Werewolf game 4: Underworld edition

[Winter Mist]

Two people down... we're losing our inhabitants hand over fist now... :(

[the dude]

*hopes the last werewolf eats you all!*

[Kadere]

I'm so confused as to what's been going on. All I know is they killed Dude and Dude was a werewolf. Oh well. *Continues to haunt village.*

[Zylazlo-]

True, this game has been really topsy turvy this time. And fast... I like fast. So... any leads on anyone else...?

[Talya]

I'm upset that I have lost my apprentice she was showing promise even though she was outspoken at times...I fear this may have been her downfall. Why see was coming to see me in the middle of the night I do not know.

I also have more bad news, the night for me did not go well...I did not see an evil person but someone good. The only consolation is that out of the 11 I know myself and another are on the good side. This leaves 5 good,4 evil.... so just under 50% chance of getting an evil.

Is there anyone who has any suspicions?

[Alys Kinch]

i've got nothing. you were confirmed.

[Nevare]

*feasts on ghost villagers with dude* You know ghost people taste a lot better than regular people. Not as crunchy. Go werewolves!

[Lukys Kinch]

*has been looking through this thread for a little while now*

 

Ok, without any help from Tessa or Sira, I've gone through the thread and the only person that really sticks out to me (surprised I didn't see it before) is Kaznen. Again, I'm just saying this and not really accusing anybody yet (could use some backup from Tessa on who is innocent and who isn't), but he did work pretty hard to make Tessa out to be a vampire. He also voted for her. It could have been innocent guessing, but if he was a bad guy he would at least have known she wasn't a fellow baddy.

 

He also seemed to be a little handy with those lynching ropes...

 

Ah well, you don't have to listen to me, I'm just throwing something out there since nobody else is.

[goldeneys]

he always is Lukys...*yawn* he always is.

[Alys Kinch]

wow, this place is like a ghost town. did killing the dude kill the party?

[GoodGrief]

*isn't dead yet*

 

*rejoices*

 

Well, at least we can trust Tessa for sure, now. Sira said she had that tingling feeling of impending death, didn't she? And frankly I think we all expected it. I doubt she would have made some of her last words an argument in Tessa's favour if she knew she wasn't the seer.

 

I have a question for our Moddess: If one of the evil teams is eliminated, does the other evil team get to 'feed' every night, or is it every second night as before? This would obviously have an enormous impact on gameplay for the innocents, but I don't think the rules mention it.

[Direwolf Jon]

I don't know Alys, but I think it might have. Hmmm...*Plans a party* Let's keep the party going!

[GoodGrief]

I just came across this from the first day:

 

So we've killed our first villager' date=' tonight another one may die. Of course a vampire may kill a werewolf or the other way around so we may be good. [/quote']

 

Makes you laugh, no?

[Alys Kinch]

omg, that is funny.

[GoodGrief]

Is it the stresses of living in a town plagued by nasty bitey things, or were we just morbid to begin with?

 

Sira was suspicious of Alys as a potential werewolf and Wintermist as a potential vampire. Wintermist for reasons outsides this game and Alys for reasons within it. I'm disinclined to be suspicious of either right now, but the two that have drawn my attention are Kaznen and Zylazlo.

 

These were the two that voted with the Dude for Tessa in round one. Kaznen actually kicked off the voting. Since the wolves usually break up their vote and put the majority on the intended target, it seems likely that one of these is the Dude and Nevare's last remaining team member, since Nevare didn't vote.

Of course, as it was round one they might not have had an intended target, especially since there was no pressure on them from the lynch vote that day. Then again, if they knew that that night was the vamps turn they might have been in a hurry to catch one. Sound reasoning considering what happened.

[Kadere]

Someone will avenge me!.......please?

[GoodGrief]

Okay, as far as the vote that condemned the Dude goes, Tessa (seer), Angyl, Sirayn (seer's apprenctice), Griefy (me), Alys, Zylazlo and Lukys Kinch made up the fatal seven votes, while Wintermist jumps on at the last minute. She's also the only one who voted for the Dude after his reveal when he was already doomed. She may be innocent villager who missed the vote because she has a life, she may be a vampire who killed Nevare in vengeance, or that may just be a coincidence ... and she's a werewolf But like I said I'm disinclined to be suspicious of her right now.

Several people voted shortly before his reveal, and he could have communicated his intention to his teammate to allow them to jump on board and save themself, but he didn't reveal until he was doomed, and it seems unlikely he would make a play like that after expressing what I suspect was genuine disappointment that this game had become a thing of numbers, strategy and the greater good.

 

So I'm looking at Kaznen. He's been awful quiet since Nevare got killed ... lying low?

[Raena]

GoodGrief said...

I have a question for our Moddess: If one of the evil teams is eliminated, does the other evil team get to 'feed' every night, or is it every second night as before? This would obviously have an enormous impact on gameplay for the innocents, but I don't think the rules mention it.

 

Yeah, if one team is eliminated, the other team gets to kill every night.

[Talya]

I agree with Alys gone a bit quiet....so I've baked some chocolate (of course) muffins and brownies and got some nice cold beer to help those little grey cells going.

 

I could reveal who the innocent was but that will just put him/her in the firing line when the night comes and the guardian may have a difficult job. We don't want to lose any innocents if possible that would be a last resort.

 

The other thing to consider is that if we get the last werewolf....we would be easy pickings for the vampires every night. With one werewolf still alive....every other night the chances are better for an evil to be killed. When the night comes for the vampires it does reduce (only slightly) the chances of it being an innocent.

 

Back to griefy's theory...I do quiet like it but I was thinking that so as not to throw suspicion on themselves, they got each person in their team to vote for a different person or abstain from voting.

As the Dude votes for me, Nevere didn't vote so the other may have been in the group that voted for Kadere. If the vamps did the same or similar that would point to Kaznen or Zylazlo being a vamp.

 

This is all conjecture mind you so I'm not accusing anyone here. And I wish I had followed this theory last night but I went with something else and it back fired.

[Kaznen]

I've been busy. If you want to lynch me and kill an innocent go ahead. Then when the werewolfs and vampires kill you don't come crying to me.

[Talya]

IF you've been busy sit down and have a beer and muffin.

 

These are only ideas if you have any of your own we'd all be delighted to hear them :D

[Kaznen]

If tonight is the werewolf's night. Then I hope we get a vampire. If we get the werewolf, the vamps will have an open season on the innocences. But if we get a vamp there is a decent chance the werewolf will kill another.

 

A long shot I'll grant but if those were the odds in Vegas, I'd play.

 

BTW: I'm setting up a werewolf like game in the Aiel (Org) and I need players. If intrested go to the org and check it out. :D

[Raena]

The vampires will kill when night falls.

[Kaznen]

The vampires will kill when night falls.

 

Oh....Well, we still need to kill a vampire, then maybe they'll kill the werewolf.

[Kaznen]

Okay, I'm voting for Dark Justice. And the reason?

 

I took the list of players and removed the dead ones (can't kill them twice) and myself (know I'm not an evil) leaving me with ten names. And if Tessa's number came up I would assume she is the seer and roll again.

 

Then I used the automatic dice roller aviable at http://www.wizards.com and roll a 10d10 and took the mean as the one to vote for. The first one rolled an equal mean of 3 and 10 so I did a playoff role and 3 won (or lost depending how you look at it) when I checked my list Dark Justice was 3 so I'm voting for him.

 

At this time this is as dependable as anyother way short of the seer telling us who a bad guy is.

 

BTW: It's lynchin' ropes not lynching. The is no "g".[/i]