[Basic] Die Hard for Mafia Game Thread

[Darthe]

Ive seen the replacement thing done before but Dice wouldn't. He has too much integrity for it.

 

Prob town tbh. Like almost certain between that and those interactions I quoted with notbob. So if we cross out myself peace dice salami and one more that should be game. Three good cop views would go a long way right now.

[Luciena]

What do you mean you've seen the replacement thing done before Darthe? Like a tactic?

[Andrej]

I don't necessarily agree with you on Dap Luci, but you're analyzing which is good. Which posts of his stuck out to you? How do you think what he said in those posts apply to the big picture? That's how you need to think.

[Lenlo]

Sort of like lurking.

 

Welcome to the discussion Lenlo. Got nothing?

Hi there, your backhanded accusation of me lurking is bullcrap and actually kinda rude. I gave my thoughts back when this day first started yesterday so go back and read it cause nothing thats been said has changed it. I now await your response and hope its actually got something in it instead of a stupid question. 

[Luciena]

Thanks for the heads up AJ. I'll go have a look and quote them here for you. Soonish

[Darthe]

What do you mean you've seen the replacement thing done before Darthe? Like a tactic?

Sadly yes, moreso on MS where psople like to keep a win loss record. Its also provided some amazing saves though. When a game I know of like this finishes I will link it for the point.

[Luciena]

Thanks Darthe :)

[Luciena]

Thanks to the rest of you for explaining things to me. Really appreciate it.

[Pralaya]

Out of the people who have not claimed
 
Peace, Luci, Andrej, Kaylee, Dice, lenlo and Dap
 
So, 2 out of these are scum. 
 
The replacement tactic is kind of far fetched for this game. Dice has been having RL problems, I think - has come up in other games too. 
 
Anyway, just went back and was reading and I came across this. This was kind of close to deadline, so I did not observe it then but looking back this stands out. Andrej's vote came quite late when it was sure NotBob is going to get lynched. Especially obvious is how he is linking up NotBob to others as if KNOWING he will flip scum.

 

Nowhere in this post he says why he thinks NotBob is scum. All he does is links people to NotBob and votes him as if he is almost out of time.

  

So, we've got Cloud discrediting Pral further while voting for Peace. (Peace never said he'd believe any role on D1, just that he believed Pral's, btw. That's an important detail that you're misrepresenting here.)

 

At this point, these are the associations that I see.

 

Cloud and Kaylee are against NotBob's train. Cloud through his interference by going after Peace and now arguing with Dap. Kaylee more subtle with first the unvote that gained some attention and then revoting Pral to even out the trains.

 

Peace wants to lynch NotBob over Pral on the basis that he believes Pral's VT claim. Why NotBob, Peace? I don't remember you actually making a case on him before.

 

vote NotBob

 

At this point, with NotBob having the most votes and this close to DL, I think he should be our lynch. If he flips scum then I think Cloud and/or Kaylee are his teammates.

 

 

vote Andrej

[Luciena]

 

Kk gonna go ahead and state intentions to vote plralaya or cloud atm.

You vote Len, I vote pray and we get competing trains going?

To vica Versa (I know it's not cloud but we can do that tomorrow)

 

 

 

Or we both vote cloud actually and get a three way started

 

 

 

Or we both vote cloud actually and get a three way started

 

I don't wanna vote Len but I do want to see a response from Pral and Cloud before making the next step.

 

 These are the quotes I that made me suspicious of Dap and Darthe. However Darthe is the Vig. No idea what to think of Dap. That's why I want to hear more from him. He's been completely silent. 

 

Hope it makes sense AJ

[dapianoplay3r]

Luc. Ive had an assignment due

60pages

 

plus this game needs a case

I should be able to reread and get oneout today

[dapianoplay3r]

Luc. Ive had an assignment due

60pages

 

plus this game needs a case

I should be able to reread and get oneout today

[dapianoplay3r]

Luc. Ive had an assignment due

60pages

 

plus this game needs a case

I should be able to reread and get oneout today

[dapianoplay3r]

Luc. Ive had an assignment due

60pages

 

plus this game needs a case

I should be able to reread and get oneout today

[Luciena]

Luc. Ive had an assignment due

60pages

 

plus this game needs a case

I should be able to reread and get oneout today

Bold: Ouch! Good luck with that. :) 

 

As for the rest. I look forward to seeing it

[peacesells]

got it the first 3 times Dap, the 4th was just overkill.

