[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[monstrman]

I kind of just want to see how calder reacts to being a wagon when he returns

[dicetosser1]

sorry i forgot to chop that down

 

 

you want the bottom bit monstr

[monstrman]

ty dice <3

[dicetosser1]

np

[Zander?]

Believer- Had the chance to jump on me and not look bad if he was Scum.  His rebuttals and D1 stubbornness remind me of his Town game even when the early reads didnt.  Im willing to accept the play each role differently for now when I factor these other things in.  Still wanna reread the back and forth he had with Dice.

Monstr- He is very engaged and involved.  His AtE tho easy to fake is also on par with what I know of his Town game.  One of the biggest things I see tho is his ability to readjust his reads on the fly.  Its feels very fluent and genuine imo.

Dice- Have learned Dice is fully capable of fooling people including myself.  Will need some more time to feel comfortable assigning a strong read to Dice either way but his posts have been very Dice Like-  May have a better feel once I reread his and Believers thing but thus far np here.

Besie- Admittedly the worse feel of my Slight Town reads.  The early Meta stuff and saying I got her ML'd was sketch but shes definitely putting in the work.  If she has found a new respect for Towning I know shes the type of person who would give it 110%.  I also dont get the feel atp that shes trying To push things to make them fit. Also well aware Im not good at reading her and have a bit of a personal bias.  Also shes the most likely person who is capable of pocketing me imo.

 

Tink- Would have him higher but his WTF vote on me is WTF.  Want to see his reasoning behind it.

Sooh- Liked Sooh out of the gate.  Felt like she was throwing shade at me and Tink as well.  Liked her responses to my questions.  Even tho I dont see how Sooh was pushing me for the things she was, I remember the game where she did this same thing and we were t/t and I ML'd her replacement Turin.

Darhe- Ive seen Town!Darthe be really really wrong while displaying false bravado before unfortunately.  He's playing different then his last game where he was Town admittedly but Ive still seen this from Town!Darthe before.  All this said I will admit I read Darthe as badly as he reads me tho.

Pral- Interactions with Besie are interesting imo.  The whole he didnt play with her before could be a legit didnt remember but the fact he said he was ISOing her Town game early and stuff is a little weird.  Now his activity level and thread awareness seem pretty good after reading his reads list.  I may not agree with them but not a bad look

 

Nolder- I have thoughts but I kinda wanna see what shakes out here first.

Hellion- lol

Nego- I have no idea how to read him.  hes been fairly involved and hasnt done anything Scummy thus far but I dont have any confidence giving him a lean either way.

 

Calder- He gives a vague reason for voting me.  I know Im Town and I feel theres very little chance imo Im not being pushed by Wolves.  He just calls me Scum earlier and as you can tell makes 0 attempt to try and progress his read to even see if he could be wrong.  And I dont see how that comes from a Town!Calder PoV,  The Calder calling himself Scum stuff is completely Null.   i disagree with Monstr when he said Calder Towny for approaching me like this.  Especially if Calder is like the Vet Wolf of the Scummate if he's Scum.  he doesnt quote answer or respond to most of my questions Ive addressed to him nor really comment on anything Ive said to others iirc.  He'd already decided Im Scum very early on and that was it.

 

[v] Calder [/v]

[monstrman]

[v]unvote[/v]

 

his iso left me unsure

 

I'm gonna sleep on it

 

adios

[monstrman]

That's a good list z

[Zander?]

First group is Slight Villa leans

 

The 2nd is people who have enough content to comment on and start to formulate reads but not confident enough to really give me a lean either way till I get a reread in.

 

Null is Null

 

And Scum is Calder.

 

Anyways this is where Im at right now.

[monstrman]

I feel like Nego might be a bit low but I also might be biased in his favor

[Zander?]

@ zander

 

 

tormentings a bonus

 

So you dont think the same thing you said about Besie applies to me?

 

If you dont Id like you to explain why please?

 

Especially considering the following.

 

What do you think of me being the only real train?

 

 

let's stick with

 

[v]unvote[/v] for now

 

once I see zander's reads list I'm gonna reiso calder and then make a decision

 

Its done brother....really like to hear your take on it and get your read of me please!!!!!

[monstrman]

Well I was at "if you're scum you're scum with besie" but your read of her doesn't seem like it comes from a w/w perspective so I kind of just think you're town

 

You're not scum with anyone on your wagon I don't think so

[Zander?]

Believer- Had the chance to jump on me and not look bad if he was Scum.  His rebuttals and D1 stubbornness remind me of his Town game even when the early reads didnt.  Im willing to accept the play each role differently for now when I factor these other things in.  Still wanna reread the back and forth he had with Dice.

Monstr- He is very engaged and involved.  His AtE tho easy to fake is also on par with what I know of his Town game.  One of the biggest things I see tho is his ability to readjust his reads on the fly.  Its feels very fluent and genuine imo.

Dice- Have learned Dice is fully capable of fooling people including myself.  Will need some more time to feel comfortable assigning a strong read to Dice either way but his posts have been very Dice Like-  May have a better feel once I reread his and Believers thing but thus far np here.

Besie- Admittedly the worse feel of my Slight Town reads.  The early Meta stuff and saying I got her ML'd was sketch but shes definitely putting in the work.  If she has found a new respect for Towning I know shes the type of person who would give it 110%.  I also dont get the feel atp that shes trying To push things to make them fit. Also well aware Im not good at reading her and have a bit of a personal bias.  Also shes the most likely person who is capable of pocketing me imo.

