Blackhoofs Warhammer 40'000 Game [BASIC]

[Sakaea]

Gut feeling that is now probably wrong. I'm vanilla town, if we mis-lynch today, it's game probably. I think we should lynch Amega or Lenlo, but I don't have enough of a read on either to say which...I still don't believe Red, tho.

[amegakure]

So once again your ignoring a direct question.....Now you getting bouncy between lily and red and now me and lenlo? Ill ask my question again...why did you think lily was suspicious early?

[bgrishinko]

Well obviously Red or Lily is lying. I personally doubt Red. Lily could be (again it was Kae who spoke against Lily earlier), but given the low numbers of people, I think fake claims become higher and higher probability from Mafia to draw out important roles like Docs or Cops. Being as the Doc is SUPER important right now with a killer still on the loose, it makes sense to try and get rid of the Doc ASAP. In fact, it could even be the SK for the same reason.

 

Also, if by random chance the second killer is a Vig, PLEASE let us know who you are so we can work together instead of taking pot shots.

[amegakure]

so i just went back and counted shouldnt there still be 7 players?

 

christine

me

red

lily

bg

sak

lenlo

[LilyElizabeth]

No, it's only 6 players. You have both me and Christine down, and I replaced her.

[Blackhoof]

Vote Count

 

Red(1)- Lily

Lily(1)- Red

Sakaea(1)- Amega

 

With 6 players left 4 is needed to lynch

 

You have until 9AM 21st Feb EST to reach a majority or a random will be mod-killed!

[amegakure]

ohh okay.... i was wondering i havent seen her post in a long time... i thought you were just late or something...

[bgrishinko]

Vote Red

Just to reiterate my vote is supposed to be there.

[Red2111]

  On 2/16/2012 at 9:16 PM, amegakure said:

well best not get into a CC debate...Id vote sakeae but i dont know wether i trust red or lily more. IM actually more interested in how quick bg comes to sakaea's aid. VOTE BG

 

i don't see where BG came to Kae's defense, all he did was voice his disagreement about my thoughts concerning Kae's supposed "ninja" hammer on Levi. which i still think is BS btw.

 

 

  On 2/16/2012 at 9:19 PM, Lenlo said:

So we got a split. Both claiming to be the same thing. I would say the real one would have no reason to lie while the other would have every reason. This reminds me of that old riddle/puzzle, Your in a room with 2 people and 2 doors. One door leads to certain death the other to life. One always lies the other only tells the truth. How do you learn which door to go through?

 

We could try asking them does the other one lie, but of course they are not bound by the rule of they can only lie. We guess wrong here and it will most likely mean death. Guess correctly and we still have a chance.

 

if i wasn't so sure Lily wasn't town i'd so be voting you right now. why not voice your thoughts on the situation instead of quoting a riddle that isn't going to help us

 

btw, thats from the Movie Labrynth isn't it?

 

 

  On 2/16/2012 at 11:51 PM, Sakaea said:

I unvoted, dear mod.

 

However, I think I'm going to have to call BS on Red. The odds of you randomly getting doc in 2 basic games at once are so small it's ridiculous. 13 players in X-men, 12 in 40K. You pull doc in both? Highly unlikely.

 

What do the rest of you think?

 

so your reasoning for me not to get the role is because i was Healer in another game unless you and hoof talked about your set ups together when roles went out this makes absolutley no sense. just because you get one role in one game doesn't make it any more likely or less likely you'd recieve the same role in another game. especially when talking about roles that are in every game.

 

 

i call bullshanks on this reasoning.

 

 

 

  On 2/17/2012 at 2:37 PM, bgrishinko said:

Vote Red

Just to reiterate my vote is supposed to be there.

 

fine, if you want to get rid of the healer then go ahead.

[Lenlo]

  On 2/17/2012 at 3:36 PM, Red2111 said:

if i wasn't so sure Lily wasn't town i'd so be voting you right now. why not voice your thoughts on the situation instead of quoting a riddle that isn't going to help us

 

I am voicing my thoughts. We have a dilemma about who to believe and I dont know which one to side with. I dont want to casually throw out a vote like what happened in the very beginning of this game because now it is literally life and death. As for voting for me would you care to explain that? You tell me to voice my thoughts but I am much more interested in yours right now. After all, I am not the one under suspicion of lieing.

 

  On 2/17/2012 at 3:36 PM, Red2111 said:

btw, thats from the Movie Labrynth isn't it?

