Merlin Mafia [Advanced!]- Town Wins!!!

[Thorum]

I got reminded of the double role because of kaylee's lie, but couldn't push on it at the end of day.

 

I've only seen the series up to series 3, when Lancelot was definitely alive and good. Thanks for the spoiler,btw :(

 

Wombat claimed a confirmed townie vig would be a good lynching candidate. To which I replied a confirmed townie is always a good thing.

[peacesells]

I do lurk when it suits me and the last two games I have made it until end game and been a major contributing factor in the town winning. Do you think quoting Einstein will do the same?

 

 

Zing!  I actually lol'd

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

 

WWWwombat 132 peacesells 58 鲍勃不是我的名字 56 lolguy26 56 Kaylee 49 Despothera 49 dapianoplay3r 48 Thorum 47 Tiinker 44 Tigraine 41 Misheru Sedai 36 TGlems 35 alannalynn 34 Darthe 31 Vambram 30 Krakalakachkn 30 wheeloftime13 26 Hallia 23 Rhea 15 Razen 11 Basel Gill 8 Graendals favourite 1

Sure looks like I'm lurking huh?

Post count does NOT equal lurking. If you drift through the game and rarely offer any true reads or insight, then you're lurking. You yourself admitted to your own lurkiness. The majority if your posts this game have been wifomy "I wonder why this happened..." type posts. The few times you have tried "scumhunting" its been putrescent.

Looks like I struck a nerve! People don't often call BS on you do they?

I think you completely misunderstand the concept of the phrase "striking a nerve", and/or have completely misread the tone of my posts. You have struck no nerve, besides the nerve that gets set off when scummy lurkers whine about being called out on it.

 

You imply I ever put forth bs to be called out on. Even when I lie its still a springtime breeze compared to the stuff you've spouted lately. Either way, try and point out what you think is "bs" about anything I said.

[Tigraine]

 

If you are going after lurkers, looks like there are a lot more to choose from than me but hey. Whatever floats your boat.

 

I think you put in a lot of fluff about physics and crap because your points suck and using big words makes it look more solid ;)

Its true there are a lot of Lurkers to choose from, and if I could I'd lunch them all today. Their play is hurting town, just like it hurts it in every game.

 

And I'm sorry my big words confuzzle you, I could try typing more slowly if that helps? There's a big difference between me having a big vocabulary and using the right word for the situation and trying to write big fluff posts full of vapid wanna-be fanciful speech like Darthe was writing.

Lol "big words" don't bother me at all darlin' it's when I feel they are completely out of context in a mafia game that I choose to ignore the attempt to seem like a town contributor

[hazelkrs1]

I do lurk when it suits me and the last two games I have made it until end game and been a major contributing factor in the town winning. Do you think quoting Einstein will do the same?

Its sadly true, that lurking can get you to endgame. Doesn't mean you're helping out town AT ALL. Had you actually stepped up to the plate and contributed more to those games maybe they wouldn't have come down to the wire. Don't try to convince me lurking helps town in any way. Its completely selfish, and shows you're too scared to actually play mafia and would rather stick your head in the sand till endgame.

 

And I never quoted Einstein btw.

[Tigraine]

I think the whole conversation between you and wombat was merely "I'll show you mine if you show me yours" if ya catch my drift ;)

 

I'm not whining about being called out...I have nothing to hide. My question about going after a claimed vig created a big discussion that a lot of people got involved in. Discussions=information. What did you and wombat accomplish with the physics discussion?

[hazelkrs1]

Lol "big words" don't bother me at all darlin' it's when I feel they are completely out of context in a mafia game that I choose to ignore the attempt to seem like a town contributor

Show me one example of me using a word "out of context". Don't blame me because your vocab isn't as enriched as mine. Reading is fundamental.

[hazelkrs1]

I think the whole conversation between you and wombat was merely "I'll show you mine if you show me yours" if ya catch my drift ;)

 

I'm not whining about being called out...I have nothing to hide. My question about going after a claimed vig created a big discussion that a lot of people got involved in. Discussions=information. What did you and wombat accomplish with the physics discussion?

The conversation between me and Wombat included a discussion about Occam's razor, and whether or not we found Thorum scummy. You keep trying to misrepresent the whole thing as this big chaotic mess that had nothing to do with finding scum when that's exactly what we were discussing.

 

What information cane out of the vig discussion you started? I saw absolutely none that was seriously useful in the purpose of finding scum, which is why I called it a distraction.

 

Your vomiting of smilies and "Lol I hit a nerve!" Type comments are making me feel even better about my vote on you.

[Krakalakachkn]

 

Personally, I'm gonna Vote Krak

 

He was the first person to bring up a Lie Detector possibility, and yet as far as I remember, he didn't join in when (mostly) everyone stated they were town. To me, it smells of mafia knowing there's an LD, probably because they have a silver tongue. He was pushing hard on me, probably hoping to distract the LD to check me and thus give the mafia another free night. Even bringing it up again today, completly uneccessary. I see no reason why he should bring it up again today. I stated quite clearly last day that I'm town. So why keep bringing it up? Maybe he was hopnig the LD would speak up and say they'd checked me, so the mafia knew who the LD was.

