[BASIC] Terminator Mafia: TOWN AND SK WIN!

[RandA lThor]

unvote Poet , basel, i don't think I am even on the list there

[LilyElizabeth]

 

Mainly it is reading between the lines on the BUT. I'm not trying to put words in your mouth, but this is definitely how I interpreted it on first read whether that was your intent or not.

 

Fair enough. I can see how it might read that way, but it wasn't my intention. English IS my native language and I have trouble expressing myself with it sometimes.

[alannalynn]

I have not tried to discredit Jack at all I'm pretty sure I said I was making a joke at his expense before this post Lily you get mad about word twisting and words getting put in your mouth yet you did just the same

 

FoS for inconsistency, I will keep my vote on BG for now for the purpose of competeing trains

Pheonix, I really don't see where this is "competing trains"-- 2 votes on three people at this point? And the other person on BG's "train" is just a random Day 1 vote. This seems off to me, Birdy, are you just trying to defend your vote with faulty reasoning?

 

Jack-Plays his trap...believes Rand to be new and town...says EP's post was scummier, lists reasons why, leaves his vote on me...State a theory on likelihood of a newbie being on the scum team..Switches his vote to Lily and gives reasons here.

Yeah, I found that behaviour suspicious from the beginning. I think I will have to vote on him after all. There are a couple of other candidates, but none as good as Jack. Therefore I vote Jack .

Other than this being a weak vote, what about the other good lynch candidates that you stated? I'd like to see cases, seems you're just tagging along with Kay for now.

 

Yeah, you do seem almost too bold to be a mafia. I don't know if a mafia would be likely to take such an active part in the debate as you have, considering there's probably (?) a finder or someone like that ... In my very limited experience that's something a mafia would fear, so I guess that speaks in your favor.

Lol- Mafia can be as bold as town if they're comfortable in their role.

[Sedai]

@night I'm always bold and decisive. I like reactions and to generate posts. :)

[Netbattler11]

Sorry for being so inactive. Finals are over on Monday and i'll try to start doing more then.

[RandA lThor]

side note: is there an official name for EP, is he firebirdy, EP, or phoenix?

 

game:

I have not tried to discredit Jack at all I'm pretty sure I said I was making a joke at his expense before this post Lily you get mad about word twisting and words getting put in your mouth yet you did just the same

 

FoS for inconsistency, I will keep my vote on BG for now for the purpose of competeing trains

Pheonix, I really don't see where this is "competing trains"-- 2 votes on three people at this point? And the other person on BG's "train" is just a random Day 1 vote. This seems off to me, Birdy, are you just trying to defend your vote with faulty reasoning?

 

Jack-Plays his trap...believes Rand to be new and town...says EP's post was scummier, lists reasons why, leaves his vote on me...State a theory on likelihood of a newbie being on the scum team..Switches his vote to Lily and gives reasons here.

Yeah, I found that behaviour suspicious from the beginning. I think I will have to vote on him after all. There are a couple of other candidates, but none as good as Jack. Therefore I vote Jack .

Other than this being a weak vote, what about the other good lynch candidates that you stated? I'd like to see cases, seems you're just tagging along with Kay for now.

 

Yeah, you do seem almost too bold to be a mafia. I don't know if a mafia would be likely to take such an active part in the debate as you have, considering there's probably (?) a finder or someone like that ... In my very limited experience that's something a mafia would fear, so I guess that speaks in your favor.

Lol- Mafia can be as bold as town if they're comfortable in their role.

 

I think that nightstrike explained his actions before in multiple posts

[alannalynn]

Rand, you mean this? ...

 

Peace thought Lily overreacted, but is it really likely that Jack and Lily are both on the mafia team? I'm almost suspecting that there are no women on the mafia team, since Jack (who I believe is mafia) seem to focus on 2 out of 4 women so far. He also says he suspects there are at least one beginner (out of 3?), which I believe could indicate that there are no beginners at all.

Peace thought Lily overreacted, but is it really likely that Jack and Lily are both on the mafia team? I'm almost suspecting that there are no women on the mafia team, since Jack (who I believe is mafia) seem to focus on 2 out of 4 women so far. He also says he suspects there are at least one beginner (out of 3?), which I believe could indicate that there are no beginners at all.

This is, of course, if I'm right and Jack really is mafia. I'm convinced, but I've never played with him before. One of the drawbacks of being a beginner.

Yeah, you do seem almost too bold to be a mafia. I don't know if a mafia would be likely to take such an active part in the debate as you have, considering there's probably (?) a finder or someone like that ... In my very limited experience that's something a mafia would fear, so I guess that speaks in your favor.

I don't see that as been "other candidates", I see Jack and Lily.

 

As for EP... ehhhhh. As long as we know who we're talking about? Right? ....

[Gabriel Kross]

I still believe my initial reason for voting BG is correct

[peacesells]

I still believe my initial reason for voting BG is correct

 

did you have a reason?

[alannalynn]

here it is.

