[BASIC] Repo! The Genetic Opera Mafia - GAME OVER - MAFIA WINS

[Darthe]

That was scummy. He can't know your ability so he can't be faulted for his actions. He is pretty much confirmed by this (as you said, Ishy was mafia RB).

[randomh3r0]

Scummy even to say he's town, like I did? Just pointing out how little that play benefited town (if at all) if its true.

So fine, Rands town, just like I said. That still doesn't make me mafia, which I'm not.

Instead of just tunneling me, saying "that's scummy" after everything I say, why not take the time to actually scum hunt a bit?

I for one am extremely interested in Nols now that Rand has a power role. Considering how much they argued, and then Nols' completely changing his game up in time for a night with only one NK, I'm wondering if he's a liar and mafia, perhaps tried to NK me since I was focused on them and was blocked by Rands protection.and Nols never claimed what he was, so now all a scum would have to do is claim a role likely to be in play after what we know.

[RandA lThor]

OK, nice deflection to Nol to try and get the attention off of you. Few things. First of all, i thought you were mafia so i used my role to try and roleblock you. Yes, that might prevent a vig, but if I roleblocked you, then I might be able to prevent a townie kill which is more likely than even having a vig in the first place. Second of all, yes, my doc could have also influenced this, yet due to the fact that you looked scummy, I seriously doubt any third party of mafia would kill you, which leaves the vig. I am differentiating the two different kills by manner of death in the scenes. Person A killed town day 1 and no one day 2. Person B killed mafia day 1 and town day 2. So here are the possible combinations. Person B is third party and Person A is vig or mafia. Person B is vig and Person A is third party or mafia. However, we can take out the third party and vig combos, because since this is a basic game, there has to be mafia. So the only combinations left is Person B is third party and Person A is mafia, or Person B is vig and Person A is mafia. This leaves Person A as mafia definitely. So your whole I blocked the vig argument doesn't work, and neither does the argument of me doccing the vig kill. If I docced someone, it was a mafia kill and therefore that person was either third party or town. So the only options that remain of what I did was.

 

1. Docced you and you are town that mafia was trying to kill

2. Docced you and you were third party that mafia was trying to kill

3. RBed you and you are the mafia who did the kill.

 

Options 1 and 2 are unlikely since mafia wouldn't try to kill someone who already looks suspicious, they would want to keep them alive. Therefore by this whole process of elimination, option 3 remains, I RBed you ad you are mafia. if you need any clarification, I will be happy to do so, since this might seem a little scattered. Kthxbye, you can role claim if you want, that might keep you alive a bit longer.

[michellem]

I was gonna write a whole long post, and then I realized... Rand just wrote it. Peace was killed. Ishy and Kae had their organs repossessed. Since Ishy was mafia and they wouldn't kill their own, Kae's death was not caused by mafia, in other words mafia was blocked at night. We know Rand blocked Random. That makes this easy.

 

Vote Random

[randomh3r0]

Fine, Rand, here it is: I'm town healer. I don't know why mafia didn't get a kill, they still could've targeted me last night if I was on to something, I don't know. I was protecting Nols, the only other power role for town that was claimed at that point.

[RandA lThor]

If there is a doc, then please CC. Random, since you were also roleblocked, that means that the only doccing that happened that could have prevented a kill was mine, which protected you. So I am unable to realize why they would kill you when you looked so scummy. If they knew you were doc, they still wouldn't kill you since you would be most likely to protect yourself. So therefore, they must have thought you were just a townie, and I still fail to see why they would kill you when you were coming off as uberscummy.

[randomh3r0]

Unless this whole play by you was an attempt to learn my role. If you're mafia, this is win-win for you guys: you learn my role or get an easy day 3 lynch by skipping your NK and not risking being blocked, or targeting Nols and being blocked by me.

vote rand

[RandA lThor]

Unless this whole play by you was an attempt to learn my role. If you're mafia, this is win-win for you guys: you learn my role or get an easy day 3 lynch by skipping your NK and not risking being blocked, or targeting Nols and being blocked by me.

vote rand

 

wtf? First of all, mafia could not have targeted Nol because he would be dead since I RBed you. Secondly, how would purposely missing a kill be for the benefit on the slight chance that you were actually the doc? Thirdly, this whole time you said that you thought I was town and now you think I'm mafia? Fourthly, you never agreed with what I said until now and you just changed it? I am feeling pretty happy with my vote right now. The only thing that makes me feel a little uncomfortable is the fact that you claimed doc. If everyone posts and no one ccs, then I will assume your doc, until then, I still think you're mafia.

[RandA lThor]

Oh and nice OMGUS btw, particularily after you didn't case me before that at all.

