Hangar 18 [BASIC GAME] Game over! Scum win. Nolder & WBK.

[_CLOUD]

This game is soo confusing..

[_CLOUD]

Vote Hallia

 

I swear if this doesn't work I'm gonna hang you myself, Darthe. 

[peacesells]

Vote Count

 

Darthe (2): Nolder, Hallia

Hallia (2): Darthe, Cloud

 

Deadline is at 3PM MST Friday.

[Darthe]

 

Darthe:  your list of set-ups is wrong; this is the list of  scenarios we can have;

 

1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, 1 Sane Cop, 1 Sane Doctor, 5 Townies

2 Mafia Goons, 1 Sane Doctor, 6 Townies

2 mafia Goons, 1 Sane cop, 1 Sane Doc, 5 townies

1 mafia goon, 1 mafia roleblocker, 1 sane cop or doc, 6 townies.

 

We don't know if there's a roleblocker or not (unless you know because you're mafia of course, and that's why those are left out... Did you slip up there Darthe?). If they targeted me N1, they could have assumed that I was being protected by someone else, or they don't have a roleblocker and that's why they didn't bother coming after me N2.

 

Darthe are you gonna respond to this at all? Or are you just gonna ignore it and hope everyone forgets about it?

Ignore it?  I had to set up my own game, thank you.  The two possibilities you listed aren't possible because if they were and mafia targeted you then we wouldn't have you around. Unless you think mafia would decisively not get rid of their doctor?  

 

Albeit, I suppose that it is possible they submitted no kill but I am doubtful of it at the moment.

[Darthe]

@Songstress: Oh I didn't mean to say they were slips on his meta. I'm saying he's dropping general scumtells. The only thing I can think of is he's playing dirty on purpose because he's the cop and doesn't want to be targeted for a nightkill but if that's the case he's played it way way too strong.

 

@Hallia: Exactly. He keeps coming at you and then backing off and coming at you again for different reasons. I think by now he's just too invested in his story about you being the scum partner of someone more experienced to let it go. He has to see it through.

It is rediculous and contrary to assume that I am some sort of sole mastermind setting this entire game up, yet that is what you are attempting to paint me as.  Mafia is opportunistic, no self respecting player would be dumb enough to go back to a case like that of mine against Hallia.  Call it whatever you want but the reactions and all else point to this one being mafia IMO.

[Nolder]

 

@Songstress: Oh I didn't mean to say they were slips on his meta. I'm saying he's dropping general scumtells. The only thing I can think of is he's playing dirty on purpose because he's the cop and doesn't want to be targeted for a nightkill but if that's the case he's played it way way too strong.

 

@Hallia: Exactly. He keeps coming at you and then backing off and coming at you again for different reasons. I think by now he's just too invested in his story about you being the scum partner of someone more experienced to let it go. He has to see it through.

It is rediculous and contrary to assume that I am some sort of sole mastermind setting this entire game up, yet that is what you are attempting to paint me as.  Mafia is opportunistic, no self respecting player would be dumb enough to go back to a case like that of mine against Hallia.  Call it whatever you want but the reactions and all else point to this one being mafia IMO.

It's funny you say that because isn't that exactly what you're accusing pretty much everyone else of doing? First it was Red but then she got lynched, then it was me but then you tried to buy me off by calling me town, who's it gonna be next?

[Nolder]

 

 

Darthe:  your list of set-ups is wrong; this is the list of  scenarios we can have;

 

1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, 1 Sane Cop, 1 Sane Doctor, 5 Townies

2 Mafia Goons, 1 Sane Doctor, 6 Townies

2 mafia Goons, 1 Sane cop, 1 Sane Doc, 5 townies

1 mafia goon, 1 mafia roleblocker, 1 sane cop or doc, 6 townies.

 

We don't know if there's a roleblocker or not (unless you know because you're mafia of course, and that's why those are left out... Did you slip up there Darthe?). If they targeted me N1, they could have assumed that I was being protected by someone else, or they don't have a roleblocker and that's why they didn't bother coming after me N2.

 

Darthe are you gonna respond to this at all? Or are you just gonna ignore it and hope everyone forgets about it?

Ignore it?  I had to set up my own game, thank you.  The two possibilities you listed aren't possible because if they were and mafia targeted you then we wouldn't have you around. Unless you think mafia would decisively not get rid of their doctor?  

 

Albeit, I suppose that it is possible they submitted no kill but I am doubtful of it at the moment.

Or she's lying and is mafia. But let's not mention that. Distancing noted.

[Darthe]

I have considered that but if she is lying then we should either have a real doc or a cop.  If cop doesn't (or didn't) view her that person is dim.  Either way this play could only last for a day.  You know things like this, why are you being so intentionally obtuse?

