DEMONOLOGY - GAME THREAD

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Looking at Snow's ISO I see nothing obvious that indicates why/when he started scum reading Lenlo

 

There's just a one-liner that says Snow is putting Lenlo into his WTL

 

Are you more inclined to lynch Snow or Lenlo since you're amazing analysis?

[Shad_]

I wonder how many wolves are hiding behind the fact that villagers are hiding behind their role pms.

 

lulz

 

so much this

[Andrej]

 

Looking at Snow's ISO I see nothing obvious that indicates why/when he started scum reading Lenlo

 

There's just a one-liner that says Snow is putting Lenlo into his WTL

 

Are you more inclined to lynch Snow or Lenlo since you're amazing analysis?

 

I'm already voting Snow bud

 

You're missing out

[Lenlo]

 

I have, but he hasnt given any reasons for me being a wolf beyond his reaction to this catchup. Beyond that his sole reason was "Hes afk", when half the game is afk. Now I dont think I am misrepping him. I think what I said, with the quotes I have shown, perfectly support what I have said. Nowhere in there however did I ever say "Snow is a wolf". "Lets lynch Snow". "Vote Snow". All I did was say that it was wolfy and that I didnt like his handleing of Zander in the first half of the game. In response to that, he hops all over me tries to argue semantics and dissect every post I make. The entire time with, what seems to me but im clearly biased in this debate, as a predetermined notion that I am a wolf. Predetermined notions like that are wolfy imo.

Blue's fine.  I mean villagers tunnel villagers too but it's generically fine.  But red, if you want to talk semantics "wolfy" vs "a wolf" is about as petty as it gets mate.  I'm reading this out of context from your actual argument with him but I would safely assume that any player ought to read your list as "Snow is the person I'm most comfortable lynching right now".

 

I'm not sure how relevant that is to your argument with him? but I guess my thinking is if Snow's a villager trying to figure out which of the people voting him is a wolf he has grounds to suspect you.

 

Still want to know what his reason for wanting to lynch you prior to your reads list was though.

 

Thats fine. Suppose I could word it better as "Leaning wolf" or whatever, but its supposed to be the middle ground between 100% wolf lynch this person and Null

 

 

Post 530, sorry. Was off by one.

Is it sad that I couldn't be arsed to look up one post or notice that you were directly quoting it above, but I remembered that it was on page 27?

 

Yeah probably.

 

It gives me the heebeegeebees for a second every time I've read it because he took up the exact same line as a wolf in TG, but I can't help but think he wouldn't say it consistently as a wolf unless he'd say it as a villager too.

 

Policy lynching is stupid but we know villagers do it. My ISO-less memory of Snow's early game was his focus on Hermes. /shrug

 

Pretty safe. Glad to know im not the only person who found it questionable though. And as AJ said, Snow hasnt given a reason for why im wolf beyond "Hes afk, put pressure on slot". So his wolf read of me is really rather recent all things considered.

[Shad_]

I am in desperate need of Pralaya content.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

I wonder how many wolves are hiding behind the fact that villagers are hiding behind their role pms.

 

lulz

 

so much this

 

 

so not this...let's vote Shad?

[amegakure]

I wonder how many wolves are hiding behind the fact that villagers are hiding behind their role pms.

 

lulz

i must have missed something. I thought hermes was the only one to claim. 

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

 

Looking at Snow's ISO I see nothing obvious that indicates why/when he started scum reading Lenlo

 

There's just a one-liner that says Snow is putting Lenlo into his WTL

 

Are you more inclined to lynch Snow or Lenlo since you're amazing analysis?

 

I'm already voting Snow bud

 

You're missing out

 

 

Nah, pretty sure I found scum...could vote Krak or Darthe...but Shad deserves to swing?

[Andrej]

also also I just reminded myself of my original hunch irt Snow

 

I though the symp theory was ~plausible considering Dave's hints/claim but Snow's original reason for wanting to lynch him was 'jokes feel forced and he's jumping around a lot' which again, is a super easy line to take as scum looking for the ML.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

also also I just reminded myself of my original hunch irt Snow

 

I though the symp theory was ~plausible considering Dave's hints/claim but Snow's original reason for wanting to lynch him was 'jokes feel forced and he's jumping around a lot' which again, is a super easy line to take as scum looking for the ML.

 

I love your persistence....how do I know you're not providing cover to Shad or Darthe?

[Shad_]

@ 11 to lynch and no lynch being even less of an option than usual I don't know that I should waste much energy trying to figure him out.  I'm never going to walk away thinking he's the towniest town to ever town.  It's more a matter of deciding whether there's a better option.

[Andrej]

 

 

 

Looking at Snow's ISO I see nothing obvious that indicates why/when he started scum reading Lenlo

 

There's just a one-liner that says Snow is putting Lenlo into his WTL

 

Are you more inclined to lynch Snow or Lenlo since you're amazing analysis?

