Merlin Mafia [Advanced!]- Town Wins!!!

[Tiinker]

well the doc would most likely protect hal, and since she claimed vig, a fairly new mafia would do their best to take out all the kills which they cant control, hence why its the most logical choice

 

That is... not true?

[lolguy26]

 

well the doc would most likely protect hal, and since she claimed vig, a fairly new mafia would do their best to take out all the kills which they cant control, hence why its the most logical choice

 

That is... not true?

 

 

i just read it and it seems confusing, i meant by she (kaylee) 

[Tiinker]

No I know what you meant. It's just not true.

[Tigraine]

I was genuinely curious about the kill, I can see how it looks like I'm playing innocent townie, I saw it before I asked. But I usually spend most of every game lurking until over halfway through because I can see the pros and cons of every statement I want to make and every suspicion...maybe I'm just too intelligent for mafia :D bahaha lmao (sorry, I crack myself up sometimes)

 

The only point I was trying to make is that it looks to me like vig or serial killer would help the mafia out in the long run. Obviously some of you don't agree with that. Quoting a couple of my posts then just saying "I don't like this" kinda seems like the cheap way out IMO and once again it's obvious that I'm not agreed with :)

[lolguy26]

No I know what you meant. It's just not true.

 

then why ?

[Krakalakachkn]

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

[Tigraine]

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

My point exactly!! So why the vote on me if you agree with that point?

[lolguy26]

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

 

whats this post supposed to mean?

 

i mean if the vig shot kaylee thats cuz he/she didnt want to CC and instead shot her

 

if it was mafia then like i said before, its to remove someone they thought was a threat 

[peacesells]

 

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

 

whats this post supposed to mean?

 

i mean if the vig shot kaylee thats cuz he/she didnt want to CC and instead shot her

 

if it was mafia then like i said before, its to remove someone they thought was a threat 

 

 

You know there is a vig?

[lolguy26]

nope, but since krak mentioned vig, i just went with it 

[Rhea]

Hey guys, I have the next 3 days off. I should be around more!

 

alannalynn...good luck with your cast removal!!!

 

I'm really not sure what to think about the NK.

 

 

 

Hallia: who are you and who did you target?

 

Just so I remember we still haven't gotten an answer to that: Hallia

 

For all clarity: I'll unvote as soon as we get her answer (well, unless she claims to be who I am).

 

 

Can someone reread Kaylee's posts. Mainly with two questions in mind:

- why did she claim vig instead of serial killer? I got the impression everyone read that claim as her having only one shot, while a serial killer obviously has a series of shots.

- who tried to strengthen her train without seeming to do so? This could have been a good tactic for mafia. 

 

Underlined blue: Why would you add that? That pings to me. Like its a threat or something. It also looks like you are implying you also have a PR. At least it looks that way to me. 

 

 

She refuses giving a character claim. Which lowers her believability enormously. Counterclaiming is not always the best course of action. Sometimes, waiting one or two days can have very good results. But no, I'm not a cop. A characterclaim will not help mafia in any way.

 

 

Way I see it, if Chuckles flips town, then TG's vote on him yesterday could have been a possible attempt at trying to follow my lead to earn my trust, and he'd be more suspect again. If Chuckles flips mafia, Wombat looks even worse and makes my fear of a potential gambit between him and Razen more likely. So he's a great info lynch imo.

What's the difference between this and "setting up a lynch", which a lot of you seem to find incredibly scummy?

 

Also, your not agreeing with my reasoning does not make it wrong. As shown in my previous post.

 

It doesn't help Town either. In fact I'm not sure what use it is at all.

 

 

I claimed my role.  Are you really getting that up in arms because I didn't say my character? Calm yoself, sir, for I am Arthur, future King!

 

I really don't know why this was necessary to force out of Hallia. 

 

 

 

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

 

whats this post supposed to mean?

 

i mean if the vig shot kaylee thats cuz he/she didnt want to CC and instead shot her

 

if it was mafia then like i said before, its to remove someone they thought was a threat 

 

 

If there is a Vig then this could be a viable explanation.

 

 

I'll do a full readthrough though. The only person sticking out to me right now is Thorum. I need to get a better handle on this game. Sorry I'm not being much help atm. 

[Krakalakachkn]

 

 

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

 

whats this post supposed to mean?

 

i mean if the vig shot kaylee thats cuz he/she didnt want to CC and instead shot her

 

if it was mafia then like i said before, its to remove someone they thought was a threat 

 

 

You know there is a vig?

