[DPR Mafia] Call-Your-Shot Mafia- Points being posted...

[Alys Kinch]

Like what? Joke and alternately he's here then he's gone? Yes. Less here when he's evil though.

[Verbal32]

Like what?

 

Edit:  what Alys said

[Alys Kinch]

Thanks, Verby. I love it when people agree with me. It gives me the warm fuzzies. :D

 

And because I forgot to way earlier: [glow=red,2,300]unvote.[/glow]

 

I forsee... us being no where near a real lynch until at least 24 more hours have passed.

[ed2funy]

I would just like to point out that in the Seanchan game, we are at like 52 pages. We are at Night 5 I believe.

 

This game is still Day 1 and we are only about 20 pages behind.

 

Just a note. ;D

[LilyElizabeth]

Well you are kind of proving my point by getting even more defensive so...yeah.

And I may be new to mafia on here, but that doesn't mean I'm an idiot.

Also I never said I panicked, considering that I did not. I was perfectly calm the whole time. I won't go into details though since the game is still going. All I said is that when I was suspected I tried to defend myself while pushing the blame on someone else, and that is what I am seeing in you to some extent. The amount of time you have played really is not relevant. Trying to defend yourself when suspected, is common sense.

And I don't know why you think I am tagging along with someone, but I can assure you I am not. I do not even pay attention to how everyone else is voting most of the time. I read the content of the post and make educated decisions on it. So far you seem the most logical choice so I voted for you. If someone else comes across as more suspicious than you, I will change my vote. But until then my vote remains the same.

And as a side note trying to make me look bad because I'm new won't affect my vote at all in either direction. I won't hold it against you, but I also don't like you using that as an excuse to try to discredit my comments. Of course it is a game, so like I said I won't hold it against you.

Oh and by the way I do agree that Pandy's move was pretty dumb, but it sounds like he is town, and if I am correct in my hunch is probably immune to being night killed now that someone said his phrase. This seems more stupid than scummy to me.

 

Bold is mine. I have several pages to read, but I had to say how impressed I am with this post. Talmanes, it's going to break my heart if you turn out to be scum. I really like the way you think.

 

And, Nae, I don't vote in retaliation, sweetie. I do OMGUS votes sometimes, but that is not what this is. I also feel you're being too defensive, and it's pinging my radar loudly.

 

Okay, back to my catching up....

 

 

[Verbal32]

I don't vote in retaliation, sweetie. I do OMGUS votes sometimes,

 

You do know that an OMGUS vote is a retaliation vote, right?

[WWWwombat]

I don't vote in retaliation, sweetie. I do OMGUS votes sometimes,

 

You do know that an OMGUS vote is a retaliation vote, right?

 

Keep reading.

[WWWwombat]

Like what? Joke and alternately he's here then he's gone? Yes. Less here when he's evil though.

 

His play is hard to describe right now.  If I had to pick one word to describe it, I would say reckless.

[ed2funy]

I think his emphasis is on "don't", which implies that that is what she does all the time.

If she said "didn't", that would put a whole new context on it.

:-\

 

EDIT: Wombat, you always double or triple post. :P

[WWWwombat]

I think his emphasis is on "don't", which implies that that is what she does all the time.

If she said "didn't", that would put a whole new context on it.

:-\

 

EDIT: Wombat, you always double or triple post. :P

 

Yeah you're right I read it as didn't for some reason.

[Alys Kinch]

I would just like to point out that in the Seanchan game, we are at like 52 pages. We are at Night 5 I believe.

 

This game is still Day 1 and we are only about 20 pages behind.

 

Just a note.

It’s like the games of old. :D We had games over 100 pages. :D But it is also the reason I keep trying to get everyone to consolidate into a group to vote. We need something to happen.

 

[Alys Kinch]

Anyone have a clue about the vote count?

[Barmacral]

Ed, any real reason for voting me? Or just because the game had been quiet for 4 hours?

[ed2funy]

I think his emphasis is on "don't", which implies that that is what she does all the time.

If she said "didn't", that would put a whole new context on it.

:-\

 

EDIT: Wombat, you always double or triple post. :P

 

Yeah you're right I read it as didn't for some reason.

 

I read it like that too.

 

Verby: You wanted action. :D

[LilyElizabeth]

Verb, yes it is, but she was implying (or at least that's how I took it) that is was a more personal retaliation. I don't do that. Ed and I are utterly dedicated to causing each other's deaths in another game, and yet, I love him to pieces. (Okay, that sounds threatening, doesn't it? You know what I mean...)

 

Rey, I like the way you think. I'm getting a good vibe from you this game. (I know we usually list our suspects, but I like to list those at the bottom of my list, too.) I know I got something about Kivam I wanted to comment on, but I can't remember. I'll go back and look.

 

Happy Birthday, Barmy, darlin'. Drink a couple for me, okay? I wanted a shot of whiskey so bad last night, but not enough to go out and buy it. I blame Ed.  :P

 

 

[Alys Kinch]

I think voting you because the game has been quiet is a valid strategy. What better gift than to kill you on your birthday?

 

Grabbed this and changed what was from there on.

 

 

Current Vote Count

 

Pete (4) - ed, Hybrid, Pale, Barms

Kivam (3) - Verbal, Lavinya, Pete

Nae (3) - Lily, Talmanes, Rey

Lavinya (2) - Kivam, Pandy

Pandy (1) - Lia

Dae (0) -

Rey (1) - Dae

Talya (0) -

Lily (0) -

Barms (1) - Ed

FDM (0) -

Alys (0) -

 

With 21 players, it takes 11 to lynch.

