[Basic]What's the theme? - ad lib mafia

[dicetosser1]

 

 

wifi,

 

why do you think hallia is a wolf, because up until that list I don't thnk you ever mentioned her except for quoting one of her posts asking 'what it means'?

 

This is a pretty good point, actually.  I don't recall seeing an answer as I caught up - did you get one?

 

 

 

 

So are you thinking it's a scum slip then, Bop?

 

I know you didn't ask me, but I'm gonna say I think it might be (subconsciously).  I've seen it happen many times before, on multiple sites.  Usually comes from newer players who don't re-read their posts before clicking the button.

 

I could switch to Wifi.

 

 

I AM TOWN.  I am not going to use RL as an excuse to cover up my accidents anymore.  If you want a mislynch right out the bat thats your problem.  I will say that I can be a good member of this town if given a chance.  Yes, I screwed up my math, but that was it.  I did NOT make a subconscious slip or whatever you are calling it.  I know there is something else you want an answer for but it will have to wait till night time for me to answer it.  

 

 

and theres the response I expected. Its totally in keeping with my understanding of wifi. 

 

 

So Dice and Verb are Town reads for being nice?

 

 

Are you saying im not nice???

 

 

cause i understand you thinking that about Verb.....

[Wildfire Sedai]

I suppose i should have had more mentors going on in the games....idk......Its so hard for me to keep up.  I tried keeping notes...took too long....

 

as for bop...no i do not.  I don't care that he pointed out the error.  I cared about the WAY he pointed out the error.  Made it like  huge and everything.  I don't see it as picking on me so much as pushing me and he has a right to do that.  However, I AM TOWN.

[MrsClov]

I'm sorry, Wildfire, but I'm not following how you got to your conclusion. I'm not disagreeing with them being nice or the read. I just don't follow the logic. I feel like for the most part, everyone is being pretty nice and respectable, so by the logic of Verb and Dice are town because they're nice, shouldn't everyone be town? 

[bopolis]

I get that it could be a mistake but i'm still having trouble with it.

 

Wifi knows exactly how many games she has played(this is her 14th according to her sig and the database, link to it is in a thread on the front page of the mafia section of the forum). However screwed up remembering that she has scummed twice and not three times. For me I would think that the village number would be harder to remember than the scum one since if you are indeed a villager here it would only be two. 

 

Also WRT the other time you subbed (for a princessbflea you mentioned), i looked through the database and it says that was the spirited away game and you were a villa.

 

I would be fine if you forgot how many total games you played in,

 

I would be fine if you forgot how many times you've been a villa.

 

But to be mafia only twice and get that wrong seems a bit weird to me,

 

but let's say it was a mistake and put it to the side.

 

 

I have issues with several of your reads. The one i have most issue with is the hallia one. Sure, you don't have to say everytime you change your mind in  the thread, but when you don't mention someone and then suddenly they are on the bottom of your list, especially at a time when alot of people are pushing or sussing her, it looks like sheeping and is a bit awkward.

 

 

I think the villa reads for people being nice look weird, but i get that more because I can understand wanting to villa read people that you like.

 

I don't like the darthe read because sure he's lying but it's been talked about that doesn't mean he's always a wolf and the fact that you are on him because solely you don't think he's watcher doesn't follow for me. 

[Lenlo]

Ive been nice! Not fair Wifi! :(

[Wildfire Sedai]

I'm sorry, Wildfire, but I'm not following how you got to your conclusion. I'm not disagreeing with them being nice or the read. I just don't follow the logic. I feel like for the most part, everyone is being pretty nice and respectable, so by the logic of Verb and Dice are town because they're nice, shouldn't everyone be town? 

 

Basically I read you town/scum off of your content in the game, then how many posts you make, then if you are nice or not or a combo thereof. 

 

 

I get that it could be a mistake but i'm still having trouble with it.

 

Wifi knows exactly how many games she has played(this is her 14th according to her sig and the database, link to it is in a thread on the front page of the mafia section of the forum). However screwed up remembering that she has scummed twice and not three times. For me I would think that the village number would be harder to remember than the scum one since if you are indeed a villager here it would only be two. 

 

Also WRT the other time you subbed (for a princessbflea you mentioned), i looked through the database and it says that was the spirited away game and you were a villa.

 

I would be fine if you forgot how many total games you played in,

 

I would be fine if you forgot how many times you've been a villa.

 

But to be mafia only twice and get that wrong seems a bit weird to me,

 

but let's say it was a mistake and put it to the side.

 

 

I have issues with several of your reads. The one i have most issue with is the hallia one. Sure, you don't have to say everytime you change your mind in  the thread, but when you don't mention someone and then suddenly they are on the bottom of your list, especially at a time when alot of people are pushing or sussing her, it looks like sheeping and is a bit awkward.

 

 

I think the villa reads for people being nice look weird, but i get that more because I can understand wanting to villa read people that you like.

 

I don't like the darthe read because sure he's lying but it's been talked about that doesn't mean he's always a wolf and the fact that you are on him because solely you don't think he's watcher doesn't follow for me. 

 

You all wanted reasonings for my reads.  It's d1   I don't usually have early reads on anyone during d1 tbh.  when I am forced to make a reads list it usually reads: questioned or didn't question all the way down the list and I would get in trouble for that.  So can't win for trying.  IF stuff happens that involves me and other people then I can get a good reads list going.  However, if its just a few people talking and I can't think of any questions to ask or they aren't answered then I can't get a read on them.

[dicetosser1]

Ive been nice! 

 

As zanders sub I feel i need to point out that Zander would disagree with this :D:D:D:D

[Wildfire Sedai]

Ive been nice! Not fair Wifi! :(

 

yes you have.  and you are probably town cause there are 9 townies plus me but its only d1 so you have to be patient

[Wildfire Sedai]

*9 other townies 

[Hallia]

Could not get on last night due to that error thing.  I'm even more behind -.- It appears to be working at least, now.

