DSage Presents: Heroes vs Villains Mafia - GAME OVER, HEROES WIN!!!!

Toy and Minion · October 14, 2009

Post Count

cosmicpanda (2): dragonsworn, cosmicpanda

mmeeshal (2): Crusher, Verbal

Smash (2): Throum, peacesells

Thorum (1): Smash

mcs (1): Talya

With 13 alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.

Not voting: mmeeshal, Pale Merlot, mcs, mnwhiterose, LilyElizabeth

Deadline: 15th Thursday, 5:00 PM (MST)

The Crusher · October 14, 2009

I'm still out of town, and not fully participating like I want to. I had some thoughts on Pandy, but I'll save them, since he doesn't seem to be in danger of lynching now, and I want to post them when I have more time. I don't know why [glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow] is doing what she's doing, so I'll vote her for now, but when I get home and think things through, I may change my mind. Do you all think maybe she's a jester or something?

[glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]This struck me as odd earlier so I marked it and adds some credence to what your saying now. So of your miller team Panda is the expendable one and thats why he put himself out their?

The funny thing is I was leaning toward mafia on you dear because you had a last minute distancing vote on LZM. But you explained herself very well and for now I trust that this very well be a miller team. Though Crusher never seen a miller team before. Yet Ive seen a team of Clydsedales and their teh awesome, but thats Budweiser. MMMMM beer.

I have to go back and get thru a couple other players before I vote and I'll have time tonight.

note: home keyboard was minus space bar, hoping to get one on way home. if not I'll at least try and post my vote.

mnwhiterose · October 15, 2009

I was going to suggest that maybe Meesh and Pandy were part of a lovers team. But then, why would Meesh say Pandy was a less valuable member? Confused now.

mmeeshal · October 15, 2009

Rose, did you miss Lily's post, or are you purposely ignoring it?

Lily and Pandy are with me in the Brotherhood of Order, a group of millers--we're heroes, and we win with the town, we get to communicate with each other, and we appear guilty when viewed by a finder.

Since class was canceled, I'm going to attempt a reread now, but I may not get through it, as my head is on fire and I'm having trouble focusing on things.

mnwhiterose · October 15, 2009

No, I'm not ignoring it. It just further tears my theory apart. I've never seen a 3-person lovers team.

mmeeshal · October 15, 2009

But why would we be lovers in the first place, is what I'm wondering. It's like a mason team, only we're millers.

I just don't understand why you thought we were lovers in the first place, and how me saying Pandy was less valuable (which was actually me correcting Peace on what Pandy said--Pandy actually said he was less valuable first) would confuse you, especially after Lily said we're all part of a big group. It's not really confusing.

You say you weren't ignoring Lily's post, but you didn't say anything about it at all until I mentioned it....

LilyElizabeth · October 15, 2009

I'm still out of town, and not fully participating like I want to. I had some thoughts on Pandy, but I'll save them, since he doesn't seem to be in danger of lynching now, and I want to post them when I have more time. I don't know why [glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow] is doing what she's doing, so I'll vote her for now, but when I get home and think things through, I may change my mind. Do you all think maybe she's a jester or something?

[glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]This struck me as odd earlier so I marked it and adds some credence to what your saying now. So of your miller team Panda is the expendable one and thats why he put himself out their?

The funny thing is I was leaning toward mafia on you dear because you had a last minute distancing vote on LZM. But you explained herself very well and for now I trust that this very well be a miller team. Though Crusher never seen a miller team before. Yet Ive seen a team of Clydsedales and their teh awesome, but thats Budweiser. MMMMM beer.

I have to go back and get thru a couple other players before I vote and I'll have time tonight.

note: home keyboard was minus space bar, hoping to get one on way home. if not I'll at least try and post my vote.

Panda is not expendable. None of us are. But of the two of them, he is less valuable. That's all I said.

I honestly didn't believe LZM was mafia. That surprised me. My "style" is to always vote on someone, eventually, but I really like to think it through first. (Except for the time I was the finder, but that is a special role, and you vote with certainty.) I guess I'm the opposite of Thorum, who likes to always have a vote on someone. *lol*

No, I'm not ignoring it. It just further tears my theory apart. I've never seen a 3-person lovers team.

We ARE really close friends, but not quite that close ;) Oh! You meant in the game? *blush*

Seriously, Rose, I don't know what the question could still be. If you kill one of us, another of us will not die, too. I assume that's what you meant by lovers. Nope. That's not the case.

