WOT: Seanchan Succession Mafia - Game Over - Town Wins!

[ed2funy]

Ok...I see now.

I wouldn't call those big tells on her being healer early on...but I have never really 'analyzed' the healer role....so maybe you see something I don't. :D

 

 

 

[Alanna]

I apologize again for the crappy find last night. I'm not perfect. I was also totally expecting to either be nightkilled or roleblocked, so I didn't think much about the names I sent in. Which was obviously a mistake *shrug* I've never been a finder before. It's a lot harder than it seems.

[ed2funy]

I think the oddity of it makes it harder.

But I think you also know that people will still find it a little bit weird.

;D Just some encouragement there. :D

[Alanna]

Yeah, I know. As soon as I got my results and saw that Pete died, I was like, great. Now innocents are going to think I'm mafia and the mafia is going to take advantage of this to say that I'm mafia. Although not many fingers have been pointed at me, which is a nice surprise. Maybe I'm just paranoid.

 

It's been a bad week. Bad, bad week.

[ed2funy]

Paranoia comes with the game I think.

 

I think I will vote after Ty weighs in. I want to see what both say.

[CUBAREY]

That's what I thought yesterday, Ed, but honestly at this point, if there is a 'real' healer besides Tynaal, they need to reveal.

 

That is just it if you are scum claiming you viewed PETE is the only safe ting for you to claim. Plus, you and tte vast majority of players were convinced Pete was town so why view him again, to convince the view of us who had voice serious doubts.

 

PLUS, you now say that if their is another healer he/she should reveal now but wouldn't that mean that any chance of protecting anyone other then themselves would be destroyed since they would immediately become the primary target of the MAfia?

 

Does my bringing up these issues make me scummy? You yourself said viewing PETE last night was stupid. The question is did you actually make a dumb mistake or are you playing dumb as it's the only explaination that might lead us not to suspect you?

 

[Jeran]

Vote Update

[glow=green,2,300]

Talmanes (3) - Wombat, Alanna, Pookie

Tynaal (1) - Rose

[/glow]

NV: Ellianora, Talmanes, Tigraine, Ed, CUBA, Tynaal, crafty

 

6 votes needed to lynch...Deadline Tuesday at 10:00 PM EST

[mnwhiterose]

Wombat: I was expecting a bigger post from you, the way you had warned us. and most of your post focused on Alanna and Talmanes. Nothing on your thoughts of the rest of us. Yet, you name myself and Cuba as being scummy with no evidence, and crafty as having a slight ping. Any reason for these?

 

I think you are fishing.

[WWWwombat]

Crafty seems to bring up irrelevant and confusing stuff.  You and Cuba have been going completely against my instincts the entire game.  If I can't ever agree with anything someone says, I tend to think he or she is scum.

[Alanna]

Yeah, I'm pretty convinced that Cuba and Rose are scum, too. I'm not sure about Crafty. She did vote for Talmanes the other day, and I agree with Pete's assessment that probably all the mafia were voting for Tynaal. So I think the fourth mafia member is either Ed or Pookie. Not sure who.

 

Cuba, I'm getting a little tired of this. I'm not going to explain again why I viewed who I did last night (which, by the way, I did not view Pete, but the names I sent in did clear Pete). I've said I was sick and not thinking, and I explained why I thought it seemed like a good enough idea of a time. I'm beating myself up about it enough; I really don't care to hear other people do it, too. You can either believe me, or not. Whatever. But, yes, by the way, your post there? Exactly why you look scummy. You're obviously trying to build a case against me.

 

I also explained why the healer revealing now would be a good idea. Look it up. I'm not explaining again.

 

 

[craftyreader]

Sorry it seems confusing and irrelevant, but I do try and read through everything before I post questions/comments.  I thought I was doing fairly well at keeping my tangential posts to a minimum.

 

I am currently in m 2d and 3rd mafia games, so i am sill on a bit of a learning curve.

 

:P

[Tynaal Consen]

Okay I really dont know what to say to defend myself. But I am the Healer.

 

And I didnt want to reveal, but you guys made me.

 

And all arguements that have been said on my behalf I would use too. I really truely cannot defend myself anymore than I have.

 

And besides. If I was fake, why hasnt the other healer claimed?

[Talmanes]

The only good reason to reveal in my opinion, is if you have an important role, and are in danger. Right now whoever the real healer is, they are completely off the radar. It could be almost anyone. This way they are safe from being targeted by the mafia.

[Talmanes]

And sorry to double post, but I'm just still not buying the healer thing from Tynaal. I mean she claims she doesn't remember who she healed before, all of the mafias kills have been successful, she now claims she was blocked. I mean if she was really the healer I realize her getting blocked would be possible, but she has no one to back up her claim, and hasn't given any evidence so far. I cleared Elli and Tigs, and found that either Pookie or Tynaal are scum, and based on Alanna's viewing the right choice seems obvious.

[Alanna]

I don't understand what you mean about someone backing up her claim. When you get healer protection, you don't know that you get healer protection. You aren't notified by the mod. So, there's no one that could come forward and say, hey, I was protected by the healer last night.

[Talmanes]

I meant that there was no one that survived a mafia kill. They had a successful every time so far. She hasn't actually healed anyone yet, and now the person she claims she healed died.

[WWWwombat]

The nk almost always goes through unless there aren't many players left and one is a healer or roleblocker.  Also, If she were scum, wouldn't it be easier to claim that she healed Alanna than claiming that she was roleblocked?

[Talmanes]

Not if she is trying to sound innocent.

[craftyreader]

So if Tynaal's assertion that she is the healer could be vouched for, you would believe her?

[Talmanes]

Well unless Alanna has been lying to us it isn't possible for her to actually be the healer, it is just my point that she has absolutely no evidence.

[craftyreader]

That doesn't answer the question.

[Talmanes]

If someone somehow "proved" her power, I would probably suspect that they are scum too.

[Tigraine]

So either way it goes, people are going to have a hard time believing that she is or isn't the healer...what do we do?  If we lynch her and she's right then we lynched our healer and an innocent.  But she could be lying and our true healer is staying under the protection.

[mnwhiterose]

Wait - how do you know that all the kills have been mafia? Why couldn't they have been serial killer kills? the only way you would know if they are mafia kills is if you were mafia and you just made a major slip.

 

[glow=red,2,300]unvote

 

Talmanes[/glow]

[ed2funy]

You stole my thunder!

I was going to post that. :(

 

Anyways....Tal, at this point I believe the Healer would have revealed (when is the deadline?) to help us evade a lynch on Ty. She is most likely the Healer.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vote Talmanes[/glow]