[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[Nynaeve]

Can I get some constructed thoughts on Believer plz if someone can oblige. 

 

He really likes nipples.

[monstrman]

 

Nego has a style where he floats under the radar

 

Usually as a villager Ive seen more from him by now, but I also don't really know what his wolf game looks like and he was in three games at once

 

Is that literally all you have to say about the major buddying and agreeing with Besie who it seems like you've disagreed with all game? 

 

 

Idk, I'm iffy on them being on a team because of one post that I saw where nego was shading besie when I was arguing with her

 

I mean, I guess it wasn't anything too difficult to fake. As noted by my giant walls of math related posts, I don't think in teams so much as I think in "this concentration of players has wolves in it"

[monstrman]

If anything Nego's lack of presence is the scummiest thing about him to me

 

I know he had meta in the other game but he's also had a lot of time to adjust in this game

[monstrman]

As far as believer is concerned, he's either super confident town that's wrong or scum that's going to get lynched. I don't really have anything else constructive to say about that.

[monstrman]

Seeing as I just made three posts with content in a row immediately, does it seem plausible to you now wild that I simply just posted those votes that fast?

 

because that's what happened and the other way makes no sense

 

I had my other tabs open for isoing, not for posting in the game thread. I keep the game thread in one tab. I don't even understand where you came up with this idea.

[monstrman]

homework?

 

no, mafia

 

school?

 

no, mafia

 

anything?

 

no, mafia

 

ok monstrman ty

[Hallia]

 

Can I get some constructed thoughts on Believer plz if someone can oblige.

He really likes nipples.

True

[Believer]

 

 

Can I get some constructed thoughts on Believer plz if someone can oblige.

He really likes nipples.

 

True

 

Can confirm.

 

/Out for sleep

[monstrman]

For the record, tiink is absolutely a villager

[monstrman]

 

Okay so this is my reads list.  I am doing it off the top of my head so that's why there are so many nulls.  I am just trying to get it done before the night is fully over so I will have time to ISO at least 1 of my nulls.  

 

1. Zander - Lt. Gillette - Lynched D1

2. Darthe- null - slightly scummy - first off I wanna start by saying that since I've subbed in as scum with him, I ALWAYS (if you can count 2 games as always) see him as wolfy rotb. That being said, darthe hounded zander all d1.  he never let up on him.  which I guess could be a townie in a tunnel.  However, zander was showing some townieness before the lynch happened....I think a good RL day before.  Darthe knows zander very well.  If darthe is a townie I do not understand how he could not see zanders townieness.  I mean if I could, I believe darthe definitely could.

 

3. Dice - null -  townie - I like the fact that he wasn't going to vote zander and that he is asking the same questions I am asking about roles in a basic game.

 

4. Monstr - null - scummy - I don't know where to start.  However, I believe I have pointed out some of his posts in catch up that I thought were scummy if not, I am sorry.  Anyway, the most damning of evidence is his EoD voting.  I don't see how he could have voted within the same MINUTE without having it set up with open tabs ahead of time, taking into account how slow DM is on reloading.  

 

5. Hellian Wildfire - TOWN QUEENIE

6. Kat/Pral - null - slightly townie - I like pral's posts so far.  Kat has just started to post so will let her do her thing.  I commented on the posts of pral's that I like so will leave it at that.

 

7. Besie - null - I am going to keep besie as null for now.  I know you all will hate it but I am just not sure...I had her as scum in my catch up but more current posts had me thinking townie.  I need to do a full ISO on her to get the two to mesh.  Depends when I get done with this if it gets done tonight or tomorrow.

 

8. Nego - null - another I am going on null for.  Needs a full ISO.  Not enough posts for me to get a good read on.

 

9. Sooh - null - slightly scummy - I didn't like her posts at the beginning of the game.  I believe they were calling for zander's lynch but I am not sure so DO NOT quote me on it. 

 

10. Believer - null - Is he playing this game???  I have only seen a couple of posts from him.  Need to ISO.

 

11. Tiinklove = null - slight townie - by process of elimination (POE) there's gotta be some townies somewhere....I seem to have more wolfies than I do townies and nullls....but nulls will be taken care of tonight (hopefully at least one) and tomorrow.

