[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[Darthe]

Id like to say its sad to see you fall below poop jokes, but if we're being honest you were never above them.

[BFG]

 

 

 

@DPR most mods would punish town over mafia for a no lynch, but I doubt Chris would do either. Sooh is almost always town through gameplay and was the only kill last night. If we have 2 kills tonight then it may be worth considering, but I still have her as town almost always

 

 

Not trying to be confrontational here, but none of that is actually true.

 

Mafia typically has a NK, so punishing the town for a No Lynch makes no sense whatsoever. Game balance demands that the burden of action be placed on the scum team - it also keeps them from lurking.

 

Why would you doubt that the mod would try something new. You need to rent Pleasantville and watch it over and over and over. It's not really a good movie, but it makes a point... 

 

Please stop with the "Sooh is almost always town" stuff. Seriously. Why bother playing this game if everyone plays the same way every game? It's why clearing townies is such a backwards way of problem solving. One day Sooh is going to zig when you were sure she was going to zag.

 

Agree to disagree on the first. Standard on Dm when I started playing was hammer games where a no lynch resulted in a random janitored kill, that's basically anti-town, especially early game.

 

And no, bluntly. My read on Sooh this game has little to do with meta or range (game isn't active enough to force anyone out of scum ranges) and more to do with the fact that the reads she was making and when she was making them made a lot of sense. She was grounded, level headed and townie. I can go into a meta read if you want though :) nor am I going to change the way I play because you don't like it

 

 

For the sake of posterity, random janitor kills are murder on game balance. 

 

For the rest, what if I put this nice, crisp fiver on the table, eh? Eh?

 

For the sake of posterity I have never modded a game with random janitor kills :p

 

For the rest /shrug

[DPR]

[V] dpr [/v]

[V] darthe [/v]

 

If you think im a wolf then match me DPR

 

You've been my top vote for 2 out of 2 days. No one is confused about where I stand on you.

 

The group will decide who faces off. 

[DPR]

Id like to say its sad to see you fall below poop jokes, but if we're being honest you were never above them.

 

But it's so true.

[BFG]

 

 

Wifi is sick

*hugs

 

But that has no bearing on your alignment in the game and I don't feel like I have anything to read you off

 

 

OMG. You're a grammar teacher, aren't you.

 

No :( my parents always told me that they'd disown me if I became a teacher

[DPR]

 

For the sake of posterity I have never modded a game with random janitor kills :p

 

For the rest /shrug

 

 

*slowly replaces the fiver with a 10 spot and lifts eyebrows*

[Darthe]

 

[V] dpr [/v]

[V] darthe [/v]

 

If you think im a wolf then match me DPR

You've been my top vote for 2 out of 2 days. No one is confused about where I stand on you.

 

The group will decide who faces off.

[DPR]

 

 

 

Wifi is sick

*hugs

 

But that has no bearing on your alignment in the game and I don't feel like I have anything to read you off

 

 

OMG. You're a grammar teacher, aren't you.

 

No :( my parents always told me that they'd disown me if I became a teacher

 

 

Why? 

[seph]

 

Let's think twice about putting Cuth into the ring tonight. Chances are high that either he or I was investigated last night.

Chances are slightly lower that Darthe was, but I feel like a fight between him and Seph will be productive and informative.

Picture a wolf where DPR is a wolf and what does this post do for you? For me it's heavy posturing.

Idk about that, but the post in general bothers me. The big thing about the fight was indeed the no lynch mod announcement. I wish I wish people would have voted (me included) because at the time I didn't know about the vote counts, and I'm sure no one else did. But I think it would have been a informative night, compared to now where so much more strategy will be in place.

 

 

@darthe how come you didn't give us any takes on start d2? You came in defended you self with a few posts and left.

[Darthe]

I got busy with rl man

[Darthe]

Did I defend myself at the start of D2??

[seph]

@cuth why do you want me to respond to DPR about?

[seph]

Did I defend myself at the start of D2??

Unless I am misremembering. I'm a go check

[DPR]

 

 

Let's think twice about putting Cuth into the ring tonight. Chances are high that either he or I was investigated last night.

Chances are slightly lower that Darthe was, but I feel like a fight between him and Seph will be productive and informative.

Picture a wolf where DPR is a wolf and what does this post do for you? For me it's heavy posturing.

Idk about that, but the post in general bothers me. The big thing about the fight was indeed the no lynch mod announcement. I wish I wish people would have voted (me included) because at the time I didn't know about the vote counts, and I'm sure no one else did. But I think it would have been a informative night, compared to now where so much more strategy will be in place.

 

 

@darthe how come you didn't give us any takes on start d2? You came in defended you self with a few posts and left.

 

 

 

Oh, look, it's Seph back from his movie and nap.

 

I am Jack's utter lack of surprise.

[seph]

The push against me doesn't have merit. I don't see points being made, just quoting a post of mine and going "if darthe is a wolf heres what he is doing".

  

 

 

The push against me doesn't have merit. I don't see points being made, just quoting a post of mine and going "if darthe is a wolf heres what he is doing".

Of course it has merit. Why don't you go ahead and explain your vote on me and I'll point to the merits you're looking for.

My vote on you? Early it was a joke vote, later it was self pres. Who else was I gonna switch to when I returned DPR?

It was night 1, and it wasn't as bad as I thought, but still dissapointed in this was all you gave.