[peacesells]

Lenlo bringing out the EMO.  I could lynch him or Andrej as well.

[Darthe]

I won't be lynching dice peace or dap this game and likely not luci either.

 

unvote vote andrej

[Andrej]

 

Sort of like lurking.

Welcome to the discussion Lenlo. Got nothing?

 

Hi there, your backhanded accusation of me lurking is bullcrap and actually kinda rude. I gave my thoughts back when this day first started yesterday so go back and read it cause nothing thats been said has changed it. I now await your response and hope its actually got something in it instead of a stupid question.

Show me. All I've seen from you this day are short posts where you simply agree with what's been said by others.

 

Out of the people who have not claimed

 

Peace, Luci, Andrej, Kaylee, Dice, lenlo and Dap

 

So, 2 out of these are scum. 

 

The replacement tactic is kind of far fetched for this game. Dice has been having RL problems, I think - has come up in other games too. 

 

Anyway, just went back and was reading and I came across this. This was kind of close to deadline, so I did not observe it then but looking back this stands out. Andrej's vote came quite late when it was sure NotBob is going to get lynched. Especially obvious is how he is linking up NotBob to others as if KNOWING he will flip scum.

 

Nowhere in this post he says why he thinks NotBob is scum. All he does is links people to NotBob and votes him as if he is almost out of time.

  

 

 

So, we've got Cloud discrediting Pral further while voting for Peace. (Peace never said he'd believe any role on D1, just that he believed Pral's, btw. That's an important detail that you're misrepresenting here.)

 

At this point, these are the associations that I see.

 

Cloud and Kaylee are against NotBob's train. Cloud through his interference by going after Peace and now arguing with Dap. Kaylee more subtle with first the unvote that gained some attention and then revoting Pral to even out the trains.

 

Peace wants to lynch NotBob over Pral on the basis that he believes Pral's VT claim. Why NotBob, Peace? I don't remember you actually making a case on him before.

 

vote NotBob

 

At this point, with NotBob having the most votes and this close to DL, I think he should be our lynch. If he flips scum then I think Cloud and/or Kaylee are his teammates.

 

 

vote Andrej

This is bunk. NotBob made it obvious that he had no intent to add content to the game. Look back to my first post of the game where I listed NB as one of my scum reads. You're right, I was very confident that he would turn up mafia so I began to look at other's actions when it came to his train. Hence my suspicion of Kaylee.

[Andrej]

And Cloud for that matter.

[Andrej]

Pral, look at the whole picture. When I joined the game NB was already sitting high in the VC. I voted him initially to even out the trains. I later unvoted and in the same post questioned you and NB why you had both voted Lenlo. You explained, NB gave some BS like he had been all game. I had already voted him again based on the actions of others regarding his lynch because I figured his flip would give us information to those player's intent. You're taking my post out of context.

[Luciena]

Ok it's midnight here. Will be back tomorrow evening for me/morning/afternoon for wherever else you guys are 

[Lenlo]

 

 

Sort of like lurking.

Welcome to the discussion Lenlo. Got nothing?

Hi there, your backhanded accusation of me lurking is bullcrap and actually kinda rude. I gave my thoughts back when this day first started yesterday so go back and read it cause nothing thats been said has changed it. I now await your response and hope its actually got something in it instead of a stupid question.

Show me. All I've seen from you this day are short posts where you simply agree with what's been said by others.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lenlo...why are you voting Dice?

This also has me curious. As I recall he hasn't posted much due to RL issues. I'm curious why you just seem to follow without any comment of your own.

 

Are you talking about about me or Dice?

