[ADVANCED] Forsaken in the White Tower: Town wins!

[Talya]

 

 

Yeah, RTE's claim sounds fishy. 

 

Only if he claimed Siuan...

 

It's not what he claimed, it's that he first posted a quote or something and then claimed. It just seemed off. 

 

Yes I know...if was a joke!   and a dig at him saying about having some fun in Mafia

[dapianoplay3r]

This is late coming...VOTE TIINK

 

So Player is town, stop ruining my guesses Ishy :P

 

Lets see what Tiinks is, if he isn't Godfather I would say Roo is. don't like Time's claim neither, RTE's is a better claim for now! 

This is odd. You went after me but one cop viewing and you let it go, yet because others think Pandy could be a GF you doubt his viewing

 

Why not doubt mine?

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Cindy, I swear just sign up for a game. You are watching so many games, I'm sure you'll be one of the best if you just play for once :)

 

been there, done that, got the T-shirt, made grown men cry like little girls.

 

so tempted but the humans in real life who care say i can't.

 

but hell yeah i'd pwn y'all if i could.

 

tasting the blood and it is sweet but it cannot be for me.

 

play on.

 

and do not let your game post count fall below mine, kinderleh. 

[dapianoplay3r]

How about you try match my post count

[Talya]

Sorry I don't believe you 100%, I don't believe that list until I see in a coroners report. So don't ever assume I suddenly think you are town, I just think those two are more likely for Mafia...I'm still not sure about your claim, but seems a bit better than the others at the moment, they are two very obscure AS's most of the others had quite a bit to do in the books...even Laras was in it quite a bit! I have been suspicious of Pandy/Roos for ages, and Time's actions or lack of anything, seems very off to me. I still didn't like the way you came in and started on me the day I was compulsed, so you aren't let off the hook, neither is anyone else who isn't dead! Ishy is the one I'm most likely to believe is town, and Darthe. 

[Talya]

Sorry I don't believe you 100%, I don't believe that list until I see in a coroners report. So don't ever assume I suddenly think you are town, I just think those two are more likely for Mafia...I'm still not sure about your claim, but seems a bit better than the others at the moment, they are two very obscure AS's most of the others had quite a bit to do in the books...even Laras was in it quite a bit! I have been suspicious of Pandy/Roos for ages, and Time's actions or lack of anything, seems very off to me. I still didn't like the way you came in and started on me the day I was compulsed, so you aren't let off the hook, neither is anyone else who isn't dead! Ishy is the one I'm most likely to believe is town, and Darthe. 

[Talya]

Oh blast, DM is playing with me and my posts, well if you didn't read it first time to read it again!

[dapianoplay3r]

I read everything

[Talya]

did you read both? haha

 

Is DM playing for anyone else again? It's been pretty good for a while

[wheeloftime13]

Sorry I don't believe you 100%, I don't believe that list until I see in a coroners report. So don't ever assume I suddenly think you are town, I just think those two are more likely for Mafia...I'm still not sure about your claim, but seems a bit better than the others at the moment, they are two very obscure AS's most of the others had quite a bit to do in the books...even Laras was in it quite a bit! I have been suspicious of Pandy/Roos for ages, and Time's actions or lack of anything, seems very off to me. I still didn't like the way you came in and started on me the day I was compulsed, so you aren't let off the hook, neither is anyone else who isn't dead! Ishy is the one I'm most likely to believe is town, and Darthe. 

 

what you call lack of anything or my actions is how I always play...

[_CLOUD]

 

Cindy, I swear just sign up for a game. You are watching so many games, I'm sure you'll be one of the best if you just play for once :)

 

been there, done that, got the T-shirt, made grown men cry like little girls.

 

so tempted but the humans in real life who care say i can't.

 

but hell yeah i'd pwn y'all if i could.

 

tasting the blood and it is sweet but it cannot be for me.

 

play on.

 

and do not let your game post count fall below mine, kinderleh. 

 

Awesome. 

 

How about you try match my post count

 

Hah you have way too much free time I can never match that, even if I actually put in some effort. 

[Talya]

 

Sorry I don't believe you 100%, I don't believe that list until I see in a coroners report. So don't ever assume I suddenly think you are town, I just think those two are more likely for Mafia...I'm still not sure about your claim, but seems a bit better than the others at the moment, they are two very obscure AS's most of the others had quite a bit to do in the books...even Laras was in it quite a bit! I have been suspicious of Pandy/Roos for ages, and Time's actions or lack of anything, seems very off to me. I still didn't like the way you came in and started on me the day I was compulsed, so you aren't let off the hook, neither is anyone else who isn't dead! Ishy is the one I'm most likely to believe is town, and Darthe. 

