BASE MAFIA - Mafia Wins!

[dapianoplay3r]

He better have a hell of a reason

[Turin Turambar]

Dap, yes I saw that and I hate when anyone makes that argument. The dreaded newb mafia team that is unpredictable.

 

I want to hear from TG about his result. it is easy to post that sentence. Player X is (town/mafia). Maybe he is getting his sock puppets.

 

I also want to hear from AJ about where I said or implied that Snow was the cop. It is coming off like he took something I said and used it to get his team to NK Snow.

[dapianoplay3r]

Peace was on their team. I find i hard to believe he didnt bring up the NK especially whenn Turin claimed

if i knew id be off a QT when i died id give my thoughts. Same as when i think im getting NKed i post thoughts to the town

 

its a BS argument ishy

[Tyler Glembo]

I posted that because I was hoping to get make scum uneasy and hopefully get some sort of tell out of them.  My thoughts were that many of us have posted enough to give some tells, and the way Hallia voted Turin with me and then voted RTE seemed a little scummy so I investigated her. 

 

Hallia is town

 

As for Ishy, you do have quite the ego sir.  When, besides the last game, have I investigated you?  Maybe you're just sour about the last game still?

[John E. Kelley]

I'm....not arguing about it? I'm just stating my opinion of what I consider a good or bad decision. You certainly don't have to agree with my opinion, I actually couldn't care less. Take my opinion or leave it, doesn't matter to me.

[Tyler Glembo]

So, at least there are three confirmed town now.  That will give us better chances to lynch scum the next few days.

[John E. Kelley]

*facepalm*

 

Hallia? You investigated Hallia? Who was suspicious to no one and had next to no WIFOM surrounding her at all?

 

Well played.

[dapianoplay3r]

That was one of the most anti climactic experiences of my whole mafia career

[Tyler Glembo]

Yes, facepalm.  I did so for exactly the reasons stated, I figured I'd take a chance to look at a player who was entirely off the radar. 

[Tyler Glembo]

Which is exactly why I breadcrumbed it in hopes of getting something more.

[John E. Kelley]

Which would be fine if you were a regular Cop. In this game we had One. Shot.

 

And you blew it.

[Tyler Glembo]

Yes, I noticed. 

[Hallia]

So we know TG is town, and myself, at least that's something right? *brightsideoflifesong*  ^.^ So who are we going to lynch now?

[Turin Turambar]

With an innocent view I would have preferred that you not reveal just yet TG. there was still a lot of day and although you had heat you were not the only candidate for lynch. I say this because I think it would have been better if the mafia had to still worry about the possibility of being viewed. Also I think it gives too many nights now for the mafia to kill the confirmed people.

 

We still need to hear from AJ, Chuckles and Time to hear if anyone will be cc'ing.

 

I also still want to hear from AJ about the NK stuff he posted and where I said Snow was the cop.

[Turin Turambar]

Hallia, who do you think is mafia?

[dapianoplay3r]

Right. Turin is the first to call Rand out. He calls him over eager mafia for his vote on WOT

I wasn't officially in the game yet but it was a weird post

Then he starts back pedalling (http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/79409-base-mafia-day-3/?p=2788193)

AJ does some distancing and defending (http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/79409-base-mafia-day-3/?p=2788203)

 

 

 

So much defense but no unvoted

 

Because it was a joke vote...  I guarantee that if I had unvoted you would have said that I'm taking off my votes with little pressure.  FoS Dap.

 

He is trying hard to be as unscummy as possible. He starts to throw FOSs out to get us off his trail

 

Then AJ comes along

 

As I stated before, I think Rand's vote was a joke as most D1 voted are initially but his defense was notable. If it was a joke vote then why not just say so right out instead of commenting on personality traits first?

Also, I think an eye needs to be kept on Hallia. She seems eager to cast suspicion on other players.

 

He goes along with the idea that Rand is scummy but tries to move everyone away towards looking at Hally

 

Then Peace

 

Rand on the other had is most definitely scum.  VOTE RAND.

Full on attack on Rand. One mafia moves away from the team mate, the other dives head long in

Note; This is before Peace was getting any real looking at

 

 

It may be the drugs I'm on (been sick for 6 days) but I don't see what the deal is with Tinks post.  It makes sense to me.  We can case the newb all we want..but if we find him scummy, save him for day 2 lynch.

 

How does he learn if scummy actions arent pointed out?  What's difficult about this?

 

And really, it looks like people are just upping their posts counts by arguing a null issue anyway.  FOS a few of you.

He was referring to AJ there, it seems pretty obvious.

Then just a wild FOS, doesn't even bother to name the people

  

Thus far Peace no one has pointed out my actions as being scummy. Unless I'm wrong, I'm the newb you mention right? If you see something scummy in what I've posted thus far, please enlighten me.

