[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[RandA lThor]

There he is. Ishy can you tell us who you doubled last night, I may have missed it?

[Sakaea]

Official Vote Count:

 

Nightstrike (2) - Despo, Eds

Dice (1) - Red

 

 

Not Voting (11): Ishy, Kaylee, EP, Verbal, Dice, BG, Misheru, JLM, Rand, Cyan, Basel

 

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

 

No deadline yet.

 

Cyan has been replaced by Nightstrike.

[John E. Kelley]

EP would have had two NA's last night due to me targetting him the night before. I'd rather not say who I doubled last night just yet, so the scum won't target them tonight before they get to use their NA.

[bgrishinko]

I think there's another person thats a doubler Red.

 

Ishy is a motivator which is effectively a role doubler. Pay attention people. How are we to scum hunt when people can't even get the claims right?

[JenLenaMom]

I find it interesting that after a little bit of pressure Cyan decided she couldn't play anymore. I mean I understand having time constraints and being worried about tests but it was only after people started poking her that she decided she needed out.

[RandA lThor]

EP would have had two NA's last night due to me targetting him the night before. I'd rather not say who I doubled last night just yet, so the scum won't target them tonight before they get to use their NA.

 

OK, but tell us tomorrow, allows us to verify your cultitude. I'm just going to throw this out there, everyone with a role should always be checked whether they used it or not and all RB roles like EP should definitely say it. Best way to catch culted people.

[Red2111]

Ishy, did you character claim??

 

 

i stress the character claims becuase well if you've revealed yoru role you might as well and charcter claims have nabbed us the SK and 1 Scum so its a good track record in this game imo. wont help with Cult, but will help with scum imo

 

 

EP - Jon Snow - Jailer

Red - Catlyn Stark - Even Night Healer

ED - Robb Stark - Finder

BG - Gendry - RB Enabler

Ishy - ??? - Motivator

[John E. Kelley]

Let's just say that I always pay my debts.

 

And I have a weakness for whores and beer.

[John E. Kelley]

And rereading that, I now realize how ambiguous that was. Going off that clue, I could be claiming.....Ishy.

 

I'm Tyrion Lannister.

[Red2111]

hmmm so your claiming a Lannister then. but not just any Lannister, the Imp.

 

 

i'm ify on this one tbh. Tyrion is a good character, but still sides and protects his family.

 

 

and i like the Imp, he's one of my favs in the series. it pains me greatly to think about voting you. also, your role doesn't work the same night?? thats ... odd. why the delay??

 

 

however. Ed claiming to be blocked still has me etchy on him and is the most concrete thing to go on right now imo. BG, did you target Basel last night??

 

 

*notes JLMs appearance again after being mentioned* i also dislike how she's pushing the Cyan thing now on general principle. if a perosn backs out of a game because their getting pressure then thats poor play, but imo its poor play to use that in a case to push their lynch.

 

 

also, have i left anyone off the list??

 

EP - Jon Snow - Jailer

Red - Catlyn Stark - Even Night Healer

ED - Robb Stark - Finder

BG - Gendry - RB Enabler

Ishy - Tyrion Lannister - Motivator

[bgrishinko]

I don't target anyone. While I'm alive, RBers keep their powers. If I die, they get nerfed. That's why I thought with 3 RB's one of them might have started cult with Tress as Despo had suggested. It made sense to me that there would be 1 town, 1 mafia, 1 cult blocking role considering my role.

[RandA lThor]

hmmm so your claiming a Lannister then. but not just any Lannister, the Imp.

 

 

i'm ify on this one tbh. Tyrion is a good character, but still sides and protects his family.

 

 

and i like the Imp, he's one of my favs in the series. it pains me greatly to think about voting you. also, your role doesn't work the same night?? thats ... odd. why the delay??

 

 

however. Ed claiming to be blocked still has me etchy on him and is the most concrete thing to go on right now imo. BG, did you target Basel last night??

 

 

*notes JLMs appearance again after being mentioned* i also dislike how she's pushing the Cyan thing now on general principle. if a perosn backs out of a game because their getting pressure then thats poor play, but imo its poor play to use that in a case to push their lynch.

 

 

also, have i left anyone off the list??

 

EP - Jon Snow - Jailer

Red - Catlyn Stark - Even Night Healer

ED - Robb Stark - Finder

BG - Gendry - RB Enabler

Ishy - Tyrion Lannister - Motivator

 

I think those are all the claims. Are you trying to get mass roleclaim for powered town? Not that that is always mafioso, just a legitimate question

[JenLenaMom]

I'm not pushing anyone's lynch just posting my observations since my lack of doing so is apparently your main point against me.

[Red2111]

No rand, not trying to get a mass claim going on. just want all the revealed info in one place thats easier to keep track of for all of us. and as i stated in a previous post, if you role reveal then you might as well character reveal. especially seeing how helpful character reveals have been thus far in the game (getting us the SK and getting us a scumster)

 

I don't target anyone. While I'm alive, RBers keep their powers. If I die, they get nerfed. That's why I thought with 3 RB's one of them might have started cult with Tress as Despo had suggested. It made sense to me that there would be 1 town, 1 mafia, 1 cult blocking role considering my role.

