PotC Mafia Game - mafia won!!

[Katiora]

8 hours ago, Dragoon said:

What would you like to know?

 

Just an FYI @Cass has been getting smashed at work and she has just started a 14 hour night shift. So probably won't be super active.

 

8.Dragoon  (13 of 50)

I'd just like to know what you're thinking. Your take on different people in the thread. Your thoughts on the lynch yesterday and on the two "trains" (for lack of a better word since it's just eld on amega) that are here so far today. 

 

What do you think of Elds reveal? What about his reaction to Amega and BG's votes on him? Plus any other thoughts about people that you seem to be having. 

[Darthe]

1 hour ago, Eldrick4221 said:

Thank you for not letting my outburst affect your read. I agree that my reveal has muddled up the thread, and I'm sorry for that. I am the optimal lynch so town can get back to hunting scum.

 

Eldrick2 

:/

 

If you're town we have seen your lists, but I still want to know who you push for tomorrow?  

 

 

[BFG]

Votecount:

 

Eldrick (3): Amega, BG, Darthe

 

Amega (1): Eldrick

 

not voting (3): Cass, dragoon, Kat

 

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch <3

 

end of day:

 

[Eldrick4221]

31 minutes ago, Darthe said:

:/

 

If you're town we have seen your lists, but I still want to know who you push for tomorrow?  

 

 

 

This implies I survive the day.

 

If we lynch you or Amega, and the flip is town, I would obviously push the other, as I believe there's scum between the two of you.

 

If we get a scum lynch between you two, I have gone over who doesn't make sense to be your teammate, and would evaluate who might be your teammate.

 

Not sure why you're asking this. It's basic stuff.

 

Eldrick2 

[Darthe]

I'll answer that easily enough. I don't think you think I'm a wolf.  I've seen you pidgeonhole it into your posts, but then you've went and followed me on nearly everything I spoke about.  Hell, you revealed, even after questioning it and while sussing me.  

 

So I don't think you think I'm a wolf.  I'm set in my vote.

 

Ftr, I don't appreciate this sort of AtE that you've displayed either, it's not a respectable strat to keep your head off the block.

[Cass]

Ok, we made it back to station. I know there's stuff to go back and reply to, will get to it as I can. Reads first.

[Cass]

TLDR in case I get interrupted with a job, I think I'm happy with 

 

Kat/Rich

 

Scum in Eldrick/Amega/Darthe/BG

[Dragoon]

2 hours ago, Katiora said:

I'd just like to know what you're thinking. Your take on different people in the thread. Your thoughts on the lynch yesterday and on the two "trains" (for lack of a better word since it's just eld on amega) that are here so far today. 

 

What do you think of Elds reveal? What about his reaction to Amega and BG's votes on him? Plus any other thoughts about people that you seem to be having. 

1) Calder made little attempt to clear his name when attention moved to him.

2) Dice got NK when at the time Eldrick seemed the most Townie

3) Eldrick then made a claim which basically resulted in no advantage to town and is unverifiable unless he flips. (Pointed out by, me (no vote), you (no vote), Amega (voted E) and BG (voted E) in that order)

4) Eldrick and Amega then got heated

5) Eldrick self voted and then went back to Amega

 

Which has lead me to: see below

 

8 hours ago, Dragoon said:

 

Complete TINFOIL, but is anyone else got this vibe?

8.Dragoon  (15 of 50)

 

I'm thinking both "trains" are suss 

 

If I am onto something then the scum team has it setup that one of them will go but goes a long way to clearing the other.

 

In saying this I am going to hold off voting (Give @Cass a chance to make some input)

 

8.Dragoon  (17 of 50)

[Cass]

  

 

Kat - tone is good. I like the way she's picked up from D1. Reading through EoD I thought her return/catch up thoughts/emotions were pretty pure and kind of how I've felt all day trying to figure this out. I struggled with her having Amega sounding as her scummiest then switching to Calder, but ultimately he would've been the lynch anyway and her explanations sounnded ok enough, she's been answering well.

 

Rich - is playing thought out and logical and picking up after D1, which is just as I would expect from his personality. Not many alignment thoughts on other players to here but I think it fits and he is asking questions and holding his own - and with cheeky humour, which is most likely a good sign.

