The Founding of Quahog (Peter's Progress) Mafia - Game Over

[Clovdyx]

Chris pls vote before you go regardless of whether it's no lynch or otherwise

I was planning on abstaining again for Lola though!

[BFG]

 

 

 

IMO BFG is the most common denominator in scum lists today.

[v]BFG[/v]

Based in sheer numbers, I think you're probably wrong.

 

Based on my reads, this is a bad vote.

Then I'm wrong, but this is where I'm at right now.

So the Tldr of your read is that voting no lynch is scummy?

Because that's all I'm getting from your posts and thats a generality which means nothing on an individual basis and doesn't take into account my reasons

[Verbal32]

 

 

 

How confident are you on ben?

I'll own the loss if he's a wolf.

I am not used to making game-deciding decisions on D2.

You know how I am about these things. I'm committed to the read at this point. Doesn't make me right but I'm willing to lose to it under circumstances where we might only have two day phases to catch a wolf. Do you follow me?

Fair

Does this mean you're trusting his read on Ben? You were pretty sure he's mafia. Who is Verb with?

 

 

She's switching her stance to fit the current narrative.

[Turin Turambar]

IMO BFG is the most common denominator in scum lists today.

 

[v]BFG[/v]

this is a bad reason to vote and you should feel bad.

[Verbal32]

 

 

 

IMO BFG is the most common denominator in scum lists today.

[v]BFG[/v]

Based in sheer numbers, I think you're probably wrong.

Based on my reads, this is a bad vote.

Then I'm wrong, but this is where I'm at right now.

Who do you think she could be scum with? Who is she definutely not with?

 

 

You or Shad - currently, I think you're slightly less likely to be scum.

[Clovdyx]

Let her answer please.

 

You can answer my questions to you though :P

[Shad_]

I mean I think the side of BFG's point that I agreed with (and hence instinctively read it at) wasn't that Verb wasn't going through solve motions but that they didn't really make sense in terms of actually solving.

Basically in terms of figuring out which of me/BFG/Chris is town if he's really that convinced that Tiinker and Ben have to be villagers.

He's certainly playing very bold for a wolf and I don't know what's normal for him.

[Verbal32]

 

IMO BFG is the most common denominator in scum lists today.

 

[v]BFG[/v]

this is a bad reason to vote and you should feel bad.

 

 

Yeah, like I haven't had her in my 3 WTL all phase or anything.  Right.

 

You're going to re-read some of this and realize how silly you sound.

[Verbal32]

 

 

 

IMO BFG is the most common denominator in scum lists today.

[v]BFG[/v]

Based in sheer numbers, I think you're probably wrong.

 

Based on my reads, this is a bad vote.

Then I'm wrong, but this is where I'm at right now.

So the Tldr of your read is that voting no lynch is scummy?

 

 

I said that?  Where?

 

Can you point me to that?

[Shad_]

 

I mean BFG's not a wolf so there's that.It's kind of obvious that Verb's not going to win that fight so there's also that.

I don't disagree with either of those points. And he's my best bet, but I don't have the confidence it's absolutely not Ven/tink you seem to

 

 

Can you remind me why Verb/Tiink doesn't jive?  Is it more than the hard town read?  Decent chance I have forgotten things.

[BFG]

 

 

 

 

How confident are you on ben?

I'll own the loss if he's a wolf.

I am not used to making game-deciding decisions on D2.

You know how I am about these things. I'm committed to the read at this point. Doesn't make me right but I'm willing to lose to it under circumstances where we might only have two day phases to catch a wolf. Do you follow me?

Fair

Does this mean you're trusting his read on Ben? You were pretty sure he's mafia. Who is Verb with?

She's switching her stance to fit the current narrative.

Lol

 

My read on Ben is still the same, based on individual posts I think he's town, based on general approach scum

 

It's fair for shad to have that perspective

[Shad_]

 

I mean BFG's not a wolf so there's that.It's kind of obvious that Verb's not going to win that fight so there's also that.

I don't disagree with either of those points. And he's my best bet, but I don't have the confidence it's absolutely not Ven/tink you seem to

 

 

Nevermind I completely misread this because my brain translated Ven as Verb instead of Ben

[Verbal32]

I mean I think the side of BFG's point that I agreed with (and hence instinctively read it at) wasn't that Verb wasn't going through solve motions but that they didn't really make sense in terms of actually solving.

 

Basically in terms of figuring out which of me/BFG/Chris is town if he's really that convinced that Tiinker and Ben have to be villagers.

 

He's certainly playing very bold for a wolf and I don't know what's normal for him.