 

i disagree tbh. havign a RBer with a cult would over power the cult and does nothign for game balance. Town has a RBer to help stop the NK; Mafia has a RBer to help stop the finder or healer. cult benefits more by having a back up recruiter if two start out (which is generally the case)

 

 

 

edit for JLM - no, my main point against you has been adn always is your actionas agaisnt Strike N1. the casing and how you and Mish were the two who stood to gain the most from Red 1.0's NK. your lurking and such are additaves to point out.

[John E. Kelley]

@Red

 

Ask Tywin how much I side with and protect my family, m'kay?

[Red2111]

Twin was the exception, and rightly so. but he protected Jamie and Cercies secret, even tolerated Joffery and had a fondness for his other Niece and Nephew.

 

 

this games also takes place before that particularly epic scene happens.

 

 

thsi said. i'm goign back to work, off my lunch break now

[bgrishinko]

No rand, not trying to get a mass claim going on. just want all the revealed info in one place thats easier to keep track of for all of us. and as i stated in a previous post, if you role reveal then you might as well character reveal. especially seeing how helpful character reveals have been thus far in the game (getting us the SK and getting us a scumster)

 

I don't target anyone. While I'm alive, RBers keep their powers. If I die, they get nerfed. That's why I thought with 3 RB's one of them might have started cult with Tress as Despo had suggested. It made sense to me that there would be 1 town, 1 mafia, 1 cult blocking role considering my role.

 

i disagree tbh. havign a RBer with a cult would over power the cult and does nothign for game balance. Town has a RBer to help stop the NK; Mafia has a RBer to help stop the finder or healer. cult benefits more by having a back up recruiter if two start out (which is generally the case)

 

 

 

edit for JLM - no, my main point against you has been adn always is your actionas agaisnt Strike N1. the casing and how you and Mish were the two who stood to gain the most from Red 1.0's NK. your lurking and such are additaves to point out.

 

Yeeeahhhh.... but then there's the Jailer which throws off that balance I think.

[Verbal32]

I blocked Verbal last night. So we know that he wasn't the one to make the kill, even if he is scum.

I blocked Verbal last night. So we know that he wasn't the one to make the kill, even if he is scum.

 

Um..........

 

Didn't EP do that like Day 1-3?

I blocked Verbal last night. So we know that he wasn't the one to make the kill, even if he is scum.

 

Basel actually blocked nobody.

 

I blocked 2 people last night. Basel and Dice. I pretty much picked a random for the second. However I do not believe basel to be town so blocked him.

 

Apparently I was a hot topic last night. I even wore my nice dress. >_>

 

 

 

As for Verb, he was the LAST vote on Darthe, so that def could have been a bussing vote after Darthe had the slip he did.

 

Then he says here that he was considering voting Razen, but is now reconsidering because of the speed of the votes. Seems like it could be a possible attempt to derail Razen's lynch.

 

Thanks for that. I'm actually with you on this.

 

Vote: Red

 

Then he bandwagons on to BG's case on Red, and never moves his vote before the hammer is dropped on Razen.

 

Speaking of BG's case on Red, since he is still thinking something might be up: I doubt that Red was recruited. Your case on her def made a lot of sense, but it seems more like she is just not paying as close attention to the game anymore. Red is a very high profile player, and because of this tends to get lynched or NK'ed early fairly often. CL's tend to steer clear of high profile players because of this- the longer cult goes by unnoticed, the better for them, so once again I doubt Red was recruited, and without a CC she's pretty much cleared as not being mafia

 

Back to Verb: You really can't deny that the challenge that Darthe issued does connect him and Verb in some way, Verb was the leading train when Darthe issued the challenge. Verb tried playing this off later, but his responses didn't really cut it for me. When you add in that he seemed to be distancing himself from a lynch on Razen, it makes the case against him look even stronger

 

In conclusion, my top 3 for remaining mafia are Cyan, Dice, and Verbal. Kaylee strikes me as possible cult, and I have some other ideas about who could have been recruited, but for now we should focus on getting the last mafia so we don't have a NK to worry about when we try finding the rest of the cult.

 

Vote Cyan, yall. She's teh mafialuminatous

 

Wait, you think I distanced from Razen? Ha, talk about connecting dots that don't exist....I was on the fence with Razen, and I liked BG's case on Red. I wasn't around before the deadline, so I didn't peel off. That does not equate to distancing on Razen.

 

I do, however, agree that Darthe basically linked himself to me with the timing of his challenge that day. Nothing I can do about that, but answer questions posed to me. You have to admit, when mafia link with a townie and defend them, it can set up their lynch later in the game - if nothing else, it was a good play by Darthe, especially if it gets me lynched later on.