 

12. Calder- Town Doc - Killed N1

13. Nolder - scummy - I think his tracker claim is fake and that he would only make a claim like that if he was scum trying to get townie points.

 

DISCLAIMER:  this is my FIRST reads list. It WILL CHANGE.  It may have already changed.  It will change according to my emotions and whims.  It just does.  

 

I mean...I am a terrible townie and I have rand townie in all my games except where I've subbed in and Darthe's BTW which doesn't count cause EVERYONE but 3 SK, 2 Masons, 1 Jester were mafia in a 15p game.  I tend to use run on sentences and make weird mafia teams which no one can think of why they are, except me.   and to be honest I forget why they are too usually even as I am writing the explanation.   However, they make perfect sense at the time.  Also people tend to like to put me under the burner all the time.  Usually because they find me confusing. I do not understand this.  I make perfect sense. 

 

The above is JFYI for the new people.  So maybe I don't have to go through what I have had to go through every game, please.  

 

 

ok hang on reread this list

 

null

 

null

 

null

 

null

 

null

 

null

 

null

 

null

 

null

 

Why is everyone null except for SLIGHT leans? Your progressions also don't quite match up with what I've experienced in the thread, most notably that you found a few of my posts villagery but didn't talk about them at all abandoning them to instead shade me about an EoD for something that just doesn't make any sense for anyone to do let alone a wolf

[monstrman]

*snip* 

 

Reread thoughts.

 

 

 

Zander

- seems town p1 from intro

- reacts to me asking nego whether he liked what he randed (as i predicted) on p9. i know many people think that i only like to rand wolf. i'm taking this as slight town - he's going by his meta of me to figure out the game. solving.

- jumps at opportunity of me being wolf because of my slight read on darthe - town indicative. obv trying to find anything that seems off. solving

- still seems solving on p10 when asking darthe on his opinions - town indicative

- sussing of me occurs for the next few pages but i'm just going to stick with what i said above. solving

- votes me p10 

- p16-17 explains his thoughts on me to sooh which isn't alignment indicative

- p17 #336 his thoughts on sooh, which i don't really get but it's more meta things. probably slight town indicative

- p19 was the whole thing on me liking wolf more but being excited to rand town too - which bothers z due to his meta of me (see point 2). town indicative of him, imo. he's trying to solve the game and in the meta of a person changing, he has to change his opinion too, and he knows this - thus the frustration.

 

Nolder

- not really saying anything p2.

 

Sooh

- seems relaxed when talking to zander. Of course, it is p1 so doesn't actually mean anything.

- last post p3, doesn't really answer whether i should trust her but the way she does answer seems confident - not sure whether this is alignment indicative

- p16 #305 she asks questions about people's thoughts. probably not alignment indicative

- p16 #309 she questions tiink's decisions. seems to be solving. town indicative

- #312 same as above

- p17 #329 states that darthe is village due to nothing indicating otherwise? mmm.

- #335 questions zander on his opinion of me which seems more solving. town indicative imo

 

Nego

- I like Nego's intro tone on p2. Not alignment indicative yet, i think.

- I read it but it went over my head - this is your first game on DM? Welcome :)

- I like his tone p3 - seems to be game solving to start with

- 7 of the same posts so definitely scummy on p3 (joking ofc)

- joke votes Believer on p5 (continuous joking from IC lynch of a previous game) - doesn't mean anything alignment-wise; unvotes p6

- votes me on p8 for saying "interesting" - which i'm fairly certain is not the main reason, but rather that he voted me for the same reason darthe was suspect

- unvotes p13 (#249) when finding that it's a hammer game. not alignment indicative

- p15 #286 he asks about my meta. seems game solving. towny indicative if any

- p18 #351 he explains his thoughts. i'm going to go with slight town indicative, as he's sharing his thoughts and thus making himself easier to read to others

 

Tiink

- appears p3 but doesn't really say anything I can use to figure out alignment

- votes zander on p11 for... who knows? not enought to be alignment indicative

- and unvotes on the same page.

