BASE MAFIA - Mafia Wins!

[Andrej]

You're right, I'm just getting frustrated.

 

As far as a claim goes though, there hasn't been a night phase yet so it wouldn't be like he could give us any real information if he were cop. It doesn't specify whether the vig is day or night kill, but being as this is a "basic" game I believe that both roles are NA only. Who is to say he isn't lying? This early I doubt anyone would come out with a counter claim considering there is no doc to protect them.

[dapianoplay3r]

That post makes it sound like you would lynch him if he were the cop?

They need to be alive to use tgeir NA

[Andrej]

Not at all. I was making a comment to Turin about him being able to provide us with info although there hasn't been a night phase. If he claims, it'll likely save him. And then time will tell.

[dapianoplay3r]

Sttill, there are reasons for not hammering and you need to accept that

[Andrej]

I do accept it, what other choice do I have?

That doesn't mean I have to like the fact.

 

I admit that I hadn't considered the fact he could claim, so I appreciate you pointing that out for me.

[peacesells]

If someone claims cop or vig day 1 they won't be able to use their role regardless.  They will be dead night one. 

[dapianoplay3r]

Im a stickler for tradition

3 hours ish till i said id vote regardless

[Turin Turambar]

AJ, I am not saying that he could provide a viewing if he claimed cop or that he could necessarily shoot someone with a day shot as a vig. When I mentioned information I was referring to what he says and who he mentions or doesn't mention. there are loads of ways to get to who the mafia are as long as people keep talking. That is why I am okay with not hammering right away. The longer this day goes, the more time the inactive people will have to justify not posting and if we can actually get everyone involved in the game then we have a better chance of finding the mafia.

[dapianoplay3r]

Ive been in a game before where mafia were left alive to see what they would do

[Hallia]

Known mafia? Or the cop watched them for a while before revealing them?

[dapianoplay3r]

Known

 

Then there was the BG game where the dead were part of the game. Dam that was confusing

[John Snow]

If someone claims cop or vig day 1 they won't be able to use their role regardless.  They will be dead night one. 

Nah, vig can shoot

[dapianoplay3r]

Plus if he claims he has to try live up to the claim

[Andrej]

That kind of goes without saying Dap.

[Turin Turambar]

Snow, I never saw my ISO. Now I need to sleep so maybe I can see it when I wake.

 

Oh and since there is still no deadline, I will unvote for now. I will vote again in the morning if Tiink is not hammered already.

[peacesells]

Tink was last online at 8:43pm.  1 1/2 hours ago.

[dapianoplay3r]

Really? He was elsewhere on dm but not here

[peacesells]

Really? He was elsewhere on dm but not here

Click his name...shows the last time he was on.

[peacesells]

It's how I find lurkers. :-)

[Andrej]

On the subject, Rand just signed up for another mafia game.

[dapianoplay3r]

I cant do that on my phone. I do it on my laptop sometimes

 

dm has a lurker setting though. So you can read threads but appear iffline

[dapianoplay3r]

I expect to see him here soon

[peacesells]

I cant do that on my phone. I do it on my laptop sometimes

 

dm has a lurker setting though. So you can read threads but appear iffline

Then you just have to hit their content button and see if they are posting elsewhere.

[Andrej]

Did you kick him in the QT just now Dap?

[dapianoplay3r]

Ok slogging through i.managed to find that on my phone. When i find content though it shows me this as his top content

so can someone else verify he was around not here

 

AJ if hes seen around then i expect he will appear here soon. If not thats majorly scummy

but we wait and see for now