You have been pretty nonexistent, and in 1 post gave more information than all your others combined.

[Darthe]

I.. Agree?

[seph]

 

 

 

Let's think twice about putting Cuth into the ring tonight. Chances are high that either he or I was investigated last night.

Chances are slightly lower that Darthe was, but I feel like a fight between him and Seph will be productive and informative.

 

Picture a wolf where DPR is a wolf and what does this post do for you? For me it's heavy posturing.

Idk about that, but the post in general bothers me. The big thing about the fight was indeed the no lynch mod announcement. I wish I wish people would have voted (me included) because at the time I didn't know about the vote counts, and I'm sure no one else did. But I think it would have been a informative night, compared to now where so much more strategy will be in place.

@darthe how come you didn't give us any takes on start d2? You came in defended you self with a few posts and left.

 

 

Oh, look, it's Seph back from his movie and nap.

 

I am Jack's utter lack of surprise.

Do you try to be annoying as shit?

I just got back from my movie and I checked on the thread, is there any reason to try and start crap??

I enjoy checking the thread as often as I can.

 

Also of you all didn't know as this is important info. Sooh was most likely town, just ask dpr...

[BFG]

 

For the sake of posterity I have never modded a game with random janitor kills :p

 

For the rest /shrug

 

*slowly replaces the fiver with a 10 spot and lifts eyebrows*

 

I have about 80 Brazilian rial, 18p and a voucher for the cinema

[seph]

I.. Agree?

I'm basically saying your play has been bad/nonexistent until this page and need you to keep this intensity so I can actually formulate a read on you. Plz :)

[DPR]

 

 

 

 

Let's think twice about putting Cuth into the ring tonight. Chances are high that either he or I was investigated last night.

Chances are slightly lower that Darthe was, but I feel like a fight between him and Seph will be productive and informative.

Picture a wolf where DPR is a wolf and what does this post do for you? For me it's heavy posturing.

Idk about that, but the post in general bothers me. The big thing about the fight was indeed the no lynch mod announcement. I wish I wish people would have voted (me included) because at the time I didn't know about the vote counts, and I'm sure no one else did. But I think it would have been a informative night, compared to now where so much more strategy will be in place.

@darthe how come you didn't give us any takes on start d2? You came in defended you self with a few posts and left.

 

 

Oh, look, it's Seph back from his movie and nap.

 

I am Jack's utter lack of surprise.

Do you try to be annoying as shit?

I just got back from my movie and I checked on the thread, is there any reason to try and start crap??

I enjoy checking the thread as often as I can.

 

Also of you all didn't know as this is important info. Sooh was most likely town, just ask dpr...

 

 

 

So sensitive. 

[Songstress]

Do you try to be annoying as shit?

 

Where do you think Darthe learned it from?

 

 

 

[BFG]

 

 

 

 

Wifi is sick

*hugs

 

But that has no bearing on your alignment in the game and I don't feel like I have anything to read you off

 

 

OMG. You're a grammar teacher, aren't you.

 

No :( my parents always told me that they'd disown me if I became a teacher

 

 

Why?

 

Dad's a teacher /shrug

[Darthe]

 

I.. Agree?

I'm basically saying your play has been bad/nonexistent until this page and need you to keep this intensity so I can actually formulate a read on you. Plz :)

Words hurt. I pretty much said what I wanted to, but im gonna be around now. My busy time is passed.

[BFG]

Im back and just finished a read up.

 

Heres everything I see:

 

Tress and seph both look townie to me. Yesterday Tress drew votes for basically nothing and today is the same with seph, its Cuth making a statement and half the thread following because he seems more involved. In particular, I thought seph showed up hard over the last couple of pages though it would have been good to see him respond more to DPR.

 

Which brings me to DPR. He is the bottom of my list rn, reason being that he yesterday mirrored cuth on me, and has continued to do so, along with a few wolfy posts and his reaction to my early joke vote.

 

Cuth himself, ive still got no idea where the red is coming from. We're he not so earnest about it and still spending time in other things id be very sus of him. Its a townie tunnel imo.

 

Rn, im cool with duking it out. I dont think that I want to with seph though. Id rather DPR.

 

 

Oh, and for reads in general,

 

 

Seph - whole package this game

Dice - the aussie is aggressive in the right way and is being weird in the right way, not quiet.

Bfg - strong presence, good questions, no pushiness that ive seen.

Marsh - your soul lays itself bare to me bruh, sorry. On the real though, his recent questions about votes and confusion should be telling.

Ed - I hesitate to put this above cuth, he could prob be lower, bit I think the sooh kill spews him and I dont have much else on him.

Cuth - tinfoil drops him, but he is playing strong.

Tress- dont really have much ti say here, she has been aight, but shouldnt have gained the traction she did yesterday imo.

Crush - whered the bacon king even go? I dont like him being quiet like this

Hally - same as above, she hasnt done anything.

Wifi - hasnt sussed me this game. Thats a big deal, because she does every other game and she hasnt been absent here.

Dpr - dudes a wolf, and there are a bunch of reasons, part mentioned above, but also I'll grab a quote above and mention that the no lynch swap once we found out we all could was telling. Cuth was never gonna die there.

Do you have more on DPR?

[seph]

I get annoyed easily just ask darthe...

 

Dpr why do you think me and darthe would provide useful info in a fight?