[BASIC] Lord of the Rings Mafia GAME OVER!!!

[Ithillian Turambar]

Even though I was the first vote on Ley? Interesting. Kind of goes against your own logic but fair enough. Of course I wanted him dead before I even started the game - check out the sign up thread if you don't believe me. The fact that he turned out to be Mafia was a total bonus.

 

And Ledinna is a new member of my Social Org - and yes this is Mafia, but I still feel a little responsible. Of course I still remember that bloody Initiate Kate who played the clueless Newb card and ended up being Darth Vader - could she have even been any eviller? So I am still keeping a close eye on Dinna. If she is on the Mafia team, they could have recommended she use this tactic to avoid suspicion.

 

Hmmmm, being British and all - there has been a long tradition of not trusting primates. Way back during the Napoleonic Wars - when a french ship was sunk of the coast of Hartlepool - the only survivor was a monkey, dressed like a sailor. The Hartlepool Fishermen thought it must be a french spy, having never seen a frenchman before, and so questioned it. When it failed to respond - they hung it.

 

 

Talking about night kills is a scumtell? Ok (adds to list) I never got that far in my lessons with Jack.

 

Strange how you have not called Ishy out for his almost constant commentary of EVERTHING. That's been pinging me like a crazy thing.

 

Of course you have now said that you don't want to play like APE anymore - which is a shame cos I really would have made you a lovely siggy.

 

*blows kisses*

[John McClane]

Little bit o' FOS went a long way with you... That's some defensive post.

 

Did you just say you take lessons from Jack? Oh dear.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Yeah he was brilliant. I had a lot of fun.

 

You think that was a defensive post lol. You are so funny. I've been dying to post about hanging the monkey since I realised you were in this game lol.

 

You never really responded to most of my points though. Nice Avoidance and swinging it back at me. You really are sneaky. If Gollum wasn't already dead .......

 

[John McClane]

Yeah he was brilliant. I had a lot of fun.

 

You think that was a defensive post lol. You are so funny. I've been dying to post about hanging the monkey since I realised you were in this game lol.

 

You never really responded to most of my points though. Nice Avoidance and swinging it back at me. You really are sneaky. If Gollum wasn't already dead .......

 

 

It was defensive.

 

I could tell you wanted to big game hunt me right off the bat, which makes me less compelled to worry about responding to your line-by-musings. I'm not avoiding anything other than getting sucked into a rathole by a Jack-style player, which I get the impression you are. When you have valid points or questions to pose, I'll react in kind.... But I'm not really compelled to give a crap about your baseless insinuations, and whatever other ramblings you expect me to weed through.

[John McClane]

Strange how you have not called Ishy out for his almost constant commentary of EVERTHING. That's been pinging me like a crazy thing. .

 

*blows kisses*

 

This I'll respond to... I've called out Maw because of his voting pattern and you because its good to kick tires.

 

Only thing strange I see here is you saying that Ishy is pinging you, yet you are voting me for reasons unrelated to the game... Because u decided during signups u wanted to lynch me.

 

Credibility fail.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Ok. I will restrain myself.

 

1. I voted first for Lerann and never shifted it through the whole game. That goes against your Mafia would have tried to deflect from Ley theory.

 

2. You think I am Mafia because I have been helpful to a new player and commented about the NKs and who did what. Other players have done the same - Ishy comments about everything and seems incapable of making a post where he doesn't state he is Town. - ah you have just answered this one kind of.

 

3. This is not how Jack taught me to play. He just outlined the basics and told me to find a place where I could have fun with the game, instead of being wound up by everything everyone says.

 

4. I didn't want to lynch you in sign ups. I wanted to lynch Ley cos he is annoying. I didn't spot you in sign ups. I saw you when the game started and the Hartlepool Monkey always made me laugh - you playing gave me a good reason to share it.

 

5. Voting you got you to say stuff. Its a valid strategy. You're a strong player. I was interested in what you would do and say.

 

I can be a bit spammy at times. Its how I deal with the game. But I've got what I came for now thank you.

 

unvote

[Ithillian Turambar]

Also I love the fact that technically you responded to the kisses - as you left them in the quote. I knew you loved me really.