[michellem]

 

 

Darthe:  your list of set-ups is wrong; this is the list of  scenarios we can have;

 

1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, 1 Sane Cop, 1 Sane Doctor, 5 Townies

2 Mafia Goons, 1 Sane Doctor, 6 Townies

2 mafia Goons, 1 Sane cop, 1 Sane Doc, 5 townies

1 mafia goon, 1 mafia roleblocker, 1 sane cop or doc, 6 townies.

 

We don't know if there's a roleblocker or not (unless you know because you're mafia of course, and that's why those are left out... Did you slip up there Darthe?). If they targeted me N1, they could have assumed that I was being protected by someone else, or they don't have a roleblocker and that's why they didn't bother coming after me N2.

 

Darthe are you gonna respond to this at all? Or are you just gonna ignore it and hope everyone forgets about it?

Ignore it?  I had to set up my own game, thank you.  The two possibilities you listed aren't possible because if they were and mafia targeted you then we wouldn't have you around. Unless you think mafia would decisively not get rid of their doctor?  

 

Albeit, I suppose that it is possible they submitted no kill but I am doubtful of it at the moment.

 

Like I said, they could have thought someone else protected me. I'm not gonna assume they don't have a roleblocker before I make it through the next night alive.

 

 

Kronos, Hallia, Cloud (I know you're sick dear, but still) , Tress, you guys really need to be more active. We're such a small game and can't afford for anyone to sit back and watch (but no Nol, I'm not gonna start policy lynching on inactivity).

[Hallia]

I sit and refresh this off and on all day, I am just hesitant to post super often if I'm not sure quite how to voice my suspicions. XD

[Hallia]

I have considered that but if she is lying then we should either have a real doc or a cop.  If cop doesn't (or didn't) view her that person is dim.  Either way this play could only last for a day.  You know things like this, why are you being so intentionally obtuse?

 

So if on this next night phase (assuming I don't get lynched lol) I don't die, is it safe to assume a doc protected me?

[michellem]

Not at all, since I'm the doc and honestly, unless a cop reveals, I'm not gonna protect anyone but myself...

[WolfbrotherKronos]

I have considered that but if she is lying then we should either have a real doc or a cop.  If cop doesn't (or didn't) view her that person is dim.  Either way this play could only last for a day.  You know things like this, why are you being so intentionally obtuse?

 

Agreed - I'm pretty much sure that Mish is probably doc for the same reasons.

 

Not feeling good on Cloud.  Hallia I'm unsure on, but dislike her logic on thinking Darthe is scum because he voted for her. Darthe I'm unsure.  I still think Nolder is scummy as well.  Want to hear Tress's ideas.

[Hallia]

 

I have considered that but if she is lying then we should either have a real doc or a cop.  If cop doesn't (or didn't) view her that person is dim.  Either way this play could only last for a day.  You know things like this, why are you being so intentionally obtuse?

 

Agreed - I'm pretty much sure that Mish is probably doc for the same reasons.

 

Not feeling good on Cloud.  Hallia I'm unsure on, but dislike her logic on thinking Darthe is scum because he voted for her. Darthe I'm unsure.  I still think Nolder is scummy as well.  Want to hear Tress's ideas.

Unless you and she are both Mafia O.o

[Darthe]

Hally why would a doc protect you? Are you cop?

 

Also since you watch the thread so muc you should have no trouble giving your read on every living player.

[Darthe]

Hally?  I know you're on right now.

[Hallia]

Yep! I am.  I have been thinking, it does seem like you are town.  You genuinely seem to care about who is/isn't scum.  I don't know everyone very well yet, but it seems like you're willing to hear people's cases when they defend themselves.  I think Nolder's town, but I am getting a funny feeling about Kronos.  

[Hallia]

So if I think Kronos is scum, and he  suspects you and Nol but defends Tress, would he be defending a fellow mafioso?

[WolfbrotherKronos]

When did I defend tress Hallia. I said I wanted to hear her thoughts.

[Hallia]

I skimmed through to fast, my apologies! :)  You did indeed just ask for her thoughts.

[Darthe]

So, you will be doing that comprehensive list when?  

[Hallia]

Soon as I get home from work. :D

[_CLOUD]

So, you will be doing that comprehensive list when?  

 

Dude, stop pushing her. She will write down her case when she has the time or when she feels like doing so, or else we just play on as we always have. 

 

I'm more interested in that case Nolder said he would write about each player. 

[Darthe]

I'm more interested in getting a solid string of thoughts from every player in the game instead of the half that have been posting.  The inactivity quite frankly disgusts me.  I don't say that to sound pompous but I do not consider winning by not playing to mean anything and I think it against the spirit of the game.

[WolfbrotherKronos]

Mish is good - I think she is town doc and I'm willing to believe that role for now.

 

Hallia - Not sure - don't understand your case on her Darthe though

 

Cloud - Not comfortable with his play - lots of jumping votes - he says his vote on Red was not OMGUS - I still think it was.  He also refused to move from her on day 2.

 

Nolder - Don't like his play either for the reasons I stated Day 1

 

 

 

My vote is on Cloud