 

what you call lack of anything or my actions is how I always play...

 

I don't know you I just look at it as someone trying to avoid committing to much and trying to stay under the radar. 

[wheeloftime13]

okay, i understand... i was just letting you know that i always do that...

[John E. Kelley]

She's consistent with her usual meta Talya.

 

Still don't trust her this time though. But it's not due to meta.

[dapianoplay3r]

 

 

 

Cindy, I swear just sign up for a game. You are watching so many games, I'm sure you'll be one of the best if you just play for once :)

 

 

been there, done that, got the T-shirt, made grown men cry like little girls.

 

so tempted but the humans in real life who care say i can't.

 

but hell yeah i'd pwn y'all if i could.

 

tasting the blood and it is sweet but it cannot be for me.

 

play on.

 

and do not let your game post count fall below mine, kinderleh. 

 

Awesome. 

 

How about you try match my post count

 

Hah you have way too much free time I can never match that, even if I actually put in some effort. 

I dislike that you are not putting effort in but that's a personal thing rather than a scummy thing

[Tiinker]

A little overly eager on the hammering don't you think?

[dapianoplay3r]

Care to add something useful?

 

What's your real character?

[_CLOUD]

 

I dislike that you are not putting effort in but that's a personal thing rather than a scummy thing

 

I didn't mean it like that. I'm doing my best in keeping up with everything, but I can never reach such a high post count. This is probably my worst game ever, but you guys are doing fine without me. I will finish this game, and make sure to not get tangled up between keeping up with mafia games and RL stuff anymore in the future. 

[John E. Kelley]

Game time bitches!!

 

Be back later.

[dapianoplay3r]

Since time has such a poor number of posts I might as well do all of them

 

Helloo!!!

 

Useless

 

interesting combos....

Unimportant

  

 

There! Had to show the site I'm not a robot!

 

 

 

Mr. Bean and his hand teddy.

 

 

Fixed.

I don't get it...

  

Not game related

ummm... okay...

 

Tells us nothing

 

vote Len 

 

his cleverness is too much...

  

Something! But it's just a lousy vote for no good reason

it's interesting how everyone does that their first game... (even me...)

Not actually important in my book but could be taken as a defence I guess?

I don't believe that Thom would be in this game.... although, he did help Nynaeve and Elayne hunt down the Black Ajah in Tanchico and was with Mat in Tear, so it is possible...

A game related post! But it doesn't take a stand at all

Paired with the one below

  

I'm wondering if there would be some from the Salidar tower, too...

It looks to me like she could be fishing for information to make fake claims

 

 

 

 

Rand missing is suspicious to me.... unvote vote Rand

 

Rand had been gone for all games.  Why is Rand being gone suspicious here?

 

UNVOTE

 

VOTE WHEEL

 

Seems like scum trying to come up with a reason to vote.

 i quoted it like this because it was easier and I agree with peace

this is the only game I'm playing with him right now.... plus, I might not be on tomorrow because I have to go to the doctor to check my concussion... I find it better to vote for him now instead of tomorrow people complaining that they don't want the vote to go random and start telling people to switch their votes and me not being there to do so... while I'm more confident with a Lenlo lynch, Rand seems the way to go right now...

 

Rand was also the safest way to go. You haven't actually commented on the case against him nor on the one on Len. Yet you leave yourself open to go for both

 

have you ever played with me before?? even though this is my fourth or fifth game, I'm still learning what to do because I've never been good at analyzing things, and everyone always thinks that I'm mafia... then they either end up lynching me, or I'm night killed and proven town... 

Post. Make some actual game related posts

Secondly you never say that when you are lynched you are proven town when people find you scummy, and so far you haven't been NKed.... Odd since you are the perfect low activity choice for mafia

Kaylee....

 

this is the only game I'm playing with him right now.... plus, I might not be on tomorrow because I have to go to the doctor to check my concussion... I find it better to vote for him now instead of tomorrow people complaining that they don't want the vote to go random and start telling people to switch their votes and me not being there to do so... while I'm more confident with a Lenlo lynch, Rand seems the way to go right now...

There are lots of people in a game. If you had voted Len and been away for the doctor we would of understood and been fine

I don't like a no lynch, but from the claims, it seemed better than lynching town.... I don't quite believe Lenlo's claim, but it is possible that Birgitte's in here...