- post pings me p12 #228 - he asks how to get on monstrman's good side. feels like pocketing? (i'm not terribly convinced that i actually know the proper definition of that word). either way, slightly scummy alignment

 

Dice

- his intor on p3 seems relaxed - not sure whether i think it's alignment indicative or no

- back on p21, #404. he shares his thoughts on other's thoughts but not much more. Not alignment indicative.

- obv dislikes the fact that believer doesn't want to participate much or even form an opinion D1 and votes him #412. Kinda want to say slight town indicative? maybe just null. it's good that he wants people to participate, but he needs to participate himself - or at least share more thoughts.

 

Monstrman

- checks in on p4 in no way that i can determine anything

- continues on p4 in what i perceive as attempting to solve something in the past whole 3 pages - initially i had thought this was towny but on reread.. damn. it's just 3 pages. I'm making that not alignment indicative

- just a note* - interacts with darthe p5-6 (to look out for pocket/distance/sheep)

- my post #122 on p7 is both me squinting at the things darthe said (mostly on the interaction notes) but also saying that he's slightly towny. monstrman immediatly asks why i think him slightly towny after squinting. I'm taking that as town indicative. feels like he squinted at the post (bad joke) and is trying to figure out my thoughts, and seeing how it compares to his - as a way to decide my alignment. so, solving.

- last post on p11 feels honest, like he's saying he wants to solve the game and will do it to the best of his ability? i believe him. slight town alignment

- answer tiink in full even though it wasn't even necessary? p12 #230. not deciding on any alignment here yet. feels like it could have been planned. maybe. just a feeling. not alignment indicative yet.

- i understand his reasoning on last post p12, and even though it looks like nego backed off of the vote on me, he didn't unvote at this point yet. nego only unvotes later (#249) when he learns its a hammer game. He still seems to be solving and i like that he picks up on the small things like these. going to go with maybe town alignment indicative

- still calmly answering questions and sharing his thought process on p14 #274. as two above. i want to say town indicative. but something. ...

- and then #278 he states that darthe is bullying him. so i'm just going to go with null on that whole thing.

- post #280: "Guarantee we have low posting wolves that are loling at whichever villagers are sussing each other though" - no one has commented on. Mmm.

- reached this point and just realized that manbat is batman in reverse. thumbsup.gif

- thoughts on p15 #285 regarding zander being towny, because of z saying he's hard to read? i missed that. thanks to zander for providing the quote - p14, #262

- p16, #310, states that sooh is probably a villager. not alignment indicative, but funny that he doesn't follow his own "how to be a villager" advice to darthe.

- annnnddd nvm cause in #313 he gives his reasoning. 

- also interested in others's opinions in #314 which isn't aligment indicative rn but could does indicate interest in where others are standing

 

Calder 

- alive on p4. his intro post slightly pings me because i don't know whether he's joking completely or just stating what he's actually doing. It's the "blending in" part that makes me wonder. for now, not alignment indicative. later, p9, zander confirms that he does it as either alignment according to his meta, so definitely not alignment indicative.

- starts asking his questions that i can't see helping anything on p6 - not alignment indicative 

- i asked him why he was posting the questions and he responded by asking me questions - which i answered p8. i took his answers as being joking but i don't get it. is this psychology or something? he finally answered sooh later (p9, #179) on why but meh - i don't get it.

- says it amuses him on p10 - which may be more accurate. not alignment indicative? unless it's some way of being in the thread without actually saying or doing anything.

- shaking things up with his first proper thought-sharing game post on p10, #190 - but not enough for me to say it's alignment indicative. he seems to just be asking questions at this stage, to see what people respond with

 

Believer

- checks in on p4 with reference to being IC in a previous game - i didn't think twice about this and still don't take it seriously at all; unvotes p7

- joke votes nego back on p5 (so obv not aligment indicative)

- states again that he doesn't like d1 on p13. bit scary that he says he would vote anyone. surely he need at least some kind of an opinion before voting? not sure what this means alignment wise. he did say it earlier though so i'm leaning null

 

Pral

- checks in on p5 with a post on chinese, which overall isn't alignment indicative

- calls me wolfqueenie on p6 - definitely wolfy - (joking ofc)

 

*snip* 

 

 

Hey manbat, y u say besie is on a wolf team with nol in particular?

