PotC Mafia Game - mafia won!!

[bgrishinko]

By the way, sorry for the late entrance to the game. I ended up being on-call at work the past few days so I was distracted.

 

So far the only read I feel like I have is ElderScrolls4000 here seems to be doing a go job of trying to suss out Day 1 info, beating the bushes etc. to get responses. So I've got a town lean on him at this point. The rest is still fairly null Day 1 for me.

4. BG (3/50)

[dicetosser1]

7 hours ago, Eldrick4221 said:

 

Your read on Amega is baffling the hell out of me.

 

The reaction in question was presumably to your scum team pairing, which you have written off as humor.

 

If it was just a joke, why did you tell Cass he may be scum for his response? Why did you tell me you were waiting for his response? If it was a joke, why would his response matter?

 

You calling it humor just doesn't sit well with the rest.

 

I feel like you are scum backpedaling. Please explain what's going on here.

 

MY comment was humorous. or meant to be. that doesnt mean that HIS response cant be weird or sus. or worth looking at

 

i also find ure comment that you didnt get the humour weird as you have seen enuff people say that sort of stuff before

 

7 hours ago, Eldrick4221 said:

I will go ahead and mark it off as referencing the last game. Thank you for addressing it. I realize you responded the way you did because of the face value "you didn't feel it needed a response"

 

Vote dice

 

 

and finally he votes.

 

btw you didnt unvote.

[Katiora]

9 hours ago, Cass said:

 

... ZandertunnelsTM

 

  Reveal hidden contents

*shudders*

 

 

 

 

Butttt no excuses when Zander isn't here! Point is that D1 isn't hopeless unless everyone clams up, and tbh I don't read all your entries as the same? Penny for your thoughts when you're around?

 

Honestly i don't know. Tinfoiling a bit on Eld right now. He is "solving" which can be towns, but it's also an easy play for a good scum. 

 

Other er than that I just don't know. It's so easy to turn anything into something suspicious this early. That's the main reason I'm tinfoiling on eld so hard I think. It's almost like he's purposely reading too much into stuff. 

 

 

3 hours ago, dicetosser1 said:

 

MY comment was humorous. or meant to be. that doesnt mean that HIS response cant be weird or sus. or worth looking at

 

i also find ure comment that you didnt get the humour weird as you have seen enuff people say that sort of stuff before

 

 

 

and finally he votes.

 

btw you didnt unvote.

We don't have to unvote. It's in the rules you didn't read  

 

 

in real life my 4yo just started  throwing up so I may not be around a lot tonight. But I'll try to check in a few more times if we don't end up back in the shower. *sighs* 

[Cass]

11 hours ago, Eldrick4221 said:

 

I took it seriously because it felt serious. He has been treating it as serious all along until he called it humor.

 

I got the meaning of the gif, which is why I felt it odd that you were accepting it as "humor"

 

Ok Dice has answered so can get to this.

 

The point wasn't that you reacted as if it was serious, but that there was a difference in the way he reacted to your response vs Amega's.

 

Bold - Maybe but he hadn't actually gone anywhere with it yet, still hasn't so IMO it's null/can easily be Dice either way. He posted X-X scum team, and poked other places in between. 

 

Italics - I didn't say I accepted it as humour? I posted a graphic comment on Dice saying there was something to be missed, Amega saying he got humour and you saying you missed it.  I was waiting to see where he went with it, hence the earlier "Dice, game impressions?" post. 

 

Following up, Amega's opening was awkward for me and he's hanging back enough here like in Hackers that I can't pull him out of WTL yet when he gave opinions/vibes straight up last game. I disagree on giving his entry Town points and my impression of your reaction to his entry is that you ran with it/gave it more credit than it should deserve, then pressed Dice and Darthe over him from there, when both of them are also players with histories of early mislynch. 

 

/shrug #earlydayz

[Cass]

Cass7 ^

[Eldrick4221]

6 hours ago, dicetosser1 said:

 

MY comment was humorous. or meant to be. that doesnt mean that HIS response cant be weird or sus. or worth looking at

 

i also find ure comment that you didnt get the humour weird as you have seen enuff people say that sort of stuff before

 

 

 

and finally he votes.

 

btw you didnt unvote.

 

I originally laughed it off. IIRC I have you town cred for the initial post.

 

It's your treatment of Amega's response to it that bothers me.

 

Amega responds by asking what your w/l record is. In answering Cass about your reads, you call this response scummy. How is it scummy?

 

When I asked you about your reads, you say you are waiting for his response to you asking about the w/l thing. Once received, you write this whole thing off as supposed to be a joke.

 

The way you treated it just doesn't match up with it being originally a joke.

 

And yes, I'm finally voting. I was torn between voting you and waiting for your response. When Darthe eased my mind about the beginning bit and I was moving my vote off him, I decided to go with voting you before your response.

 

And I'm not happy with your response, so the vote stays. 

[Eldrick4221]

Crap

 

Eldrick2

[Eldrick4221]

8 hours ago, bgrishinko said:

Do my eyes perceive a Slip? Probably just a poor choice of words. But I cannot ignore this.