Another post of agreeing and disagreeing, not taking a stand

 

Right so far I say 4 content posts out of all those

That's all of the first day and night and half of day 2

[dapianoplay3r]

Okay... first off, what is a mail carrier?? at the moment, the people that I think are town are

 

1. Darthe- he's claimed Nynaeve, and in my opinion, that'd be a pretty hard claim to fake...

2. Cloud- claimed Thom, town doublevoter... even though I'm wondering how Thom could be a doublevoter, Cloud has been actively looking for mafia, but ill admit that it's odd that everyone followed him after he voted no lynch...

3. Player- mostly gut feeling, but he's not really had any scummy posts

 

 

the people that I'm unsure of are...

 

1. Kaylee- seems to be thinking things over and analyzing everything, leaning town

2. Tiink- unsure

3. TG- I'm leaning town, but I'm unsure 

4. Kae- she seems  hard to convince at some things, but I'm leaning town

5. Rand- mostly buying his Elayne claim, but not completely sure about being vanilla... and in one of his posts, i could barely understand what he was trying to say

6. Tina- leaning towards town

7. Pandy- I'm unsure what to think

8. Talya- leaning towards town... mainly a gut feeling, though

9. Lenlo- not completely buying his Birgitte claim, and to me he was acting scummy on Day1, so for me he could go either way...

10. Kronos- came in for Mish, hasn't really had any scummy looking posts to me, but he did say that there might be a SK in here, so I'm unsure what to make of his suggestion, but I'm leaning town

 

people who I think are mafia or am leaning towards thinking mafia are

 

1. Peace- seems jumpy to me... I've never really played with him before, so I wouldn't know if it's how he normally plays... for now though, I think he's being too jumpy voting one person, then a few hours or thereabouts later, he votes someone else... also, his back and forth thing with RTE looks to me like a) he's trying to make him look like mafia, or b) they're trying to distance themselves

2. Moon- never played with her before either, but at the beginning of the game, she possibly looked a little too closely at Len and Darthe's banter in my opinion... 

3. Ishy- his asking if Kae and Tress are dead yet, and then Tress ending up dead is bugging me... 

4. RTE- his back and forth with Peace looks like he's trying to distance himself from him, but Peace could be trying to make him look like mafia...

 

I think that what Ishy has said is bugging me the most as of right now, so...

 

vote Ishy

  

I actually like this post

 

lol..RTE I'm you #1 suspect yet you vote Ishy?

I didn't number in order... i just numbered as I went along...

You are quick to defend yourself aren't you

what does TL;DR mean??

Not game related. Last post for about 5 pages

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Darthe, I can only speak for myself.  I haven't posted all of my thoughts on who is coming across as scummy.

 

I'll throw you another one.

 

Ishy is probably scum.

 

Oh...I can see the responses to that statement already.

 

 

Better question then the one I almost doled out.  Why on Earth are you doling out your reads like treats and without any form of evidence?  This is the same sort of thing tha got you on my radar.

 

Also @Ishy you never did reply to how you know Egwene is in the game and you implied that it was more than simple logic

My role PM provides me with certain info. I'm not allowed to elaborate further than that. I had to ask Basel if I was able to even say that much.

this interests me, and I'm considering removing my vote, but I'm also cautious about doing so because I remember in the WWII game Ithi said she received info because of her role, had some people convinced and then turned out to be mafia...

  

That a little bit of fishing methinks. Plus I love how you make a reason to keep your vote on him, just so you don't have to try explain it later

that's true, but we didn't really know who was who and who a lot of people were in some of the early days when Siuan was Amyrlin... she was only Amyrlin for 3 books we saw her in...

But we did know who was who? You can just google it. Once again you are trying to keep all claims very ambiguous

Long quiet patch again

Then this

here...

 

Not important really

 

possibly.... i'm not sure what to make of talya more than likely being made to vote for Kaylee... as Peace pointed out, there are a few possible reasons...

More than likely? Odd way to phrase that.

Anyway you follow peace and offer no reasoning of your own

let's hope not... and I think that silence could be very hard to fake, but it is possible... 

You try to move people away from thinking of faking a silencing. Kae was just silenced and the night of this post she gets offed and janitored

 

No.  Some of the people voting Kaylee were voting Talya before and she is on that wagon.  in addition your logic was that kaylee was linked to Dap so if I was going to vote one of the two it would be Dap.  Besides, that train got run up without reasoning.

 

Talya hinted that she was being made to vote Kaylee.... that's how the train got started I think...

