[Basic C9++] Murder Mystery Mafia D5

[DPR]

Can you bare to be a day behind me on the lynch?

 

 

There's my scum Darthe. 

 

 

He's the Coroner.

 

[Darthe]

I have absolutely no idea where to vote right now. Both Darthe and Niniel are near the bottom of my list, and both seem opposed to each other - and I'm pretty sure have been most of the game? Darthe's entire wagon is more or less question marks for me, and Niniel's starts that way.

 

Is there any way I can just lynch them both?

 

Sure, youve just got to pick an order

[Cory Caboose]

 

I would like to have a better read on Tress right now than I do

 

Gonna read her ISO

Shes villa.

 

You know you're not actually voting nin, yeah?

 

 

Yes I am

[Darthe]

 

Can you bare to be a day behind me on the lynch?

 

There's my scum Darthe.

 

 

He's the Coroner.

I'll bite, wutido?

[Darthe]

Crap I keep forgetting you are a hydra

[Cory Caboose]

 

I would like to have a better read on Tress right now than I do

 

Gonna read her ISO

Shes villa.

 

You know you're not actually voting nin, yeah?

 

 

You might be right on Tress, still reading

 

Drop some more hot truths for me?

[Cory Caboose]

I am A W A K E N I N G

[Shad_]

#BringBackDMTurbos

always /in for turbos

[seph]

#lost how much time is left?

[Shad_]

2 and a half + I think

[Darthe]

 

 

I would like to have a better read on Tress right now than I do

 

Gonna read her ISO

Shes villa.

 

You know you're not actually voting nin, yeah?

You might be right on Tress, still reading

 

Drop some more hot truths for me?

Ok, here's one. Tigraine is prpb town. Been a while since I played with em so meta isnt what im using, I just think we've seen a lot of development and comfortability in providing reads for someone whos been gone a while.

[seph]

Votes before Kronos came in were pretty stagnant.

I really think Kronos might be a villager

 

I think niniel is a wolf, Ed has had multiple spurts where I thought he was a villager so I pretty much would be voting niniel over him.

 

Cory why is niniel a wolf to you? You hadn't talked much about her.

 

I saw your scum team and I'm having a hard time believing cloves is mafia atm. He has been villagery af.

[Shad_]

 

too distracted to pull it right now but Clov literally asked 1) thoughts on seph 2) who would you shoot and Tig answered in that order. Looked weird out of context because she didn't draw a line between A and B

 

Yeah, we know - Tigraine and I both already pointed that out

 

I have this problem where I just read two or three random posts on a page and respond to them as if I know what's going on.

[Darthe]

I think my other point against wbk was dumb and half cocked. His vote should be more neutral, the timings way off for it to be sneaky or disingenuous.

[seph]

Hey Darth

What do you think about me/tigranes read on me?

[Cory Caboose]

Tress

 

Just seems very natural. Her town game is very much [her as a person], she likes to explain her thoughts in narratives & stories, she speaks very naturally & gracefully, she doesn't fabricate information if people ask her about something she's not sure about. Her reads feel legitimately but look at the self-dialogue in:

 

 

 

OK, so.  Summary of thoughts as of right now.

 

2. Darthe - At least 75% of the time I want to lynch Darthe regardless.  It might not be a bad move. :unsure: OK, I kind of like some of his posts.  Let's call it "not today".

 

3. Shadory (cory caboose & Shad_) - I feel pretty good about these two and expect to firm that up within the next day phase or so.  

 

4. SoJames (Sooh & E James Todd) - Have we scared off James?     Engagement is good, seems to be pursuing leads aggressively. Gut feeling is probably town, she has fooled me before but I'm not too worried about her just now.

 

5. ed2funy - mehhhhh. Not sure I can read him.  Too much drunk posting.  He's probably OK.

 

6. Tigraine (Hallia) - Zero posts.  Waiting for Godot.

 

7. seph - Some of the things he's said realllllly remind me of his approach in Fight Club.  I was iffy on him at the time I noticed them in Fight Club, but he ended up as town. So, thinking he might be town here? 

 

8. Niniel - Potentially willing to vote here.  Her catchup notes felt really... superficial?  Cautious? 

 

9. DPR (DreadPirateRoberts) - I haven't seen anything from him that worries me yet, and I have seen at least one post that struck me as being exactly what I'd expect him to say as town.  So, slight town lean although I wouldn't trust the pirate as far as I can throw him.