 

Eld - Honestly? I can't weigh the claim, or the self-protect, against WIFOM from either PoV. I think he probably needs to flip now to clear things up. I'm wary of the quick votes but I have MASSIVE amounts of tinfoil because I've seen him suggest claims like this in scum chats almost every time. I never understand the ins and outs of roles so it goes over and around my head, but that's what I recall and I can't seem to let it go. Feels off. Honestly, on reread I feel like that back and forth with Amega was fake and possibly a final ditch at distancing, tunnel and WIFOM maybe, but it's there like the feeling I got in the beginnign.

 

Amega/Darthe/BG I'm still backwards and forwards on also. Need to go back and dig.

 

[Katiora]

I kind of agree with you. If eld flips it doesn't clear anyone really.. except maybe Darthe. Darthe has been suspicious of him too much. I could see some distancing, but I think that would be too much for even that. Though I have tinfoiled on it a good bit. 

 

 

Though Honestly I think it's a good chance that Eld flips town. Some scum does the thing he did, but normally it's a town. But until he flips he doesn't know. Honestly at this point I don't know if we could get the votes together to get someone else. I'm really at a loss. 

 

And I'm holding off voting as well to give Cass time. 

 

[Cass]

7 minutes ago, Dragoon said:

1) Calder made little attempt to clear his name when attention moved to him.

2) Dice got NK when at the time Eldrick seemed the most Townie

3) Eldrick then made a claim which basically resulted in no advantage to town and is unverifiable unless he flips. (Pointed out by, me (no vote), you (no vote), Amega (voted E) and BG (voted E) in that order)

4) Eldrick and Amega then got heated

5) Eldrick self voted and then went back to Amega

 

Which has lead me to: see below

 

 

I'm thinking both "trains" are suss 

 

If I am onto something then the scum team has it setup that one of them will go but goes a long way to clearing the other.

 

In saying this I am going to hold off voting (Give @Cass a chance to make some input)

 

8.Dragoon  (17 of 50)

 

LOL mindmelds from opposite ends

[Katiora]

Ninja'd!!! lol btw ^^^ Kat6

[Cass]

Darnit, job

[Dragoon]

2 minutes ago, Cass said:

Darnit, job

 

Well there goes any chance Cass being back by deadline. @Katiora what do you want to do?

 

without Cass it is either Eldrick or it goes random....  

 

8.Dragoon (18 of 50)

 

[Cass]

Sorry

 

You have me for ETA 3 mins

 

I can vote now or?

[Katiora]

Well the only way we KNOW we can resolve eld is by lynching him. I hate to do it if he's town but right now i'd say there's a 50/50 chance he's not. If he isn't I think we will have to look hard at Amega tomorrow. Hopefully there's a cop and if they're still around tomorrow it might actually be a good idea to reveal. 

 

 

What do you think?? 

[Cass]

YOLO

 

Vote:Eldrick

 

Sorry if we're wrong Eld

[Eldrick4221]

1 hour ago, Darthe said:

I'll answer that easily enough. I don't think you think I'm a wolf.  I've seen you pidgeonhole it into your posts, but then you've went and followed me on nearly everything I spoke about.  Hell, you revealed, even after questioning it and while sussing me.  

 

So I don't think you think I'm a wolf.  I'm set in my vote.

 

Ftr, I don't appreciate this sort of AtE that you've displayed either, it's not a respectable strat to keep your head off the block.

 

I have been back and forth on you being a wolf. I have reasons, and then I doubt those reasons. Then I find new reasons. You keep popping up on my radar.

 

And my "AtE" has literally nothing about keeping myself from being lynched. I have said as much. If you see it that way, you SHOULD hate it. It's a gross strategy to get out of a lynch. Something I am not trying to do.

[Dragoon]

1 minute ago, Cass said:

YOLO

 

Vote:Eldrick

 

Sorry if we're wrong Eld

What she said

 

Vote Eldrick

 

8.Dragoon (19 of 50)

 

[Eldrick4221]

Good luck town.

 

...*bleh*

[BFG]

Votecount:

 

Eldrick (4): Amega, BG, Darthe, Cass

 

Amega (1): Eldrick

 

not voting (2): dragoon, Kat

 

That's a lynch

 

@Nynaeve

[BFG]

Sorry I don't have the info to do flips <3

[Nynaeve]

15 minutes ago, BFG said:

Sorry I don't have the info to do flips <3

Im here no worries

[BFG]

Nyn GOAT <3

[Nynaeve]

Eldrick was lynched. He was....

 

dead... duh. But also...

1xtown doc