 

so lenlo doesnt like Peace's post but then does as he is told??  And Peace directs the game apparently.

 

Any Reasons for the vote people?  cause i haven't seen one yet. 

Not what I said, stop purposefully misinterpreting. I said I dont like the pool that he gave because he omitted himself, Kaylee and Pral as if his own personal reads were 100% accurate. The only reason for anyone to follow his small list of 5 people would be if they trust him completely, which is something I rarely do in a mafia game. Other than that I have no problem with his post or his vote.

 

Lenlo...why are you voting Dice?

Right now its cause hes the lowest poster. He has the same amount as Quib, who was replaced awhile ago. From what little he has said I cant actually get much so I either want to force him into greater activity or just lynch him. Thats why I have no problem voting him.

 

Deal with it AJ. Not short at all and shows why im voting Dice.

 

Lenlo bringing out the EMO.  I could lynch him or Andrej as well.

 

[Lenlo]

 

 

Sort of like lurking.

Welcome to the discussion Lenlo. Got nothing?

Hi there, your backhanded accusation of me lurking is bullcrap and actually kinda rude. I gave my thoughts back when this day first started yesterday so go back and read it cause nothing thats been said has changed it. I now await your response and hope its actually got something in it instead of a stupid question.

Show me. All I've seen from you this day are short posts where you simply agree with what's been said by others.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lenlo...why are you voting Dice?

This also has me curious. As I recall he hasn't posted much due to RL issues. I'm curious why you just seem to follow without any comment of your own.

 

Are you talking about about me or Dice?

 

so lenlo doesnt like Peace's post but then does as he is told??  And Peace directs the game apparently.

 

Any Reasons for the vote people?  cause i haven't seen one yet. 

Not what I said, stop purposefully misinterpreting. I said I dont like the pool that he gave because he omitted himself, Kaylee and Pral as if his own personal reads were 100% accurate. The only reason for anyone to follow his small list of 5 people would be if they trust him completely, which is something I rarely do in a mafia game. Other than that I have no problem with his post or his vote.

 

Lenlo...why are you voting Dice?

Right now its cause hes the lowest poster. He has the same amount as Quib, who was replaced awhile ago. From what little he has said I cant actually get much so I either want to force him into greater activity or just lynch him. Thats why I have no problem voting him.

 

Deal with it AJ. Not short at all and shows why im voting Dice.

 

Lenlo bringing out the EMO.  I could lynch him or Andrej as well.

 

[Lenlo]

 

 

 

Sort of like lurking.
Welcome to the discussion Lenlo. Got nothing?

Hi there, your backhanded accusation of me lurking is bullcrap and actually kinda rude. I gave my thoughts back when this day first started yesterday so go back and read it cause nothing thats been said has changed it. I now await your response and hope its actually got something in it instead of a stupid question.

Show me. All I've seen from you this day are short posts where you simply agree with what's been said by others.
 

 

 

 

 

Lenlo...why are you voting Dice?

This also has me curious. As I recall he hasn't posted much due to RL issues. I'm curious why you just seem to follow without any comment of your own.

 

Are you talking about about me or Dice?

 

so lenlo doesnt like Peace's post but then does as he is told??  And Peace directs the game apparently.

 

Any Reasons for the vote people?  cause i haven't seen one yet. 

Not what I said, stop purposefully misinterpreting. I said I dont like the pool that he gave because he omitted himself, Kaylee and Pral as if his own personal reads were 100% accurate. The only reason for anyone to follow his small list of 5 people would be if they trust him completely, which is something I rarely do in a mafia game. Other than that I have no problem with his post or his vote.

 

Lenlo...why are you voting Dice?

Right now its cause hes the lowest poster. He has the same amount as Quib, who was replaced awhile ago. From what little he has said I cant actually get much so I either want to force him into greater activity or just lynch him. Thats why I have no problem voting him.

 

Deal with it AJ. My reasons for voting Dice and its not a single short post.

 

Lenlo bringing out the EMO.  I could lynch him or Andrej as well.

Hurtfuuuuuuuull.