That is actually an interesting point, and I completely forgot about my suspicions on Krak. I'd be willing to vote him as well, but first I want to go back and check to see if he really was the first one to bring up the LD thing. I thought it was Tink.

 

We still have two days until deadline, so we got some time but we need people being forceful with their votes, not acting like little timid children.

 

 

Nah, it was me.  I didn't like how Misheru phrased her post concerning masons/mafia and Kaylee.  I don't like how she's been laying low lately.  She was on several scum lists for a while and hasn't been heard from much since the whole LD thing.

 

@So why keep bringing it up? Maybe he was hopnig the LD would speak up and say they'd checked me, so the mafia knew who the LD was.

 

Damn.  You mean I wasn't being sneaky about that? 

 

@He was pushing hard on me, probably hoping to distract the LD to check me and thus give the mafia another free night.

 

Not sure how that computes.

 

@I stated quite clearly last day that I'm town.

 

Oh good.  I should clearly take you at your word because nobody lies in a mafia game.  And why would you even include that snippet, as if your statement holds the keys of truth that all should bow to?  Obviously no one is just going to up and claim to be not town, and you repeating it like a catechism isn't going to make me believe it or say it with you.

[WWWwombat]

Where does Thorum get off calling himself a confirmed townie? And I never said anything about him being a confirmed townie. All I said is that one-shot vig isn't a huge role to potentially risk.

 

Also, Tigs appears to have struck a nerve lol.

[WWWwombat]

And the discussion on parsimony wasn't game related. I simply cannot abide the propagation of misinformation.

[Krakalakachkn]

And the discussion on parsimony wasn't game related. I simply cannot abide the propagation of misinformation.

 

Then why the f*&% do you play mafia?

[michellem]

 

 

Personally, I'm gonna Vote Krak

 

He was the first person to bring up a Lie Detector possibility, and yet as far as I remember, he didn't join in when (mostly) everyone stated they were town. To me, it smells of mafia knowing there's an LD, probably because they have a silver tongue. He was pushing hard on me, probably hoping to distract the LD to check me and thus give the mafia another free night. Even bringing it up again today, completly uneccessary. I see no reason why he should bring it up again today. I stated quite clearly last day that I'm town. So why keep bringing it up? Maybe he was hopnig the LD would speak up and say they'd checked me, so the mafia knew who the LD was.

That is actually an interesting point, and I completely forgot about my suspicions on Krak. I'd be willing to vote him as well, but first I want to go back and check to see if he really was the first one to bring up the LD thing. I thought it was Tink.

 

We still have two days until deadline, so we got some time but we need people being forceful with their votes, not acting like little timid children.

 

 

Nah, it was me.  I didn't like how Misheru phrased her post concerning masons/mafia and Kaylee.  I don't like how she's been laying low lately.  She was on several scum lists for a while and hasn't been heard from much since the whole LD thing.

 

@So why keep bringing it up? Maybe he was hopnig the LD would speak up and say they'd checked me, so the mafia knew who the LD was.

 

Damn.  You mean I wasn't being sneaky about that? 

 

@He was pushing hard on me, probably hoping to distract the LD to check me and thus give the mafia another free night.

 

Not sure how that computes.

 

@I stated quite clearly last day that I'm town.

 

Oh good.  I should clearly take you at your word because nobody lies in a mafia game.  And why would you even include that snippet, as if your statement holds the keys of truth that all should bow to?  Obviously no one is just going to up and claim to be not town, and you repeating it like a catechism isn't going to make me believe it or say it with you.

 

 

Purple: I haven't been online much. Check my posts if you'd like.

 

Green: You were trying to make the LD check out me last night, instead of you or one of your mafia buddies...

 

Blue: I stated that I was town, so that if the LD did like you wanted to and looked at me, they knows that know, and since nobody has spoken out about having a scum reading on me, that should calm you down for a little while. Of course, they could have checked any other person that jumped on the "I'm town"-train.

[peacesells]

Mish...why are you acting like there is a confirmed LD in this game?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

If you are going after lurkers, looks like there are a lot more to choose from than me but hey. Whatever floats your boat.

 

I think you put in a lot of fluff about physics and crap because your points suck and using big words makes it look more solid ;)

 

Agree with this observation.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

If you are going after lurkers, looks like there are a lot more to choose from than me but hey. Whatever floats your boat.

 

I think you put in a lot of fluff about physics and crap because your points suck and using big words makes it look more solid ;)

Its true there are a lot of Lurkers to choose from, and if I could I'd lunch them all today. Their play is hurting town, just like it hurts it in every game.

 

And I'm sorry my big words confuzzle you, I could try typing more slowly if that helps? There's a big difference between me having a big vocabulary and using the right word for the situation and trying to write big fluff posts full of vapid wanna-be fanciful speech like Darthe was writing.

 

 

It's not the big words.  It's using the big concepts to sell a theory that doesn't serve the town's interest.  Hence my vote on Wombat.  If you want to talk physics fine.  Another thread maybe?  If you want to use physics to insinuate you see something you cannot explain to others and try to sell that to the town as gospel I have to balk.  