It's for a specific reason that I will reveal if she's in fact scum, but tbh I don't think so, and I'm not too enthused on Nego being scum either

 

To be honest, this game seems much different from the last scum game I saw calder play so I'm inclined to think he's town. Incidentally, I also think that if zander is a wolf all he's doing is pushing townies right now, i.e. he and believer are never on a scum team. Aorn i'm torn because I don't really notice believer saying much itt aside from defending himself and i'd like to see more reads. I cannot say I have confidence in a read on his alignment one way or the other, and it's probably at least halfway a me problem.

 

I have darthe as a villager mostly because of a gut feeling based on how you're reading me, I'm just waiting on you exploding with wim again to call you a lock villager. I think if you're a villager it will come as the game progresses too

 

Besie I had as town because the way she said that she was leaning town on me but (player I think darthe or zander) had a good point about something I had said or done and it read to me like besie is a player that seems to have trouble separating her reads and the reads of other players, likely because she has a hard time not doubting herself. That said, I understand that it's possible she was just saying that to appease me and also leave herself the option of voting me later, so I don't necessarily think she's a lock villager either just someone I don't consider worth voting yet. If my personality read is wrong, she's probably a wolf.

 

 

I really like this post from manbat.  He is really digging and trying to solve.  Gives me more info on players I do not know.

 

 

 

Eh I guess it's just this one post.

 

We'll see what happens tomorrow

[monstrman]

*snip* 

 

Reread thoughts.

 

 

 

Zander

- seems town p1 from intro

- reacts to me asking nego whether he liked what he randed (as i predicted) on p9. i know many people think that i only like to rand wolf. i'm taking this as slight town - he's going by his meta of me to figure out the game. solving.

- jumps at opportunity of me being wolf because of my slight read on darthe - town indicative. obv trying to find anything that seems off. solving

- still seems solving on p10 when asking darthe on his opinions - town indicative

- sussing of me occurs for the next few pages but i'm just going to stick with what i said above. solving

- votes me p10 

- p16-17 explains his thoughts on me to sooh which isn't alignment indicative

- p17 #336 his thoughts on sooh, which i don't really get but it's more meta things. probably slight town indicative

- p19 was the whole thing on me liking wolf more but being excited to rand town too - which bothers z due to his meta of me (see point 2). town indicative of him, imo. he's trying to solve the game and in the meta of a person changing, he has to change his opinion too, and he knows this - thus the frustration.

 

Nolder

- not really saying anything p2.

 

Sooh

- seems relaxed when talking to zander. Of course, it is p1 so doesn't actually mean anything.

- last post p3, doesn't really answer whether i should trust her but the way she does answer seems confident - not sure whether this is alignment indicative

- p16 #305 she asks questions about people's thoughts. probably not alignment indicative

- p16 #309 she questions tiink's decisions. seems to be solving. town indicative

- #312 same as above

- p17 #329 states that darthe is village due to nothing indicating otherwise? mmm.

- #335 questions zander on his opinion of me which seems more solving. town indicative imo

 

Nego

- I like Nego's intro tone on p2. Not alignment indicative yet, i think.

- I read it but it went over my head - this is your first game on DM? Welcome :)

- I like his tone p3 - seems to be game solving to start with

- 7 of the same posts so definitely scummy on p3 (joking ofc)

- joke votes Believer on p5 (continuous joking from IC lynch of a previous game) - doesn't mean anything alignment-wise; unvotes p6

- votes me on p8 for saying "interesting" - which i'm fairly certain is not the main reason, but rather that he voted me for the same reason darthe was suspect

- unvotes p13 (#249) when finding that it's a hammer game. not alignment indicative

- p15 #286 he asks about my meta. seems game solving. towny indicative if any

- p18 #351 he explains his thoughts. i'm going to go with slight town indicative, as he's sharing his thoughts and thus making himself easier to read to others

 

Tiink

- appears p3 but doesn't really say anything I can use to figure out alignment

- votes zander on p11 for... who knows? not enought to be alignment indicative

- and unvotes on the same page.

