GoT Mafia "A Song of Wolves and Villagers"

[Andrej]

I mean I’d probably kill Cory first just because he’s such a road block but Nyn wouldn’t be out of discussion either.

[Andrej]

33 minutes ago, Cory Caboose said:

 

Do you know how many times in my mafia career I have seen someone "slip" and the whole town dump on them for their obvious wolfiness, they get lynched and flip town somehow?

No thank you, I will continue trying to communicate until I feel like I understand the situation 100%.

 

I know you want to accuse me.

 

do it already 

[Cory Caboose]

I like to believe my whole existence is an under the surface but never materializing accusation of you AJ :P

 

you are NOT a priority for me atm. You’d be in my poe but near the end.   

[Andrej]

I’d rather hash it out now.

[Cory Caboose]

  Game respect game

[Andrej]

Let’s find a middle ground and squash it. I won’t accept this snipes moving later into the game.

[Andrej]

Just now, Cory Caboose said:

  Game respect game

 

 

its not even a question 

[Cory Caboose]

Whats there to hash out?

I'm a little unsettled you've taken a step back from the convo today, considering d2 tends to be one of the more 'crucial' days, and I feel like we're making good progress and you're not there

You had a head full of steam d1 and have sputtered a bit since and been a little more snappy instead

 

Are there worlds where you are a wolf? Sure
Are there worlds where you are a villager who's had less time this day phase because of work/life? Sure
Does some of the stuff you've done today bother me? Sure
Does it discount the stuff you've done that I like? Nope

[Cory Caboose]

2 minutes ago, Andrej said:

Let’s find a middle ground and squash it. I won’t accept this snipes moving later into the game.

 

What's your take on Sociopath rn?

Tress?

Kat?

[Cory Caboose]

What's your take on me?

[Andrej]

Just now, Cory Caboose said:

 

What's your take on Sociopath rn?

Tress?

Kat?

 

I think your take on the Hoof vote was good. Socio hasn’t posted at all D2 so that’s not generally a positive thing.

 

Tress has the VT thing going for her.

 

Kat hasn’t moved the needle much at all. She was quick to run with the idea that one scum was in each QT (which as we said is game breaking) and idk what to think about that. It’s a good narrative for scum to abuse. But I also know she’s a tinfoil hat wearing mofo.

[Cory Caboose]

Do you think it's surprising I'm extra paranoid with you, considering games like The Stand, Sailor Moon, Dragonball Z? :P

[Andrej]

6 minutes ago, Cory Caboose said:

Whats there to hash out?

I'm a little unsettled you've taken a step back from the convo today, considering d2 tends to be one of the more 'crucial' days, and I feel like we're making good progress and you're not there

You had a head full of steam d1 and have sputtered a bit since and been a little more snappy instead

 

Are there worlds where you are a wolf? Sure
Are there worlds where you are a villager who's had less time this day phase because of work/life? Sure
Does some of the stuff you've done today bother me? Sure
Does it discount the stuff you've done that I like? Nope

 

What convo is there really to be had? We have three inactive slots that basically haven’t done anything since then, with one of them damn near admitting to being Mafia and then disappearing.

 

I can be snappy regardless of my alignment. I’m a person and I have moods and I don’t particularly love the direction the game has gone into, though I don’t think it’s unexpected considering the rarity of neighborhoods on DM.

 

overall I just feel you think I am Mafia and are instead wanting to kill my team versus take me head up because it’s the easier path. I don’t blame you, but I don’t particularly feel we’re on good standing either.

[Andrej]

4 minutes ago, Cory Caboose said:

Do you think it's surprising I'm extra paranoid with you, considering games like The Stand, Sailor Moon, Dragonball Z? :P

 

I mean, no.  But am I outside of games like Jurassic Park, House of Cards, etc?

[Cory Caboose]

Just now, Andrej said:

 

I mean, no.  But am I outside of games like Jurassic Park, House of Cards, etc?

 

Not at all

 

I know there's a box of stupid flakes in my pantry

[Andrej]

11 minutes ago, Cory Caboose said:

What's your take on me?

 

You’re either Town or leveling me in such a way it’s causing me frustration.

[Cory Caboose]

Perhaps I am just an >> optimist << but I think being able to clear Darthe/Hallia, likely Marsh + have liked the input from Tress/Kat/Beads/Dice has been a net positive for me on my feelings on the gamestate

[Cory Caboose]

Vote Illian Tear

[Songstress]

28 minutes ago, Clovdyx said:

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

• ILLIAN- 2 -Beadsman, Andrej

 

Phase ends at 6:00 PM Eastern on Thursday, 11/1.  As a reminder, I'm better at this game than literally all of you - probably combined - and Tom Brady is better at life than me, so maybe talk less crap yeah?

 

Er. Um.

 

Did my vote get missed?

[Cory Caboose]

If I'm frustrating you, it's definitely not my intent

Trust me when I say I know what it's like to feel like you've earned trust and receive skepticism because people always think you could be the Big Bad

[Andrej]

You’re giving Dice way too much credit imo. He hasn’t done anything that I would normally look for, and I thought me attacking him would bring that out.