[John McClane]

Rather presumptuous to say I "think you are mafia" tbh. You say you followed the last game... Then you should know I'm a pretty aggressive scum hunter, you should also know that I will push on A, in order to observe what B does.

 

So basically... We are just feeling each other u....errr... Out.

 

Also, your rambling jump from topic to topic then ask people why they didn't respond to you tactic is 100% jack, unfortunately for you.

[John McClane]

Also I love the fact that technically you responded to the kisses - as you left them in the quote. I knew you loved me really.

 

Everything I do is with purpose. ;)

[Netbattler11]

GAH! checking in... I checked for this thread when i got the original PM and didn't see it... Assumed I would get another pm when it was actually up... Anyway, here now... Also, to prove ley's prophecy correct, VOTE LEY.

 

 

Yay, wifom! Ledinna's case is a pretty long shot, and I shall be on the lookout for others, but right now she is the most promising. Sorry, but UNVOTE VOTE LEDINNA.

 

 

Yeah, I guess I can see newbie slip-up. Not that the case was really that strong in the first place. Of course, neither is this one, but... UNVOTE VOTE LEY

 

Votes for scum.

 

Switches vote to opportunistic train, which could have been intended to swing momentum from Ley to Ledinna.

 

Switches back to scum, at about the time I'd expect fellow scum tontry hissing.

 

Vote Maw

 

Best I got from quick re-read. Ith seems to want a piece of me too... But her helpful townie routine combined with the classic recap of night kills commentary, are both scum tells that are more often than not reliable. I'd vote her too.... OMGUS and all.

 

This. This is why i get lynched. Because i play agressive on day one. Because we have no real info to work from, so i go with the flow. Is there really a better strategy i should be using?

[Minuet]

I think you are our best candidate for a lynch Maw. Nothing personal. Just think you are scum is all.

 

Vote Maw

[Netbattler11]

*sigh*

 

Story of my (mafia) life.

 

If anyone cares, I was the other Mason. The only masons were me and Ama. And leelou had to go and kill her...

[John E. Kelley]

Ishy comments about everything and seems incapable of making a post where he doesn't state he is Town.

 

I'm incapable of making a post where I don't state I'm town? Do you maybe have an example you'd care to share with us? But we all already know the answer to that, there isn't one. There isn't one single post in this game where I say a word about roles / alignments anything like that where it concerns me. Not one. FoS at you for trying to paint me in a negative light. If you want to make accusations about me, at least try to use something based on facts and not made up, non-existant gibberish.

 

I'm Ishy and I approve of this message.

[Minuet]

Unvote

 

 

Maw, you claiming to be the other mason is convenient. It also does not mean you are the only mason left in the game. Unless you know there isn't another team out there. Sorry, been in too many games where there are roles you can't imagine in them. So, unless you know everyone's role, I would not make absolutes.

 

Ishy, care to tell us who you viewed and if they are scum or not? I am thinking you would have pipped up if you found scum.

 

Now, back to more scum hunting. aka re-read

[Minuet]

Sorry Ishy. Wrong game. Oops.... Have to remember which game is which. For those of you not in the other game, Ishy claimed Finder there and we are waiting for day break. I suppose having both links open next to each other isn't a help for me either.

[Ledinna Sedai]

Now I try to really start thinking.

 

So serial killer is not mafia but s/he still lynches people of the town in the night. And now this guy (leelou) is dead. And mafia didn't know who was the SK. Is this all right? Pls correct me if I got something wrong...

 

Aww... I liked Sam so much... Sniff.

[Tiinker]

Frodo wouldn't have got far without Sam..

 

But yeah you're right there.

[Sakaea]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Maw (1) -- Ape

 

Not voting: Maw, Ithi, Ledinna, Verbal, Ishy, Tiinker, Min, WWWomby

 

 

 

"Keep it secret! Keep it safe!"

 

The Ring is in need of a new Master. The first person to PM me becomes the Ringbearer! Do not say anything on thread about ownership. Do not let anyone else know (and I do mean ANYONE, in ANY fashion) that you are the Master of the One Ring!

[Netbattler11]

Okay, i shall clarify.

 

Ama and I were the only masons in our group. I am assuming that we were the only mason group in this small of a game, but i could be incorrect.