 

Otherwise, I see you trying to defend Tiink. His posts obviously contradict themselves. Perhaps it is the drugs you're on, which hopefully are some good shiz, or you're trying to defend a teammate. Am I wrong to presume that it's typical gameplay for first-gamers to get a D1 pass? I don't see why Tiink is against it so much.

 

AJ distances from Peace, but still leaves the drugs as an opening to change his opinion if needed

 

 

Bah..Turin..it is the drugs.  I mix you two up at times.  My post should have said Turin, not Tink.  That explains Andrej's reaction.

 

Andrej is this your first mafia game or just your first one here?

He knows he is a noob. He called him that already. Feels like another case of making sure something is said on thread and it helps protect AJ

 

 

Bah..Turin..it is the drugs.  I mix you two up at times.  My post should have said Turin, not Tink.  That explains Andrej's reaction.

 

Andrej is this your first mafia game or just your first one here?

It's my first gave ever, but I'll take that question as a compliment

 

I did my fair share of reading before signing up.

I believe you have named this sort if thing as buddying. It does feel a bit chummy don't you think?

 

  

 

 

 

Rand on the other had is most definitely scum.  VOTE RAND.

 

 

 

gee, why don't I just deflect attention away from myself and then to another person who it looks might get a train for a joke vote.  

 

Distancing....

 

 

 

Now rand. Yes im poking and proding and appling pressure, its how people play and it works. Yes i would of probably thought an.unvote scummy but less so than not doing it.

Lastly your FOS of me. Feels like an OMGUS but without the balls to vote and because i havent actually voted you or really done much so, but you needed to do soomething to attemp to look like you were doing non jokibg stuff

 

People have voted me for unvoting too soon... I'm pretty sure the reaction would have been worse if I had removed my vote.  The situation I was in there would have made people look at me scummily both ways, just because I didn't specify it was a joke vote.  Seriously, I thought that me voting someone because they were too polite would have been seen as a joke vote.

 

But yes, I do get the poking and prodding part, and the FoS on you was exactly what it is meant to be.  I have some suspicion on you, but not enough for a vote.  However, peace is looking much more scummy right now, major FoS on him right now.  And no that's not because I'm scared of an OMGUS, if I voted for him with legitimate reasons, it wouldn't be an OMGUS anyways.

 

You were just scared to vote a teammate that wasnt getting too much flack.

 

Rand..the fact that you are even thinking about how your votes/unvote are gonna be intrepreted makes you scummy.  Town don't worry about how they look.  They just play. Scum worry.  Rand is scum.

 

Oh..and are you gonna OMGUS everyone who points a finger at you?

Peace keeps pushing hard. I don't think he thought Rand would get lynched. So why not distance

 

Getting to you Ishy. Still haven't seen Turin name snow a PR

[Andrej]

So you would rather the cop dies today than you. real town behavior there RTE. /sarcasm

I wasn't making this up lol

 

At the time RTE was voting Snow, who else could you have meant as the cop?

[John E. Kelley]

Still losing sleep waiting on Dap......

[Andrej]

Also, TG... sigh.

 

Right now you guys are just spinning in circles and creating more WIFOM for the mafia team to hide behind. Them killing Snow was a rookie mistake, call me scummy for saying so but I genuinely believe that. Time and Lolly have been hanging back all game and just letting us all poke at each other. Luckily, we fished out Peace. We now have 3 confirmed townies. That leaves 6 other players, 4 town and 2 scum.

 

And Dap dude, if you're gonna dig that deep for some trash on me just man up and throw down your vote already. If my train gets enough speed I'll hammer my damn self so you guys can all feel very stupid when I flip as a good guy.

[Hallia]

The people I'm leaning towards are Chuckles, Rand, Aj and mayyyybe Dap.  Going back through for the things I caught. (I just had a bunch, but while backspacing to take out unnecessary parts I messed almost all of them up. >.< )

[Andrej]

Rand?

[Hallia]

As far as Time, I'm pretty sure she said she was doing her book signing tonight, we may not see her.

[Hallia]

Sorry! Rand was suspicious earlier.  I totally blonde momented when he got replaced.  I think that was mainly due to him not being around much.

[Hallia]

I keep my mafia notes on a little pad by my desk, I didn't scratch him out when he got replaced, just added Ishy. XD

[Turin Turambar]

 

So you would rather the cop dies today than you. real town behavior there RTE. /sarcasm

I wasn't making this up lol

 

At the time RTE was voting Snow, who else could you have meant as the cop?

RTE was advocating that a random lynch was preferrable to his lynch. Even though it was possible for the random to take out the cop. It  actually could have taken out several people. You are new so you may not know this. In a Darthe game if there is no lynch acheived he uses a random number generator fo select a number for each player. If a particular number comes up for the individual, they die. so if we were unlucky multiple townies could have died.

 

Interesting tho that you were the one mentioning it and also surmising that the mafia used that to decide to kill Snow. How would I know who the cop was? I am obviously the vig, or was anyway. Only the actual cop knows that they are the cop.

 

vote AJ