You tried to take some of the validity from the train with this I feel

 

I don't remember Rand claiming Egwene....

 

You were quick with this which to me suggests you are following closely but not posting

 

I have to agree that Len's claim right now isn't looking right as of now.... from the information we've gathered about who is who, Len's claim is sticking out as being the least likely... I'm unsure about the Kaylee/Talya thing because as it's already been pointed out, it could either be mafia trying to make Kaylee seem suspicious, or they could be trying to make her look town... I'm starting to lean toward the second option, but I'm still unsure...

It looks like Kaylee is going down so you start setting up that you think she is mafia

did you make that story yourself??

 

Not important

 

that was very good and amusing...

Not important

I don't really trust Lenlo's claim.... vote Len....

Once again you just follow the least scummy option

well this stinks... I mean the info helped, but we've lost too many town...

 

This post stinks.

 

I gave a list of who I thought was town and mafia... and I obviously have to go over and revisit my list...

Promising to go back and case...

I don't believe Moon's claim.... Else was too minor a character to matter at all in Tower matters... vote Moon

You vote her for the claim? Not the case, not the fact that she is scummy. Cos you don't think the claim is major enough

Still no case

happy birthday Rand!!! when day comes, I'm going to post my thoughts on who's mafia.... and as for your guys' "case" on me, i do that basically every mafia game...

 

No comment on moon. Puts off a case

Waiting to see who looks worse after who to NK is decided?

 

im not trying to agree wth veryone, im trying to look at every possibility....

You aren't sharing your thoughts much

vote Kaylee

No case yet

No comments on kaylee or Tiink

Just a vote

 

 

Breaking it here. Last few posts next

[dapianoplay3r]

Right last little bit

 

Yeah, I'd agree.

 

Time and RTE...what are you characters? 

 

I am Pevara...

 

Still not a word about Tiink or kaylee or her case

As for the reveal. It feels worked on

 

neither was Birgitte though..... she didn't come in until book 5... pevara came in in book 7... also, she was hunting black ajah...

 

http://wot.wikia.com/wiki/Pevara_Tazanovni

  

See worked on. Who better to claim than someone actually hunting the BA

that was just falme... she wasn't a major or recurring character until book 5..

 

You are happy to fight about this but not to talk about the actual game

 

I don't have a team and it's not a fake claim....

Wanna bet

Tiana- http://wot.wikia.com/wiki/Tiana_Noselle

 

 

vote Tiink

Interesting that you are the one to defend this. Especially since you were the one to bring up Salidar Aes Sedai

 

 

Sorry I don't believe you 100%, I don't believe that list until I see in a coroners report. So don't ever assume I suddenly think you are town, I just think those two are more likely for Mafia...I'm still not sure about your claim, but seems a bit better than the others at the moment, they are two very obscure AS's most of the others had quite a bit to do in the books...even Laras was in it quite a bit! I have been suspicious of Pandy/Roos for ages, and Time's actions or lack of anything, seems very off to me. I still didn't like the way you came in and started on me the day I was compulsed, so you aren't let off the hook, neither is anyone else who isn't dead! Ishy is the one I'm most likely to believe is town, and Darthe. 

 

what you call lack of anything or my actions is how I always play...

 

Covering yourself with meta.... Scummy

 

okay, i understand... i was just letting you know that i always do that...

So that case you said you would make like 20 pages ago?

 

Anyway your scummy.

About a quarter of your posts are actually content orientated. That's about 2 per phase

Still my favourite part is when you mentioned Salidar and now defend someone all these pages later who is using a Salidar claim

[Darthe]

Thank you all for moving this forward :)

[Basel Gill]

The team thought they had found another Forsaken. Tiink had seemed suspicious the last day or two.  But when he told everyone he was the kitchen mistress and Dap said he was also the kitchen mistress, things began to coalesce. Ishy said he believed Dap, and his words carried weight. One by one, the group advanced on Tiink He began to form a weave of Fire, but found himself shielded and bound in Air. He managed to free one arm and threw a quick punch at Ishy, but it was easily blocked. Three of the group then punched him at once, knocking him out cold.

 

 

Vote count:

 

Tiink (6): Roo, Ishy, Time, Rand, Dap, RTE
 

Not voting (5): Everyone else

 

It's freezing and I'm drunk! It is now Night 6. DL is Tuesday, Jan. 6th at 9 PM EST. Scene later.

 

Tiink, Moghedien, Mafia 1-shot weaver of Illusion (Janitor), has been lynched.

 

(Sorry about the game, Rand.)

[dapianoplay3r]