 

10. Kronos the Wolfeh (WolfbrotherKronos) - Willing to vote.  Whoever mentioned he really hates being mafia, that is also what I recall.  I would have expected him to pop in to at least give us a heads up if he was going to be absent.  He was a lot more active in our Old West Mischief game, even early on.

 

11. Clov (Clovdyx) - I wouldn't normally feel comfortable town reading him D1 but I don't know that he'd bother doing what he's been doing as mafia.  Let's call it cautiously optimistic.

 

12. Killashandra - I want to give her time to settle in and learn the game and see where it goes.  Nothing has struck me as off just yet, which is a good sign.

 

13. manbat - Monstr is one of those people that I feel like I ought to be able to read better, but I never feel quite confident that I can.  Gun to head I'd say leaning town, but very unsure.  I would trust Town!Cory's read on him 95%.

 

 

Not willing to lynch atm:  SoJames, Shadory, Clov... possibly Ed, Darthe, DPR, Seph.  Most willing to lynch Kronos or Niniel today.

I think she's a villager outright but [if nothing else] I feel it'll become more apparent / obvious as the game goes on.

[seph]

your entire reads list is predicated on my alignment it seems so

let's hear it

Lol I thought this last game.... sorry cuth:(

[Darthe]

Hey Darth

What do you think about me/tigranes read on me?

Im fine with you, id say slight town. What did tograines say?

[Cory Caboose]

 

 

 

I would like to have a better read on Tress right now than I do

 

Gonna read her ISO

Shes villa.

 

You know you're not actually voting nin, yeah?

 

You might be right on Tress, still reading

 

Drop some more hot truths for me?

 

Ok, here's one. Tigraine is prpb town. Been a while since I played with em so meta isnt what im using, I just think we've seen a lot of development and comfortability in providing reads for someone whos been gone a while.

 

Darthe if you're a villager there's probably a deep wolf faffing about so we can't mess around much

 

Might be that pesky Clovdyx

 

Pesky pesky

[seph]

 

Hey Darth

What do you think about me/tigranes read on me?

Im fine with you, id say slight town. What did tograines say?

I'll go find it... its a few pages back

[Cory Caboose]

seph do you have a cement read on me yet?

[Darthe]

 

 

 

 

I would like to have a better read on Tress right now than I do

 

Gonna read her ISO

Shes villa.

 

You know you're not actually voting nin, yeah?

You might be right on Tress, still reading

 

Drop some more hot truths for me?

Ok, here's one. Tigraine is prpb town. Been a while since I played with em so meta isnt what im using, I just think we've seen a lot of development and comfortability in providing reads for someone whos been gone a while.

Darthe if you're a villager there's probably a deep wolf faffing about so we can't mess around much

 

Might be that pesky Clovdyx

 

Pesky pesky

Im aware

[Cory Caboose]

but will you

 

stay woke?

[seph]

Sorry guys, been dealing with 2 sick kids.

Anyway, my apologies to Sooh for my previous post, after reading again I didn't see what had pinged on me last night.

I'm not comfortable with the lunch on Kronos, not because I necessarily feel he is town but because I'm very suspicious of Manbat, early on he called out players about his playing style, Shad in particular about being able to tell if he's scum. With my town read on Shad, it feels like an attempt to pull in support from someone. Could be wrong but it's my take.

Dont feel too swell on Seph, as I stated before he was in the back and forth banter and it seemed to me like a pretty strong attempt at pushing suspicion to others.

My read on Clov is actually scum too and it's pretty much for the same reasons. Not much to build a case on for any of the three but it is still day 1. I think it would be a little freckles for all of them to jump on a train early on and stay there but I would still guess that two of them are scum.

With all I've had from Ed being majority drunk posting it's been pretty difficult to pinpoint my feelings there. Kind of strange though, as I remember him being more active and having more input.

My feelings on DPR are still the same. He always had more input than we've gotten here but his input is usually helpful to a degree, scum or not.

Killasandra still doesn't sit right with me but it could just be where she is new and needs to learn the ropes.

Kronos stated that he felt a townie vibe from Shad that was backed up by his partner being Cory and I agree with that. That's what I get off of both of them.

Song isn't really pinging for me so I don't really know which side to lean with her.

niniel hasn't shown me much either way.

 

 

hello tigraine i am monstrmanbat

what do you think of seph/shad/manbat/sooh in regards to their alignments (v/w)?

