Ghost Mafia - 3 out of 33 survive - Town wins!

[WolfbrotherKronos]

I've been thinking along the same lines Nolder - those who have been confirmed have a good chance to have been turned.  I think you are taking the first chance you get to get someone though.

 

I'm gonna

 

vote Nolder

[Nolder]

I've been thinking along the same lines Nolder - those who have been confirmed have a good chance to have been turned.  I think you are taking the first chance you get to get someone though.

 

I'm gonna

 

vote Nolder

Fair play but it doesn't address the fact that he is dead wrong about Ape's meta and ignores the fact that before EP posted I was all over Peace's case.

 

In other words I do not think that my actions come off as "taking the first chance to get someone".

 

Do you have anything else?

[RandA lThor]

First of all, sorry for being gone so long, I was swamped and was barely holding onto modding my own game.  I am all caught up now.

 

So I AM in this game after all lol. I still don't have my role/alignment pm, so for now I'll start catching up under the presumption that I am third party unlynchable unkillable Survivor. Should be a challenge.

 

*facepalm*

 

10:00 pm

 

There are 3 Possessed.

 

With 30 players, it takes 16 to lynch.

 

Well looks like my theory was atleast half wrong. This phase will answer the other half.

 

 

 

In a smaller game I'm not sure I'd want to keep plugging away like this, but this game is still too big.

MOAR!!

Unvote
Vote: RTE

Steven is a girls' name.

Agreed. Luckily, my name is Stephen. You angling to be today's EP? You might not have a Bieber haircut, but the results will be the same if you'd like to go toe-to-toe.

;-)

 

Where is a Deathnote book when you need one?

 

@Leelou: Who says they aren't possessed?

@Ape: Shove it, this forum sucks for reliability. As a matter of fact I'm on the mobile version right now because the reply boxes wont load on the regular version of the site. It's just as much an issue as someone's computer or net giving out. You whining about the excuses is far more annoying than the excuses themselves.

When did we let Joffry in this game? Don't make me Imp slap you.

 

 

On a serious note, the fact that Rand slipped free 2 phases in a row bothers me. For the same reasons as last phase.

 

VOTE RAND

 

I haven't slipped past, there just hasn't been enough support for lynching me.  There's a difference.  Having a big handful of people vote me doesn't mean I slip by all the time.  Seems like really lazy reason.  Also, your votes past that have been very instinctive based on what just happened, no consistency with where you're voting.  Makes me think you don't really care who gets lynched.  

My professional advice is to not google the world "ultry"

Ahhh, I should have probably listened. 

 

I think Wombat was killed for hunting inactives. Think we should continue on that trail.

Vote: RTE

Wow.  First, that was some pretty bad WIFOM, he might have very well been killed so more inactives could die instead.  Not seeing anything important there.  Secondly, another lazy vote, without too much thought, don't like that at all.  

 

Nolder screams...

 

Everyone rushes to his side, looking at him questioningly.

 

"Spider - sorry, everything's cool."

I have to admit, I loled in this scene.  However, there is a small chance that DPR did include game info in this scene, as he said he is apt to do.  The scene indicates that Nolder is scared of something that is not the real threat, possible hint at saying that Nolder is not voting the right person?  Just something to keep in mind.

 

 

I would rather scumhunt and lynch someone else besides an inactive.  Let RTE be modkilled or something like that, but wasting a potential scum-killing lynch at this point doesn't help, IMO.

 

... so this stance will make people like RTE and other inactives perfect for conversions.

 

That said, I primarily agree with your first sentiment about scum hunting. What I don't like about this day is the people that jumped in after the Wombat death scene and started pointing to people that would have had motives for shooting Wombat. Reeks like framing. Remedial stuff, so I was surprised to see it from Verbal. 

 

Also surprised to see Verbal back off Leelou, since he sold it moderately well yesterday that she was a good vote.

 

I agree strongly with the bolded.

 

 

The case on Rand, from what I remember, is that water is wet.  I mean Rand was acting scummy. 

I lolled so hard at this.

I think...if Peace were scum he'd rather try to beat Des in a debate rather than kill him and WIFOM. It's not like 4 votes is a huge threat with 11 needed to lynch. I also don't much like the company I'm in on his train. I'll leave you be for now Peace but I have to say I don't think much of your play so far this game.

Unvote
Vote Darthe

Again with the WIFOM, trying to frame or not frame people because of another death is not good play.  It could have easily been Peace if he felt he was fighting a losing battle, and then he could just bring up that he wouldn' be so obvious.  I would continue looking at Peace's play instead.

 

I killed despo.