 

No idea. Havnt ever seen the movie Labrynth.

 

  On 2/17/2012 at 3:36 PM, Red2111 said:

so your reasoning for me not to get the role is because i was Healer in another game unless you and hoof talked about your set ups together when roles went out this makes absolutley no sense. just because you get one role in one game doesn't make it any more likely or less likely you'd recieve the same role in another game. especially when talking about roles that are in every game.

 

 

i call bullshanks on this reasoning.

I can agree with you on this. I dont see how being something in a different game would affect what you get here. Though thay may just be inexperience.

[Red2111]

  On 2/17/2012 at 4:16 PM, Lenlo said:

  On 2/17/2012 at 3:36 PM, Red2111 said:

if i wasn't so sure Lily wasn't town i'd so be voting you right now. why not voice your thoughts on the situation instead of quoting a riddle that isn't going to help us

 

I am voicing my thoughts. We have a dilemma about who to believe and I dont know which one to side with. I dont want to casually throw out a vote like what happened in the very beginning of this game because now it is literally life and death. As for voting for me would you care to explain that? You tell me to voice my thoughts but I am much more interested in yours right now. After all, I am not the one under suspicion of lieing.

 

i'd be voting for you becuase you're giving the apperance of helping without really helping. this is a well known scum tactic. your pinging me as a solo right now; waiting for us to sort out the CC mess then submitting your kill on whoever doesn't get lynched. the stench of SK is strong on you

[amegakure]

i already exlplained my mistake red...

 

Depending on what happens today im going to try and go bak and find some info on BG and lenlo. Sakaea is also very high on my list maybe shell answer a question when she gets back.

[Sakaea]

I did answer your question. I said it was a gut feeling. That's all there is to it. I have no case.

 

I'm going to Vote Lenlo because he does scream third party right now, and I'm thinking we wanna stay away from Red and Lily today. 50/50 chance of picking right between them; I don't think I wanna take the risk right now.

[amegakure]

alright... vote lenlo in case im not around during school...i was going to go back and see if there was harder evidence than our guts but well see what happens after work..

[Lenlo]

Believe what you will, I can assure you I am a town. Since it seems people are not comfortable with my vote just hanging here I shall

vote Red

[Sakaea]

Unofficial Vote Count

 

Red(3)- Lily, BG, Lenlo

 

Lily(1)- Red

 

Sakaea(1)- Amega

 

Lenlo (1) - Kae

 

With 6 players left 4 is needed to lynch

 

 

Way to put one of our claimed docs at L-1, scummy mcScummerson

[Lenlo]

We are going to have to decide between them at one point or another. Sooner is better than later IMO.

[Sakaea]

I disagree. I think we should lynch you. You scream of third party or scum to me.

[Lenlo]

Just be sure before you vote. Lynch any townie today and we all die.

[LilyElizabeth]

I agree that Lenlo sounds third party, but I'm Red is definitely scum, so my vote stays where it is. Depending on the mafia's win condition, lynching the SK today might still lose us the game.

[LilyElizabeth]

That was going to say I'm sure Red is scum, and I changed it to Red is definitely scum, but I messed up.

[Lenlo]

Personally I see two paths.

1) Lynch me, a self proposed townie and apparently possible 3rd party or

2) Lynch Red/Lily one of two self proposed doctors. A 50/50 shot at a pretty much guaranteed scum. After all, why would a townie fake being a doctor?

 

The reason I chose Red is because he said doctor first and Lily wouldnt have said it after word unless it was true. If she wasnt the doctor she risks alot trying to bet against Red and if she is the doctor she has to call the other person out on it. Why take that risk unless she really was the doctor?

 

I could be horrible wrong on this, though I hope/dont think I am. Now its time to wait for the votes and see what happens.

[Sakaea]

...you're new at this, aren't you?

 

Lily, as scum, could say she's the doctor to try to get us to lynch the real doc. Red, as scum, claiming doc to not get lynched, draws the real doc out, so now scum/SK know who the doc is.

 

And Red is female, btw.

[amegakure]

what you just said is pretty much the outline of a gambit...and they happen all the time. The mafia likes to lie down WIFOMS so heavy it would make spiderman cringe. Still i believe youve been acting strange and it seems two of the mafia veterans believe you to be a sk. So my vote remains..

[Sakaea]

PING!!!!!!!!!!!! Your vote is on me, you voted for Lenlo without unvoting me, and now say your vote shall remain on me. Inconsistent much?