[Andrej]

2 minutes ago, Cory Caboose said:

If I'm frustrating you, it's definitely not my intent

Trust me when I say I know what it's like to feel like you've earned trust and receive skepticism because people always think you could be the Big Bad

 

Meh. I’ll just claim when I rand Mafia so I don’t have these problems as Town

[dicetosser1]

6 hours ago, Cory Caboose said:

I think equating Blackhoof voting Socio to Socio being townspewed by Blackhoof is really foolhardy

Blackhoof wasn't even around when Socio became a real wagon

Wolves vote other wolves like, all the time, especially early in games, especially when it's most irrelevant bceause they wanna 'look good' later on

I'm not super familiar with Blackhoof as a player, but from what I know I wouldn't think at all he's someone who wouldnt vote a partner in the early game

 

6 hours ago, Songstress said:

Trying to sort through thoughts in my head this morning before work, but my cat is making it difficult. He's a majestic mini-panther solid black kitty, and prefers to be indoor-outdoor, but today is Halloween and for his own safety i keep him locked inside from bedtime on October 30th until I get up in the morning November 1st.   

 

He started about 5:00AM this morning with yelling at me periodically to draw my attention to the closed pet door.  Now it has degenerated to piteous meowing every 3.5 seconds, which only gets worse if I respond to him.  It makes it very hard to concentrate.

 

It may take me a while to draw conclusions but I'm going to try to put my thoughts out there as much as possible, starting with this:

 

9. Hallia - Mod confirmed innocent child
12. Darthe - Town per Nyn peek

 

10. Marsh - claimed vigilante (potential SK equity but with the Hoof kill unclaimed, is at least more believable than not... and AJ has a great point in that claiming vig as SK is a great way to get shot by the actual vig)

 

Which leaves probably 3 mafia and an SK in this group:

 

2. Kat 
3. Cory
4. AJ
6. Illian Tear
8. Krak
11. Beads
13. Dice
14. The Sociopath 
17. BFG

 

Illian Tear, Krak and BFG haven't really given enough info to know what to think of them just now and all of us need more from all 3 slots, so yeah.  Do that thing today, people.  

 

Beads I kinda want to trust.  He's said some things that have made me wonder if he's crafty scum, but I'm leaning toward town getting used to a new mode of gameplay with mostly new people.  I have another reason for tentatively wanting to trust him but that's not discussable and falls under the possible craftiness as scum WIFOM if I think about it too much.

 

Socio has a few arguments for being town, unless Dice's mod-gaming exercise was a colossal red herring and Hoof really was preemptively bussing a teammate.  I suppose he could be 3p also, but that might just be his screen name making me wary on that front.

 

I know I've gotten worse at reading Dice, and I want to trust Dice.   I kinda think this is Town!Dice, and I've proven to myself that just because i'm not 100% sure doesn't mean he ISN'T town, so I shouldn't let my doubt make me doubt more.   Again with the mod-gaming thing, but when I realized what he was getting at suggesting Kat might be clear because she was in the QT with him, Hoof and Kaylee, my first thought was "what are the chances all of them BUT Kaylee were mafia?  DPR put 2 mafia with a town in a 3 person QT in Suras Blades..."   But that's seriously tinfoil territory and I do think an even mafia distribution by the mods is somewhat more likely, unless they random.org'd the QT composition entirely.  So I probably should trust Dice.  Probably.

 

I'm marginally weirded out by the fact that Kat actually voted D1, since my recollection of her most games is that she doesn't feel like she has a good enough handle on the game to even venture that much, and her vote wasn't actually needed to achieve a lynch.  Just a little niggling worry.  She's definitely demonstrated the indecision I expect from her as town early game, and I'm kinda right there with her on the rampant tinfoil until we can pin down the D1 Inactive Crew.

 

Because unless all 3 of the D1 inactives were non-town, I'm afraid either Cory or AJ might be non-town (Light, please don't let it be both!) and I'm pretty sure I won't be able to tell.  

 

My plan for tonight after work is to comb back through D1 and look at things a little harder, make some notes and whatnot.

 

In the meantime, I'll be hoping for some decent content from Illian, Krak and BFG.

 

5 hours ago, Cory Caboose said:

Tom Brady would have won 0 rings if he were drafted by the Browns

 

4 hours ago, Cory Caboose said:

and fwiw

 

If you were expecting on me to comment about Tress not being dressed yet

The better question would've been "who stole dice's binoculars"

 

 

I upgraded my technology   i have video cameras now

 

 

4 hours ago, Songstress said:

OK, I'll add this bit here, and then I must drive.

 

@Illian Tear - can you pick out the one thing you have said today that you have no legitimate way of having knowledge of?

 

I mean, there is ONE possible explanation, but it seems highly unlikely to me.

 

4 hours ago, Ironeyes said:

It's a good thing I'm still riding high from the Red Sox victory in the World Series or my pride in Boston sports might demand that I duel you XD

 

shuddup.

 

 

4 hours ago, Illian Tear said:

Oh I know the post

 

2 hours ago, Songstress said:

 

He was the other one involved in the conversation that Illian somehow has knowledge of.

 

My QT last night had 4 people who posted aside from the mods.

 

Beads has basically confirmed by voting that he isn't the one who passed information from our QT to Illian.

 

And I'm kinda feeling like his revealing that he understood why I might want to trust Beads (based on knowledge from that QT) was a slip.

 

 

all right im not getting what the thing he did actually was. can someone quote the post plz?

[Andrej]

It’s unfortunate thing, because honestly would anyone have fun if every game the Mafia just lurked?

 

people like us make games interesting.

[Cory Caboose]

3 minutes ago, Andrej said:

You’re giving Dice way too much credit imo. He hasn’t done anything that I would normally look for, and I thought me attacking him would bring that out.

 

Like I said - I am open minded. I have room for him in the PoE too!

 

1 minute ago, Andrej said:

Meh. I’ll just claim when I rand Mafia so I don’t have these problems as Town

 

Didn't know you got all Rand Al'Thor when you drink :P