- post pings me p12 #228 - he asks how to get on monstrman's good side. feels like pocketing? (i'm not terribly convinced that i actually know the proper definition of that word). either way, slightly scummy alignment

 

Dice

- his intor on p3 seems relaxed - not sure whether i think it's alignment indicative or no

- back on p21, #404. he shares his thoughts on other's thoughts but not much more. Not alignment indicative.

- obv dislikes the fact that believer doesn't want to participate much or even form an opinion D1 and votes him #412. Kinda want to say slight town indicative? maybe just null. it's good that he wants people to participate, but he needs to participate himself - or at least share more thoughts.

 

Monstrman

- checks in on p4 in no way that i can determine anything

- continues on p4 in what i perceive as attempting to solve something in the past whole 3 pages - initially i had thought this was towny but on reread.. damn. it's just 3 pages. I'm making that not alignment indicative

- just a note* - interacts with darthe p5-6 (to look out for pocket/distance/sheep)

- my post #122 on p7 is both me squinting at the things darthe said (mostly on the interaction notes) but also saying that he's slightly towny. monstrman immediatly asks why i think him slightly towny after squinting. I'm taking that as town indicative. feels like he squinted at the post (bad joke) and is trying to figure out my thoughts, and seeing how it compares to his - as a way to decide my alignment. so, solving.

- last post on p11 feels honest, like he's saying he wants to solve the game and will do it to the best of his ability? i believe him. slight town alignment

- answer tiink in full even though it wasn't even necessary? p12 #230. not deciding on any alignment here yet. feels like it could have been planned. maybe. just a feeling. not alignment indicative yet.

- i understand his reasoning on last post p12, and even though it looks like nego backed off of the vote on me, he didn't unvote at this point yet. nego only unvotes later (#249) when he learns its a hammer game. He still seems to be solving and i like that he picks up on the small things like these. going to go with maybe town alignment indicative

- still calmly answering questions and sharing his thought process on p14 #274. as two above. i want to say town indicative. but something. ...

- and then #278 he states that darthe is bullying him. so i'm just going to go with null on that whole thing.

- post #280: "Guarantee we have low posting wolves that are loling at whichever villagers are sussing each other though" - no one has commented on. Mmm.

- reached this point and just realized that manbat is batman in reverse. thumbsup.gif

- thoughts on p15 #285 regarding zander being towny, because of z saying he's hard to read? i missed that. thanks to zander for providing the quote - p14, #262

- p16, #310, states that sooh is probably a villager. not alignment indicative, but funny that he doesn't follow his own "how to be a villager" advice to darthe.

- annnnddd nvm cause in #313 he gives his reasoning. 

- also interested in others's opinions in #314 which isn't aligment indicative rn but could does indicate interest in where others are standing

 

Calder 

- alive on p4. his intro post slightly pings me because i don't know whether he's joking completely or just stating what he's actually doing. It's the "blending in" part that makes me wonder. for now, not alignment indicative. later, p9, zander confirms that he does it as either alignment according to his meta, so definitely not alignment indicative.

- starts asking his questions that i can't see helping anything on p6 - not alignment indicative 

- i asked him why he was posting the questions and he responded by asking me questions - which i answered p8. i took his answers as being joking but i don't get it. is this psychology or something? he finally answered sooh later (p9, #179) on why but meh - i don't get it.

- says it amuses him on p10 - which may be more accurate. not alignment indicative? unless it's some way of being in the thread without actually saying or doing anything.