 

Tink- Would have him higher but his WTF vote on me is WTF.  Want to see his reasoning behind it.

Sooh- Liked Sooh out of the gate.  Felt like she was throwing shade at me and Tink as well.  Liked her responses to my questions.  Even tho I dont see how Sooh was pushing me for the things she was, I remember the game where she did this same thing and we were t/t and I ML'd her replacement Turin.

Darhe- Ive seen Town!Darthe be really really wrong while displaying false bravado before unfortunately.  He's playing different then his last game where he was Town admittedly but Ive still seen this from Town!Darthe before.  All this said I will admit I read Darthe as badly as he reads me tho.

Pral- Interactions with Besie are interesting imo.  The whole he didnt play with her before could be a legit didnt remember but the fact he said he was ISOing her Town game early and stuff is a little weird.  Now his activity level and thread awareness seem pretty good after reading his reads list.  I may not agree with them but not a bad look

 

Nolder- I have thoughts but I kinda wanna see what shakes out here first.

Hellion- lol

Nego- I have no idea how to read him.  hes been fairly involved and hasnt done anything Scummy thus far but I dont have any confidence giving him a lean either way.

 

Calder- He gives a vague reason for voting me.  I know Im Town and I feel theres very little chance imo Im not being pushed by Wolves.  He just calls me Scum earlier and as you can tell makes 0 attempt to try and progress his read to even see if he could be wrong.  And I dont see how that comes from a Town!Calder PoV,  The Calder calling himself Scum stuff is completely Null.   i disagree with Monstr when he said Calder Towny for approaching me like this.  Especially if Calder is like the Vet Wolf of the Scummate if he's Scum.  he doesnt quote answer or respond to most of my questions Ive addressed to him nor really comment on anything Ive said to others iirc.  He'd already decided Im Scum very early on and that was it.

 

[v] Calder [/v]

 

 

I feel like Nego might be a bit low but I also might be biased in his favor

 

 

First group is Slight Villa leans

 

The 2nd is people who have enough content to comment on and start to formulate reads but not confident enough to really give me a lean either way till I get a reread in.

 

Null is Null

 

And Scum is Calder.

 

Anyways this is where Im at right now.

 

For Monstr irt Nego

[monstrman]

Yeah I guess "low" isn't the right way to characterize "null" but really what I was saying is I think he has potential to be a villager and i'd like to see how he plays tomorrow

[Believer]

You never lynch Zander here.

 

 

NEVER

[monstrman]

Prolly just calder then but I'm not voting him because I don't know how close we are to major and I don't want things to get out of hand

[Zander?]

You never lynch Zander here.

 

 

NEVER

 

are you just trying to pocket me?!?!!?!?!??

 

Can you explain why you feel this way atp?

 

Prolly just calder then but I'm not voting him because I don't know how close we are to major and I don't want things to get out of hand

 

Ya I want to see what he comes back with plus we've got time.

[Believer]

 

You never lynch Zander here.

 

 

NEVER

 

are you just trying to pocket me?!?!!?!?!??

 

Can you explain why you feel this way atp?

 

 

I thought you had me as town? No?

 

I feel you're town and I'm trying to prevent a mislynch here.

 

 

 

 

If I wanted to pocket you, I could just PM you with my nipples, it wouldn't even have to be public.

[dicetosser1]

 

@ zander

 

 

tormentings a bonus

 

So you dont think the same thing you said about Besie applies to me?

 

If you dont Id like you to explain why please?

 

Especially considering the following.

 

What do you think of me being the only real train?

 

 

 

 

no it doesnt apply to you

 

first off you arnt besie  so some of those reasons dont work for you

 

second  ure the only train halfway thru the day  not at the BEGINNING of the day. that DOES make a difference

 

thirdly  i can see why people think you are scummy and voting you. i dont think besie was scummy

[Darthe]

Y'all need jesus, sheep me and win.

[Guest]

Nego- I have no idea how to read him.  hes been fairly involved and hasnt done anything Scummy thus far but I dont have any confidence giving him a lean either way.

The secret to reading me is reading all my posts in a creepy whispery voice in your head and figuring out if that voice makes the post you're reading sound scummy or not.

 

 

I guess it depends on whether you find my whispering sexy or not.

[Guest]

Prolly just calder then but I'm not voting him because I don't know how close we are to major and I don't want things to get out of hand

 

Yeah, I thought about switching my vote to Calder but this is a good point.

 

What's the current tally like?

[Calder]

 

 

 

I cant imagine a world where anyone except Zander or Nolder gets lynched today.

I barely have anything on Nolder but his pop-ins are shady.

 

Zander is not on my wtl today.

Nolder's pop-in analysis post was the fakest looking catch up assessment of a game I have ever seen.

I think it's funny I wasn't on your radar until I spoke out against you.

 

Worried?

Another painfully scum post from you. You werent on my radar bc you hadnt been posting. Nice distraction attempt.

[Calder]

Wow. So many questions.

 

1. Why would you all post so much on Friday night.

 

2. Not so much a question as hahhahaha for letting Zander off the hook. Not only is his play so obv off, that list where he bullshitted together and only has me as schm, and his scum flip gets us Besie too.

 

Just wow.

[Calder]

That's a good list z

Are u drunk? It takes him until now to produce any non defensive game content and its a reads list with 1 scum read?!?!?!

 

Even worse its the person going after him. Once again my low expectations for mafia players are not even met.

[Tiinker]

VC plz