[Verbal32]

I just realized that "dress" comment might make you think it was a character hint - it was not.

 

I'll claim if folks want it - I just don't see the need right now.

[Nightstrike]

Well there's Basel who doesn't seem too scummy to me, but his choices of who to use his blocking thingie on is questionable. Could be anyone really, don't know.

EP is very loud and seems to like having all the attention on himself but I don't think he's mafia. He could be cult cuz of his char, but I think it's more likely that he's town.

I think Kaylee is lurkey and has a few oddly placed votes. I dislike how she disappears so often. I think she's probably cult and she's pretty much just stayed under the radar for now.

I'd really like to believe BG's cult. He's just said so many things that have pinged me that I just can't see him as town. But then I don't see cult recruiting him, so I'm at a loss.

I don't think Red is mafia as I think it would be stupid to fake claim a major character but I don't like how she's had time to post a lot during the night about a bunch of unrelated stuff but then isn't around as much during the day.

The new Rand I keep getting confused with the old Rand.

Dice is really very lurkey and needs to post more. With how it is now, I think he's likely to be scum.

For some reason I've got the feeling that JLM is mafia, but I don't know why exactly. I haven't seen her around all that much.

I think Ishy, Mish and Ed are town.

Verbal is one of the people I didn't pay enough attention to in the beginning and it's too late now to look back. But I figure with so many of you thinking he's scum, one of you is bound to post a case on him sooner or later, and then I'll come to my own conclusions.

I think I agree with the essentials of what Cyan said. I used to think Ed might be a scummie, but I probably reacted to things from earlier. Someone said he was off his meta or something, and that might also have been something that I got stuck with. Mish seemed townish to me before, and she still does, I guess. Red is very likely town, I think. Kaylee seemed slightly scummish to me before, during the time of "NS the first" (gut feelings from the train of NS-1), although I might have missed something important that happened later - but still, Cyan seemed to have the same opinion (or similar, at least) . I'll have to reread what took place back then, and maybe I see things in a different light now?

[Verbal32]

Is the vote count being reset for NS, or remaining as is?

[dicetosser1]

EP why the change? you have been absolutely adamant about Verb all game and now u dont block him?

 

You really should start reading the game more closely or taking notes, I stated previously that while I still don't trust Verb, call it stubborness if you will, he isn't a main concern at this point. We know Razen isn't the Mafia killer at this point, I had half expected basel bussed him for townie cred hence the vote on basel. However, your White Knight act for Tress earlier in game and your lack of attention to details in the game is what nudged me towards you over some other people.

 

all i asked for was a reason EP which you didnt give. As for details...look at this i go to bed for less then 8 hrs and u guys put on 3 pages when i go to work i come home to like 7 pages try catching up quicklyh and catching ALL the details. Im not a note taker never have been never will be....thats too much work and this is sposed to be a game not work

 

As far as what I was originally going to comment on, Dice follows along with Razen's logic onto BG, even though his vote was counted for Darthe.

 

Dice, why wouldn't you have said something if your vote wasn't counted correctly?

 

This pings pretty big to me, both the vote for BG and the fact that he didn't ask the mods for clarification.

 

Then there's the fact that Dice has only contributed 34 posts out of 2,500 total (Yay! I'm post #2,500! ), which is obviously a very small percentage. And he replaced in day 1, so he can't use that excuse for his low post count.

 

Now with his recent faint pushing on EP, I gotta say he's pinging pretty big

 

Des i ALWAYS have low post counts and you have played with me enough to know that.

As for the vote i didnt mention it cause i didnt notice it. for further explanation look above

[Sakaea]

Official Vote Count:

 

Dice (1) - Red

 

 

Not Voting (11): Ishy, Kaylee, EP, Verbal, Dice, BG, Misheru, JLM, Rand, Cyan, Basel, Despo, Eds

 

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

 

No deadline yet.

 

 

Votes on Cyan/NS have been cleared to give NS a fair shake.

[bgrishinko]

Okay so Vote Kaylee.

 

At this point with mafia and cult on our hands, we can't have people lingering on the edges. Too many potential people to try and ride out the storm. I know she's been fairly active (even posting WoTs!) in some other games, so her lurkyness here is notable. Cyan has been replaced so NS should do some more posting there, Dice is starting to talk more. Everyone else has been speaking I think.

[bgrishinko]

1. Ishy - Tyrion - Motivator

6. EP - Jon Snow - Jailer

7. Red 2.0 - Catlyn Stark - Odd Doc

13. BG - Gendry - RB Enabler

21. Eds - Robb Stark - Cop

 

22. Basel 2.0 - ? - Roleblocker

 

2. Kaylee - ??

11. Verbal - ??

12. dice - ??

17. Misheru - ??

18. JLM - ??

19. Rand 2.0 - ??

20. Nightstrike 2.0 - ??

23. Despo - ??

 

On our list of claims, Basel Gill didn't character claim that I remember.