Thorum · October 15, 2009

I'm going to try to clear this mess up. I am also on the Miller team with Pandy and Meesh. We are the Brotherhood of Order - good guys, who appear bad if viewed. Pandy is right that of the two of them, she is more important to the town. Look at the vote tallies carefully. The mafia has probably already picked up on her ability. If you must lynch one to verify our claim, I hate to throw a teammate under the bus, but Pandy is the one. I'd rather you just believe us, though.

As long as there were only 2 of you, I'm willing to believe you (for now).

Three of you get too close to a maffia team ploy if it isn't verified..

[glow=red,2,300]pandy[/glow]

LilyElizabeth · October 15, 2009

Well, Thorum, I guess your "mafia" would show too much if you voted for Meesha or me. I've had you on my radar since the beginning of the game, and you just cinched it. And, no, folks, this is not an OMGUS vote. He has been a suspect of mine (gut feeling) since the beginning, like I said.

Vote [glow=red,2,300]Thorum[/glow]

Thorum · October 15, 2009

Why can I never make a vote that is not immediately retaliated?

LilyElizabeth · October 15, 2009

Post Count

mmeeshal (4): Smash, Crusher, Verbal, Talya

[glow=yellow,2,300]dragonsworn (2): mmeeshal[/glow]

cosmicpanda (1): dragonsworn

With 13 alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.

Not voting: cosmicpanda, peacesells, Thorum, Pale Merlot, mcs, mnwhiterose, LilyElizabeth

Deadline: 15th Thursday, 5:00 PM (MST)

For those that need proof, it's right here in the part I yellow glowed. I'm not terribly experienced at mafia, but to my knowledge, a double voter is a town role. If you think it's just a typo or something, look back at other vote polls. You will always see one "extra" vote where Meesha voted. I've not only vouched for the Miller team, I've given you proof, or as close to proof as is possible in a mafia game, anyway. ;) Now, can we move on to finding the real mafia? Please? There's not even a full day left until deadline.

Sorry to "out" you, Meesh, darling, but you know the mafia already knew anyway, if they're any good.

Thorum · October 15, 2009

to my knowledge, a double voter is a town role.

In mafia, everything is possible. Especially if DSage is the organiser

Smash · October 15, 2009

Why can I never make a vote that is not immediately retaliated?

Beacuse you never give a good reason for your vote.

The Crusher · October 15, 2009

I'm still out of town, and not fully participating like I want to. I had some thoughts on Pandy, but I'll save them, since he doesn't seem to be in danger of lynching now, and I want to post them when I have more time. I don't know why [glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow] is doing what she's doing, so I'll vote her for now, but when I get home and think things through, I may change my mind. Do you all think maybe she's a jester or something?

[glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]This struck me as odd earlier so I marked it and adds some credence to what your saying now. So of your miller team Panda is the expendable one and thats why he put himself out their?

The funny thing is I was leaning toward mafia on you dear because you had a last minute distancing vote on LZM. But you explained herself very well and for now I trust that this very well be a miller team. Though Crusher never seen a miller team before. Yet Ive seen a team of Clydsedales and their teh awesome, but thats Budweiser. MMMMM beer.

I have to go back and get thru a couple other players before I vote and I'll have time tonight.

note: home keyboard was minus space bar, hoping to get one on way home. if not I'll at least try and post my vote.

Panda is not expendable. None of us are. But of the two of them, he is less valuable. That's all I said.

I honestly didn't believe LZM was mafia. That surprised me. My "style" is to always vote on someone, eventually, but I really like to think it through first. (Except for the time I was the finder, but that is a special role, and you vote with certainty.) I guess I'm the opposite of Thorum, who likes to always have a vote on someone. *lol*

No, I'm not ignoring it. It just further tears my theory apart. I've never seen a 3-person lovers team.

We ARE really close friends, but not quite that close ;) Oh! You meant in the game? *blush*

Seriously, Rose, I don't know what the question could still be. If you kill one of us, another of us will not die, too. I assume that's what you meant by lovers. Nope. That's not the case.

Hmmmm, I did get a new keyboard but I fell asleep last night and didn't have time to read. The overly obvious move would be to lynch one of the miller team and then have two confirmed innocents. But Im struggling here because of two things:

1. Would mafia really put their entire team out in the open at this stage of the game?

2. Panda self voting twice just seems way too bold a move considering if he did get lynched and popped mafia. Essentially mafia loses with the immediate lynching of the rest of his team.

Am I missing something? Where my cornflakes spiked? Im not sure so I will not be voting until I can ponder this. I believe we have till 5pm tonight.

mnwhiterose · October 15, 2009

1. Would mafia really put their entire team out in the open at this stage of the game?

This could be a ploy - have all the mafia members out in the open, but claim to be a miller team that always shows up as evil. Hiding in plain sight. Sorry, very suspicious of this.

