Create-Your-Own-Role Mafia 7: Everybody Wins *game over*

[Gabriel Kross]

meh I dont care I was asking to be lynched 3 days ago congrats on being down 2 town this cycle

[Basel Gill]

meh I dont care I was asking to be lynched 3 days ago congrats on being down 2 town this cycle

 

If you wanted out of the game, you should have asked to be replaced. Going ballistic and throwing around rants and insults is not the best option.

[Gabriel Kross]

well I wasn't really ranting until hoof was blatantly skimming not to mention skipping the whole rules section the rest was just antagonistic gameplay to get the ball rolling as I was bored but anyways I'm out

[Ironeyes]

Antagonistic gameplay by whom?

[LilyElizabeth]

If I'm counting correctly, EP needs one more vote. Allow me.

 

Unvote

Vote EP

 

Mostly because of the lack of respect issue, but he was definitely defensive, too.

[LilyElizabeth]

Note to self - never try to count votes when you just wake up....

[Gabriel Kross]

I guess I do owe you guys an apology though I was in a pretty bad way when I lost it on Hoof it wasn't completely his fault as I was hitting about a 9/10 on the pain scale all day and just flipped on Hoof due to haveing a short fuse already sooo i apologize

[LilyElizabeth]

I'm sorry to hear that, EP. Are things better?

[Gabriel Kross]

not really I'm atleast off until monday though so I guess that's a plus?

[LilyElizabeth]

I'm sorry to hear that. I hope you feel better quickly.

[Basel Gill]

EP, just to make things clear, no hard feelings. I hope things improve for you.

[Nolder]

EP's unprofessional and generally uncivil conduct hasn't impressed me. @EP: Generally when I play I try to maintain some respect for my fellow players, even when I think they are scum, and also when I am scum and plotting against them. On the flip side, my biggest overreactions in games have come not due to votes on me but when I did not feel I was receiving that same respect in return. Your actions the last couple of days have not been very respectful towards the rest of us. Whether it is overreacting due to pressure on you or what, I don't know. But I do take note of Pandy having warned you in mod mode, and then voted you as a player besides.

 

Unvote. Vote EP. And this is a policy vote on my part.

What a cop out

Don't make an excuse Basel

You voted him for no gameplay reason and I plan on holding you accountable for it

 

If I'm counting correctly, EP needs one more vote. Allow me.

 

Unvote

Vote EP

 

Mostly because of the lack of respect issue, but he was definitely defensive, too.

You know better than most that in this game things like that happen sometimes

scummy vote if I've ever seen one

 

big FoS to the both of you

[LilyElizabeth]

Nolder, I see where you're coming from. I thought my vote was needed to hammer, and we're approaching deadline. I feel silly about that now, and I wouldn't have switched otherwise.

[Nolder]

I'm more concerned that you're using the excuse of "bad manners" (more or less) to vote him rather than the vote itself.

What kind of reason is that? Are you and Basel even trying to get mafia? Because it doesn't look that way right now that's for sure.

[Basel Gill]

@Nol: So you don't think, then, that EP was over the line with his conduct? He was warned by Pandy. Twice, if you count player-Pandy's "vote" from someone who had supposedly been without a vote. EP did apologize, but we had no way of knowing if he would do so at the time. Nor did we know if his conduct would continue as it had been if he remained in the game. I would just as soon not have to keep putting up with stuff along the same lines as what he had been putting out the past RL day or two. I stand by my action in voting him.

[Nolder]

@Nol: So you don't think, then, that EP was over the line with his conduct?

Technically no

I believe any form of behavior should be allowed in mafia

having said that I don't think there was cause to blow up like he did but maybe it was all part of some plan idk

 

He was warned by Pandy. Twice,

CP is not a moderator on these forums

I respect his right to moderate his game however he likes but his limits may not reflect the actual forum limits

to give an example Cosmic might throw you out of the game for saying "fiddlesticks" but he's not going to be able to ban you from the forum

 

I would just as soon not have to keep putting up with stuff along the same lines as what he had been putting out the past RL day or two. I stand by my action in voting him.

and I stand by what I said

you had no in game reason to vote him

it was either personal (which I'd argue is also bad conduct in a mafia game) or you're just using it as an excuse because YOU are mafia and you know EP is not

[Basel Gill]

He was warned by Pandy. Twice,

CP is not a moderator on these forums

I respect his right to moderate his game however he likes but his limits may not reflect the actual forum limits

to give an example Cosmic might throw you out of the game for saying "fiddlesticks" but he's not going to be able to ban you from the forum

 

And this is relevant how? When did banning him from the forum ever come up? Did I ever say anything about Pandy being a forum mod? No. EP was warned by the person running the game, in the context of, as you put it, moderating his game however he likes. The fact that he was warned by the game mod shows that his conduct was going too far, and was likely getting close to being evicted from this game. I didn't need an ingame reason to vote him, his behavior was plenty.

[Blackhoof]

I guess I do owe you guys an apology though I was in a pretty bad way when I lost it on Hoof it wasn't completely his fault as I was hitting about a 9/10 on the pain scale all day and just flipped on Hoof due to haveing a short fuse already sooo i apologize

 

I accept your apology. I also understand how frustrating it can be when people Lynch you and you have no idea why. However, the point of mafia is to form the best case with what we have. Without a cop viewing, we will rarely have something conclusive. In mafia, the lynchee is the scummiest of a scummy lot, no more, no less.

[LilyElizabeth]

I think you're making a mountain out of a molehill here, Nolder. I listed more than one reason for voting him (between the two posts) yet you focus on only one. It sounds like this has more to do with you and your ethical code than the game. Rest assured, I wouldn't have voted someone based strictly on them being disrespectful, but added to other things, it's one more straw.

[Nolder]

He was warned by Pandy. Twice,

CP is not a moderator on these forums

I respect his right to moderate his game however he likes but his limits may not reflect the actual forum limits

to give an example Cosmic might throw you out of the game for saying "fiddlesticks" but he's not going to be able to ban you from the forum

 

And this is relevant how? When did banning him from the forum ever come up? Did I ever say anything about Pandy being a forum mod? No. EP was warned by the person running the game, in the context of, as you put it, moderating his game however he likes. The fact that he was warned by the game mod shows that his conduct was going too far, and was likely getting close to being evicted from this game.

Yes but as I said he could have been warned for saying "fiddlesticks"

being warned by a game moderator does not actually indicate the extremity of someones misbehavior, if any

 

I didn't need an ingame reason to vote him, his behavior was plenty.

you voted him for personal reasons not because you thought he was mafia

 

that's all that needs to be said don't you think?

[Nolder]

I think you're making a mountain out of a molehill here, Nolder. I listed more than one reason for voting him (between the two posts) yet you focus on only one. It sounds like this has more to do with you and your ethical code than the game. Rest assured, I wouldn't have voted someone based strictly on them being disrespectful, but added to other things, it's one more straw.

I'm more focused on Basel than you

I threw you in for good measure because of the hammer vote but at least you'd stated before you'd be fine with lynching either one and you cited over defensiveness

 

Basel didn't and seems to have voted either for personal reasons or he's using that as cover for putting his vote on since he couldn't be bothered to type a case or at least cite something others had said

[Myndrunner]

We all accept your apology, EP. Here's your noose.

[cosmicpanda]

Pandy mod mode:

 

 

Votecount 18:

 

EP: 7 (Wombat, Alanna, Blackhoof, Christine, Ironeyes, Pandy, Mynd)

Christine: 2 (Basel, Thorum)

Hoof: 3 (Nolder, Lily, EP)

 

Deadline. With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch!

 

 

 

Pandy Points Count:

 

Christine: 13

Ironeyes: 13

Lily: 4

Nolder: 2

Mynd: 1

Pandy: -5

EP: -7

 

 

EP, a townie, has been lynched. It is now night. Send 'em in, folks! Night deadline.

[cosmicpanda]

CP is not a moderator on these forums

I respect his right to moderate his game however he likes but his limits may not reflect the actual forum limits

to give an example Cosmic might throw you out of the game for saying "fiddlesticks" but he's not going to be able to ban you from the forum

 

To clarify: Pandy player mode's vote for EP shouldn't be considered part of Pandy mod mode's warning. Also, I believe that the conduct I warned EP for arguably contravened DM's CoC; if it hadn't, there would have been no need (there's no rule that says you can't say 'fiddlesticks', either in this game or for the forums in general).

[Christine]

So what do I do with all these points at night?