Mafia - Star Wars vs Star Trek - GAME ON - Start Pg. 5

[Moghedian]

Grr, the mafia won... ::)

That was a fun game though!  ;D

[Barmacral]

There was 6 mafia, a full 1/3rd of the game. We were expecting some high powered roles to be put up against us. I was slightly surprised at how little there was going against us. Of course, we haven't seen Bcx's final layout of the game yet.

[Daetirion]

I'd love to see a master plan of this game

 

I'm sorry but from a Mafia point of view this all looked cobbled together as it went along, with seemingly random role changes and alterations. I know we were expecting something odd, but half of the changes i saw don't seem to fit with any kind plan or importantly, grand strategy.

 

And kudos to Vemy for stepping in to Mod the end of this game - much appreciated once BC disappeared

[Alys Kinch]

I agree, I watched the whole thing go, and that's a lot of evilness to stack against the innocents unless there was a counterbalance. and even if the assassin type roles count as innocent, they usually fall halfway between because they lack extra information. *shrugs*

[Loreina]

I want to know who killed me? I laughingly told BCX when I sent in my kill that it would be my luck that it'd backfire on me and kill me, because I was going to enjoy being a 'bad guy'. Is that what happened? Or did the Mafia just get lucky?  :)

I was going to target the evils first. My goal was to be the last one standing. Instead, I was the first to die. You can imagine my disappointment. But it was fun while it lasted.  ;D

[Verbal32]

Ok, five of us left?

 

Korin

Verbal

Barm

Talya

Jelly

 

We've probably gotten all the mafia, unless Talya is right and there is 1 more, so there is likely 1 more role out there - either another serial killer or an assassin/vigilante.  Not sure the difference between the 2, but whatever.

 

I'm torn between Korin [glow=red,2,300]and either Talya or Barm[/glow].  Reasons for Korin are already stated, and I think that one of the others (Talya or Barm) are not on the level.  Who? - I have no clue.  :-\

 

So, with 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.  Here's the current status, I think:

 

Korin (2) - Talya, Jelly

 

Regardless of how many evils/bad roles left, I think Talya is right - we can miss one more time, but then we need to be correct.  I'm iffy a bit here on Korin, but I'll be the hammer if I don't hear what Barms has to say by this afternoon....

 

Barms?

 

*smacks himself in the head*  Doh!

 

A little late to have had that thought, but eh, at least it means the radar isn't completely jammed, lol.

 

A agree that the game was stacked huge against us.....oh well, it was still fun.  Darn Sith......*mumbles*

[loki redfern]

wow ..that ..yeh im thinking we (ie people other than me that didnt inisiate consecutive finder and then healer lynches) did pretty well considering.. but at the end i was almost wanting to scream that crow was so clearly just not mafia, though i understand how easy it is to set up on him from a mafia point of view .. though i was thinking either jelly or talya at the end then ..half right :)

 

hehe me thinks Bcx is a is a liker of star wars rather than star trek

[Talya]

well with only three left you couldn't really go wrong, could you Verb..when you name two out of the three...lol

 

And Lor it was us that killed you, at least I think so.

 

I must admit we thought it odd that there were so many of us. And I have to agree with Barm I thought there would be some things stacked against us. As it was on the last night I got asked to kill one of the Mafia guys off, and had to choose ...sorry Dae it was me. The only things was the healer role being transfered after Boyo's death, but it wasn't for long.

 

 

[Daetirion]

I knew Tal - and i deem it the right decision. I would've been lynched the next day i think any way.

 

Oh and Lor.... I suggested killing you. Think i was just aiming for the inactives and got lucky but - i knew, honest, and it was all part of a grand strategy.... ;)

 

Well played by all