[ADVANCED/KITCHEN SINK] The Axe or the Hammer - GAME OVER

[bgrishinko]

I dunno what happened on the Wombat viewing. Maybe the redirector can choose whether I know if I was redirected.

 

Knowing what I know now, I'm confused though.

 

My best bet is to go with Nolder or Ledinna since Wombat usually has pretty good instincts.

[John E. Kelley]

Interesting. Mafia, please shoot BG. He is guaranteed cult. Thanks in advance.

Are these the good instincts of Wom's that you're referring to BG?

[bgrishinko]

Well, obviously he's not perfect.

[Nolder]

hey guys sorry I've been a bit scarce lately

kinda busy

I will continue to be scarce at least until Sunday (I'm going to a wedding...)

I hope nothing really needs my immediate attention and that we learned our lesson about speed lynching someone lol

also

 

Did anyone suspect Wombat of being cult in the first place? I thought he was mafia and nothing I've seen has convinced me otherwise.

 

And an "in-hindsight" FoS at Nol as well.

for being right?

well he wasn't Mafia true but no one AFAIK suspected him of being cult

why am I singled out for what everyone was thinking?

[Amadine]

Vote Count:

BG (2) - Kate, Ishy

Nolder (1) - Soy

Not Voting: Nolder, Verb, BG, Player, Des, Ledinna

[John E. Kelley]

hey guys sorry I've been a bit scarce lately

kinda busy

I will continue to be scarce at least until Sunday (I'm going to a wedding...)

I hope nothing really needs my immediate attention and that we learned our lesson about speed lynching someone lol

also

 

Did anyone suspect Wombat of being cult in the first place? I thought he was mafia and nothing I've seen has convinced me otherwise.

 

And an "in-hindsight" FoS at Nol as well.

for being right?

well he wasn't Mafia true but no one AFAIK suspected him of being cult

why am I singled out for what everyone was thinking?

Wait, what? Being right? You flat out say he's scum, and he flips town. Where exactly does the being right part come into play?

[Nolder]

hey guys sorry I've been a bit scarce lately

kinda busy

I will continue to be scarce at least until Sunday (I'm going to a wedding...)

I hope nothing really needs my immediate attention and that we learned our lesson about speed lynching someone lol

also

 

Did anyone suspect Wombat of being cult in the first place? I thought he was mafia and nothing I've seen has convinced me otherwise.

 

And an "in-hindsight" FoS at Nol as well.

for being right?

well he wasn't Mafia true but no one AFAIK suspected him of being cult

why am I singled out for what everyone was thinking?

Wait, what? Being right? You flat out say he's scum, and he flips town. Where exactly does the being right part come into play?

I, along with pretty much everyone else (except maybe who the quote is directed towards?), was right about him not being cult

[John E. Kelley]

hey guys sorry I've been a bit scarce lately

kinda busy

I will continue to be scarce at least until Sunday (I'm going to a wedding...)

I hope nothing really needs my immediate attention and that we learned our lesson about speed lynching someone lol

also

 

Did anyone suspect Wombat of being cult in the first place? I thought he was mafia and nothing I've seen has convinced me otherwise.

 

And an "in-hindsight" FoS at Nol as well.

for being right?

well he wasn't Mafia true but no one AFAIK suspected him of being cult

why am I singled out for what everyone was thinking?

Wait, what? Being right? You flat out say he's scum, and he flips town. Where exactly does the being right part come into play?

I, along with pretty much everyone else (except maybe who the quote is directed towards?), was right about him not being cult

So you're saying that everyone besides me bought into the whole "Wom is scum" plan other than me? Methinks that the vote count tells a different story. You've made it plain, at least to me, who is what, at this point.

[John E. Kelley]

Unvote. Vote Nolder.

 

You're either cult or scum, at this point, I have no idea which, but either way, you are definitely not town, so I'm OK with this vote.

