Hangar 18 [BASIC GAME] Game over! Scum win. Nolder & WBK.

[Hallia]

His case is very good, I'll go with it.

 

Vote Darthe

[_CLOUD]

I prefer to wait a little longer before hammering him Hallia...

[Hallia]

*nodnod* I didn't think I was the hammer vote, so I figured it was safe for me to do so.

[_CLOUD]

Yeah, but the mafia can now just sweep in and end it with one vote, because you just put Darthe on L-1. 

[_CLOUD]

Votes aren't counted at once. 

[michellem]

I gotta admit, I'm sorta resigned to the fact that we'll loose this. I don't even feel the passion for this game anymore; all my lust for the scumhunting has gone down the drain with the weak and cowardly way the mafia has played this. How about we just lynch me, and the mafia can get their NK, and we call this game done and never think about it again? Because honestly, I'm starting to feel embarrased each time I enter this game (Peace, this is in no way your fault). One of the things I love about mafia is the feeling of each team trying to out-smart the other. Here it's more like mafia saying "meh, F it, let's just f*ck with the other players"

[WolfbrotherKronos]

Yeah Nolder's case is very strong. It might be due to the big font sizes he used but it kinda convinced me. I'm also having a hard time getting a good read on Darthe, but the evidence against him is out there. 

 

Finally!  Scum team is Cloud and Nol, I got the linking I was looking for.  

 

Nol has stated he has no good reads on anyone else the entire game but look at how amiable they are with one another.  Of course, I expect that you all suspect me enough to not want to dive into this.  Thus I request that nobody else makes a vote on either of them unless we have exhausted the idea of no lynch and people are not amiable.  

 

Quite a statement you got there. 

 

Amiable? Furthermore, first you tell us that you don't expect us to follow your lead due to your scuminess, but then you go ahead and make a request to go for the no lynch. This post is contradicting in my eyes. 

 

>

Actually, that last post was a bit ham fisted.  Based on the way Nolder is pulling these last second pushes for a lynch I feel more strongly than I was able to early game.  The link to cloud is tenuous upon his casing here, the only real interaction that those two have had in this game.  You all know I am down to those three, but I will leave myself open to the possibility of a WBK train until I see Nol's case there.

 

Also, mafiaaaa come out to plaaayyy!

 

Ok, so you aren't so sure anymore that I'm scum? That was fast. You should make a decision and stick with it. Your play here isn't helping you out. 

 

This was what I was saying in my previous post - also Cloud - it takes 4 to Lynch...Darthe is at L-2.

 

I'm leaning towards Darthe.

[Hallia]

O.o Oh.  We should wait then for the rest to make their case then, shouldn't we?

 

Unvote

[Darthe]

I gotta admit, I'm sorta resigned to the fact that we'll loose this. I don't even feel the passion for this game anymore; all my lust for the scumhunting has gone down the drain with the weak and cowardly way the mafia has played this. How about we just lynch me, and the mafia can get their NK, and we call this game done and never think about it again? Because honestly, I'm starting to feel embarrased each time I enter this game (Peace, this is in no way your fault). One of the things I love about mafia is the feeling of each team trying to out-smart the other. Here it's more like mafia saying "meh, F it, let's just f*ck with the other players"

Somewhat my line of thinking. At least they putted themselves. That I haven't been hammered means both mafia are on me already and relying on the clear pressure to get the newbies to do it for them. Simple mafia ploy.

 

Don't be fools. If I was mafia why would I vote no lynch? It gains me nothing.

[Darthe]

Also that was a reference to Nolder specifically. Halley is clear town.

[_CLOUD]

I gotta admit, I'm sorta resigned to the fact that we'll loose this. I don't even feel the passion for this game anymore; all my lust for the scumhunting has gone down the drain with the weak and cowardly way the mafia has played this. How about we just lynch me, and the mafia can get their NK, and we call this game done and never think about it again? Because honestly, I'm starting to feel embarrased each time I enter this game (Peace, this is in no way your fault). One of the things I love about mafia is the feeling of each team trying to out-smart the other. Here it's more like mafia saying "meh, F it, let's just f*ck with the other players"

 

Yeah, I feel the same way.. This however doesn't mean that we should just give up on the game. No matter how the mafia has been playing this game, it would be a total loss if town just gave up on everything and quit. 

[Hallia]

*nodnod* Never give up, never surrender!

[peacesells]

Vote count:

 

No lynch (1): Darthe

 

Darthe (1): Nolder

 

Not voting Mish, Cloud, WBK, Hallia.

 

With 6 players it takes 4 to lynch.  Deadline is Tuesday night 11 pm MST.

 

THE RECENT TALK ABOUT THE GAME DISAPPOINTS THE MOD AND IS SHORT SIGHTED.

[michellem]

I'm sorry Peace, but that's how I feel right now.

[Hallia]

Just my take, but I'm happy with it.   Been a good game for getting my feet wet so far, with great people!

[Darthe]

hey people, vote no lynch and force the mafia to give us info or take a draw!

[Nolder]

 

I gotta admit, I'm sorta resigned to the fact that we'll loose this. I don't even feel the passion for this game anymore; all my lust for the scumhunting has gone down the drain with the weak and cowardly way the mafia has played this. How about we just lynch me, and the mafia can get their NK, and we call this game done and never think about it again? Because honestly, I'm starting to feel embarrased each time I enter this game (Peace, this is in no way your fault). One of the things I love about mafia is the feeling of each team trying to out-smart the other. Here it's more like mafia saying "meh, F it, let's just f*ck with the other players"

Somewhat my line of thinking. At least they putted themselves. That I haven't been hammered means both mafia are on me already and relying on the clear pressure to get the newbies to do it for them. Simple mafia ploy.

 

Don't be fools. If I was mafia why would I vote no lynch? It gains me nothing.

 

 

Also that was a reference to Nolder specifically. Halley is clear town.

 

I am so tired of pointing out your contradictions. You will say anything to get your way. Which is fine I mean you're playing the game I don't blame you. But you should try to make sense at least.

[Nolder]

Anyway

It's on Mish, Cloud, WBK, and Hallia

One of you is Darthe's partner so whatever and the other three are town

It sounds like you guys are resigned or tired of the game

What do you want to do? Should I finish casing everyone or what? I don't want to waste my time if no one is going to care and wont read it anyway.

[Hallia]

I would love to hear it!  I find it to be very useful information. :)

[Darthe]

Does anybody have a legitimate reason to not vote no lynch?  If you do I would love to hear it.  

 

 

Can anyone at all think of a strategic reason for the mafia to want to do this?  One that holds half a shred of viability?

 

 

Rushing has gotten us screwed up to this point.  That and only having 25 pages on D4 but I am tired of criticizing that.  No lynch is the only safe lynch today.  

[michellem]

Nol I'd like to see the rest of your cases, I find them very helpful.

 

 

I've been mulling over Peace's post, and... Do you guys thinks there's any chance that mafia only have even-night NKs?

[Nolder]

Alright then I'll keep them up I guess. I'll finish Cloud in a few hours or so.

 

Also no I don't think there's any chance of that being the case. This is a basic game and I feel like that would be something too unbalanced to do to the mafia without being upfront about it from the beginning.

[michellem]

I just can't understand what Peace ment otherwise.

[Nolder]

I think he was trying to say it's still anyone's game. It's true. One wrong move and one side will win and one side will lose.

[_CLOUD]

I'm willing to lynch Darthe. After reading Nolder's case he seems to be the scummiest player by far. I will give everyone a chance to case each other before voting though.