Underworld Mafia [Basic] - Game Over. TOWN WINS!

[Ithillian Turambar]

Writing is too little and takes ages to load. And I don't get the full list on the 'poster list'

 

I also have problems concentrating on more than one at a time. But that's how I play and today I'm going for peace. Confirmed killer and dubious alignment.

 

Sounds like good odds to me.

[hazelkrs1]

Left Dice and Chuckles off the list... Dice replaced someone, didn't he? Panchi or Hallia maybe?

 

Yeah that group (Hallia, Panchi, Vam, Dice, Mish, and Chuckles) needs to weigh in more.

 

And yes, of course i agree that its possible Peace isn't town. You don't seem to find it possible that he is.

[hazelkrs1]

Fair enough. Difference in play styles I suppose. Some would rather take out any one that could be a threat to town, I'd rather focus on the biggest threats to town.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Well then, I wouldn't want to get accused of flip flopping lol

 

But yeah - I don't see how he could be, considering the majority of play in the film.

 

Ugh.

 

Now I am thinking about the whole premise of bad guys becoming good guys and vice versa. Cos Victor seems very much good guy and then is most definitley not.

 

Who would all the good guys be? That would determine who Lucien wanted to not kill I guess.

 

So far we've had William and that second in command guy that I can't remember - the other mafias will be victor and marcus I guess?

 

Isn't marcus the bat guy.

 

How many started?

 

If was 17 - then 12 town, 4 mafia and an SK 3rd party.

[Andrej]

We started with 15 players.

 

Dice was an original player - @Despo. BG replaced in for WBK

 

I think you are weighing too heavily on the lore Ithi. The fact that I am Michael and powerless goes to show. Don't misunderstand me with Peace. I am not against the thought that he could be SK. However, I don't personally believe it. My judgement is based purely off what I see in game.

 

I like Despo's thoughts on the matter. Peace is more or less neutralized if he doesn't want to get lynched. Lets find the remaining Mafia

[Andrej]

We started with 15 players.

 

Dice was an original player - @Despo. BG replaced in for WBK

 

I think you are weighing too heavily on the lore Ithi. The fact that I am Michael and powerless goes to show. Don't misunderstand me with Peace. I am not against the thought that he could be SK. However, going with my gut I don't think he is.

 

I like Despo's thoughts on the matter. Peace is more or less neutralized if he doesn't want to get lynched. Lets find the remaining Mafia

[Andrej]

Stupid phone.

[Ithillian Turambar]

We all play our own ways.

 

This is RTE's 1st mafia game. I think he will have stuck to the story. I'm just deciding which story :)

 

15 makes a difference.

 

Let me think on it.

[michellem]

God damnit I'm hungover, I can hardly think, lol. The good news is I have no plans today, so I have a lot of time to spend here.

 

I also think that even if Peace is an SK (instead of a vig), he's not my biggest concern right now. Like someone (Des?) said, he's more of a threat to the mafia right now. For today, we're def in a good place, two mafia down and only one town down, so I'd like to continue with the good trend. Peace, we can always take him later if the mafia doesn't NK him; the numbers are in our favour right now and Peace seems willing to co-operate with town for now. I'd rather try to take down another mafia.

 

I'm gonna do a reread after I've gotten some breakfast and my head clears a little, so I'm gonna hold of my vote until then. But Dap is def one of my top suspects too. Secound would be Hallia, she is WAY to quiet compared to how she usually plays. Feels iffy for sure.

[lolguy26]

So I just reread the game

 

My thoughts on D1

 

Cloud's lynch: started by ithi, she found his case bad (it was bad) it sorta stalled by dap when cloud claimed doc, ithi CC (the eve claim), dap sided with cloud, AJ claimed micheal VT, and it ended with cloud getting lynched and being mafia good

 

N1: darthe's saying he could have been killed

 

D2: peace claims lucian (day vig/SK)

 

 

 

 

 

 

People who need to post more

 

Mish (much too quiet this game)

Pank (very quiet)

Hal (very quiet)

[Ithillian Turambar]

Well that was an awful post.