[Nolder]

no

whoever I was talking to in the initial quote

this quote "Did anyone suspect Wombat of being cult in the first place? I thought he was mafia and nothing I've seen has convinced me otherwise."

was it you? if so then uhhh I guess

someone made a comment about Wombat probably not being cult and I thought it was weird since no one had called him cult in the first place that I could remember

 

make sense now?

[John E. Kelley]

no

whoever I was talking to in the initial quote

this quote "Did anyone suspect Wombat of being cult in the first place? I thought he was mafia and nothing I've seen has convinced me otherwise."

was it you? if so then uhhh I guess

someone made a comment about Wombat probably not being cult and I thought it was weird since no one had called him cult in the first place that I could remember

 

make sense now?

 

No, it absolutely wasn't me, and no, it makes no sense now.

 

We're at end-game, and you're flailing around to save your team. I get it, I understand it, but I hope that everyone left on Team Town gets it too.

 

You're not Town, and if we have any hope of winning, you gotta go.

[Nolder]

eh?

I think you're being kinda unreasonble honestly

but that's understandable if you're just looking for an excuse to vote me

 

anyway the obvious choice here is BG

if he was still town he wouldn't have gotten a guilty result on Wombat

 

Vote: BG

[Nolder]

does anyone have anything else to say?

[Nolder]

hmmmm

 

may as well take this opportunity to do some rereading actually

BG is an option but like...wombat? pointed out earlier he's not the CL for sure

really need to hunt out whoever that is I think

 

Unvote: BG

[dapianoplay3r]

*sheepish*

I completely forgot to say anything and the thread never popped up till now to remind me

 

 

The BG thing seems clear cut to me. He lied about his NA meaning he probably was recruited

Vote BG

 

 

Unvote. Vote Nolder.You're either cult or scum, at this point, I have no idea which, but either way, you are definitely not town, so I'm OK with this vote.

Also this is odd. I know he is probably one of the two. There aren't many left so he is very likely by the numbers, but BG did make a very telling slip and is assured. Why not BG?...

[Amadine]

Vote Count:

BG (2) - Kate, Player

Nolder (2) - Soy, Ishy

Not Voting: Nolder, Verb, Des, Ledinna

[Ledinna Sedai]

Either BG and Nold is scum/cult. I hope I'm not choosing just the wrong one... Player pretty much stated the reasons I have too, so I think it's useless to repeat them.

 

Vote: BG

[Amadine]

Vote Count:

BG (3) - Kate, Player, Ledinna

Nolder (2) - Soy, Ishy

Not Voting: Nolder, Verb, Des

 

8 alive = 5 to lynch

[John E. Kelley]

I think we all need to think about this for a second. It seems pretty obvious that Bg has been recruited. And yes, it would be good to lynch a cult. But if we never get the CL, it makes no difference as they would just be replaced tonight. We need to get the CL more than anyone else imo. And Nol seems the most viable candidate for that role to me. Barring that, we need to find scum, but the cult has gained a new member every night I'm assuming and that makes getting the CL our numer one priority. If anyone else has a feel one who that could be, we really need to hear your theories now.

[John E. Kelley]

Is anyone else playing anymore?

[bgrishinko]

Here's the deal Ishy, your right. I'm assuming you are town as you seem to be the only one around... I think mafia and Cult are just bidding time waiting one way or the other. Neither have a majority else this game would be over. Currently I think scum are voting who they think is cult and cult is voting scum.

 

 

There are 8 people, with Despo MIA for internet issues, 7 active people. I'm guessing 2 scum and 4 cult by this point with 2 town. Town have lost. Cult, I think, can simply hold out for random. I say, we both vote Desp and hope to get recruited tonight in order to win.

[bgrishinko]

Vote: Desp

[Verbal32]

Sorry peeps, a lot of stuff this weekend and mafia was the last thing on my mind.

 

For the game - I'm leaning Des, but I'd like to hear from him and whatever post Nolder mentioned he was looking for.

[Amadine]

A DEADLINE HAS BEEN SET

http://www.timeandda...0&sec=00&p0=240

(thanks Womby!)

[WWWwombat]

I got it from Meesh. <3 Meesh.