I actually think that this means that he is not possessed, at least not now.  It would not work to his advantage to have this be common knowledge as people would work towards lynching him for revenge killing.  Trust him a little more because of this.

 

So for now, 

 

vote Nolder

 

for using WIFOM to set up lynches after town deaths and a gut feeling on recent vote reactions. Can't really explain that part in writing though.

[Nolder]

Telling you why I am voting someone is not framing them.

What you are doing is exactly what I was doing, speculating.

[Gabriel Kross]

 

UNVOTE VOTE APE

 

I don't like the way APe is playing. He usually takes a more forward approach to games. Yes yes he was busy with rl stuff but stillI've never seen Ape ask for so much info instead of looking for it himself. Meta reasons but it makes sense to me.

Unvote Vote EP

 

You're wrong. When Ape is busy he often asks for someone to fill in the gaps for him.

I think you've been turned.

 

Well I've not played a game with Ape when he's been busy so moot point

 

You're wrong however, I have not been turned. However I'm busy irl so you can lynch me to test it if you like.

[Tyler Glembo]

 

 

You're wrong however, I have not been turned. However I'm busy irl so you can lynch me to test it if you like.

 

 

Okay.  vote EP

[WolfbrotherKronos]

EP's reaction actually makes me more comfortable with not lynching him.

[Tyler Glembo]

I personally am not a fan of the martyr play, whether town or mafia are pulling it. 

[Basel Gill]

Vote Leelou.

 

I'm still suspicious of her.

[Nolder]

EP's reaction actually makes me more comfortable with not lynching him.

As RTE's appearance after pressure made me more comfortable with lynching him.

 

If you're going to paint my actions as scummy I think you need to take a second look at your own play.

[michellem]

Really Basel? Tunnel vision much? I don't trust Leelou either, but right now you're just being lazy, putting your vote in the same place over and over so it'll look like you're participating.

[Basel Gill]

Really Basel? Tunnel vision much? I don't trust Leelou either, but right now you're just being lazy, putting your vote in the same place over and over so it'll look like you're participating.

 

I've already laid a case out on her. She made a lazy post backing up a lynch of Ithi by saying it would be more informative than any other lynch, without saying anything that could actually support that, instead relying on stuff that would apply to any lynch at all. Trying to look like she is scumhunting without really doing so? And her vote on me on p. 94 was so much OMGUS, even if it did come way after I originally began to case her.

[WolfbrotherKronos]

 

EP's reaction actually makes me more comfortable with not lynching him.

As RTE's appearance after pressure made me more comfortable with lynching him.

 

If you're going to paint my actions as scummy I think you need to take a second look at your own play.

 

 

I know my play looks scummy...defending myself won't change your mind anyways.

[John McClane]

First of all, sorry for being gone so long, I was swamped and was barely holding onto modding my own game.  I am all caught up now.

 

So I AM in this game after all lol. I still don't have my role/alignment pm, so for now I'll start catching up under the presumption that I am third party unlynchable unkillable Survivor. Should be a challenge.

 

*facepalm*

 

10:00 pm

 

There are 3 Possessed.

 

With 30 players, it takes 16 to lynch.

 

Well looks like my theory was atleast half wrong. This phase will answer the other half.

 

 

 

In a smaller game I'm not sure I'd want to keep plugging away like this, but this game is still too big.

 

MOAR!!

 

Unvote

Vote: RTE

Steven is a girls' name.

Agreed. Luckily, my name is Stephen. You angling to be today's EP? You might not have a Bieber haircut, but the results will be the same if you'd like to go toe-to-toe.

 

;-)

 

Where is a Deathnote book when you need one?

 

@Leelou: Who says they aren't possessed?

 

@Ape: Shove it, this forum sucks for reliability. As a matter of fact I'm on the mobile version right now because the reply boxes wont load on the regular version of the site. It's just as much an issue as someone's computer or net giving out. You whining about the excuses is far more annoying than the excuses themselves.

When did we let Joffry in this game? Don't make me Imp slap you.

 

 

On a serious note, the fact that Rand slipped free 2 phases in a row bothers me. For the same reasons as last phase.

 

VOTE RAND

 

I haven't slipped past, there just hasn't been enough support for lynching me.  There's a difference.  Having a big handful of people vote me doesn't mean I slip by all the time.  Seems like really lazy reason.  Also, your votes past that have been very instinctive based on what just happened, no consistency with where you're voting.  Makes me think you don't really care who gets lynched.

My professional advice is to not google the world "ultry"

Ahhh, I should have probably listened. 

 

I think Wombat was killed for hunting inactives. Think we should continue on that trail.