- shaking things up with his first proper thought-sharing game post on p10, #190 - but not enough for me to say it's alignment indicative. he seems to just be asking questions at this stage, to see what people respond with

 

Believer

- checks in on p4 with reference to being IC in a previous game - i didn't think twice about this and still don't take it seriously at all; unvotes p7

- joke votes nego back on p5 (so obv not aligment indicative)

- states again that he doesn't like d1 on p13. bit scary that he says he would vote anyone. surely he need at least some kind of an opinion before voting? not sure what this means alignment wise. he did say it earlier though so i'm leaning null

 

Pral

- checks in on p5 with a post on chinese, which overall isn't alignment indicative

- calls me wolfqueenie on p6 - definitely wolfy - (joking ofc)

 

*snip* 

 

 

Hey manbat, y u say besie is on a wolf team with nol in particular?

It's for a specific reason that I will reveal if she's in fact scum, but tbh I don't think so, and I'm not too enthused on Nego being scum either

 

To be honest, this game seems much different from the last scum game I saw calder play so I'm inclined to think he's town. Incidentally, I also think that if zander is a wolf all he's doing is pushing townies right now, i.e. he and believer are never on a scum team. Aorn i'm torn because I don't really notice believer saying much itt aside from defending himself and i'd like to see more reads. I cannot say I have confidence in a read on his alignment one way or the other, and it's probably at least halfway a me problem.

 

I have darthe as a villager mostly because of a gut feeling based on how you're reading me, I'm just waiting on you exploding with wim again to call you a lock villager. I think if you're a villager it will come as the game progresses too

 

Besie I had as town because the way she said that she was leaning town on me but (player I think darthe or zander) had a good point about something I had said or done and it read to me like besie is a player that seems to have trouble separating her reads and the reads of other players, likely because she has a hard time not doubting herself. That said, I understand that it's possible she was just saying that to appease me and also leave herself the option of voting me later, so I don't necessarily think she's a lock villager either just someone I don't consider worth voting yet. If my personality read is wrong, she's probably a wolf.

 

 

I really like this post from manbat.  He is really digging and trying to solve.  Gives me more info on players I do not know.

 

 

 

Eh I guess it's just this one post.

 

We'll see what happens tomorrow

[Darthe]

Darthe you seem to be very rigid this game.

this game or this day?

[Darthe]

You think Nolder's claim is fake? If you're CCing you may as well just do it or there is no point in saying that.

 

Also, is WiFi scum? lol her town game is usually a lot more sporadic and the logic is difficult for me to follow, however, this list reasoning seems more "crafted" in comparison.

What? No.  Dice asked me about roles in the game and I'm saying that his goes against the traditional basic setups by and large.  It's not out of bounds, by any means.  Tbh you look like you're baiting atm but without getting too into it we are probably screwed with our investigator out in the open.  

 

As to wifi, I agree she looks a lot more crafted, it's of concern to me.  

[Tiinker]

 

You think Nolder's claim is fake? If you're CCing you may as well just do it or there is no point in saying that.

 

Also, is WiFi scum? lol her town game is usually a lot more sporadic and the logic is difficult for me to follow, however, this list reasoning seems more "crafted" in comparison.

What? No.  Dice asked me about roles in the game and I'm saying that his goes against the traditional basic setups by and large.  It's not out of bounds, by any means.  Tbh you look like you're baiting atm but without getting too into it we are probably screwed with our investigator out in the open.  

 

As to wifi, I agree she looks a lot more crafted, it's of concern to me.  

 

 

My post was in response to WiFi and her read on Nolder

[Darthe]

I figured that out after

 

I dont get her, the fake thing is pretty baseless and is gonna look like tmi if it is fake.

[Wildfire Sedai]

This is NEGO's ISO:

 

 

 

Does anybody know Chinese? I had to go thorough multiple Chinese posts to find this game

 

Duibuqi. Wo de Zhongwen bu hao.

 

DUI can not afford. W O Z Hung text is not good.  the above as translated.  Just out of curiosity: Is this in anyway game related??

 

 

 

 

Good morning everyone. IC reporting in.

 
[v]Believer[/v]

 

[v]Nego[/v]

Only scum hates IC's.