 

It read to me as satire, and very obviously so.

[Eldrick4221]

3 hours ago, Katiora said:

That's the main reason I'm tinfoiling on eld so hard I think. It's almost like he's purposely reading too much into stuff. 

 

I'm trying so hard because the game is so ridiculously dead already. Bring on the tinfoil. Some of my best reads come from my interactions.

[amegakure]

I think eld is on to something. Glad i let that play out longer. 

 

Feel better about darthe too although it's still early. 

 

Not sure about Cass. What are your thoughts on everyone not dice/eld. Feel free to start with me. 

 

Imo it seems your involved alot but not solving. Help me Help you.  

 

 

[amegakure]

Vote Dice

 

13.amega.13

[dicetosser1]

9 minutes ago, amegakure said:

I think eld is on to something. Glad i let that play out longer. 

 

Feel better about darthe too although it's still early. 

 

Not sure about Cass. What are your thoughts on everyone not dice/eld. Feel free to start with me. 

 

Imo it seems your involved alot but not solving. Help me Help you.  

 

 

 

cause eldrick gave you a reason to jump on a town train that you think wont look sus?  wrong

 

vote amega

[Eldrick4221]

9 minutes ago, dicetosser1 said:

 

cause eldrick gave you a reason to jump on a town train that you think wont look sus?  wrong

 

vote amega

 

I like this point a lot. If dice flips town, it's time for a hard look at amega.

 

This could also just be scum omgus, so this is only a post-flip point.

[amegakure]

train? i think you're responding to pressure rather poorly. Omgus much!?

[dicetosser1]

Hey you know i was watching for what you did when you came back. you wanna out ureself by being scummy? thats your problem. My job is to lynch ure scummy self

[Eldrick4221]

What made you sus him in the first place?

[amegakure]

You're acting like a child.

[Eldrick4221]

Please don't resort to name calling. Let's keep it civil.

[dicetosser1]

his reaction to my scum team post.

[amegakure]

That's not name calling. If that crosses a line that's fine, i'll rein it in. Just describing his reaction to my vote. As such i'm more than happy to leave it there. 

[Eldrick4221]

18 minutes ago, dicetosser1 said:

his reaction to my scum team post.

 

You mean when he asked about your w/l record?

 

Please explain how that is scummy.

 

Eldrick2

[Eldrick4221]

19 minutes ago, amegakure said:

That's not name calling. If that crosses a line that's fine, i'll rein it in. Just describing his reaction to my vote. As such i'm more than happy to leave it there. 

 

It's a line that kind of comment heads towards. Wanted to make sure it doesn't. 

[Cass]

1 hour ago, amegakure said:

I think eld is on to something. Glad i let that play out longer. 

 

Feel better about darthe too although it's still early. 

 

Not sure about Cass. What are your thoughts on everyone not dice/eld. Feel free to start with me. 

 

Imo it seems your involved alot but not solving. Help me Help you.  

 

 

 

1. Why do you feel better about Darthe?

2. What made you feel bad about him in the first place? 

 

3. Bold is literally answered several posts above the Eldrick one you're basing your vote off:

 

 

3 hours ago, Cass said:

 

Ok Dice has answered so can get to this.

 

The point wasn't that you reacted as if it was serious, but that there was a difference in the way he reacted to your response vs Amega's.

 

Bold - Maybe but he hadn't actually gone anywhere with it yet, still hasn't so IMO it's null/can easily be Dice either way. He posted X-X scum team, and poked other places in between. 

 

Italics - I didn't say I accepted it as humour? I posted a graphic comment on Dice saying there was something to be missed, Amega saying he got humour and you saying you missed it.  I was waiting to see where he went with it, hence the earlier "Dice, game impressions?" post. 

 

Following up, Amega's opening was awkward for me and he's hanging back enough here like in Hackers that I can't pull him out of WTL yet when he gave opinions/vibes straight up last game. I disagree on giving his entry Town points and my impression of your reaction to his entry is that you ran with it/gave it more credit than it should deserve, then pressed Dice and Darthe over him from there, when both of them are also players with histories of early mislynch. 

 

/shrug #earlydayz

 

Adding to that, I now don't like that you haven't bothered to read/reply to my post, or the shade of your underlined above. 

 

For me, working on the players I feel I know best and comparing their reactions and reactions to them first is solving.

 

Aorn I'm happy enough to

 

Vote Amega pending replies.

[Cass]

>.< Cass7 ^

[dicetosser1]

18 minutes ago, Eldrick4221 said:

 

You mean when he asked about your w/l record?

 

Please explain how that is scummy.

 

Eldrick2

 

fine i will try to expand.

 

the tone of his response was both defensive and aggressive.

pugnacious is a good word for it.

its kinda like "yeah and what r u gonna do about it" picture it with his chin jutting forward.

 

it got my attention.

 

since then hes done nothing. he hasnt put any work in. he just jumped at the first opportunity someone gave him to vote me.