 

Where in any of my posts did I give you the impression that I wasn't trying to figure out which of you was the other townie?  Hell, didn't I even address that at some point today?

[Clovdyx]

Verb/Tink does jive. It was the way I've been leaning since verb basically wrote tink off for minimal reasoning and then proceeded to do nothi ng to resolve his POE.

 

But I want to cover my bases. I don't have time to camp out here and decide

[Turin Turambar]

Jokes on you. I'm not rereading this thread.

 

I will just check the dead thread once I die. Sooooooooonnnn.

[BFG]

 

 

 

 

IMO BFG is the most common denominator in scum lists today.

[v]BFG[/v]

Based in sheer numbers, I think you're probably wrong.

 

Based on my reads, this is a bad vote.

Then I'm wrong, but this is where I'm at right now.

So the Tldr of your read is that voting no lynch is scummy?

I said that? Where?

 

Can you point me to that?

When you agreed with tiinkers analysis

 

I've asked you what you agree/disagree with but you have yet to answer. If you disagree then I don't know what it is you are agreei with so?

[Verbal32]

I mean, if I'm so wrong this game that I have cleared the exact 2 people that are scum, then I guess I'll just say "lolVerbal" once the game is over.

 

But I have to believe I'm not that wrong (I hope I'm not wrong at all), so I'm sticking with my reads and not changing them at this point barring some crazy reveals.

[Verbal32]

Jokes on you. I'm not rereading this thread.

 

I will just check the dead thread once I die. Sooooooooonnnn.

 

Ok, so you're not helping then.

 

Thanks, I guess.

[BFG]

If I've missed a post where you explain why I'm scummy then feel free to point it out, or explain why Chris/shad are town/scum, or explain why thevway Ben is using ate is inherently townie when you apparantly mean it's generic... You know the questions ive been asking you

[Verbal32]

 

 

 

 

 

IMO BFG is the most common denominator in scum lists today.

[v]BFG[/v]

Based in sheer numbers, I think you're probably wrong.

 

Based on my reads, this is a bad vote.

Then I'm wrong, but this is where I'm at right now.

So the Tldr of your read is that voting no lynch is scummy?

I said that? Where?

 

Can you point me to that?

When you agreed with tiinkers analysis

 

I've asked you what you agree/disagree with but you have yet to answer. If you disagree then I don't know what it is you are agreei with so?

 

 

That your NL vote looked like you pretending to contribute based on timing.  I agreed.  That it was a NL vote is not the important part.

[Verbal32]

Verb/Tink does jive. It was the way I've been leaning since verb basically wrote tink off for minimal reasoning and then proceeded to do nothi ng to resolve his POE.

 

But I want to cover my bases. I don't have time to camp out here and decide

 

Can you explain what you mean by the bold?  I've been trying to resolve my POE all day, ever since I stated it.  How do you mean this?

[Andrej]

Vote Count

 

Verbal32 - 2 - Turin Turambar, BFG

BFG - 2 - Gentled Ben, Verbal32

No Lynch - 1 - Shad_

 

4 to lynch

 

Deadline in 3 hours

[BFG]

 

Verb/Tink does jive. It was the way I've been leaning since verb basically wrote tink off for minimal reasoning and then proceeded to do nothi ng to resolve his POE.

 

But I want to cover my bases. I don't have time to camp out here and decide

Can you explain what you mean by the bold? I've been trying to resolve my POE all day, ever since I stated it. How do you mean this?

How has what you've done tried to resolve it?

[BFG]

Vote Count

 

Verbal32 - 2 - Turin Turambar, BFG

BFG - 2 - Gentled Ben, BFG

No Lynch - 1 - Shad_

 

4 to lynch

 

Deadline in 3 hours

Pretty sure I'm not self-voting lol

[Verbal32]

If I've missed a post where you explain why I'm scummy then feel free to point it out, or explain why Chris/shad are town/scum, or explain why thevway Ben is using ate is inherently townie when you apparantly mean it's generic... You know the questions ive been asking you

 

You realize what POE means, right?  I can't explain the why of any of you 3 above the others, except I think you're the most scummy.

 

As for how you 3, I said this already - I'm clearing the others as townies.  I had Ben and Sooh originally, and had to find another when Sooh died.  I think I found Tiinker, and I'm also saying Turin is prob town because of his role even though he wants to be silly and vote me for somehow casting shade at somebody by saying they're prob town.....like in what world does that makes sense, but I digress --- I have my townies and that makes the 3 of you contain the 2 scum.

 

Simple as that.