 

 

Didn't Kaylee claim Vig?

 

 

I'm pretty sure she claimed vig.

[Krakalakachkn]

I'm vig.

 

 

See.

[peacesells]

 

 

 

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

 

whats this post supposed to mean?

 

i mean if the vig shot kaylee thats cuz he/she didnt want to CC and instead shot her

 

if it was mafia then like i said before, its to remove someone they thought was a threat 

 

 

You know there is a vig?

 

 

Didn't Kaylee claim Vig?

 

 

I'm pretty sure she claimed vig.

 

 

Dude...she flipped SK.

 

#2 on my scum list is Krak.  And he's quickly over taking Mish for the #1 spot.

[Tigraine]

Something that pinged me when it first happened and it still reeks to me is Tiiinks vote on Basel. He pops in, becomes the 3rd vote on Basel saying he will explain when he gets back online, and I still haven't heard ANY reasoning.

 

Looks like a way to officially start a train without havin to explain why.

[Tigraine]

I think the point he's tryin to make is that he isn't the one who first suggested a vig..it was kaylee claiming it that brought the idea to the discussion

[Krakalakachkn]

I think the point he's tryin to make is that he isn't the one who first suggested a vig..it was kaylee claiming it that brought the idea to the discussion

 

 

See, now I know you're trying to be helpful, but that wasn't a great move.  I goofed and have been called out and for you to come in and try to put words into my mouth, no matter how nice or helpful you're trying to be, can be bad for you (should I be lynched/killed and turn out scum).  Also, if I were mafia and trying to come up with an excuse or parry, you gave me one just now that I could maybe roll with.

[Tigraine]

Now I remember why I lurk a lot!!

[peacesells]

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

This post is where Krak mentions the word Vig.  He doesn't come close to implying there is one existing.

 

 

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

 

whats this post supposed to mean?

 

i mean if the vig shot kaylee thats cuz he/she didnt want to CC and instead shot her

 

if it was mafia then like i said before, its to remove someone they thought was a threat 

 

Chuckles runs with it saying "if the vig shot kaylee".  This implies knowledge that was not previously stated. 

 

 

 

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

 

whats this post supposed to mean?

 

i mean if the vig shot kaylee thats cuz he/she didnt want to CC and instead shot her

 

if it was mafia then like i said before, its to remove someone they thought was a threat 

 

 

You know there is a vig?

 

 

I question this knowledge.

nope, but since krak mentioned vig, i just went with it 

 

He blames Krak. (we should all blame krak cause krak kills.)  <=joke

 

 

 

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

 

whats this post supposed to mean?

 

i mean if the vig shot kaylee thats cuz he/she didnt want to CC and instead shot her

 

if it was mafia then like i said before, its to remove someone they thought was a threat 

 

 

You know there is a vig?

 

 

Didn't Kaylee claim Vig?

 

 

I'm pretty sure she claimed vig.

 

Now..for some unknown reason Krak supports Chuckles. 

 

Now I remember why I lurk a lot!!

 

Lack of lurking isn't the problem.  Answering for others is one problem...not reading things in context thoroughly before responding is another.  There is no reason you should be lurking.

[peacesells]

Now that I've posted that..I think I have 3 candidates for scum.  Mish, Krak and chuckles.  I'll move off of Mish for now as no one seems to be seeing her the way I do.

 

UNVOTE

VOTE LOLGUY.

[lolguy26]

hmm

 

your only reason is cuz i mentioned a hypothetical situation, if you notice the many "IF"'s there  

[Tigraine]

Okie dokie then....

 

I want Tiink to answer my question- what was his reasoning for voting Basel when he did and why didnt he ever explain?

 

vote Tiink

 

His vote placement, putting Basel up to a competing train, was a big move IMO. I'd STILL like to hear the explanation of what he though made Basel look scummy.

[Krakalakachkn]

 

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

This post is where Krak mentions the word Vig.  He doesn't come close to implying there is one existing.

 

 

I was answering lolguy's question for Tiinker.  That's why I didn't imply anything.

[peacesells]

 

 

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

This post is where Krak mentions the word Vig.  He doesn't come close to implying there is one existing.

 

 

I was answering lolguy's question for Tiinker.  That's why I didn't imply anything.

 

I know that.  Didn't imply otherwise.

[Thorum]

Rhea3, the red is not a threat, but a precaution/terrible joke.

 

Krak, if you agree that it`s a strange nightkill: why vote tigraine?