 

 

good response

 

[unvote]

 

you can go to the "maybe town" pile.
 

 

 

I like this exchange.  Shows townie on both sides.

 

 

 

What? No. I said faking to correct a typo where I accidentally typed taking -.-

 

Interesting.

 

In my experience wolves say "interesting" 90% of the time.

 

[v]BlomBesie[/v]

 

 

See quote below: vvvvvv

 

 

His reaction was... none of the reaction. Noneee of it.

 

Moving on.

 

What other reason do you have for voting me, Nego?

Also, does it count that you said "interesting" in your post about me saying "interesting" and if so, do you count as part of the 90% that say "interesting"?

 

Hmm.... When you put it that way...

 

 

And nah, I don't have any other reason for voting you yet. The phase won't end until Saturday so consider this just a warmup joke vote.

 

 

This looks like another townie push....His first one was voting believer when believer said "IC reporting in".  Now he does this...Looks really good.

 

 

 

 

Besie saying she has a slight town read from manbat there is prob her best post to me. That is how townies typically get comfort. Seeing other players try to solve makes them feel better.

Your criticism there worries me. You trying to push a false wagon?

Gonna say Calder is a slight town read for me because of this post just to make it look like i'm a townie typically getting comfort.

Kinda wolfy tbh

 

 

intentionally so
 

 

 

I think here he is mixing the waters again to get action going. The wording of his first response needs to be looked at closely...and I am running out of time. I have 10 minutes to finish this ISO.  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Would I vote Negp?

Yes you would other Barry. Yes. You. Would.

If you think I'm scum, go ahead.

I'd prefer lynching actual scum though.

Wolfy that you felt the need to add this on tbh

:thumbsup:

Do you understand why?

Of course but I'm not worried about it.

Good, let's not make it a habit though or I will start to worry about it.

Let me wolf the way I want to wolf please.

Id prefer if you towned.

 

Good, then neither of us have nothing to worry about.
 

 

 

This is a pretty weird exchange that has me going

 

 

[Wildfire Sedai]

 

 

I'm back, have read/skimmed most of the thread.

 

Are you guys still lynching Zander? Stop that.

 

+1

 

 

Yeah I have to say I'm feeling the same way.

 

 

Townie post all the way...

 

 

 

 

I don't want to vote you if there's a possibility you're town and there is

So that's not quite a 100% flawless philosophy

honestly i'm not going to be much use today so either lynch me or wait until d2. i'll try to step it up when there's less ppl for me to read but right now it's not possible.

 

i'm just going to catch up and then go to bed. it's already half past two am.

But I don't want to take it to that extreme I just want to talk to you and see what your new reads are

 

And then lynch you if I think you're a wolf

 

sorry, not going to happen. i have no new reads.

 

i think lynching zander is a bad idea. dice still hasn't said or done anything that would make me think he's town. i keep mixing calder/nolder together because of their names but both seem scummy, the one with the futurama avatar even more so i wouldn't mind lynching there.

 

besie, believer, and you are my best picks for town. sooh is close but i'm not really feeling her. tiink i believe is townish enough.

 

 

Good reads list....wondering about manbat and dice but others seem okay.....I don't know which one has the futurama avatar cause I don't know futurama but if its nolder then yeah....calder no...

 

 

Also seems like you're suggesting I may be a wolf by proxy there.

 

I forgot all about you.

 

i view you as null. at times you're trending down, then i forget why and you say things that make me think you are town, and then i forget why. i don't know why but i can't read you.

 

but then again iirc that was the case in haunted house as well?

 

 

I like this.  reminds me of how I make all of my reads sometimes.     basically why I have a lot of people on null atp.

 

 

Posts between Monstr's nolder and zander votes:

 

 

[v]nolder[/v]

 

 

 

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Calder (4): Besie, Zander, Pral, dice

Zander (3): Calder, Sooh, Tiinker

Nolder (3): Believer, Darthe, monstr

dice (1): Nego

 

Not voting cause all the rum is gone (2): Hellian, Nolder

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

 

Deadline:

 

 

 

Holy hell, dude he has two votes and only needs three to tie!!! We have two peps who want to vote him!