 

Vote: RTE

Wow.  First, that was some pretty bad WIFOM, he might have very well been killed so more inactives could die instead.  Not seeing anything important there.  Secondly, another lazy vote, without too much thought, don't like that at all.  

 

Nolder screams...

 

Everyone rushes to his side, looking at him questioningly.

 

"Spider - sorry, everything's cool."

I have to admit, I loled in this scene.  However, there is a small chance that DPR did include game info in this scene, as he said he is apt to do.  The scene indicates that Nolder is scared of something that is not the real threat, possible hint at saying that Nolder is not voting the right person?  Just something to keep in mind.

 

 

I would rather scumhunt and lynch someone else besides an inactive.  Let RTE be modkilled or something like that, but wasting a potential scum-killing lynch at this point doesn't help, IMO.

 

... so this stance will make people like RTE and other inactives perfect for conversions.

 

That said, I primarily agree with your first sentiment about scum hunting. What I don't like about this day is the people that jumped in after the Wombat death scene and started pointing to people that would have had motives for shooting Wombat. Reeks like framing. Remedial stuff, so I was surprised to see it from Verbal. 

 

Also surprised to see Verbal back off Leelou, since he sold it moderately well yesterday that she was a good vote.

 

I agree strongly with the bolded.

 

 

The case on Rand, from what I remember, is that water is wet.  I mean Rand was acting scummy. 

I lolled so hard at this.

I think...if Peace were scum he'd rather try to beat Des in a debate rather than kill him and WIFOM. It's not like 4 votes is a huge threat with 11 needed to lynch. I also don't much like the company I'm in on his train. I'll leave you be for now Peace but I have to say I don't think much of your play so far this game.

 

Unvote

Vote Darthe

Again with the WIFOM, trying to frame or not frame people because of another death is not good play.  It could have easily been Peace if he felt he was fighting a losing battle, and then he could just bring up that he wouldn' be so obvious.  I would continue looking at Peace's play instead.

 

I killed despo.

I actually think that this means that he is not possessed, at least not now.  It would not work to his advantage to have this be common knowledge as people would work towards lynching him for revenge killing.  Trust him a little more because of this.

 

So for now, 

 

vote Nolder

 

for using WIFOM to set up lynches after town deaths and a gut feeling on recent vote reactions. Can't really explain that part in writing though.

 

 

The red highlights in this are disgusting.

 

"The boy who cried WIFOM" in a big way. To me, it's just as lazy to point out wifom's (since most statements in these games are) as the lazy accusations he's making.

 

The part where he insinuates DPR's scene might be a legitimate hint about Nolder is crap. Bad form. If you are going to case Nolder, case him. All you are doing here is pointing at WIFOMs he's stating, and then leveraging a DPR scene to sell a half-assed narrative. 

 

I particularly don't like the logic at the end regarding how Peace telling us he killed Despo makes him town still. If someone with the vig ability took a shot, then got converted it makes total sense to admit to shooting someone. Nobody is going to "revenge kill", and admitting it is the best sort of bluff for scum, one rooted in the truth. 

 

I feel like Nolder is definitely town still. EP's "Ape not being Ape" case was garbage, and Nolder called him on it. Nolder knows that when my life gets buys, it gets VERY busy and he also knows I signed up for this game reluctantly. So half-assed participation is not outside of the realm of possibility from me. I usually bust Nolder when he's scum, so he could have taken EP's case as an opportunity to oust me. He didn't. 

 

Of the two of Rand and Nolder, I'd vote Rand. 

 

I also feel like EP took a crack at me, only AFTER I narrowed the aperture on who we should be looking at (those viewed via FLIR). EP had zero suspicion of me before I suggested that. Then all of a sudden he's rolling out a false-meta case on me. 

 

If you want to come at me, case me on my play, not on the pre-occupation of my RL. EVERYONE that knows me and has played with me, KNOWS I'd never intentionally hide behind RL. 

 

I think Rand and EP make good votes today.

[John McClane]

Really Basel? Tunnel vision much? I don't trust Leelou either, but right now you're just being lazy, putting your vote in the same place over and over so it'll look like you're participating.

 

That or it makes it look like distancing. 

 

Rand, EP, Leelou and Basel makes a nice narrow pool. 

[John McClane]

 

Really Basel? Tunnel vision much? I don't trust Leelou either, but right now you're just being lazy, putting your vote in the same place over and over so it'll look like you're participating.

 

I've already laid a case out on her. She made a lazy post backing up a lynch of Ithi by saying it would be more informative than any other lynch, without saying anything that could actually support that, instead relying on stuff that would apply to any lynch at all. Trying to look like she is scumhunting without really doing so? And her vote on me on p. 94 was so much OMGUS, even if it did come way after I originally began to case her.

