[Basic] Mafia with Quibby- GAME OVER

[Tiinker]

@Red Yeah I haven't helped much here have I. But it's only because I didn't want to lynch Krak but at the same time I really couldn't put a finger on anyone at all. Everyones pretty much still in the D1 phase imo.

 

But indeed it's time to see what we can dig up.

 

Moddygoddy will the Night early if you receive all the NA's?

[Quibby]

Yes, it will. I would also like to pose a question to all of you:

 

As you know, the day cycle lasts for 72 hours. If we go into a day cycle at the beginning of the weekend, would it be helpful to everybody if I added 48 hours to the deadline for those whose internet access is spottier on the weekends?

 

Bold Green your votes.

[Sedai]

no

 

I'll be on. So I'm fine with 48 hour deadlines

[Sedai]

1) red are you suspicious of me yet. Your neglect to mention it has greatly increased my scum read on you. Normally when your town you think I'm scum

 

2) I don't know if I believe lee, but I'm hesitant to believe red. We can move from there and lynch someone else leaving both claimants alive until it's absolutely imperative that we lynch scum. It's not an ideal situation but it is a viable option.

 

3) if there is a vig they should shoot at one of the two tonight. If they hit the real healer then they can say they are the vig and come after the real scum. If they hit scum then we have a confirmed townie in either lee or red and the vig is still hidden.

[John E. Kelley]

No.

 

Same as Jack, I work Mon-Fri so I'm actually on more on the weekends.

[Tiinker]

Yes

 

Well maybe not 48 hours. But 12 - 24 hours. I'm going to Greece this sunday so I really have no idea if I'll be able to get internet but by Monday morning I should be set.

[Nolder]

no

 

3) if there is a vig they should shoot at one of the two tonight. If they hit the real healer then they can say they are the vig and come after the real scum. If they hit scum then we have a confirmed townie in either lee or red and the vig is still hidden.

that's a good idea

I support it

[csarmi]

yes

 

why i do habe net at weekends, game tends to die then

[Christine]

Don't Give a Crap

 

The husband lands in... *checks clock* 3 hours. So, I am going to be in and out for the next few days anyways, but I expect him to sleep a ton, so I will be on and off regardless of the weekend.

 

Anywho, as promised, I am about to start my reread. Incoming Wall of Text.

[Quibby]

With a glare, the Lord Mod eyed Christine appraisingly as bolts of Modly Lightning sparked around His hand.

 

The angel set a restraining hand on His shoulder. "Look, dude. You can't just fry people for trying to figure out who's who. That's just not nice. Besides, don't you want people to kill people? Isn't that the whole point of this exercise?"

 

With a sullen sigh, the Lord Mod slumped back in His throne. "But Walls of Text make Big Moddy sad. Lots of word hurt."

 

"How you got to be Ruler of All Thou Surveyest is beyond me."

 

"... I don't want to talk about it."

[Christine]

Reread:

 

Posts 1-46 are really just the normal chit chat and blah stuff. Nothing really big to point out except that Jack and Red are calling eachother scummy, but to be honest, that raises no flags. The first bit of serious conversation appears at:

 

Post 47: BG: He makes a very good point that fingers are always pointed at bandwagons on Day 1, even though it is all for laughs. Sakaea then responds to BG once he votes for her, calling him out on the bandwagon, and BG then shifts his vote to Krak. From there, Ishy then adds on his vote to Krak, and suddenly, Krak has half of the votes needed for a lynch.

 

BG, you don't seem the sort to shift votes with a slight push. What's up with that?

 

 

So we move forward a few more posts, and by Post 65, BG now has 4 votes on him... Ishy was on both of those trains being the fourth one.

 

Anxious for a lynch, Ishy?

 

 

Moving on, we seem to hit joke votes again. La-Dee-Da

 

 

And Red has to be serious again around Post 100. She points at Krak and BG for jumping around so much, which I entirely agree with (Scary, right?), and especcially BG not even fighting it... But she doesn't point at Ishy? Ishy seems ready to jump on a bandwagon and keeps shifting votes. How did you miss him?

 

 

So basically, just went as far as my Drunk Post the middle of the night Tuesday. At this point, my eyes are really glaring at BG, Krak, and Ishy. I have a question about why Red didn't mention the third, but for the most part, we are on the same page.

 

 

Moving on.

[Christine]

*stomps foot* NO COOKIES FOR THE MOD GOD IF HE BOLTS ME! I don't think that my Walls of Text are too bad. I don't include quotes but instead link to previous posts, and I don't think I am too long worded.

[Christine]

Alright. Now I am at CS's Post 123, where he is getting on me for not doing the coding. I was wasted at a bar, drinking away the fact that I missed my husband. Blah. I had to get on DM while I was there to respond to a PM from a Wolfkin, and then I saw people had posted and I was feeling fiesty. Bite me.

