitive
Atleast she's had a cop view

As we can be almost sure that the remaining scan is gf...

 

Most likely or it could be a true townie viewing.

 

 

If there is a GF, they can be anyone but Peace/Me, actually, and we're never going to get any new info on that as we know it's the last one standing.

Kaylee, I think.

Here it is...the statement where you say you think I'm GF if there is one.

 

Something else stood out to me about the cop view comment...let me go back and see if I can find it.

[Kaylee]

 

Peace either way knowing your target can be helpful. I'm still going to look at the unknown. Dap should've been on that list too. I didn't realize I missed him.

Peace knows his job.

Let's focus on scumhunting and run people up. I'm sure he'll stop the wrong train, if need be.

 

Here it is. I put it in purple so it really stands out. I ask Peace about his findings...in the same post I say I'm going to still look at the remaining players.

Yet you seem to be saying to focus on scumhunting (as I've stated I planned to do), and not worry about Peace's findings. Then later on you ask about them?

[Kaylee]

Just seems an odd way for a Doc to act is all I'm saying. Seems odd for anyone really.