 

 

 

Oh no, he might actually have a life, we should lynch first and find out later with much better candidates just lying around.

 

Btw im totally not a wolf.

 

He knew when DL was, if he wasnt gonna be around if could have let us know

 

shrug

 

also not the only reason to suss him imo

 

 

 

dude theres ONE A?ND ?HALF MINUTES and ure the only vote on him!

 

 

Vote nol and he dies dice

 

 

I feel like you're stepping over the line, Zander. No need to swear or freak out this much. If there was more time it would have made me relook at you. As is I'm just going to not listen to you for the last 5 minutes of today because wow.

 

 

[v]zander[/v]

 

I'm not seeing the pressure here, Monster...

 

I don't see the pressure either...atleast in these posts...will have to look at EoD again...I have a lot to do tomorrow...a bunch of ISO's and EoD again....Not sure if I can do full ISO's like this either before DL.  

 

 

 

Not lynching Monstr or Wildfire. Sooh is within my town reads as well.

Curious as to why not Wildfire. People who haven't played with her before tend to want to lynch her all the time. Why not you?

 

 

I liked her posts from N1. Dunno how I feel about her posts from D2 though.

 

 

Gonna hafta check the differences between my N1 and D2 posts prior to this post...cause I just don't get it...as most of them were all catch up posts....except my rudeness post....which I apologized for....NEGO???

[Wildfire Sedai]

Seeing as I just made three posts with content in a row immediately, does it seem plausible to you now wild that I simply just posted those votes that fast?

 

because that's what happened and the other way makes no sense

 

I had my other tabs open for isoing, not for posting in the game thread. I keep the game thread in one tab. I don't even understand where you came up with this idea.

 see I made 2 very long posts right after each other...premeditated

[Wildfire Sedai]

I figured that out after

 

I dont get her, the fake thing is pretty baseless and is gonna look like tmi if it is fake.

 

Actually I don't think it's baseless.  I am learning how to pick up on the slight nuances of the game.  I think there is a cop in the game....a REAL cop not a FAKE tracker...of course the person that I am thinking is cop could be scum throwing out fake hints as well....so you see I am in a catch 22...however I trust the person I feel is the real cop more than the fake tracker.  So yeah it is very convoluted.  However, isn't that how this game is played.

 

Yes I stayed up later tonight than normal....I needed to finish Nego's ISO and then catch up before bed...saw this post and had to respond....now I am going to bed.

[Darthe]

Definitely not how the game is played if you want to win a lot.  Your basing your assumptions of people off of assumptions of other people.  That's like trying to look at a puzzle where the pieces are spread out and trying to mentally put them all together at once so that you can then just see the picture.  

 

It'd be a whole lot easier to figure out where one piece goes before moving on to the next.  The picture will come.

[Darthe]

I wish I used half the stuff I know about mafia effectively =(

[monstrman]

Me also too as well

[Tiinker]

Me also too as well

 

:D

[Guest]

Helloes

 

 

Considering my style as a player, nothing is ever premeditated.

Trying to use it as reasoning against me is not good

Besie being around for EoD but having nothing to say weirds me out. I don't care how strange that sounds bringing it up 24 hours after the fact, it just does

 

Do you mean in the last minutes as time ran out, between that and the flip, or after the flip?

 

 

 

 

darthe can u stick ure mod hat on for a sec and lay something out for me??


what roles GENERALLY are found in a basic game?

Cop can cc tracker unless we also have a vig which means wolves will have a gf and an rb

does this mean that you only find tracker if there is no cop? can they both exist together?

Imho? No, that would be really unlikely.

 

 

I also wondered; thank you for asking this, Dice. 

 

Guess what DM's refresh time is for me

 

.5 seconds

 

lol

 

like I literally don't even know what to say about this

 

I agree with Monstrman here. It's possible to send something on DM, and literally send something again within a second. DM has no wait-time like many other sites do.

 

For the record, tiink is absolutely a villager

 

Will you please share your reasoning?