 

We can speculate about the setup all we like, but the only way we're going to find out is to play. The basic outline that Jack gave for setup seems standard to me, but I don't want to go too much further, as we'd be gaming the mod if we're trying to guess exactly how Basel set the game up. The SK idea seems like it could be an interesting idea for a basic game in the future, though.

 

Well I'm trying to get the game started and also set a trap.

 

The basic theory of the "set-up" trap is that the mafia essentially know who and how many scum is on their team. So I'm trying to figure out if I can pick up some extra knowledge.

 

Well now you went and ruined it.

 

 

this feels like a HA nice way to fail post to me.

 

UNVOTE VOTE BG

^this is his reason.

[Gabriel Kross]

yea bcus BG doesn't normally make a comment like that without a reason as seen in the lolcats game

[RandA lThor]

You have a point, but that doesn't mean that he will never make a comment like that.

[Basel Gill]

unvote Poet , basel, i don't think I am even on the list there

 

It is Day 1. The deadline for reaching a majority is Monday, June 11th, at 9 PM EST. With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

Vote count:

 

Peace (1): AJ

Kaylee (1): Maw

Jack (3): Lily, Poet, NS

BG (2): Kaylee, EP

Lily (2): Jack, Peace

Maw (1): Razen

 

Not voting: BG, Rand

 

http://timeanddate.c...0&sec=00&p0=422

 

Rand, I don't know what happened to your vote. I had it earlier. However, I registered your unvote, so it's all good, you wouldn't be on the list either way right now.

[RandA lThor]

Its fine Basel

[Nightstrike]

Rand, you mean this? ...

 

Peace thought Lily overreacted, but is it really likely that Jack and Lily are both on the mafia team? I'm almost suspecting that there are no women on the mafia team, since Jack (who I believe is mafia) seem to focus on 2 out of 4 women so far. He also says he suspects there are at least one beginner (out of 3?), which I believe could indicate that there are no beginners at all.

Peace thought Lily overreacted, but is it really likely that Jack and Lily are both on the mafia team? I'm almost suspecting that there are no women on the mafia team, since Jack (who I believe is mafia) seem to focus on 2 out of 4 women so far. He also says he suspects there are at least one beginner (out of 3?), which I believe could indicate that there are no beginners at all.

This is, of course, if I'm right and Jack really is mafia. I'm convinced, but I've never played with him before. One of the drawbacks of being a beginner.

Yeah, you do seem almost too bold to be a mafia. I don't know if a mafia would be likely to take such an active part in the debate as you have, considering there's probably (?) a finder or someone like that ... In my very limited experience that's something a mafia would fear, so I guess that speaks in your favor.

I don't see that as been "other candidates", I see Jack and Lily.

How did you miss reply #84 and reply #140? I've got a couple of other candidates, but I'd rather keep them to myself for now, to see how well my theory works.

[Nightstrike]

Those quotes have nothing to do with what Rand talked about.

[Nightstrike]

Or at least two of them have nothing to do with what Rand talked about.

[Nightstrike]

I have not tried to discredit Jack at all I'm pretty sure I said I was making a joke at his expense before this post Lily you get mad about word twisting and words getting put in your mouth yet you did just the same

 

FoS for inconsistency, I will keep my vote on BG for now for the purpose of competeing trains

Pheonix, I really don't see where this is "competing trains"-- 2 votes on three people at this point? And the other person on BG's "train" is just a random Day 1 vote. This seems off to me, Birdy, are you just trying to defend your vote with faulty reasoning?

 

Jack-Plays his trap...believes Rand to be new and town...says EP's post was scummier, lists reasons why, leaves his vote on me...State a theory on likelihood of a newbie being on the scum team..Switches his vote to Lily and gives reasons here.

Yeah, I found that behaviour suspicious from the beginning. I think I will have to vote on him after all. There are a couple of other candidates, but none as good as Jack. Therefore I vote Jack .

Other than this being a weak vote, what about the other good lynch candidates that you stated? I'd like to see cases, seems you're just tagging along with Kay for now.

Do you have a stronger vote? Maybe you can persuade me?

[LilyElizabeth]

It's been quiet in here this weekend...

[Basel Gill]

Just a bit, Lily. I am back home now, maybe having your mod present will help some.

[LilyElizabeth]

I think maybe we have more than the usual percentage of players who go MIA on weekends.

[Kaylee]

I'm here, well I'll be in & out.

[Sedai]

I'm still here and have been so. I've also said my Oppinions and cast my vote. I have nothing further to add so I don't like to post for the sake of posting. I'll see if anyone has anythinginteresting to say Or if they have anything they want addressed.

[Sedai]

I think maybe we have more than the usual percentage of players who go MIA on weekends.

 

I've just been crazy busy

[Sedai]

@Night why are you canvinced I'm mafia? It's only day one, I wasn't convinced Kay was mafia I was leaning that way so I voted. I wasn't convinced EP was mafia do I left my vote on him. I haven't really been convinced and I've had a lot more evidence then you've had to be convinced Im mafia so I'd like to know.