 

 

 

OMGUS =/= scummy. 

 

Your case on her was that she made a lazy case on Ithi, who turned out to be scum? "Not trying to scum hunt" is the most subjective BS accusation I see people make in these games. It's completely subjective, and means as little as saying "you made a wifom". Means nothing. 

[John McClane]

EP's reaction actually makes me more comfortable with not lynching him.

 

You can't be serious?

 

I personally am not a fan of the martyr play, whether town or mafia are pulling it. 

 

This.

[John McClane]

Ooooh... going to see Star Trek! YES! 

 

Catch y'all later... once I see a vote count, I'll cast my vote as well. WOOT!

[Basel Gill]

Your case on her was that she made a lazy case on Ithi, who turned out to be scum?

A. We don't know that Ithi was scum at the time L made that post.

2. Even if Ithi was scum, this could have been a bit of distancing. Making it look like she wanted Ithi gone without actually coming out with something that might persuade others to vote Ithi.

[Nolder]

 

Your case on her was that she made a lazy case on Ithi, who turned out to be scum?

A. We don't know that Ithi was scum at the time L made that post.

2. Even if Ithi was scum, this could have been a bit of distancing. Making it look like she wanted Ithi gone without actually coming out with something that might persuade others to vote Ithi.

 

I think Ithi was Possessed from the beginning pretty much. Her claim seems to have been a complete lie and iirc she made that somewhere around H1 or H2.

[peacesells]

 

Your case on her was that she made a lazy case on Ithi, who turned out to be scum?

A. We don't know that Ithi was scum at the time L made that post.

2. Even if Ithi was scum, this could have been a bit of distancing. Making it look like she wanted Ithi gone without actually coming out with something that might persuade others to vote Ithi.

 

 

You really have the full on Tunnel going don't you.  Are you even going consider other options?

 

 

VOTE CLOUD

[michellem]

Uhm... Is that post correct Peace? If so, what's your reason for voting Cloud?

[Gabriel Kross]

I personally am not a fan of the martyr play, whether town or mafia are pulling it. 

Wasn't a martyr play. It'd be doing me a favor honestly. As it stands I see no way to win. My schedule is about to be completely full from June to July (had not expected that when I signed up for 2 games...) I gave a few people I absolutely want to see lynched Rand and Cloud. However there was never any body willing to follow through. We town are beating ourselves this game, that's all there is to it.

 

 

First of all, sorry for being gone so long, I was swamped and was barely holding onto modding my own game.  I am all caught up now.

 

So I AM in this game after all lol. I still don't have my role/alignment pm, so for now I'll start catching up under the presumption that I am third party unlynchable unkillable Survivor. Should be a challenge.

 

*facepalm*

 

10:00 pm

 

There are 3 Possessed.

 

With 30 players, it takes 16 to lynch.

 

Well looks like my theory was atleast half wrong. This phase will answer the other half.

 

 

 

In a smaller game I'm not sure I'd want to keep plugging away like this, but this game is still too big.

 

MOAR!!

 

Unvote

Vote: RTE

Steven is a girls' name.

Agreed. Luckily, my name is Stephen. You angling to be today's EP? You might not have a Bieber haircut, but the results will be the same if you'd like to go toe-to-toe.

 

;-)

 

Where is a Deathnote book when you need one?

 

@Leelou: Who says they aren't possessed?

 

@Ape: Shove it, this forum sucks for reliability. As a matter of fact I'm on the mobile version right now because the reply boxes wont load on the regular version of the site. It's just as much an issue as someone's computer or net giving out. You whining about the excuses is far more annoying than the excuses themselves.

When did we let Joffry in this game? Don't make me Imp slap you.

 

 

On a serious note, the fact that Rand slipped free 2 phases in a row bothers me. For the same reasons as last phase.

 

VOTE RAND

 

I haven't slipped past, there just hasn't been enough support for lynching me.  There's a difference.  Having a big handful of people vote me doesn't mean I slip by all the time.  Seems like really lazy reason.  Also, your votes past that have been very instinctive based on what just happened, no consistency with where you're voting.  Makes me think you don't really care who gets lynched.

My professional advice is to not google the world "ultry"

Ahhh, I should have probably listened. 

 

I think Wombat was killed for hunting inactives. Think we should continue on that trail.

 

Vote: RTE

Wow.  First, that was some pretty bad WIFOM, he might have very well been killed so more inactives could die instead.  Not seeing anything important there.  Secondly, another lazy vote, without too much thought, don't like that at all.  

 

Nolder screams...

 

Everyone rushes to his side, looking at him questioningly.

 

"Spider - sorry, everything's cool."