I honestly can't say more that I think 2 of the 4 are scum. As to which two.....I have no idea. I think it's a good strategy to back and forth with a couple you know are town to later refer to as "this looks suspicious"

Tigrane. What do you think of me shad sooh and manbat. You didn't really go into any detail

See above. I can't pinpoint which, but my best guess is that two are scum.

villagy tho i have made this exact observation in threads before

how experienced of a player are you?

I played for a couple years. Not sure on the amount of games but I should be able to find out with that awesome chart of Shad's. Has been a while though. I feel rusty.

  

 

 

Sorry guys, been dealing with 2 sick kids.

Anyway, my apologies to Sooh for my previous post, after reading again I didn't see what had pinged on me last night.

I'm not comfortable with the lunch on Kronos, not because I necessarily feel he is town but because I'm very suspicious of Manbat, early on he called out players about his playing style, Shad in particular about being able to tell if he's scum. With my town read on Shad, it feels like an attempt to pull in support from someone. Could be wrong but it's my take.

Dont feel too swell on Seph, as I stated before he was in the back and forth banter and it seemed to me like a pretty strong attempt at pushing suspicion to others.

My read on Clov is actually scum too and it's pretty much for the same reasons. Not much to build a case on for any of the three but it is still day 1. I think it would be a little freckles for all of them to jump on a train early on and stay there but I would still guess that two of them are scum.

With all I've had from Ed being majority drunk posting it's been pretty difficult to pinpoint my feelings there. Kind of strange though, as I remember him being more active and having more input.

My feelings on DPR are still the same. He always had more input than we've gotten here but his input is usually helpful to a degree, scum or not.

Killasandra still doesn't sit right with me but it could just be where she is new and needs to learn the ropes.

Kronos stated that he felt a townie vibe from Shad that was backed up by his partner being Cory and I agree with that. That's what I get off of both of them.

Song isn't really pinging for me so I don't really know which side to lean with her.

niniel hasn't shown me much either way.

 

1) Who do you feel Seph was putting suspicion on?

1B) Can you talk about why you think that makes him mafia?

 

2) If you had to kill somebody right now, who do you shoot?

I noticed the italicized "mafia," are they not referred to as scum anymore?

 

 

[v]Hallia[/v]

she is teh scum!

Kinda looks good on dpr imo

Shoddy intro

  

I ate the rest of my kid's gummy bears because he was bad.

 

As much as this made me laugh, I still don't feel good about you guys :(

 

inb4 wolves haven't posted yet

Darthe's intro seemed less... intense(?) than he usually is. Hard to put my finger on exactly what to say here but like usually I get a "My name is Darthe and this is how I'm playing suck it nerds" vibe but here feels more like "my name is Darthe and here's some reads."

I actually disagree and most of your posys read oddly to me.

I actually liked his post right after he did his I do and don't like there intros.

  

also i see you shad

i will make proper reads of you slot accordingly

aorn I have you polarized to cory villa shad wolf but we'll see as the game progresses

 

Maybe I just got confused here, but it kinda contradicts your op. Regardless I think I'm confused actually, as I know most of this is joking, I just dislike your banter for some reason.

[V]manbat [/v]

 

there is a 90% chance i will be useless reading cory this game but it's okay cause I'm just gonna hope he's a villager and nail his scumbros if he's not

also hi everybody else

  

This is the intro post I found pretty Damm odd

 

Super stressed but nothing that won't be finished eventually so can't really complain. Things are going pretty well

You?

I personally think that stress is a townie look on you, apparently.

this is the Darth post I liked, wasn't sure I had it in here.

I also kind of like clov, but I usually tend to try way to hard to read him and screw it up.

Ps. Soohza I hope you are town :)

  

 

also that cory post is because Cory and I have a history of doing that ~every game

nothing is odd about anything you have posted that is just your brain incorrectly attributing wolfiness to my posts because this is a game of perception

or you are a wolf

we'll see as the game goes on

That makes sense, FYI I really am starting to hate these same op people do every game lol.

I don't think anything you did was really scummy, more of I just had a bad feeling about your posts.

  

 

what makes you think Clov ia villagery, seph?

I'm not sure I agree given the gamestate

I just liked his vote, and the timing of it.

This back and forth votng Manbat the unvoting and pointing fingers every which way. Starting suspicion on someone then backing off only to start it elsewhere. Also the "I like his vote" comment. I didn't like it. Didn't like the explanation.

If I had to shoot one person right now it would probably be Manbat. He pinged first and he pinged hardest (giggity)

Here darthe

[Darthe]

Lol, do you think that anyone in this game is gonna stay town in my mind all game?