[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

[Spadeszee]

 

 

 

So let's assume for a sec that she is the seer. And that lzm and spades are her peeks.

 

Where does that leave us?

 

I disagree with Aussie being scum. Cass has been doing a lot of work solving and dice is too emotionally invested for them to be scum imo

Exactly. Her being the seer doesn't mean her gut instinctively points out scum. She has given NO reason for this feeling.

She also didn't give a reason for Alex last night and hit the nail on the head there.

Right but he pinged A LOT of people. Plus it was Day 1. Not as much to go on.

 

This is based upon her experience playing with Dice/Cass. I know that she has experience with them and so does Tress. Please read Tress' comment about her reads on them as well. 

[Eldrick4221]

 

Thank you for covering other people, tigs. I'm gonna go check out Adella's iso for myself. She's the one that jumped out the most on your list.

 

@dice that vote feels very much like OMGUS. Do you have more reason to vote there?

 

@Spades nice catch on Hally. Looking forward to seeing how this develops. Could move my vote there.

id already given them. she wasnt solving. her tone sucked.

 

 

Tress gets it...

neither of you get it.

 

[unvote]

 

You're right.

 

It's been bugging me since she posted the second peek. As I said before, I'm not comfortable with claiming fake peeks while also trying to solve. The fact that she is means she is probably either the actual seer or she is scum.

 

Either way, lzm is probably town. Unless it's exactly alex/hally/lzm

what town says this?

[V]darthe [/v]

 

Mostly gut. Mainly because of how he handled my peek of him.

thats it. ure either scum or i just give up on you

 

 

vote eldrick

:thumbsup:

 

Tired of trying to figure this game out anyway.

 

Looking forward to the solve in dt

[dicetosser1]

 

 

@Tigs - in this type of setup the seer starts the game with the name of one confirmed vanilla townie in their role PM, known as a N0 peek - it's randomized by the mod.

 

That's why so many of us were hard clearing someone as town D1, to lay down cover for the actual seer to be able to reveal their results.

Okay I get that, spades said she was Hallia's N1 so where does Dice/Cass fall into scum role?

 

She said "Early on good feels, asking questions etc/ Dice being fluffy to start – Then Cass slips into it seems only question asking/answering mechanics mode, which can be done regardless of alignment"

 

It doesn't state what is wolfy exactly, but is says why they aren't cleared in her mind. As seer maybe self pres as well, I don't know and I myself don't see them scummy.

 

 

think what u underlined is what shes talking about and it IS true. I MAJORLY suck at reading cass in games but I have the advantage here   i KNOW shes town this time!\

 

 

 

 

 

@Tress, I really need your help here. My gut tells me to trust your instincts and experience right now.

 

Eldrick is screaming wolf at me, but Ed is also. I don't see Cass-Dice, but I don't know them well like you do.

Cass is coming across as very town. The only thing about her play that worries me is the fact that she was able to give a detailed explanation of why mafia would have considered Redd to be seer over anyone who gave a clear N0 peek.

 

Cass has been known to fool me, so I don't trust my town read on her too much.

 

Dice, however, is someone I have a long history of gut reading correctly when he's town, when a lot of other people struggle with it. There have been times I missed him as mafia, but those games were ones where I had a milder town read on him and got distracted looking elsewhere.

 

This game I haven't gotten that strong gut town read from him, and it worries me. I don't expect everyone else to go with it, but I can't shake it.

 

I'm willing to switch if necessary, there are 2 mafia alive and I have at least a couple of people I am not comfortable with as town.

 

I have also been advised about Cass' ability to ask questions and seem present and Dice's ability to give detailed reads and I haven't seen any of that from that slot. But they still haven't read wolfy to me.

 

I'm stuck between Ed and Eldrick, honestly. What are your thoughts for those two.

 

Also what about Darthe? Where did he run off to?

 

 

so did cory say that im good at giving detailed reads? cause if so hes probably pulling ure leg lol. hes had enuff experience of my vague gut reads to know :D

 

 

@Tigs - in this type of setup the seer starts the game with the name of one confirmed vanilla townie in their role PM, known as a N0 peek - it's randomized by the mod.

 

That's why so many of us were hard clearing someone as town D1, to lay down cover for the actual seer to be able to reveal their results.

Okay I get that, spades said she was Hallia's N1 so where does Dice/Cass fall into scum role?

 

She said "Early on good feels, asking questions etc/ Dice being fluffy to start – Then Cass slips into it seems only question asking/answering mechanics mode, which can be done regardless of alignment"

 

It doesn't state what is wolfy exactly, but is says why they aren't cleared in her mind. As seer maybe self pres as well, I don't know and I myself don't see them scummy.

 

[Eldrick4221]

Cmon spades. You wanna lynch me too, right?

[Eldrick4221]

Gonna laugh when it really is darthe.

[LedZepMan]

Wow. I come home after paying my bills and, well, just wow.

 

So, i haven't paid too much attention unfortunately, as life and stuff happens, but I just wanna say thanks for getting my back while I was away. You have convinced me as to the townie within.

 

Ed is never this quiet in a game. It may be work, but my gut is telling me he is scum. The same for Darthe. Never seen him this subdued.

 

Now, to tie it up or to hammer on Cass.

 

Hmmmm

[Eldrick4221]

Darthe/ed maybe?

[Eldrick4221]

Wow. I come home after paying my bills and, well, just wow.

 

So, i haven't paid too much attention unfortunately, as life and stuff happens, but I just wanna say thanks for getting my back while I was away. You have convinced me as to the townie within.