I have to admit, I loled in this scene.  However, there is a small chance that DPR did include game info in this scene, as he said he is apt to do.  The scene indicates that Nolder is scared of something that is not the real threat, possible hint at saying that Nolder is not voting the right person?  Just something to keep in mind.

 

 

I would rather scumhunt and lynch someone else besides an inactive.  Let RTE be modkilled or something like that, but wasting a potential scum-killing lynch at this point doesn't help, IMO.

 

... so this stance will make people like RTE and other inactives perfect for conversions.

 

That said, I primarily agree with your first sentiment about scum hunting. What I don't like about this day is the people that jumped in after the Wombat death scene and started pointing to people that would have had motives for shooting Wombat. Reeks like framing. Remedial stuff, so I was surprised to see it from Verbal. 

 

Also surprised to see Verbal back off Leelou, since he sold it moderately well yesterday that she was a good vote.

 

I agree strongly with the bolded.

 

 

The case on Rand, from what I remember, is that water is wet.  I mean Rand was acting scummy. 

I lolled so hard at this.

I think...if Peace were scum he'd rather try to beat Des in a debate rather than kill him and WIFOM. It's not like 4 votes is a huge threat with 11 needed to lynch. I also don't much like the company I'm in on his train. I'll leave you be for now Peace but I have to say I don't think much of your play so far this game.

 

Unvote

Vote Darthe

Again with the WIFOM, trying to frame or not frame people because of another death is not good play.  It could have easily been Peace if he felt he was fighting a losing battle, and then he could just bring up that he wouldn' be so obvious.  I would continue looking at Peace's play instead.

 

I killed despo.

I actually think that this means that he is not possessed, at least not now.  It would not work to his advantage to have this be common knowledge as people would work towards lynching him for revenge killing.  Trust him a little more because of this.

 

So for now, 

 

vote Nolder

 

for using WIFOM to set up lynches after town deaths and a gut feeling on recent vote reactions. Can't really explain that part in writing though.

 

 

The red highlights in this are disgusting.

 

"The boy who cried WIFOM" in a big way. To me, it's just as lazy to point out wifom's (since most statements in these games are) as the lazy accusations he's making.

 

The part where he insinuates DPR's scene might be a legitimate hint about Nolder is crap. Bad form. If you are going to case Nolder, case him. All you are doing here is pointing at WIFOMs he's stating, and then leveraging a DPR scene to sell a half-assed narrative. 

 

I particularly don't like the logic at the end regarding how Peace telling us he killed Despo makes him town still. If someone with the vig ability took a shot, then got converted it makes total sense to admit to shooting someone. Nobody is going to "revenge kill", and admitting it is the best sort of bluff for scum, one rooted in the truth. 

 

I feel like Nolder is definitely town still. EP's "Ape not being Ape" case was garbage, and Nolder called him on it. Nolder knows that when my life gets buys, it gets VERY busy and he also knows I signed up for this game reluctantly. So half-assed participation is not outside of the realm of possibility from me. I usually bust Nolder when he's scum, so he could have taken EP's case as an opportunity to oust me. He didn't. 

 

Of the two of Rand and Nolder, I'd vote Rand. 

 

I also feel like EP took a crack at me, only AFTER I narrowed the aperture on who we should be looking at (those viewed via FLIR). EP had zero suspicion of me before I suggested that. Then all of a sudden he's rolling out a false-meta case on me. 

 

If you want to come at me, case me on my play, not on the pre-occupation of my RL. EVERYONE that knows me and has played with me, KNOWS I'd never intentionally hide behind RL. 

 

I think Rand and EP make good votes today.

 

Put you're money where your mouth is, vote Rand and I'll trust you. Like I said I've never played a game with you in which you have had rl stuff come up, so I was basing off all the games I had played in with you. If I were right and you were mafia, you would be the biggest threat we have as town. So I went with a gut feeling.

[Tyler Glembo]

Ooooh... going to see Star Trek! YES! 

 

Catch y'all later... once I see a vote count, I'll cast my vote as well. WOOT!

 

I'm a bit jealous I admit, only movie out that looks even remotely worth seeing...

[Leelou]

Basel, that was not an omgus vote on you, I really feel you are possessed. I still haven't changed since my claim when verbal voted me. I'm still a vanilla town and I have never received an item. I have been playing crappy this game, and it's not because I'm scum it's because I really haven't been able to get into the game. You are just putting your vote on an easy target. I feel Basel, Kronos and the ones who have been viewed or the inactives are good areas to look today. I know some people are away, but we haven't heard from tig in days and when she was around she's hardly posted anything relevant.

 

For now vote tig