 

Yes, i realize that it is extremely convenient. This is more for info that may be helpful-ish after i die than any attempt at self-preservation.

[John McClane]

Unvote

 

No counter-claim seems legit.

[John McClane]

VOTE COUNT:

 

Maw (1) -- Ley

 

Verbal (1) -- Ledinna

 

Ley (2) -- Ithi, WWWWomby

 

Ledinna (4) -- Ape, Ishy, Ama, Maw

 

Deadline is Thursday, 0930 PST.

 

 

 

I just really didn't think with the voting. Somehow I just wanted to take someone already voted and just be part of the majority... Just thought that I'll pick somebody and vote. I was planning to avoid unvoting as far as possible, you see.

 

Now, a try to stay alive, Unvote vote Maw

A-a-a-a staying alive.... Hopefully

 

Luckily my psychology course starts tomorrow and maybe then I will be more able to understand all this! That may be too late, though.

 

 

Got my pm and I'll be back in a few hours to give someone beef.

 

Although it has been almost 12 hours since this, kinda strange Tink.....

 

Yaaaa I went to bed.

 

Maws innocent vote on Led pings though.

 

Vote Maw

 

 

VOTE COUNT:

 

Maw (3) -- Ley, Ledinna, Tiinker

 

Ley (2) -- Ithi, WWWWomby

 

Ledinna (4) -- Ape, Ishy, Ama, Maw

 

Not voting: Verbal, Min, Leelou

 

Deadline is Thursday, 0930 PST. That is in 23 hours!

 

 

Ledinna since this is your first game I will cut you some slack. However, if you are scum, don't think for a second being new will save you. I just won't lynch you till I really think you are scum is all.

 

Okay, Those of you who wanted to jump on Ledinna before she explained has me concerned. This is why I started by just asking about the votes on Verbal.

 

Well, snap we are less then 24 hours till deadline and I don't have a vote. The only one really pinging my radar at the moment is Maw and John/Ape.

 

Vote Maw

 

 

VOTE COUNT:

 

Maw (4) -- Ley, Ledinna, Tiinker, Min

 

Ley (2) -- Ithi, WWWWomby

 

Ledinna (3) -- Ishy, Ama, Maw

 

Ama (1) -- Ape

 

Not voting: Verbal, Leelou

 

Deadline is Thursday, 0930 PST.

 

Maw is mason. Leyrann was Gollum. She voted Maw first, dumb of me not to catch this the first time through.... Scum needed a competing train with Leyrann and that Maw train was rapid. Ledinna also needed a competing train... Ledinna, Tink, Minuet.

 

At least one of those 3 are scum, without question. Look at how the D1 trains moved, you'll see it.

 

Vote Ledinna

 

Don't care what order we lynch them in, tbh. Ledinna is playing opportunistically and could be getting some coaching.

[Tiinker]

Even though I was the first vote on Ley? Interesting. Kind of goes against your own logic but fair enough. Of course I wanted him dead before I even started the game - check out the sign up thread if you don't believe me. The fact that he turned out to be Mafia was a total bonus.

 

Wouldn't be surprised if one of the early ones on his train were mafia. It's not unlikely that you voted him first to create distance and then just facepalmed when he got lynched :P

[John McClane]

Even though I was the first vote on Ley? Interesting. Kind of goes against your own logic but fair enough. Of course I wanted him dead before I even started the game - check out the sign up thread if you don't believe me. The fact that he turned out to be Mafia was a total bonus.

 

Wouldn't be surprised if one of the early ones on his train were mafia. It's not unlikely that you voted him first to create distance and then just facepalmed when he got lynched :P

 

Really?

 

Unvote

Vote Tinker

[Tiinker]

Odd though, you'd think that Merry and Pippin would be the two masons and that Sam would have the role of a bodyguard or some sort. Doesn't really fit the story for there to only be two masons but with no one calling you out on it I wont doubt you either.

[Sakaea]

 

The Ring has a new master. The Ringbearer is now a Bomb in addition to any role they may already have. This Ringbearer may not own the Ring for the rest of the game. The Bomb, if lynched, will kill the hammer vote, if NK'd, they will kill the person to send in the kill.