[Hallia]

Self pres ofc, but also, you're scum reading me because I defended Darthe? Wha?

 

 

 

Vote: Wifi

[Wildfire Sedai]

[v] hallia [/v]   

[Wildfire Sedai]

just for the record....I was scum reading you hallia but not voting you until you voted me.  I was going to leave it to our peers as we were even and it would have gone to rand.

[Wildfire Sedai]

I guess it is still even now.

[Hallia]

So...what exactly are you scumreading me for, besides defending Darthe?

[Verbal32]

 

 

 

What is the case on Wilfire?

Someone can correct me on this if I'm wrong, but Bop noticed that she said this was her 14th game and she played as scum 3 times. He checked her sig and showed only 2 scum games listed, so he asked if this was her 3rd scum game. She responded by putting him in her null to scum pile. I believe some of the others are for posts that were not great as well. 

 

So they think they caught a slip? Ok.

 

Yup. 

 

I'd rather lynch Hallia, but I'm not opposed to a Wildfire lynch either. I haven't really been able to connect with her line of thought. 

 

 

You keep saying this, and I keep frowning each time.  I can't put my finger on it yet, but I'm noting it for future reference.

 

 

 

 

So Dice and Verb are Town reads for being nice?

 

I can dig it!

[Verbal32]

So...what exactly are you scumreading me for, besides defending Darthe?

 

Why are you only aiming at the 1 person who could be the lynch instead of you...........instead of asking the others on your train?

[MrsClov]

 

 

 

 

What is the case on Wilfire?

Someone can correct me on this if I'm wrong, but Bop noticed that she said this was her 14th game and she played as scum 3 times. He checked her sig and showed only 2 scum games listed, so he asked if this was her 3rd scum game. She responded by putting him in her null to scum pile. I believe some of the others are for posts that were not great as well. 

 

So they think they caught a slip? Ok.

 

Yup. 

 

I'd rather lynch Hallia, but I'm not opposed to a Wildfire lynch either. I haven't really been able to connect with her line of thought. 

 

 

You keep saying this, and I keep frowning each time.  I can't put my finger on it yet, but I'm noting it for future reference.

 

 

 

 

So Dice and Verb are Town reads for being nice?

 

I can dig it!

 

You won't find anything from it. I like to see how people got to their logic; I don't get her logic at all. The more she tries to explain it, the more her point gets muddled for me. 

[Verbal32]

I'll be watching out for it, so we'll see.  ;-)

[Verbal32]

I think I need to lynch Wifi now to clear up my thoughts on Hallia & MrsClov.  I am suss of Wifi anyway based on what bopolis noted, so.....

 

[v]Wifi[/v]

[Verbal32]

 

This is where I am right now, but some of it is just random feelings because I haven´t got time to look back. 

 

 

1. Andrej - never know with him but he looks good so far. It´s hard for me to read him since he often becomes the thread leader but I don´t see anything scummy so far. Good thoughts about Hallia and asking questions. 

2. MrsClov - is also asking a lot of questions, which I think is a good sign. But I can´t really remember what her own thoughts are. It doesn´t mean that they aren´t there, just that I don´t remember.

3. Darthe - null. His claim got the game going, which is good. Haven´t done much since. Voting Nolder, which I think is good. 

4. Bopolis - if Wifi is mafia then Bopolis is clearly town. 

5. Niniel - town

6. Verbal - don´t know. Haven´t written much? 

7. Wildfire - I think Bopolis find could be a slip and her answer wasn´t good. 

8. Dice Zander -  - ehm, no idea. Nothing that he has said have made me think anything about him. Well, I liked his posts to Nolder, I think. 

9. Eldrick - still think he is town. He seems sincere and open. 

10. Nolder - still don´t get a good feeling about him but I think the cases for Wifi and Hallia is stronger right now. 

11. Lenlo - I had a good feeling about him before but then I saw a post that I didn´t like. Will have to find it later. 

12. Ironeyes - like Verb. Haven´t been here much, has he?

13. Hallia - I agree with AJ about Hallia. 

 

 

As you see, it´s not much to add but this is my thoughts right now. I will re-read during the night and be more specific then. 

 

 

Andrej 131 MrsClov 94 Eldrick4221 88 Wildfire Sedai 50 bopolis 48 Nolder 40 Lenlo 37 Verbal32 35 Darthe 35 dicetosser1 25 Hallia 20 Ironeyes 15 Niniel 14 Sooh

[Hallia]

 

So...what exactly are you scumreading me for, besides defending Darthe?

 

Why are you only aiming at the 1 person who could be the lynch instead of you...........instead of asking the others on your train?

 

Because she was here, I'm trying to skim along, but would like to talk to people in real time - If anyone else is here though, I would hope they would speak up

[Verbal32]

@Tina

 

Lenlo has 2 more posts, but you are finding more?  I haven't been Spidey'ing the whole time, ya know.

 

Same with Nolder and Dice - both around my activity, but you have stuff about them to say (albeit brief).  Seems weird.

[Sooh]

Vote count:

 

Darthe (1): Eldrick

 

Wildfire (6): Lenlo, Bopolis, Ironeyes, Niniel, Hallia, Verbal

 

Hallia (5): Dice, MrsClov, AJ, Nolder, Wildfire

 

Not voting (1): Darthe,

 

 

 

EOD1 in: 

[Wildfire Sedai]

FUDGE IT:   I'm watcher....I know this looks bad...and I will probably die tonight anyways so it don't matter if I get lynched now...but dammit.....I hate getting mislynched all the time cause people don't understand me.