[glow=red,2,300]Pandy[/glow]

Verbal32 · October 15, 2009

Well, Thorum, I guess your "mafia" would show too much if you voted for Meesha or me. I've had you on my radar since the beginning of the game, and you just cinched it. And, no, folks, this is not an OMGUS vote. He has been a suspect of mine (gut feeling) since the beginning, like I said.

Vote [glow=red,2,300]Thorum[/glow]

Actually, in this case, I think Thorum is correct. We need to vet the miller team, otherwise if they are mafia, they can just waltz into endgame without any of us being the wiser.

I also wish that the miller team had not made such strong hints as to who is more valuable than who and all that, because if truly innocent, your doublevoter will end up NKed tonight. >:(

[glow=red,2,300]Pandy[/glow]

The Crusher · October 15, 2009

Well, Thorum, I guess your "mafia" would show too much if you voted for Meesha or me. I've had you on my radar since the beginning of the game, and you just cinched it. And, no, folks, this is not an OMGUS vote. He has been a suspect of mine (gut feeling) since the beginning, like I said.

Vote [glow=red,2,300]Thorum[/glow]

Actually, in this case, I think Thorum is correct. We need to vet the miller team, otherwise if they are mafia, they can just waltz into endgame without any of us being the wiser.

I also wish that the miller team had not made such strong hints as to who is more valuable than who and all that, because if truly innocent, your doublevoter will end up NKed tonight. >:(

[glow=red,2,300]Pandy[/glow]

Two really good points. By being so overt from the beginning of the game they have created a wiform that is best served by killing one. To me it almost seems like they are daring us to lynch Pandy. Why?

I have to work a little and will come back to vote, but honestly Im terribly perplexed and must eat a delicious danish so I can think this thru.

peacesells · October 15, 2009

Unvote Vote Panda

I believe their story but to be 100% sure we have to do this.

Toy and Minion · October 15, 2009

Post Count

cosmicpanda (5): dragonsworn, cosmicpanda, Thorum, mnwhiterose, Verbal

Thorum (2): Smash, LilyElizabeth

Smash (1): peacesells

mcs (1): Talya

With 13 alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.

Not voting: mmeeshal, Pale Merlot, mcs

Deadline: 15th Thursday, 5:00 PM (MST)

The Crusher · October 15, 2009

I have my reservations but deadline is approaching and this will clear two players for the most part.

[glow=red,2,300]vote pandy[/glow]

peacesells · October 15, 2009

Doh..messed up my vote again.

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote Vote Panda[/glow]

Talya · October 15, 2009

I will go along with this. Though can't say I'm happy..

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote[/glow]

[glow=red,2,300]Pandy[/glow]

cosmicpanda · October 15, 2009

Right. Now listen to what Meesha and Lily say! :D

mmeeshal · October 15, 2009

Nice thing to wake up to, having a teammate lynched and all that... ::)

:-* It's been fun playing with you, Pandy!

And...*points to what Pandy said* What he said, y'all.

Now, time for a re-read of the thread, FINALLY, because I'm feeling a lot better today after...12 hours of sleep, total. ;D

Toy and Minion · October 15, 2009

DAY TWO

Time: 8:22 AM (SFT) – 9:13 PM (SFT)

After the death of the Jester, the group slowly begins to focus on one person. It’s suggested that finding out the truth about Cosmicpanda will aid you in figuring out what to do. You are skeptical about it, but see the logic behind it. If this…Brotherhood of Order truly exists, then you have to know. And there is only one way to be sure. Your stomach churns.

Pale Merlot leads Cosmicpanda to the rope. After undoing Calendar Man, he loops the noose over Cosmicpandas head and cinches it tight around his neck. The corpses of Calendar Man and the Jester are tossed over with the other slain Villains.

Cosmicpanda closes his eyes and nods slowly. Without warning he lifts his hands and points his open palms at Peacesells. A faint red glow surrounds Cosmicpanda’s hands and a beam shoots out from between them, cutting through Peacesells like a knife through warm butter.

Without another thought, Pale Merlot pushes Cosmicpanda down. With a sudden jerk, the rope is taught and Cosmicpanda is limp, neck broken.

Red vision. It clears. You see the bodies of two Heroes.

Cerise (cosmicpanda), Member of the Brotherhood of Order, Bomb, has been Lynched.

Captain Ultra (peacesells), Hero, Finder has been Killed.

It is now Night Two. Send in your Night Actions.

Deadline: 18th Sunday, 1:00 PM (MST)

DSage Presents: Heroes vs Villains Mafia - GAME OVER, HEROES WIN!!!!

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook