DSage Presents: Heroes vs Villains Mafia - GAME OVER, HEROES WIN!!!!

[Talya]

I really don't believe that Led was the only person that had a night kill. It seems there are a few more things going on than a normal game. There could be serial killers, the role of nightkiller could pass to another member but with limited capability. The list could go on. You do look suspicious, only because you will not look at any other possibility to why there was no nightkill (healer got it right? they hit a stab proof person) The list could go on there too.

 

I would have thought you would be open more to possibilities on this. If there are super heroes here, I would suspect there are a few more roles of all sorts out there. What if someone has a 'Day kill' instead? 

 

I will hold my vote to see what else happens for now. But I would like to see your answers to what I have said!

[Naeann]

I'm the finder.  [glow=red,2,300]Meesh[/glow] is mafia.

[mmeeshal]

Actually, and Pandy will vouch for me on this, I'm in a miller group with him.  I appear guilty upon viewing but when I die you'd see I'm innocent and win with the town.

 

*shrugs*

 

I've got nothing to hide here, people.  Have I acted scummy at all?

[Naeann]

Yes?

[mmeeshal]

Yes?

 

You're not sure??  I'm going to take that as not being sure because if you were wouldn't you say something about what I did that was scummy? ???

[Talya]

Okay, I will wait until I see if anyone else claims finder. I can't see there being two Millers in one game. I wonder what Pandy will say to this!

 

Lets hope you are right Nae!

 

 

[The Crusher]

I'm the finder.  [glow=red,2,300]Meesh[/glow] is mafia.

 

What?  Huh?  Sis?  What?  So Meesh called out LZM, who had NK ability to set up a gambit?  That would make Dragon right?  

 

So if this is correct we can assume the cult has a bunch of night kill ability and or other stuff because why sacrifice a killer?

 

Naenn and Dragon very likely are both aligned positively or negatively.  Depending on who you are and what you do.

 

With one cult down and another on the block, seemingly, Naenn steps in and claims?  Though she was very findy earlier in the game when she threw out four names in a row.  *massages third chin from the right*

 

Kinda early for a claim from a finder.  Im going to take a few minutes and a deep breathe put one sock on and ponder this.  

 

Counter claim?  Not sure if its too soon or just right.  

 

[The Crusher]

Actually, and Pandy will vouch for me on this, I'm in a miller group with him.  I appear guilty upon viewing but when I die you'd see I'm innocent and win with the town.

 

*shrugs*

 

I've got nothing to hide here, people.  Have I acted scummy at all?

 

No not at all.  But isn;t that kinda what teh mafiaso's try and do? No?  be kinda easy game if they came out all scummy and stuff.  T

[Verbal32]

I'm the finder.  [glow=red,2,300]Meesh[/glow] is mafia.

 

Actually, and Pandy will vouch for me on this, I'm in a miller group with him.  I appear guilty upon viewing but when I die you'd see I'm innocent and win with the town.

 

*shrugs*

 

I've got nothing to hide here, people.  Have I acted scummy at all?

 

To me, no. Crusher is right about his point on Meesh and LZM - that wouldn't make sense.

 

Besides, Meesh would not just call out a mafia teammate like that.  I suggest we wait until Nae can view Pandy (if she chooses to) to confirm the Miller claim.  If one were lynched and flipped mafia, the other would obviously go down as well, so on the chance that the town decided to check Meesh's claim, there's no way she just false claims Miller like that.  Too risky this early in the game.  Just my opinion.

[mcs0083]

 

 

I love how when anyone claims they are the finder, it seems like everyone licks their boots. That's kind of unrelated to my point but I was just sayin'. Anyway

I'm the finder.  [glow=red,2,300]Meesh[/glow] is mafia.

Doesn't it seem pretty funny that Nae did this quite soon after Meesh and Pete were duking it out? I mean, it's still way to early to make any accusations, but I think there may be somewhat of a connection between the two of them, be it innocent or mafia.

[LilyElizabeth]

Let me get this straight - Meesha and Dragon went at it, then Verbal says that discussion makes Dragon look scummy. Then Nae claims finder and says Meesha is mafia? Did I get that right? It could be the truth, or it could be that Mcs is on to something, and Nae is sticking up for a mafia buddy. I'm not voting until we have time to see if someone else comes forward and claims finder.

 

 

[Smash]

Dragon Nae and Meesh are three to look at. Nae (who accused 3 people to start out) is claiming Finder and pointing at Meesh, after Meesh made a case aganist Dragon. Meesh is claiming Pandy can confirm her innosence. My initial vote (day 1) was on Nae because of the behavior listed but the only person in this trio that cant prove anything right now is Nae.

 

I think we have to Lynch Nae and if she comes up finder we lynch Meesh the next day with a close eye on Pandy who she claims is aware of her situation.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote [/glow]

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vote Naeann [/glow]

[cosmicpanda]

I think that Nae is not lying about being finder, but Meesh isn't mafia. I can't say why due to fear of modkill, though.

[Naeann]

Smash are you trying to deny that I'm the finder?

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote Vote Smash!![/glow]

[peacesells]

Smash are you trying to deny that I'm the finder?

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote Vote Smash!![/glow]

 

I'm really doubting this claim now and I'm more and more believing nae has a solo win condition to get lynched.

[cosmicpanda]

Actually, I think Meesha has committed the modkill crime. Not sure. I might be up for one as well.

 

Maybe if we hum loudly enough, Sagey won't notice?

[LilyElizabeth]

Smash are you trying to deny that I'm the finder?

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote Vote Smash!![/glow]

 

I'm really doubting this claim now and I'm more and more believing nae has a solo win condition to get lynched.

 

You may be right, Peace. One thing is for sure. Nae is up to something, and I'm going to try really hard not to give her whatever it is that she wants.

 

No finder would let go of a mafia (Villain, here) and do an OMGUS vote. That's just nuts!

 

 

[Toy and Minion]

Post Count

 

dragonsworn (4): mmeeshal, cosmicpanda, Verbal

 

cosmicpanda (1): dragonsworn

Naeann (1): Smash

Smash (1): Naeann

 

With 14 alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch.

 

Not voting: peacesells, Thorum, Pale Merlot, Talya, mcs, mnwhiterose, Crusher, LilyElizabeth

 

Deadline:  15th Thursday, 5:00 PM (MST)

[mcs0083]

No real finder would haphazardly vote for someone like that, because they may be hurting their own team. Seriously. The role of finder is probably the BIGGEST responsibility and asset for the town. Well that is unless the role is not among the town...... but that is only a small possibility.

[cosmicpanda]

Smash are you trying to deny that I'm the finder?

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote Vote Smash!![/glow]

 

I'm really doubting this claim now and I'm more and more believing nae has a solo win condition to get lynched.

 

You may be right, Peace. One thing is for sure. Nae is up to something, and I'm going to try really hard not to give her whatever it is that she wants.

 

No finder would let go of a mafia (Villain, here) and do an OMGUS vote. That's just nuts!

 

 

 

It might not be optimum finder play, but I can understand why a finder would do what Nae just did. That said, it is odd, and I would like her to possibly explain herself in rational (ie. non-Mynd) terms.

[LilyElizabeth]

I know not voting is suspicious, so I'm going to explain what I'm doing. As most of you know, I'm in several games. One of them has a deadline tomorrow, and this one isn't until Thursday. I like to reread and analyze and such before voting. (Well, usually I do.  ;)) I'm paying attention here, don't get me wrong. If someone pings my radar, I will vote. Otherwise, it's going to wait until I've voted in the other game. I don't want to confuse them in my mind.

 

The only things I strongly feel is that Nae wants us to vote for her, so I won't at this point. And I don't want to vote for Meesha or Pandy. Especially with the Naeann issue still clouding things.

 

 

[Naeann]

Put it this way my friends.  Meesh shows up as mafia on finderings.  She basically said so herself after I outted her.  Pandy basically confirmed this.  That being said... why would I keep my vote on a miller?  Smash, on the other hand, voted a finder claim.  It sounds to me like hes trying to sneakily counterclaim without actually yet doing so.  Thus my vote goes on him.

 

I don't have some fangled solo win nor am I TRYING to die here.  I figured with 1 mafia down there was two left... I thought I had one so I spoke up. ::)

[LilyElizabeth]

Dragon Nae and Meesh are three to look at. Nae (who accused 3 people to start out) is claiming Finder and pointing at Meesh, after Meesh made a case aganist Dragon. Meesh is claiming Pandy can confirm her innosence. My initial vote (day 1) was on Nae because of the behavior listed but the only person in this trio that cant prove anything right now is Nae.

 

I think we have to Lynch Nae and if she comes up finder we lynch Meesh the next day with a close eye on Pandy who she claims is aware of her situation.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote [/glow]

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vote Naeann [/glow]

 

Smash, can you explain why you think it's a good idea to lynch a potential finder? If someone else claims, then I can see it, but if she's the only one, she's likely the real finder. Losing her, however odd her behavior has been, isn't good for the town, IF she is the finder. I'm kind of new at this game, but I don't see the logic here. Can you explain it to me, please?

 

 

 

 

[cosmicpanda]

Put it this way my friends.  Meesh shows up as mafia on finderings.  She basically said so herself after I outted her.  Pandy basically confirmed this.  That being said... why would I keep my vote on a miller?  Smash, on the other hand, voted a finder claim.  It sounds to me like hes trying to sneakily counterclaim without actually yet doing so.  Thus my vote goes on him.

 

I don't have some fangled solo win nor am I TRYING to die here.  I figured with 1 mafia down there was two left... I thought I had one so I spoke up. ::)

 

Makes sense. There should be a doctor - protect Nae tonight.

[cosmicpanda]

I also want to hear more from the lurkers. A brief look at the playerlist suggests that they're Thorum, Rose, Talya and Crusher.