 

Out of 21 players, 14 have voted. 7 players have not.

 

Votes to mass reveal roles (2) -Kivam, Pale

 

 

 

 

...Suddenly I am having second thoughts about pandy symping kivy...

[LilyElizabeth]

I think his emphasis is on "don't", which implies that that is what she does all the time.

If she said "didn't", that would put a whole new context on it.

:-\

 

EDIT: Wombat, you always double or triple post. :P

 

Ed, what are you talking about? I'm lost.

[ed2funy]

;D

8)

 

If I drank, I would say the same. :P

Have fun searching through 33 pages.

 

Lily: This. ;D I was hoping to clear things up.

I don't vote in retaliation, sweetie. I do OMGUS votes sometimes,

You do know that an OMGUS vote is a retaliation vote, right?

[Naeann]

You said you DON'T vote in retaliation and then said you sometimes vote OMGUS.  What Verb was saying is OMGUS IS a retaliation vote.

[LilyElizabeth]

Sorry about all the posts. It wasn't about Kivam. The reason he was in my mind was because of what Rey said, that I agreed with (at least for now.)

 

It was Pandy. I'm not giving Pandy much thought, unlike the rest of you. He's playing his own little game, and not the same game the rest of us are - the actual game. He seems to do these little side games a lot lately, and I'm not buying into it. I'm not wasting my attention on it, so I miss the really important stuff going on. That's a common strategy I've used more than once - anything to distract people from actual scum hunting. All I'm going to say is if I have a night action, it's not going on Pandy.

 

[LilyElizabeth]

Okay, guys. Enough about my voting strategy, please...lol. I voted Nae because she's pinging my scumdar. No other reason, okay?

 

*shakes head, laughing*

[WWWwombat]

Hoom hum.  Burarum.

[Alys Kinch]

Pete vote is ridiculous, but has the most players on it. Still, I am ignoring it. No reason to vote him here.

 

Nae vote is…awkward. It’s like a gut feeling that people are convincing other people to have. I see little either way.

 

Kivam vote has the most to really go on here, but I am loathe to join it for previously stated reasons. He’s wanted this before as an innocent at game start even if it’s still as dangerous and wrongheaded as it ever was.

 

Lavinya- I don’t remember the reason for this one, but it is interesting to me that Panda is following Kivy here. He and kivy have enjoyed each other’s company all game. Day one mass reveal? Check. Early reveal? Check. Anyway, you get my point.

 

These are the top 4 and the most likely to go today as of this point. That said, I wanted to elaborate on my Kivy/Pandy thing. I think I need to reread though.  Still they’ve been lockstep one way or the other all game. This screams problem to me.

 

 

Edit: Off to read 6 new posts...

[DPR]

 

All right mafia fans, I've got to get to work - then I have a business dinner - then I have a midnight deadline to get a submission in, so I'll be scarce until then.

 

Happy B'day Barm.

[Alys Kinch]

http://forums.dragonmount.com/index.php/topic,53341.msg1467359.html#msg1467359 Hey, look! Hybrid did post in the game. And like once after.

 

It's possible none of this will make sense.

 

I’m so not made for developing a case… Pandy seems to symp Kivy while Kivy keeps distant… Excepting the role reveal thing.

 

Ok, so whoever said Panda is all over the place, well you were right. Also, he may be sexist. :P He’s only voted for women. *nods*

 

Just quickly, I need somebody to say "I agree with Pandy", please. Don't ask questions, just do it. It's my ego. (Nothing bad will happen to you, if you're worried.)

 

And vote Lily for not voting

 

A little later:

That said, I really don't like Ms. "All I can do is sit and watch and hopefully pick something up", aka Lavinya.

 

Unvote, vote: Lavinya

 

Around this time is the whole role reveal thing, and then pandy begins on me and Far…

 

Wowee rolefishing much? And what do you mean, we want to keep a 'good' SK around? You're talking about the big bad psycho solo win guy who kills every night, right?

 

unvote, vote: Alys

 

Really, really, no more speculation about my role until tomorrow. (If I die tonight, so be it, at least my death will gain the town some useful info.)

 

Around that time Kivy says he agrees with the reveal- which is weird and I think helped to fuel his most recent mass role reveal attempt. Also that Pandy was clearly not mafia. To which Panda responded:

Kivam's idea is good. Here's why:

 

- In a game where everybody is a power role, individual roles like cop and doc are less important. (Thus I even disagree with Kivam that cop and doc should lie.)

 

- In the normal course of things, sacrificing a cop or a doc in order to find mafia is accepted (eg. Cop claims to have a guilty investigation, or the real cop/doc counterclaims a mafia fakeclaim).

 

- Kivam's plan will eliminate from the field of suspicion a few players, those with uncontested role claims. The players that do have contested claims will either be the real role, or mafia. The rest of us can target those players at night to figure things out. Yay!

 

But the next time Panda responds

I'm not sure that Kivam's guesses are good, especially if there is a cult. But whatever.

 

He goes on to adopt the let’s lynch Nae bandwagon… Upon which Kivy had voiced his opinion of the not joking eye rolling smiley. Kivy kind of egged the whole topic on.

 

But his vote soon gets changed (again) to where Kivy has recently voted because she seemed confused about what she was saying.

uIf I know Nae at all, I think she's telling the truth. So for now, I'm letting her off the hook and I'm back to Lavinyayayaya.

 

Unvote, vote: Laviniya

 

Anyway, the voting together sparked me to go check it out.