 

We move forward to Red's Post at 130, where she gets to pointing out we have a deadline, and that a BG or Krak vote or good, then throws in my name. Really? Really? Oh, whatever. I don't even think its possible to vote for the Mod God. Then JLM posts a random vote on Red, but doesn't get FoSd. FoS on JLM for random voting and not getting Red in a tiffy.

 

So, the Krak votes pick up again, and some more votes shifted to Red. Kind of surprised a Red bandwagon didn't pick up, but hey, its Day 1.

 

Post 147. Red Posts that she is the healer. ON DAY 1? YOU JUST WASTED YOURSELF AS THE HEALER.

 

Ya know what, I don't even really need to continue. Then out of no where comes Leelou, Counter claiming.

 

 

I think you are both scum. I think that Red and Leelou are counter claiming eachother, because when one flips scum, the other will be deemed clean. I am not even going to continue my reread. I see no point. I had a strong read on Ishy being Scum, and BG was definitly acting like a Symp to take pressure off of Ishy, but then Red and Leelou...

 

 

If I get night killed, so help me god, you had better lynch Red.

[Nolder]

but why would 2 scums do that?

they could both get counter claimed by the real doc which would basically ruin their plan

[Christine]

Yes, they could. But then we would have three docs, and just have to lynch until they are all dead, or two are dead and the one left alive has to be either mafia or doc, or whatever. The point is, it might vet one over the other. Has no one ever heard of the Gambit? It was all they talked about in one of the other mafias. Having two people go against eachother, one flips mafia, the other rides till end game, and turns out they were mafia too? And why would ANYONE reveal they were the Doc on Day 1? If I was the Doctor, and it was Day 1, and someone, or better yet two people, had just revealed that they were also docs, I would keep my mouth shut and watch for them to fight it out. Then, after one or both flipped scum, I would come out saying that I was the real doctor, and had been healing myself.

[bgrishinko]

@christine About switching at a push, it was because I didn't particularly care about who was getting the 3rd vote, I wanted to get the game going. I was jumping around, its day one. Once discussion started... I finally honed in on Ishy and stayed there, until the Red/ leelou thing. Once that gets resolved, I'm back looking at Ishy.

[Nolder]

Yes, they could. But then we would have three docs, and just have to lynch until they are all dead, or two are dead and the one left alive has to be either mafia or doc, or whatever. The point is, it might vet one over the other. Has no one ever heard of the Gambit? It was all they talked about in one of the other mafias. Having two people go against eachother, one flips mafia, the other rides till end game, and turns out they were mafia too? And why would ANYONE reveal they were the Doc on Day 1? If I was the Doctor, and it was Day 1, and someone, or better yet two people, had just revealed that they were also docs, I would keep my mouth shut and watch for them to fight it out. Then, after one or both flipped scum, I would come out saying that I was the real doctor, and had been healing myself.

it's more of an endgame strategy though

it doesn't work when we have so many mislynches because we can just lynch them all and still not lose

[amegakure]

agreed. Im stil not sure whose scum between the two i think i would have to agree with christine and say bouth of them.

[amegakure]

So im really leaning towards christines thinking. Im almost positive that both of them are scum. I went back and looked at their arguments andd it looked more like distancing each from each other than two healers counterclaiming. I also noticed they were both involved in the train on krak before the reveal. Quite suspect. Im also thinkingg that casarmi migght b scum to. He was all about just leaving two healers running around. With it being 100% that one if not both were scumm.. now that wouldn't be that bad but he also was helping the wagon on krak. And now he's with red on trying to get nolder who I have gotten innocent from the whole time.

[Leelou]

No Unless you lengthen by half a day at most.

[csarmi]

So im really leaning towards christines thinking. Im almost positive that both of them are scum. I went back and looked at their arguments andd it looked more like distancing each from each other than two healers counterclaiming. I also noticed they were both involved in the train on krak before the reveal. Quite suspect. Im also thinkingg that casarmi migght b scum to. He was all about just leaving two healers running around. With it being 100% that one if not both were scumm.. now that wouldn't be that bad but he also was helping the wagon on krak. And now he's with red on trying to get nolder who I have gotten innocent from the whole time.

 

So I'm scum for pointing out the obvious? That lynching a doc is unhealthy? Thanks.

Is your point that Red, leelou and me are all scum, they go against each other doing gambit while I support them not getting lynched? Sounds fun. :)

[Quibby]

The added time is negotiable.

 

No: 4

Yes: 2

[Sakaea]

Yes I'm barely online on the weekends. So extra time would be very nice.

[amegakure]

no

[amegakure]

And yes it is but don't feel bad ur not 100% guilty ur just pinging more than to other suspects.