 

Agreed.  Darthe is a tool without the intellectual capacity to play this game.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

I got reminded of the double role because of kaylee's lie, but couldn't push on it at the end of day.

 

I've only seen the series up to series 3, when Lancelot was definitely alive and good. Thanks for the spoiler,btw :(

 

Wombat claimed a confirmed townie vig would be a good lynching candidate. To which I replied a confirmed townie is always a good thing.

 

Only after confirmation.  Please shoot Wombat now.  This will confirm you to me.

[WWWwombat]

 

 

And the discussion on parsimony wasn't game related. I simply cannot abide the propagation of misinformation.

Then why the f*&% do you play mafia?

Because it's a fun game and the truth always comes out in the end.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

I do lurk when it suits me and the last two games I have made it until end game and been a major contributing factor in the town winning. Do you think quoting Einstein will do the same?

Its sadly true, that lurking can get you to endgame. Doesn't mean you're helping out town AT ALL. Had you actually stepped up to the plate and contributed more to those games maybe they wouldn't have come down to the wire. Don't try to convince me lurking helps town in any way. Its completely selfish, and shows you're too scared to actually play mafia and would rather stick your head in the sand till endgame.

 

And I never quoted Einstein btw.

 

 

I think Wombat did FTR.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

I think the whole conversation between you and wombat was merely "I'll show you mine if you show me yours" if ya catch my drift ;)

 

I'm not whining about being called out...I have nothing to hide. My question about going after a claimed vig created a big discussion that a lot of people got involved in. Discussions=information. What did you and wombat accomplish with the physics discussion?

 

I lol'd.  Do girls do that as well?

[WWWwombat]

 

 

 

I do lurk when it suits me and the last two games I have made it until end game and been a major contributing factor in the town winning. Do you think quoting Einstein will do the same?

Its sadly true, that lurking can get you to endgame. Doesn't mean you're helping out town AT ALL. Had you actually stepped up to the plate and contributed more to those games maybe they wouldn't have come down to the wire. Don't try to convince me lurking helps town in any way. Its completely selfish, and shows you're too scared to actually play mafia and would rather stick your head in the sand till endgame.

 

And I never quoted Einstein btw.

I think Wombat did FTR.

Not directly, but I can if you want.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

 

 

I do lurk when it suits me and the last two games I have made it until end game and been a major contributing factor in the town winning. Do you think quoting Einstein will do the same?

Its sadly true, that lurking can get you to endgame. Doesn't mean you're helping out town AT ALL. Had you actually stepped up to the plate and contributed more to those games maybe they wouldn't have come down to the wire. Don't try to convince me lurking helps town in any way. Its completely selfish, and shows you're too scared to actually play mafia and would rather stick your head in the sand till endgame.

 

And I never quoted Einstein btw.

I think Wombat did FTR.

Not directly, but I can if you want.

 

 

Fine.  Anymore locality versus causality conversation or do we need to ask Leonard Peikoff to play so we can get Ayn Rand's opinion?

 

Additionally, if you want to talk physics, did you bother to look at the double slit experiment from Dr. Quantum?

 

Can you explain how this factors into a mafia game?  Cause I'm pretty sure I can sell it.  

 

In your case, you want to use the "big concept" + "big intellectual" sounding words to pied piper the town.  

 

Me no like.  Me want to lynch you now or have the self-proclaimed Vig just outright kill you so we can confirm him + get your alignment.  

 

Best town move at this point.  Don't you think?

[WWWwombat]

Doesn't confirm his alignment, just that he has a kill. I'm well aware of the double slit experiment. The physics tangent was totally unrelated to the game. I don't know why people are having trouble with that. I brought up Occam's Razor in one post as a potential justification for not believing my previous case. Darthe defined it for Peace iirc. Then Des tried to "school" Darthe over the semantics of it because Des is even more arrogant than Darthe. The physics merely came about in the context of refuting Des' irrelevant and specious semantic argument. It had nothing to do with anything I was saying about gameplay. Get over it.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Doesn't confirm his alignment, just that he has a kill. I'm well aware of the double slit experiment. The physics tangent was totally unrelated to the game. I don't know why people are having trouble with that. I brought up Occam's Razor in one post as a potential justification for not believing my previous case. Darthe defined it for Peace iirc. Then Des tried to "school" Darthe over the semantics of it because Des is even more arrogant than Darthe. The physics merely came about in the context of refuting Des' irrelevant and specious semantic argument. It had nothing to do with anything I was saying about gameplay. Get over it.

 

Thank you!

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Doesn't confirm his alignment, just that he has a kill. I'm well aware of the double slit experiment. The physics tangent was totally unrelated to the game. I don't know why people are having trouble with that. I brought up Occam's Razor in one post as a potential justification for not believing my previous case. Darthe defined it for Peace iirc. Then Des tried to "school" Darthe over the semantics of it because Des is even more arrogant than Darthe. The physics merely came about in the context of refuting Des' irrelevant and specious semantic argument. It had nothing to do with anything I was saying about gameplay. Get over it.

 

I thought you didn't agree with the double SK in this game?