[randomh3r0]

I've cased you multiple times, gave you the benefit of the doubt on your claim, and then saw what I believe to be a potentially very scummy play. Sure, it's true I wouldn't have protected Nols, so they couldn't target him, but if mafia wanted to learn my role, or get an easy lynch, then I'm the obvious target.

It makes more sense to me that I'm the target of a mafia win-win scenario here, and you're leading the charge

[Nolder]

I am the doctor

 

Vote Random

[RandA lThor]

Yes, you were scummy, but there would be no need for all of this ridiculous claiming if we wanted you lynched. You were most likely going to be lynched today anyways. Mafia wouldn't have to do this and take this unnecessary risk if they thought this through. And you literally did a 180 in so short of a time, here let me get some quotes for you.

[RandA lThor]

Scummy even to say he's town, like I did? Just pointing out how little that play benefited town (if at all) if its true.

So fine, Rands town, just like I said. That still doesn't make me mafia, which I'm not.

Instead of just tunneling me, saying "that's scummy" after everything I say, why not take the time to actually scum hunt a bit?

I for one am extremely interested in Nols now that Rand has a power role. Considering how much they argued, and then Nols' completely changing his game up in time for a night with only one NK, I'm wondering if he's a liar and mafia, perhaps tried to NK me since I was focused on them and was blocked by Rands protection.and Nols never claimed what he was, so now all a scum would have to do is claim a role likely to be in play after what we know.

Unless this whole play by you was an attempt to learn my role. If you're mafia, this is win-win for you guys: you learn my role or get an easy day 3 lynch by skipping your NK and not risking being blocked, or targeting Nols and being blocked by me.

vote rand

 

1.5 hours, with just a few posts in between and you yourself posting only once in between these. First you were in complete support of me, I am a power role, let's look at Nol. Now its Rand is LLL!! Lets all lynch him and forget about whatever I said before. Right. :rollseyes:

[RandA lThor]

[John Snow]

Vote Random

[insert duh here]

[randomh3r0]

Well, it was either let you lynch me based on hollow logic, or point out the other possibility that you're a liar and building an easy train on me.

 

 

[Darthe]

kill it with fire! randohm

[randomh3r0]

Well I don't know what else to say, I stated my role and you're still going to lynch me.

Since the lynches everyone's decided on so far have such a great track record of finding scum... [/sarcasm]

 

[randomh3r0]

kill it with fire! randohm

Side question: why is there an h in my name magically both times you voted me?

[randomh3r0]

Not asking aggressive Dartge, just curious

[randomh3r0]

Not asking aggressive Darthe, just curious

[WolfbrotherKronos]

Fine, Rand, here it is: I'm town healer. I don't know why mafia didn't get a kill, they still could've targeted me last night if I was on to something, I don't know. I was protecting Nols, the only other power role for town that was claimed at that point.

I am the doctor

 

Vote Random

 

Well we have two people claiming to be the doctor...one of you has to be lying.

[Nolder]

It's obviously Random

 

A) They failed to kill me last night because I was self protecting so they already know who I am

B) They made Random claim because he was already under fire and hoped that somehow the tables will turn on me

 

If you look at Random's claim by itself it doesn't really make much sense

He only had like two votes on him

[randomh3r0]

The only people who made me claim were Rand and Mish. 2 votes so quickly is enough, since they were first, and claiming was my only shot at stating alive.

Even if I flip mafia after a lynch, which I won't, town is back to having no idea who scum is with the added peril that our power roles are exposed. If I flip town, you have the claimed Jailer and claimed Doc as my biggest enemies, leaving town second-guessing everyone.

If we take out time and find someone who is actually scum to lynch, town can use me as bait to find out who has NK actions with Rands ability, if its true. I can protect Rand, as I'm the doc. If mafia NKs me, you still get what you want.

Or, just waste another lynch on town as we have the last two days.

Your call.

[RandA lThor]

The only people who made me claim were Rand and Mish. 2 votes so quickly is enough, since they were first, and claiming was my only shot at stating alive.

Even if I flip mafia after a lynch, which I won't, town is back to having no idea who scum is with the added peril that our power roles are exposed. If I flip town, you have the claimed Jailer and claimed Doc as my biggest enemies, leaving town second-guessing everyone.

If we take out time and find someone who is actually scum to lynch, town can use me as bait to find out who has NK actions with Rands ability, if its true. I can protect Rand, as I'm the doc. If mafia NKs me, you still get what you want.

Or, just waste another lynch on town as we have the last two days.

Your call.

 

You know what I just love about this random? Nolder claimed a power role before you even did this. And you know what I love even more? Nolder cced and you still have your vote on me. And you know what I love even more than that? The fact that you are scum and are desperately trying to figure out a way to get out of this. And the thing I love the most? You just admitted that you think I am a jailer, and are still voting for me.