[Advanced] Lost Mafia--Game Over!

[Shad_]

Pral has been a lot more active than I'm used to. Not sure how to take that.

 

lol what?

[Eldrick4221]

I missed this and it's a decent catch.

 

Lenlo how doth thou plead?

He pleads misrep.

 

He was right. He never said town.

[Shad_]

(#832)? Calder, still not doing stuff. Either 3rd party or town, because this is exactly how I remember him behaving in the Gods and Demons cult game.

Ok this post bugs me. 3rd party and mafia play very differently. You pointed out that because of how he's playing, he's likely either 3rd party or town. You pointedly excluded mafia from the list. Now you're saying if not 3rd party he's probably mafia.

Im sorry what? I never said the bold. Your putting words in my mouth Eldrick.

 

And the way a 3rd party/mafia players is dependent on the person. The core of what im saying is, he is playing like he is not town based on past experiences.

[Shad_]

lol @ my push on Pral last game

[Lenlo]

 

(#832)? Calder, still not doing stuff. Either 3rd party or town, because this is exactly how I remember him behaving in the Gods and Demons cult game.

Ok this post bugs me. 3rd party and mafia play very differently. You pointed out that because of how he's playing, he's likely either 3rd party or town. You pointedly excluded mafia from the list. Now you're saying if not 3rd party he's probably mafia.

Im sorry what? I never said the bold. Your putting words in my mouth Eldrick.

 

And the way a 3rd party/mafia players is dependent on the person. The core of what im saying is, he is playing like he is not town based on past experiences.

 

Oh guess I did. Past me is an idiot on both counts. Calders not acting like town. Doesnt change that I want him lynched.

[Shad_]

I figured it was just a typo.  >_>

[Lenlo]

I figured it was just a typo.  >_>

Mafia and town are pretty far away from each other on the keyboard, so that would be a weird typo. No, thats probably just how I felt when writing that note and I changed my mind in the future.

[Eldrick4221]

 

(#832)? Calder, still not doing stuff. Either 3rd party or town, because this is exactly how I remember him behaving in the Gods and Demons cult game.

Ok this post bugs me. 3rd party and mafia play very differently. You pointed out that because of how he's playing, he's likely either 3rd party or town. You pointedly excluded mafia from the list. Now you're saying if not 3rd party he's probably mafia.

Im sorry what? I never said the bold. Your putting words in my mouth Eldrick.

 

And the way a 3rd party/mafia players is dependent on the person. The core of what im saying is, he is playing like he is not town based on past experiences.

I knew I read it somewhere!

[Eldrick4221]

In the catchup notes. Of course. I didn't look in those when I was fact checking because he disputed it.

[Eldrick4221]

Despise spoiler tags sometimes

[Lenlo]

In the catchup notes. Of course. I didn't look in those when I was fact checking because he disputed it.

Assuming I know what past me said was your first mistake.

[Shad_]

lol

[Eldrick4221]

Tink says he's gonna post a reads list, then there's a string of excuses why he hasn't yet.

[Eldrick4221]

 

In the catchup notes. Of course. I didn't look in those when I was fact checking because he disputed it.

Assuming I know what past me said was your first mistake.

Why was calder towny to you during catchup?

[Eldrick4221]

Silly me. Expecting people to own up to what they've said.

[Shad_]

Shad himself is playing rather similar of his last scum game, but I'm not ready to vote or strongly suss on that alone.

I'm very interested in your broad take on this. I have a knowledge gap in Hackers from the fact that you were town reading me up until you decided to yolo peek me. Can you lay out for me what sort of things feel the same and where/why you stand on me aorn?

[Shad_]

I'm unfortunately obligated to go to bed now.

 

Leaving off top of p76.

 

I'm not sold that Calder's push on AJ on p75 is honest and without doing research to confirm it makes me think of about-faces after lulls that I've seen him pull as a non-town before.

[Eldrick4221]

Good for you keeping to your schedule

[Eldrick4221]

I'm unfortunately obligated to go to bed now.

 

Leaving off top of p76.

 

I'm not sold that Calder's push on AJ on p75 is honest and without doing research to confirm it makes me think of about-faces after lulls that I've seen him pull as a non-town before.

Yeah I don't buy it either. AJ comes off as super clean and towny trying to understand tink's stance. Calder's reaction seems way out of line and his flip on tink read makes 0 sense.

[BFG]

Good morning, going to try and catch up while at work

 

For now sticking to the basics (mostly cos I keep staring at the final VC hoping for inspiration lol)

 

Nyn, why didn't you try to consolidate on AJ when it was clear the lynch was between DPR/Darthe?

 

Calder, is there more to your case than him pushing you v Tiinker? Why did you have Tiinker as mafia to begin with?

 

AJ, can you point me to where you started talking about Calder?

[Eldrick4221]

It's exchanges like that that are why I have aj as town. He is engaging. He is asking pointed questions and getting results. He is clearly trying to solve.

[Nynaeve]

Nyn, why didn't you try to consolidate on AJ when it was clear the lynch was between DPR/Darthe?

 

Because my strongest scum read is Sooh and I don't feel confident one way or the other about AJ quite yet. Was also not going to vote DPR, cause I thought he sounded a lot better through the day. And Hallia has Darthe as town, plus there was his claim.

[Eldrick4221]

Hey bfg.

 

Calder quotes the exchange on page 75

[BFG]

 

Nyn, why didn't you try to consolidate on AJ when it was clear the lynch was between DPR/Darthe?

Because my strongest scum read is Sooh and I don't feel confident one way or the other about AJ quite yet. Was also not going to vote DPR, cause I thought he sounded a lot better through the day. And Hallia has Darthe as town, plus there was his claim.

Then do I have you out of context when suggesting Aj/Sooh competing trains?

[Eldrick4221]

What's your thoughts on Calder?

It starts here.