 

I'm already voting Snow bud

 

You're missing out

 

 

Nah, pretty sure I found scum...could vote Krak or Darthe...but Shad deserves to swing?

 

 

I doubt Shad is scum. He didn't vote anyone at all D1 in the game you're talking about until near DL when you were ran up. His snap vote on Leelou is already in contrast if you wanna talk meta.

 

I won't ask about Darthe cause I already know the answer.

 

Why Krak though?

[Andrej]

 

also also I just reminded myself of my original hunch irt Snow

 

I though the symp theory was ~plausible considering Dave's hints/claim but Snow's original reason for wanting to lynch him was 'jokes feel forced and he's jumping around a lot' which again, is a super easy line to take as scum looking for the ML.

 

I love your persistence....how do I know you're not providing cover to Shad or Darthe?

 

I suppose you won't until later when we get more info.

 

Don't hate the question though

[Shad_]

I still think Leelou could easily be a wolf but I keep signing up for advanced games like a clown.

[Andrej]

@ 11 to lynch and no lynch being even less of an option than usual I don't know that I should waste much energy trying to figure him out.  I'm never going to walk away thinking he's the towniest town to ever town.  It's more a matter of deciding whether there's a better option.

 

Who are you talking about?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

 

 

 

Looking at Snow's ISO I see nothing obvious that indicates why/when he started scum reading Lenlo

 

There's just a one-liner that says Snow is putting Lenlo into his WTL

 

Are you more inclined to lynch Snow or Lenlo since you're amazing analysis?

 

I'm already voting Snow bud

 

You're missing out

 

 

Nah, pretty sure I found scum...could vote Krak or Darthe...but Shad deserves to swing?

 

 

I doubt Shad is scum. He didn't vote anyone at all D1 in the game you're talking about until near DL when you were ran up. His snap vote on Leelou is already in contrast if you wanna talk meta.

 

I won't ask about Darthe cause I already know the answer.

 

Why Krak though?

 

 

Dude deserves to swing.

 

Y not Darthe?

 

How do you have him in you town pile?

 

Could you vote Crusher?

[Shad_]

 

I wonder how many wolves are hiding behind the fact that villagers are hiding behind their role pms.

 

lulz

i must have missed something. I thought hermes was the only one to claim. 

 

 

Amega are you openly wolfing in my thread?

 

It's ok.  You can tell me.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

I still think Leelou could easily be a wolf but I keep signing up for advanced games like a clown.

 

I still think Shad could be a wolf based upon his admitted affection to clowns.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

 

I wonder how many wolves are hiding behind the fact that villagers are hiding behind their role pms.

 

lulz

i must have missed something. I thought hermes was the only one to claim. 

 

 

Amega are you openly wolfing in my thread?

 

It's ok.  You can tell me.

 

 

^^^Fake News ^^^

[Shad_]

 

@ 11 to lynch and no lynch being even less of an option than usual I don't know that I should waste much energy trying to figure him out.  I'm never going to walk away thinking he's the towniest town to ever town.  It's more a matter of deciding whether there's a better option.

 

Who are you talking about?

 

 

John Snow.

 

He's pretty obviously the default lynch at this point unless something happens to shake shit up, and we can't CFD or have competing trains come EoD.

[Andrej]

Dude deserves to swing.

 

Y not Darthe?

 

How do you have him in you town pile?

 

Could you vote Crusher?

 

Darthe will remain at null until I have seen some flips and his voting patterns/posturing around them.

 

He's said some stuff that I thought was smart/insightful but nothing I don't think he could fake.

 

What about Crusher? I don't even remember if that guy posted. So if you're asking if I'd blind lynch him? Sure why not. Dead weight is dead weight and he's carrying a lot of it lol

[Shad_]

The more Notbob calls me a wolf the more I think he's a villager.

 

God I'm so easy to pocket.

[Andrej]

It's called reverse pocketing

[Shad_]

It's worked on me for years.

 

One day the wolves will catch on.

[Andrej]

 

 

@ 11 to lynch and no lynch being even less of an option than usual I don't know that I should waste much energy trying to figure him out.  I'm never going to walk away thinking he's the towniest town to ever town.  It's more a matter of deciding whether there's a better option.

 

Who are you talking about?

 

John Snow.

 

He's pretty obviously the default lynch at this point unless something happens to shake shit up, and we can't CFD or have competing trains come EoD.

 

I doubt it tbh. Beyond the people that have already voted him there's several more who have voiced that they would as well - and seeing the penalty for not getting majority I can see a hasty consolidation lynch in the end.

 

But maybe it'll be like D1 of the Caesar game where the scummers have to pile on and out themselves bussing their Godfather? Snow is sitting at an uncomfortable null for me where I can see scum motive behind his pushes but also think some of his rebuttals have been decent.