 

You've done a re read and all we get is a recap of what's happened?

 

And a nudge towards the inactives.

 

Unvote - vote Chuckles

 

I do hope that leave Peace alive doesn't bite us later. But chuckles was making flippant posts yesterday and now this?

[lolguy26]

well what were you hoping for?

 

a revelation of some sort?! 

[Panchi]

I missed a lot. Days have been a lot hectic and I didn't get much time. I will try to come in more.

 

Peace and Lucian claim. Killing BG goes to prove that he is not mafia though SK could be a probability.

 

I will have to look again and see who supported cloud to get an idea of a mafia. Ugh headache now so I am not going through the thread again.

[Andrej]

Thanks for the help you two.

 

[lolguy26]

oh im sorry i disappointed you two, will i ever be forgiven for committing such an atrocity 

[Andrej]

oh im sorry i disappointed you two, will i ever be forgiven for committing such an atrocity

[/quote

 

*sigh*

 

Not a revelation Chuckles. But at least some input... Tell us what you are thinking. Feed us input and collectively we can put it together. My comments last night about how your play annoys me weren't meant to be personal insults; but this is exactly the kind of crap posts I was talking about. And then you post something like this. Why even sign up if this is how you're going to play? It's every game man.

[Andrej]

I am looking forward to Mish's comments later.

 

Dap, where are you hiding? Come out and play.

[Ithillian Turambar]

You are deleting the last square bracket off of the quote when you quote.

 

That is why it looks weird.

[Ithillian Turambar]

I need to read through the wiki to see if there's an extremely annoying and sarcastic character.

 

Perhaps Chuckles is softclaiming it.

[Andrej]

My phone likely did it on its own. It was having issues getting my post through.

 

Anyway, I have duty tonight so I won't be around a lot. I'm just checking in for now. I see I didn't miss much

 

Any thoughts about the 15 man set up Ithi?

[Andrej]

We could just have Peace shoot him so we don't waste a lynch lol

[lolguy26]

eh thoughts so far

 

Im confused about dap's play from D1 so not sure if he's defending a teammate so blatantly or he really believed cloud's claim 

 

Peace is more likely town than 3rd party , ive never seen a Day SK in a basic game (or atleast i dont remember) but i have seen Day vigs in a basic game (darthe's game)  

 

AJ and ithi are sorta confirmed but i still dont trust AJ's claim (neither do trust ithi's but they get the benefit of doubt for now)

 

Ive seen mish play like this before and she was scum

Hal needs to replaced or poked into posting 

 

eh im guessing thats about it 

[lolguy26]

I need to read through the wiki to see if there's an extremely annoying and sarcastic character.

 

Perhaps Chuckles is softclaiming it.

 

oh you'll find someone named lolguy 

[lolguy26]

 

 

oh im sorry i disappointed you two, will i ever be forgiven for committing such an atrocity

 

*sigh*

 

Not a revelation Chuckles. But at least some input... Tell us what you are thinking. Feed us input and collectively we can put it together. My comments last night about how your play annoys me weren't meant to be personal insults; but this is exactly the kind of crap posts I was talking about. And then you post something like this. Why even sign up if this is how you're going to play? It's every game man.

 

you do know when you tell someone "dont take this personally" you know that its mostly likely going to insult that person right? 

[michellem]

Play like what exactly, Chuckles? Lower posting? I've done that as both town and mafia. Throwing out a statement like that is poor. It makes it look like you're trying to analyze people, but all you're saying is absolutley nothing. I have had high posts counts as mafia, and low as town, and vice versa. If you're gonna call me mafia, point out exactly what about my posts makes me seem supsicious. Not just some random comment about "Ive seen her play like this as mafia". That doesn't cut it.

 

Reread starting now. Chukcles just shot way up my list.