 

Ed is never this quiet in a game. It may be work, but my gut is telling me he is scum. The same for Darthe. Never seen him this subdued.

 

Now, to tie it up or to hammer on Cass.

 

Hmmmm

Creepy ninja post..

[dicetosser1]

Wow. I come home after paying my bills and, well, just wow.

 

So, i haven't paid too much attention unfortunately, as life and stuff happens, but I just wanna say thanks for getting my back while I was away. You have convinced me as to the townie within.

 

Ed is never this quiet in a game. It may be work, but my gut is telling me he is scum. The same for Darthe. Never seen him this subdued.

 

Now, to tie it up or to hammer on Cass.

 

Hmmmm

 

And WHY would you hammer me and cass?

[LedZepMan]

Holy crap. That changed a lot in the ten minutes it took me to type that

[Spadeszee]

Cmon spades. You wanna lynch me too, right?

Best idea you've had all night.

 

[v] Eldrick4221 [/v]

 

I was feeling strong about this last night and I feel comfortable with this still.

[Songstress]

 

 

@Tress, I really need your help here. My gut tells me to trust your instincts and experience right now.

 

Eldrick is screaming wolf at me, but Ed is also. I don't see Cass-Dice, but I don't know them well like you do.

Cass is coming across as very town. The only thing about her play that worries me is the fact that she was able to give a detailed explanation of why mafia would have considered Redd to be seer over anyone who gave a clear N0 peek.

 

Cass has been known to fool me, so I don't trust my town read on her too much.

 

Dice, however, is someone I have a long history of gut reading correctly when he's town, when a lot of other people struggle with it. There have been times I missed him as mafia, but those games were ones where I had a milder town read on him and got distracted looking elsewhere.

 

This game I haven't gotten that strong gut town read from him, and it worries me. I don't expect everyone else to go with it, but I can't shake it.

 

I'm willing to switch if necessary, there are 2 mafia alive and I have at least a couple of people I am not comfortable with as town.

I have also been advised about Cass' ability to ask questions and seem present and Dice's ability to give detailed reads and I haven't seen any of that from that slot. But they still haven't read wolfy to me.

 

I'm stuck between Ed and Eldrick, honestly. What are your thoughts for those two.

 

Also what about Darthe? Where did he run off to?

I'm worried about Ed's wandering off without giving legit reads. I haven't played with him enough to get a feel for whether he'd do this as town. I do know he's been running a game offsite and apparently prioritizing other things, and the lack of effort bugs me.

 

Eldrick always, always makes me think he's scum because he posts every thought that crosses his mind in the thread with no filter and many of these thoughts are things that make me . See our D1 back and forth on this topic. I don't feel confident reading him either way.

 

Darthe, eh. He will probably turn up over the weekend and have forgotten about the game or something. lol

[Eldrick4221]

 

Cmon spades. You wanna lynch me too, right?

Best idea you've had all night.

 

[v] Eldrick4221 [/v]

 

I was feeling strong about this last night and I feel comfortable with this still.

Called it.

[LedZepMan]

An idle thought. Don't know who to vote for.

 

Let it go to random again and hope to get lucky or hammer someone. Fifty fifty, best odds in the house.

[Shad_]

 

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Eldrick (3) - Adella, Dice/Cass, Spades

 

LZM (1) - Shanti

 

Dice/Cass (2) - Hallia, Tress

 

Darthe (1) - Eldrick

 

Not Voting: Darthe, LedZepMan, ed2funy, Tigraine

 

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

[dicetosser1]

 

 

Cmon spades. You wanna lynch me too, right?

Best idea you've had all night.

 

[v] Eldrick4221 [/v]

 

I was feeling strong about this last night and I feel comfortable with this still.

Called it.

 

 

deserve it.

[Spadeszee]

 

 

Cmon spades. You wanna lynch me too, right?

Best idea you've had all night.

 

[v] Eldrick4221 [/v]

 

I was feeling strong about this last night and I feel comfortable with this still.

Called it.

 

I've been having a toss up between you and Ed all night, glad you've been reading my posts.

[Tigraine]

Mr mod sir can we get a VC?

[dicetosser1]

An idle thought. Don't know who to vote for.

 

Let it go to random again and hope to get lucky or hammer someone. Fifty fifty, best odds in the house.

 

how about you dont? how about you actually give some thoughts and commit to something.

[Tigraine]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Eldrick (3) - Adella, Dice/Cass, Spades

 

LZM (1) - Shanti

 

Dice/Cass (2) - Hallia, Tress

 

Darthe (1) - Eldrick

 

Not Voting: Darthe, LedZepMan, ed2funy, Tigraine

 

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

 

Sorry missed that. Hate mobile

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

Cmon spades. You wanna lynch me too, right?

Best idea you've had all night.

 

[v] Eldrick4221 [/v]

 

I was feeling strong about this last night and I feel comfortable with this still.

Called it.

deserve it.

I really don't get why you are coming down so hard on me, though.

[Tigraine]

An idle thought. Don't know who to vote for.

 

Let it go to random again and hope to get lucky or hammer someone. Fifty fifty, best odds in the house.

Big change from D1

[LedZepMan]

I'll commit when I find what I want to commit to. I don't know your alignment. And I don't need to give my thoughts to you. You could be scum.

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Eldrick (3) - Adella, Dice/Cass, Spades

 

LZM (1) - Shanti

 

Dice/Cass (2) - Hallia, Tress

 

Darthe (1) - Eldrick

 

Not Voting: Darthe, LedZepMan, ed2funy, Tigraine

 

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

[Tigraine]

Now I'm torn. Eld has been my top scum read but not following blindly has me rethinking.